Comments 469

Re: Video: All the PS5 Games We Think Are 10/10

IntrepidWombat

Alan Wake II is one that I can't get into. The whole mind-mapping thing is disruptive. I wasn't a big fan of Saga either.

A personal 10/10 for me is Unicorn Overlord. It and RE4 Remake are my only two this gen so far, unless we're counting ports of games that launched originally on PS4, then the number goes up.

Re: Talking Point: Does PS5 Have a Sequel Problem?

IntrepidWombat

@Nepp67 No, I haven't forgotten that Final Fantasy exists. Final Fantasy VIII is not a sequel to Final Fantasy VII. Now, Final Fantasy X-2 and Final Fantasy X have the same characters, setting, and X-2 resumes the narrative of X. That's a sequel.

Re: Poll: Five Years of PS5 - How Would You Rate Sony's Console?

IntrepidWombat

Most of the games I've played this gen have also been on PS4. The extra controller features are annoying, and the battery life is abysmal. I very much prefer the DS4. They could have had more generations worth of physical backwards compatibility without breaking a sweat, at least PS1 and PS2. The design is still hideous. With that being said, the hardware is solid. Easily-expandable storage is fantastic. I do like how the games take advantage of the fast storage. It offers a great gaming experience, especially on an OLED TV.

The first party offerings have been abysmal for my tastes. I appreciate the third party support.

Overall, I said 'just okay.' Some good, some bad. I am glad to have one. Whether or not I even buy PS6 will have everything to do with physical media support going forward. If the console is digital only, then PS5 will be my last, and I'll go to PC moving forward.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 608

IntrepidWombat

I'll be on vacation for the next week, so I may not have much gaming time this weekend. My son's desk is falling apart, so we'll hit the hardware store for some all thread, nuts, and washers. It's one of those cheap metal and glass jobs from Amazon, so it should be an easy fix. With thread locker this time.

I haven't played RE2 Remake in long enough that a casual run should be fun. If I get some gaming time, I'll mess around with that (I can't believe this game is nearly 7 years old). Trails into Reverie is good, but I'm not a fan of the perspective switching mechanic because of how it impacts pacing.

I grabbed TLOU Part 1 from Amazon for cheap. I haven't played TLOU in years, and I'm interested in comparing the PS5 re-work to the original.

Lastly, my father-in-law will be over this weekend to watch Steelers at Bears. He's a Chicago native, so some polite trash talk over some pizza will be a blast.

Have a great weekend, everybody.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 607

IntrepidWombat

Starting back up into the Trails series - I'm about 20 hours into Trails into Reverie. The game is hitting its stride, finally. I'll probably finish the Sky FC Remake after that before diving into Daybreak I & II. Horizon will be out by then, which I'll grab day one, but I'll likely be gearing up for RE9 at that point.

Have a great weekend, everybody.

Re: One of PlayStation's Best Developers Marks 40 Years of Incredible Games

IntrepidWombat

@PuppetMaster Your approach is backwards. You didn't account for what she did while she was at ND, which is more important to my point than what she did when she left. Uncharted 4 and TLOU2 (didn't play Lost Legacy) definitely missed her. Both were narratively weaker than their predecessors. They were drawn out, technically sound but meandering messes. Druckmann couldn't write a well-paced story to save his life. ND is fine from a financial standpoint, but Druckmann likes smell of his own farts too much to write a solid narrative.

The responses to this comment thread remind me of the "leave the multi-million dollar company alone!" meme. I think Hennig is a better writer than Druckmann and has done more and superior work than he has over the course of their respective careers. I didn't think that was a controversial take.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 605

IntrepidWombat

Not really tied to any particular game at the moment. I decided to get the Switch out and play a bit. I honestly forget it's there. I picked up Xenoblade Chronicles at a local shop, and I have Fire Emblem Three Houses on the way. Also finally started Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance and have Trails in the Sky FC on deck.

Echoes of the Living released in early access on Steam yesterday - if he gets the map and saving issues fixed, $20 is a bargain for how excellent the demo was.

We're celebrating my son's 15th birthday this weekend - I think lots of Madden and Smash Bros will be happening when his buddies get here.

Have a good weekend, everybody.

Re: Final Fantasy 7, Expedition 33 Prove There's Only Love Between RPG Rivals

IntrepidWombat

@somnambulance My favorite is when I hit enemies with a giant sword, and not only does it do next to no damage, they just shrug it off like it's nothing - no animation interruption or anything! But if a little rat tail hits the main character, expect him to go flying, lose half his health, and fly half way across the screen! Peak game design, IMO. Oh, and the enemy AI! It's so smart. It always knows which character you're controlling, so forget about swapping into a supporting role with a caster (that's for losers, right??) - you get all that aggro! Probably best, wouldn't want anyone to get complacent or anything. Not only that - once you swap, the AI hasn't done anything to fill ATB gauges. It doesn't steal that gameplay opportunity from you- brilliant, tbh. And all that is just the combat! Best RPGs ever!!

