In my opinion, what PlayStation desperately needs is a visionary or set of oddballs in the building that can create unique multiplayer games that have that spark and actually penetrate the market. Their current creative culture is too boring and out-of-touch for this live service thing to work on the level Nishino envisions.
The Witcher 3 is maybe my favorite game of the 2010's, but the amount of deceptive and arrogant bull**** CDPR pulled before and during the 1.0 of Cyberpunk 2077 liquidated all of the goodwill they got from me after Witcher 3 and left an immensely sour taste in my mouth. I can't even honestly say I'm that excited about their future projects, including Witcher 4.
I hate to be that guy, but Xbox shutting down Compulsion (especially after the dud that was South of Midnight) does not surprise me at all. Compulsion has great ideas, but executes them in such boring ways. With their shoddy quality control and stupidly long development times, they have no business being in this industry. Ironically, as incompetent as Xbox is, axing Compulsion is a very rare sound decision from them.
@MrPeanutbutterz I 100% agree with you. With a few exceptions, I think Xbox's output quality this generation has ranged from incredibly mediocre to downright atrocious. I've had my major issues with PlayStation's output this gen, but none of their games have sunk to the bewildering low of crap like Redfall and Hellblade 2.
Ironically, I think Xbox has a very similar problem with their curated playerbase that PlayStation now does, just in a different way. They've trained and cultivated this core playerbase to expect a very specific thing for so long that any attempts at getting them to try new things is not going to work without major and long-term shifting of expectations and brand image. Xbox needs to cut the major anchor around their neck that is Game Pass and really refocus on training their playerbase to actually buy their stuff and create trust that it will be consistently good, but I have a hard time believing they have the vision and cache to pull it off.
@AdamNovice The benefit is so Asha can score brownie points from Klobrille, Jez Corden, Tom Warren, Colt Eastwood, and the rest of the Xbox journo/influencer sycophants because they're jumping right back into the incredibly stupid strategy of building a bizarre parasocial relationship with these people.
If they want a consistently healthy business with these exclusives, then they need to stop putting all of these Xbox-published games on Game Pass day one. Simple as that.
Wow, I'm shocked that I'm maybe the most positive person in this comment section, so far, about Hellblade 3, considering I absolutely HATED Hellblade 2. This looks to be way more in line with what I really liked about the first Hellblade.
Also, yeah, this going to PS5 but Clockwork Revolution and E-Day not makes zero sense to me.
This should be the case with ALL of the new Xbox-published stuff they announced at the showcase. Also, that explanation from Xbox PR makes no sense considering Hellblade 3, State of Decay 3, and Spyro are going to PS5 as well.
And what happened to the Xbox faithful who parroted the cringe-inducing "when everybody plays, we all win" line and said exclusives were outdated and anti-consumer? Or maybe that was utter bull**** to begin with? Hmmmmmm
Looks really cool, but their exclusives "strategy" seems like Asha Sharma is just throwing random shots at a dartboard. I'm sure the Xbox fanatics on Twitter are creaming in their pants, though. Good for them getting two exclusives, I guess.
Considering that the trailer has over a million views on PlayStation's YouTube channel alone, I think there's still a decent-sized audience who would pick this up. I don't know what PlayStation expects out of this, but that remains to be seen.
@glennthefrog @Oram77 Yeah, I get that Nakamura was trying to do her whole cute and quirky thing again that people liked at that E3 ages ago, but it really did not work for me this time around. Nothing against her personally. It's just that after a rather bland and overlong gameplay presentation, the last thing I want to see is a follow-up developer interview where the interviewee is trying too hard to recapture some kind of vibe and it comes off as mildly annoying instead.
I actually thought pacing was the biggest issue with this SoP. It had a very strong opening and finale, but the middle was more hit or miss for me, especially when they spent way too much time on games that didn't grab my attention like Dune Awakening, Ace Combat 8, and especially Kemuri. Also, Kena: Scars of Kosmora being MIA when it's supposed to drop this year was an odd omission.
@Olskeezy Oh no, I was agreeing with you by adding to your point about the people that come out of the woodwork to say AI crap is "inevitable" to justify burying their heads in the sand. Everything you said is 100% on point.
Besides the really bland looking protagonist, this looks magnificent.
I'm so happy they changed direction for this, because I've been a little nervous about the much darker original vision they had for this with "choice-based" story design. But this much brighter and more traditional vision is way more my jam. Can't wait!
I'll throw my hat in the ring on "no, I don't think it will". Unless those experimental PvE modes are game-changing things that attract an enormous number of consistent players, I think the die is already cast.
@AdamNovice There's a big difference between "not every game is for everyone" and "eye-rolling waste of time that will actively piss off your core audience". Fairgames (Break In, now, maybe, I guess) is clearly in the latter category.
Comments 3,308
Re: Originally Free, You Can Now Pay $70 to Own the Worst Silent Hill Game
$70 for this trash game is highway robbery.
