For what it’s worth (maybe not much) IGN gave it an 8. I will wait for some more trusted sources on YouTube to give a fleshed out analysis before deciding, I really want to play in Old Italy but idk if they really brought the full package here based on the mixed responses and lack of transparency
I was really hyped for this but the more I have seen it just does not look like anything special at least from a gameplay perspective. I do love the setting though so I will see how the reviews turn out
The demo was fine but not nearly enough to make me open my wallet. Nothing innovative or particularly interesting to me so I’d rather play something with a better hook or at the very least better production value. Not going to compare everything to E33 but this was more expensive at launch and not even half as interesting so I don’t feel all that bad overlooking it
@DennisReynolds one nice thing they included in accessibility is the ability to turn down their intensity, not sure if you can completely get rid of them but you can minimize them significantly from my understanding. I love them though even if it means I can only ever play the game in small doses lol
@Coffeeglitch I suppose it’s kind of like a Death Stranding 2 situation where the core gameplay elements remain the same but the story is different and there’s a lot more options on how to approach things. That is working very well for me personally with DS2 and this looks like it will do the same. I guess I just don’t know what else anyone would expect
Very surprised by the negativity in these comments I thought it looked like it innovates a lot on the first game and made lots of engaging improvements. I am very much looking forward to it more now than I was before the SOP
I have yet to play Split Fiction but this list looks perfect to me. Cannot wait to get into that one. KCD2 and E33 are 1 and 1a for me but I agree with their ranking as well
@Bramble teams have deeply established roots and history in their cities with endless connections and meanings to individuals. I could understand your argument if they started the team yesterday but beyond that it holds no weight
@Ainu20 I think we should be safe just given the fact that this is only a fraction of the sales generated by a single player focused title in Elden ring. I know it’s early but it seems unlikely the game will come even close to the final sales figures of the main game, especially given the mixed reception to the quality of Nightreign. It makes sense for From to do side projects like this to make additional money and reach this kind of market but I’m hopeful that they still know where their bread is buttered
I like the show and the episode for what it is. It obviously will never compare to the game in terms of execution but I think it does a fine job conveying the story to the masses. I don't see massive issues in the writing although it can be heavy handed at times. Anyway I am enjoying it well enough
@Blacksmith1985 well it is 60 which I still consider full price, if it was 70 that would be even more egregious. It is a fun demo though and I do want to play the whole thing at some point
The demo is fun and charming but it is hard to imagine shelling out full price for a game like this when we are getting games like E33 and Mafia for 50 bucks. I do want to support these devs but the quality does not seem to match the asking price and I think it should have launched around 40 or 50 at most
@EfYI I am admittedly just a big hater of all things Don’t Nod but for me it’s a walking sim with terrible characters and a really weak story so I just don’t understand what anyone likes about it. But again just my opinion and I shouldn’t be raining on anyone’s parade for enjoying what they make
Esquie is one the funniest and strangest characters I’ve seen in media. He is just as confusing as he is lovable and I would buy this in a heartbeat, mon ami
@cburg "And just to be clear here, PlayStation is culpable in all this. While it may not be embracing the practice with its own software, it should be putting pressure on third-party publishers like Bethesda..." doesn't really read like "Sony good" to me
Sackboy ABA remains a great and underrated platformer. Love the old Little Big Planet games too and would happily play more. There is room for both him and Astro, could even be collaboration potential but alas it seems this is the end for our dear stitched friend
Such a power move to make a game of this quality only 50 bucks. Meanwhile assumedly lesser games are still more expensive in the latest PS store sale! I am waiting until my day off next month to fire this up, spent way too much money in April already but it seems amazing, really looking forward to diving in
lol the dinosaur! wtf was that. this looks so weird and like they just kind of shoved the Nightreign idea into a semi-Bloodborne universe with jet packs and dinosaurs. not upset to be missing out on another MP game, not playing Nightreign and certainly not getting a switch 2 for this
Comments 775
Re: Round Up: Total Lack of Mafia: The Old Country PS5 Reviews Is a Red Flag
For what it’s worth (maybe not much) IGN gave it an 8. I will wait for some more trusted sources on YouTube to give a fleshed out analysis before deciding, I really want to play in Old Italy but idk if they really brought the full package here based on the mixed responses and lack of transparency
Re: PS5 Sequel Darksiders 4 Has Online and Split-Screen Co-Op, By the Way
@pharos_haven it does, yes
Re: Mafia: The Old Country Averages 60fps in PS5 Performance Mode, No Word on PS5 Pro Support
I was really hyped for this but the more I have seen it just does not look like anything special at least from a gameplay perspective. I do love the setting though so I will see how the reviews turn out
Re: PS5, PS4's Vengeance Edition Helps Shin Megami Tensei 5 Reach 2 Million Sales
@B0udoir 7 is not a low score at all
Re: PS5, PS4's Vengeance Edition Helps Shin Megami Tensei 5 Reach 2 Million Sales
This game slaps. Hope more people play it. The soundtrack is unbelievable
Re: Mini Review: Wuchang: Fallen Feathers (PS5) - Decent Souls-Like Suffers Technically
Oh boy “serviceable” under pros is not a great sell lol this one looked pretty generic from the first trailer
Re: 'Increasingly Selective Consumers' to Blame for Underperformance of Blades of Fire
The demo was fine but not nearly enough to make me open my wallet. Nothing innovative or particularly interesting to me so I’d rather play something with a better hook or at the very least better production value. Not going to compare everything to E33 but this was more expensive at launch and not even half as interesting so I don’t feel all that bad overlooking it
Re: Dark Souls, Elden Ring Dev May Have Another New Game for 2026
@Frmknst what uhh...what games do you even like man?
