Comments 2,850

Re: Bubsy 4D (PS5) - The Best of a Bad Bunch

Nem

@Propaperpusher There is a demo. It isn't bad. It's just low budget. It has a Sonic feel to it. There is even a Sonic outfit for Bubsy.
For the budget it's got, it's a surprisingly fun game. Don't expect a AAA experience though. This is very much an indie level game. More comparable to Yooka-layle or whatever that is called.

Re: PS5's New Weekly Player Tracker Has Revealed Some Brutal Truths for Fans

Nem

Very easily can argue. There is a limited pool of players and hours for that kind of experience.
People playing those games can't magically play others at the same time and won't easily jump ship after investing time and money on their game of choice which on it's own now has years of content support.
So, no, it's not a case of throw 10 at the wall and one will stick. Probably none will stick after the turists go back to their game of choice.

On the topic of single player games, live services are designed to make you log on daily and do tasks. Of course the predatory design will result in more play hours. That's the point.
Single player games can be played at any time and do not "force" you to keep logging on to progress. It's a chill and pure experience. Play time is not the metric to measure their sucess.

Re: Is Bungie Sony's Worst Ever Acquisition After $765 Million Write-Down?

Nem

Well... yeah it was a weird acquisition to begin with. Another little morsel leftover from Jim Ryan's dumb live service push.
Though looking at how they have closed other studios they bought, i am not sure there were any other better acquisitions. I think they need to sort themselves out first, before bringing others in.

Re: Steelrising, GreedFall PS5 Dev Spiders Is Reportedly Soon to Close

Nem

Ah well... that's a shame.
I really enjoyed their mars war logs and technomancer games as well as Bound by flame.
The stuff they did after didn't appeal to me. I really wanted more of those two worlds. They should have focused on those IP. They tried to do it with Greedfall and the new prequel but it was too late.
I do think you need to build an IP fanbase to give you stability. They liked making new IP a bit too much for their own good.

I hope the other studios pull through.
Kyloton makes rally games i enjoy. I didn't get anything from Cyanide but those Styx games look good.

Re: 'We're Going to Pull Funding if You Don't Fix This': Uncharted 4 Was Almost Cancelled on PS4 Because It 'Sucked'

Nem

@PuppetMaster

First, you can have your opinion about uncharted 3. It's not the same as mine.

Second, it is you that wants to place all the blame on Amy.

"Excuses", "didn't do well". Because that's what happens, right? People leave their job at Sony and they must build a studio, get funding in the order of the hundreds of millions and release a game in 4 years or they are clearly incompetent.
It doesn't matter. What she has done after has no bearing on what happened before.

Sorry, but Amy shipped several hits including the first 3 uncharted's. Heck she is credited as the franchise creator.

Your assumptions are just that. You do not know what went down and why it went down.

If a co-worker goes to the boss and says you are doing a bad job, even though you proved yourself time and again in the company, what do you call that? I don't know what was going wrong, but something was.

Re: 'We're Going to Pull Funding if You Don't Fix This': Uncharted 4 Was Almost Cancelled on PS4 Because It 'Sucked'

Nem

@Ainu20 what's not realistic is that a team that made 3 uncharted games unlearned how to make them. Heck, i am certain this has nothing to do with the writing, but rather the gameplay. Many games are developed in pieces and are put together at the end. So, this demo could not be anything but a taste.
The question is why did an experienced team seemingly didn't impress? There is more context here and just blaming it on an experienced and proven director is not something i will do. She was undermined, that much is obvious to me.

Re: 'We're Going to Pull Funding if You Don't Fix This': Uncharted 4 Was Almost Cancelled on PS4 Because It 'Sucked'

Nem

@cainhurst94

I don't see her credited with any frankenstein game. Dunno where you are getting this.

The game is not indefinitly delayed. The statement was that it was delayed from it's early 2026 release window. It should still come out later this year or early in the next.
Also, as i said in the other post, let's not act like naughty dog has been doing peachy and has shipped lots of new games in the last decade.

Re: 'We're Going to Pull Funding if You Don't Fix This': Uncharted 4 Was Almost Cancelled on PS4 Because It 'Sucked'

Nem

@PuppetMaster
Ok,let's go in parts.

First Uncharted 3 was actually quite good and i don't agree with that exageration. The story was pretty good. It explored the past of nate and the special substance that gave alucinations made the story unpredictable. I don't think it was badly written at all. Yeah, some people might not like the supernatural aspect, but it's always been a part of these indiana jones like games. Tomb raider was the same.

Most games tend to not have just one writer. Regardless, it's uncontestable that she has a great track record of success with different teams and that she is the creator of Uncharted.

It wasn't her star wars project that was cancelled per se but the studio visceral games that she joined a year prior that was shutdown by EA because of Battlefield hardline failing to meet expectations. It's the default EA behaviour.

After that she did indeed start up a new studio with skydance from scratch, which is not easy to do. Marvel 1943 has currently a release date for the later half of 2026, but it's coming. Many other famous developers have tried to do this and failed. She is still going and a game will seemingly get shipped.

I don't know if uncharted 4 struggled. I believe it more likely it was a someone trying to fish for a promotion by throwing others under the bus. A team that made 3 uncharted games doesn't just unlearn hiw to make them from one game to the next. There is some context missing.

Also, let's not pretend naughty dog has been just peachy since she left. The only game they made after uncharted 4 which was a leftover, was the last of us 2. Not like things have been peachy either.

Re: 'We're Going to Pull Funding if You Don't Fix This': Uncharted 4 Was Almost Cancelled on PS4 Because It 'Sucked'

Nem

@StitchJones Same can be said about any other director. Opening a studio, securing funding and developing and shipping a game these days aren't easy tasks.
After ND she was in some EA studio that was working on a star wars game before it was closed. We had some leaked footage and it looked great. After that she started a studio with skydance.
Besides, you are well aware she got a game coming out soon.

Also uncharted wasn't her first sucess as she raised legacy of kain/soul reaver into legendary status.

So, no, the writing was not the problem and it clearly was a gameplay demo.
Still, i think this was someone who saw their chance at a promotion and decided to stirr up crap.

Re: Xbox Will 'Reevaluate' Its Game Exclusivity, Throwing Potential Doubt Over PS5 Ports

Nem

They can re-evaluate whatever they want. The Xbox platform audience is not large enough to sustain triple A game development.
PC helps them, but the big money is on playstation and nintendo and they know it.

They are free to nuke themselves some more though. Doesn't bother me. I doubt the shareholders will be happy when the division profits go down though.