Re: 'Maybe People Won't Like It': Expedition 33 Dev's Next Game Will Make Some 'Drastic Decisions'
Whatever it is, I just want something completely different from E33.
Re: This Backrooms Game Outsold Every PS5 Title on PS Store Last Month
Hulst is greenlighting a Backrooms Horizon game as we speak.
Re: 'I Don't Know What They're Thinking': Ex-PlayStation Boss Weighs in on Sony's PC Port Backtracking
This is the rare thing I disagree with Shawn Laydon about.
Re: Sony Will Continue to Chase Live Service Dream, Despite Mostly Disastrous Execution to Date
In my opinion, what PlayStation desperately needs is a visionary or set of oddballs in the building that can create unique multiplayer games that have that spark and actually penetrate the market. Their current creative culture is too boring and out-of-touch for this live service thing to work on the level Nishino envisions.
Re: Bungie Confirms Studio Layoffs After Destiny 2 Content Ends
That imbecile Hermen Hulst and his team of yes-men should also be shown the door, but that will never happen, sadly.
Re: See So Many More AA PS5 Games in THQ Nordic's Showcase This August
@PuppetMaster Sadly, it's really difficult for me to look at this list and not automatically think "damn, most of these will probably bomb".
Re: The Last of Us 2 Is Finally Getting Multiplayer, But Naughty Dog Ain't Making It
There is no way Sony won't send a cease and desist to the makers of this mod, right?
Re: The Witcher 4 Can't Be Another Cyberpunk 2077, and CD Projekt Red Knows It
The Witcher 3 is maybe my favorite game of the 2010's, but the amount of deceptive and arrogant bull**** CDPR pulled before and during the 1.0 of Cyberpunk 2077 liquidated all of the goodwill they got from me after Witcher 3 and left an immensely sour taste in my mouth. I can't even honestly say I'm that excited about their future projects, including Witcher 4.
Re: Housemarque Hints Its Next PS5 Game Could Be Smaller Than Saros
Please god no more roguelites
Re: South of Midnight Maker Said to Be Shuttered by Xbox
I hate to be that guy, but Xbox shutting down Compulsion (especially after the dud that was South of Midnight) does not surprise me at all. Compulsion has great ideas, but executes them in such boring ways. With their shoddy quality control and stupidly long development times, they have no business being in this industry. Ironically, as incompetent as Xbox is, axing Compulsion is a very rare sound decision from them.
Re: Poll: What's Your PS5 Game of the Year for 2026 So Far?
RE Requiem for me and nothing else I've played on PS5 this year comes even close.
Re: Even with PS5 Ports, Many of Xbox's Games Have Been Underperfoming
@MrPeanutbutterz I 100% agree with you. With a few exceptions, I think Xbox's output quality this generation has ranged from incredibly mediocre to downright atrocious. I've had my major issues with PlayStation's output this gen, but none of their games have sunk to the bewildering low of crap like Redfall and Hellblade 2.
Re: Even with PS5 Ports, Many of Xbox's Games Have Been Underperfoming
Ironically, I think Xbox has a very similar problem with their curated playerbase that PlayStation now does, just in a different way. They've trained and cultivated this core playerbase to expect a very specific thing for so long that any attempts at getting them to try new things is not going to work without major and long-term shifting of expectations and brand image. Xbox needs to cut the major anchor around their neck that is Game Pass and really refocus on training their playerbase to actually buy their stuff and create trust that it will be consistently good, but I have a hard time believing they have the vision and cache to pull it off.
Re: Kingdom Hearts 4 PS5 Release Date Hopium Hits New High
No way in hell is this coming in 2027. Even 2028 seems too early to me. They haven't even started revealing the Disney worlds yet.
Re: Add It to the Pile: Crunchy Action RPG Crimson Moon Confirms September Release on PS5
To be fair, Probably Monsters aren't exactly known for being smart decision-makers, besides selling off Concord.
Re: Xbox Will 'Try to Do More' Console Exclusives if the Health of Its Business Improves
@AdamNovice The benefit is so Asha can score brownie points from Klobrille, Jez Corden, Tom Warren, Colt Eastwood, and the rest of the Xbox journo/influencer sycophants because they're jumping right back into the incredibly stupid strategy of building a bizarre parasocial relationship with these people.
Re: Xbox Will 'Try to Do More' Console Exclusives if the Health of Its Business Improves
If they want a consistently healthy business with these exclusives, then they need to stop putting all of these Xbox-published games on Game Pass day one. Simple as that.
Re: Sony 'Exploring New Ways' to Deliver PS Plus Games
Considering I'm going to be downgrading back to Essential in a few months, I don't really care.
Re: Destiny 3 Isn't in Development, But It May Have Been the Most Talked About Game of the Last Week
I find it really interesting that even the BBC covered the end of Destiny 2.
Re: Rumour: Halo PS5 Trailer Was Planned for State of Play, Sony Allegedly Angered by Removal
Asha must have seen an Xbox influencer on Twitter threaten to boycott Xbox if Halo was at the State of Play.