Re: 2,800+ PS5, PS4 Games Going Cheap in New PS Store Summer Sale
@DennisReynolds one nice thing they included in accessibility is the ability to turn down their intensity, not sure if you can completely get rid of them but you can minimize them significantly from my understanding. I love them though even if it means I can only ever play the game in small doses lol
Re: Poll: Are You Sold on Ghost of Yotei?
@Coffeeglitch I suppose it’s kind of like a Death Stranding 2 situation where the core gameplay elements remain the same but the story is different and there’s a lot more options on how to approach things. That is working very well for me personally with DS2 and this looks like it will do the same. I guess I just don’t know what else anyone would expect
Re: Poll: Are You Sold on Ghost of Yotei?
Very surprised by the negativity in these comments I thought it looked like it innovates a lot on the first game and made lots of engaging improvements. I am very much looking forward to it more now than I was before the SOP
Re: Mini Review: Anger Foot (PS5) - Chaotic Kick-'Em-Up Satisfies from Head to Toe
@ShogunRok thanks Robert!
Re: Mini Review: Anger Foot (PS5) - Chaotic Kick-'Em-Up Satisfies from Head to Toe
@ShogunRok any idea how long it took to beat the main campaign?
Re: Feature: Top 20 PS5 Games of 2025 So Far
I have yet to play Split Fiction but this list looks perfect to me. Cannot wait to get into that one. KCD2 and E33 are 1 and 1a for me but I agree with their ranking as well
Re: Death Stranding 2 (PS5) - A Masterpiece in Every Sense
@scoobdoo the First Descendant is what you're using as a benchmark?!?!
Re: Death Stranding 2 (PS5) - A Masterpiece in Every Sense
@Artois2 because it was always going to be awesome
Re: Poll: What Were Your Favourite PS5 Games from State of Play? (June 2025)
007 and Pragmata look awesome. Biggest surprise was Romeo is a Dead Man. Looks really good for a Suda game I am looking forward to it quite a bit now
Re: Madden NFL 26's PS5 Box Art Immortalises One of the Coldest Moments in Recent Football Memory
@LikelySatan really weird argument. i get if it is not for you but it makes sense
Re: Madden NFL 26's PS5 Box Art Immortalises One of the Coldest Moments in Recent Football Memory
@Bramble teams have deeply established roots and history in their cities with endless connections and meanings to individuals. I could understand your argument if they started the team yesterday but beyond that it holds no weight
Re: Madden NFL 26's PS5 Box Art Immortalises One of the Coldest Moments in Recent Football Memory
@Bramble because, just as you said, the team is what represents the city
Re: Here's Your First Look at Project Spirits, the Next Flagship Title from the Makers of Stellar Blade
@saffeqwe to be fair GTA has both
Re: Elden Ring Nightreign's Enormous Success Continues, Now Over 3.5 Million Sales
@Ainu20 I think we should be safe just given the fact that this is only a fraction of the sales generated by a single player focused title in Elden ring. I know it’s early but it seems unlikely the game will come even close to the final sales figures of the main game, especially given the mixed reception to the quality of Nightreign. It makes sense for From to do side projects like this to make additional money and reach this kind of market but I’m hopeful that they still know where their bread is buttered
Re: Elden Ring Nightreign (PS5) - A Ruthless Roguelike Reinvention of the Lands Between
Decidedly not for me still given the online multiplayer focus but I am glad they aren't pumping out an overly watered down product
Re: HBO's The Last of Us Sees a Dramatic Decline in Season 2 Finale Viewers
@EfYI you will be missed
Re: Fortnite's AI Voiced Darth Vader Is Causing More Chaos in the Games Industry
I wouldn’t be surprised to learn this entire game was created by AI
Re: TV Show Review: The Last Of Us (HBO) Season 2 Episode 6 - Robbing the Story of Its Genius
I like the show and the episode for what it is. It obviously will never compare to the game in terms of execution but I think it does a fine job conveying the story to the masses. I don't see massive issues in the writing although it can be heavy handed at times. Anyway I am enjoying it well enough
Re: Play One of This Month's Most Promising PS5 Games Right Now
@guacguacboo 60 on PSN, I agree with you though
Re: Play One of This Month's Most Promising PS5 Games Right Now
@Blacksmith1985 well it is 60 which I still consider full price, if it was 70 that would be even more egregious. It is a fun demo though and I do want to play the whole thing at some point
Re: Play One of This Month's Most Promising PS5 Games Right Now