Re: Poll: Do You Play Horror Games Around Halloween?

IntrepidWombat

I just finished up Alone in the Dark. It had a lot of potential, it just lacked polish - and it was very short. For something scary this year, I may do a second play of Signalis or boot up Conscript. Parasite Eve II is another one - I remember years ago having a save at the final boss, but being soft locked because I had zero healing items. I should boot that game up, knuckle down, and finish it.

Re: Poll: Will You Be Buying Halo: Campaign Evolved on PS5?

IntrepidWombat

LAN multiplayer would have been an awesome throwback feature. I'll grab it when the price falls. The state of the physical release will determine how long I'm waiting. If it's like the rest of Microsoft's stuff, it'll be a couple years, and I'll grab it on sale when it hits the $15 range. If the game is complete on disc, I'd be fine paying $50ish.

Re: Random: Fans Can't Believe Halo Is Coming to PS5 Before Killzone

IntrepidWombat

Killzone wasn't that good. None of them were when stacked up against the third party offerings at the time. Call of Duty: Finest Hour and Black were both much better PS2 shooters. On PS3, Resistance: Fall of Man is still one of the best PlayStation exclusives ever, really. I didn't like the second one as much, but the first one caught lightning in a bottle. Their creativity was off the charts.

Re: 'Our Biggest Competition Isn't Another Console': Xbox Doubles Down on Multiformat After Halo PS5 Shock

IntrepidWombat

@LogicStrikesAgain I'm not arguing with your point, but want to point out that studios "making the most out of the hardware" was much more relevant in earlier generations when architectures were custom. The EE and Cell were unlike anything else, and from that standpoint, you're absolutely right. It took a lot of talent and institutional knowledge to make the games perform well. These days, everything is x86, except for the Switch, which is ARM (also ubiquitous since that's what our phones are). I don't think that aspect of your argument is as important now as it was 15 years ago.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 604

IntrepidWombat

I've been playing Alone in the Dark on PS5. The puzzles are neat - I like that you can set it not to hold your hand. The pacing is tight and formulaic (but in a good way). The writing lacks any kind of punch - it really doesn't take long for David Harbor to get comfortable with what's going on and just go with the flow. There's never really that, "OMG, what the hell is that?" moment. I know the character's name isn't David Harbor, but that's another issue. I don't particularly like when games use both the voice and likeness of a well-known actor. The facial animation isn't nearly good enough to let the actor become the character, and his script isn't convincing - he's just that dude from Stranger Things. The combat reminds me of the first Silent Hill in some ways. Melee combat doesn't always work as expected, but it's functional. The gunplay is discount Resident Evil 2 Remake.

For $25, this was a great pick-up. It's shaping up to be a solid 6/10 horror game.

Re: Final Fantasy 7 Remake Part 3 Will Be 'A Bit More Concise' Following Feedback on Rebirth's Filler

IntrepidWombat

"Just ignore the side content if you don't like it!" There's so much "side" content with so many rewards that the player who ignores it all is at a distinct disadvantage. The game is balanced towards completing the side content and earning those rewards. I'm not terribly good at the game, so I need every advantage that I can get. Ignoring the side quests in order to progress is not a great option because you miss on the experience gain and the items the game expects for you to have while doing them.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 603

IntrepidWombat

Wrapped up the story on Ivalice Chronicles. I love it every time. I could go right back to Trails in the Sky as I'm only a few hours in. I am in the mood for some horror - Alone in the Dark was down to $25 on Amazon, so it'll be here later today. I also still have Callisto Protocol that I picked up for $5 last year as well as Conscript still in plastic. Lastly - I have Dead Space 2 and 3 that I've never actually played. It wouldn't be hard to break out the PS3 get some of that deep backlog out of the way. In any case, it should be a good one.

Have a great weekend, everybody.

Re: Final Fantasy 7 Remake Part 3 'Will Be Loved by Everyone', Says Director

IntrepidWombat

I realized something in going through the comments and on reflecting on my time with it - Rebirth is a Japanese-made caricature of western RPGs. I don't tend to like western RPGs very much beyond the 15 hour mark - I find them boring and repetitive (radio towers...enough with the radio towers...). I cooled off on Assassin's Creed Odyssey in the same way. I have a feeling that a lot of people that are down on this game share the same sentiment.

I agree with an earlier comment in that Rebirth was a train wreck. Critics loved it, and it did well commercially - fine. It's all perspective. It's like watching a match between two teams. A resounding victory for Team A inside of Team A's stadium will receive near universal praise from those in attendance. For fans of Team B though, it's an awful collapse - and I'm Team B here.

Re: Confirmed: Oblivion Remastered's PS5 Physical Edition Requires 'Additional Download' to Actually Play

IntrepidWombat

This one and games like it are kind of a weird physical/digital hybrid - from a preservation standpoint, it's digital. They can yank it, change it, and make it so that you only play the version that they want you to play. On the other hand, you still have a physical manifestation of the license that you can sell, gift, exchange, etc. I guess it just depends on why you like physical copies in the first place.