The demo is fun and charming but it is hard to imagine shelling out full price for a game like this when we are getting games like E33 and Mafia for 50 bucks. I do want to support these devs but the quality does not seem to match the asking price and I think it should have launched around 40 or 50 at most
Re: Massive Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 Patch 1.3, First DLC Out Now on PS5
@EfYI I am admittedly just a big hater of all things Don’t Nod but for me it’s a walking sim with terrible characters and a really weak story so I just don’t understand what anyone likes about it. But again just my opinion and I shouldn’t be raining on anyone’s parade for enjoying what they make
Re: Massive Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 Patch 1.3, First DLC Out Now on PS5
@EfYI congrats on not having to finish that poor excuse for a “game” lol
Re: Expedition 33 Dev to Turn the Game's Best Character into a Plushie
Esquie is one the funniest and strangest characters I’ve seen in media. He is just as confusing as he is lovable and I would buy this in a heartbeat, mon ami
Re: Expedition 33 Dev to Turn the Game's Best Character into a Plushie
@DonJorginho thanks for sharing this. Unbelievably awesome
Re: Reaction: Game Key PS5 Discs Are a Disgrace, and Sony Should Put a Stop to Them
@cburg "And just to be clear here, PlayStation is culpable in all this. While it may not be embracing the practice with its own software, it should be putting pressure on third-party publishers like Bethesda..." doesn't really read like "Sony good" to me
Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Clair Obscur: Expedition 33?
@Frmknst awful gameplay is crazy to say but I’ve seen your comments before so I know to take them with a hundred grains of salt
Re: LittleBigPlanet Erasure Continues as Sackboy Removed from PlayStation Productions Logo
Sackboy ABA remains a great and underrated platformer. Love the old Little Big Planet games too and would happily play more. There is room for both him and Astro, could even be collaboration potential but alas it seems this is the end for our dear stitched friend
Re: State of Play Set for Wednesday, 20 Minutes of Borderlands 4 Gameplay
wow you guys really hate Borderlands lol I will at least check it out
Re: Opinion: The PlayStation Concert Hits Some High Notes, But It's Missing a Few Strings
quite an interesting read here, thanks for sharing the experience!
Re: Site News: Where's Our Days Gone Remastered PS5 Review?
@MrPeanutbutterz just an arbitrary and subjective statement
Re: Site News: Where's Our Days Gone Remastered PS5 Review?
@NathanKang 8/10 for me. Love the gameplay, like the characters and story. Love the world. Opinions are opinions
Re: Hands On: Oblivion Remastered Is Still Oblivion in All Its Glory, Crap Frame Rate Aside
hope they patch this puppy up by the time i get around to it, probably not going to be for a few months
Re: Ghost of Yotei Gets PS5 Release Date, Trailer, Pre-Order Details
@AgentCooper I would be remiss to not compliment your Protomartyr one while we are on the subject
Re: Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 (PS5) - Daring, Quirky RPG Is an Absolute Must-Play
Such a power move to make a game of this quality only 50 bucks. Meanwhile assumedly lesser games are still more expensive in the latest PS store sale! I am waiting until my day off next month to fire this up, spent way too much money in April already but it seems amazing, really looking forward to diving in
Re: Poll: Are You Playing Oblivion Remastered?
@DennisReynolds get that woman a ring right now!
Re: So Much More Death Stranding 2 PS5 Coverage Coming 8th May
@Marquez good eye!
Re: Mini Review: Rusty Rabbit (PS5) - Predictable But Fun Metroidvania Starring Scavenging Rabbits
@motorrik6 if it falls into genre trappings and doesn't do anything unique or interesting with them then yes, it makes sense to lose points for that
Re: Mafia: The Old Country Release Date Leaked, Out 8th August on PS5
Awesome. Cannot wait for this and right in time to wrap up death stranding
Re: New Animated PS5 Wallpapers for Welcome Hub Let You Celebrate PS Studios Hits
Give us a Death Stranding 2 one! instead of rise of the ronin lol
Re: Bloodborne, Elden Ring Dev Won't Be Releasing Its Next Big Game on PS5
@piratemajima relax it aint that deep
Re: Bloodborne, Elden Ring Dev Won't Be Releasing Its Next Big Game on PS5
lol the dinosaur! wtf was that. this looks so weird and like they just kind of shoved the Nightreign idea into a semi-Bloodborne universe with jet packs and dinosaurs. not upset to be missing out on another MP game, not playing Nightreign and certainly not getting a switch 2 for this