Re: Senua's Saga: Hellblade 2 Is Now Hellblade 2: Senua's Saga
Having the subtitle listed before the series name is a pretentious trend I want to see die.
Re: Hellblade Returns in 2027 with New Game Senua on PS5
Wow, I'm shocked that I'm maybe the most positive person in this comment section, so far, about Hellblade 3, considering I absolutely HATED Hellblade 2. This looks to be way more in line with what I really liked about the first Hellblade.
Also, yeah, this going to PS5 but Clockwork Revolution and E-Day not makes zero sense to me.
Re: Immersive Sim Clockwork Revolution Joins Gears of War in Skipping PS5
@PSbox I'd actually respect Xbox a lot if they had the confidence to make ES6 an Xbox exclusive.
Re: Immersive Sim Clockwork Revolution Joins Gears of War in Skipping PS5
@UltimateOtaku91 In the famous words of Asha Sharma: "the plan isn't the plan until it is the plan until it isn't a plan."
Re: 'These Are Not Timed Exclusives': Xbox Says Gears of War, Clockwork Revolution Are Never Coming to PS5
This should be the case with ALL of the new Xbox-published stuff they announced at the showcase. Also, that explanation from Xbox PR makes no sense considering Hellblade 3, State of Decay 3, and Spyro are going to PS5 as well.
And what happened to the Xbox faithful who parroted the cringe-inducing "when everybody plays, we all win" line and said exclusives were outdated and anti-consumer? Or maybe that was utter bull**** to begin with? Hmmmmmm
Re: Immersive Sim Clockwork Revolution Joins Gears of War in Skipping PS5
Looks really cool, but their exclusives "strategy" seems like Asha Sharma is just throwing random shots at a dartboard. I'm sure the Xbox fanatics on Twitter are creaming in their pants, though. Good for them getting two exclusives, I guess.
Re: Persona 6 Finally Announced for PS5 with a Surprisingly Dark Reveal
I needed footage, but the horror tone is intriguing.
Re: Rumour: Gears of War: E-Day Was Coming to PS5, Xbox Cancelled Port Very Recently
GOOD. This should remain a permanent Xbox console exclusive, especially if it turns out to be terrific.
Re: PS5's Until Dawn 2 Has Been in Development for At Least 4 Years Already
Considering that the trailer has over a million views on PlayStation's YouTube channel alone, I think there's still a decent-sized audience who would pick this up. I don't know what PlayStation expects out of this, but that remains to be seen.
Re: PS5's Until Dawn 2 Has Been in Development for At Least 4 Years Already
@Americansamurai1 The rumor was that it's using Unreal Engine 5, but it hasn't been officially confirmed.
Re: PS5's Fairgames Dodged State of Play, But Could It Be Rebranded at Summer Game Fest?
Give it to Xbox for their showcase 😂
Re: PS5 vs Pepperoni Pizza: New God of War Sparks Tense Exchange Between Sony and Domino's
This is getting embarrassing...
Re: Another Marathon Mess as Bungie Changes Misleading PS5 Store Description
Bungie - expertise in stepping on rakes
Re: Reaction: Leaks Robbed State of Play of Its Biggest Surprise, But Show Still Spotlighted Many PS5 Games I'll Buy
@glennthefrog @Oram77 Yeah, I get that Nakamura was trying to do her whole cute and quirky thing again that people liked at that E3 ages ago, but it really did not work for me this time around. Nothing against her personally. It's just that after a rather bland and overlong gameplay presentation, the last thing I want to see is a follow-up developer interview where the interviewee is trying too hard to recapture some kind of vibe and it comes off as mildly annoying instead.
Re: Reaction: Leaks Robbed State of Play of Its Biggest Surprise, But Show Still Spotlighted Many PS5 Games I'll Buy
I actually thought pacing was the biggest issue with this SoP. It had a very strong opening and finale, but the middle was more hit or miss for me, especially when they spent way too much time on games that didn't grab my attention like Dune Awakening, Ace Combat 8, and especially Kemuri. Also, Kena: Scars of Kosmora being MIA when it's supposed to drop this year was an odd omission.
Re: Poll: How Would You Rate State of Play for June 2026?
Laufey looks way better than I expected it to. Other than that and Wolverine, I thought it was fine.
Re: Xbox Will Show PS5 Logos at Showcase, But May Adjust Moving Forward as Execs Publicly Contradict Each Other
Of course it's a Klobrille tweet she's responding to. 🙄
Re: 'Have Fun in the Festering Slop Pit': Hideo Kojima Underfire for Generative AI Short
@Olskeezy Oh no, I was agreeing with you by adding to your point about the people that come out of the woodwork to say AI crap is "inevitable" to justify burying their heads in the sand. Everything you said is 100% on point.
Re: 'Have Fun in the Festering Slop Pit': Hideo Kojima Underfire for Generative AI Short
@Olskeezy 100% agree. Also, inevitable things don't automatically make them acceptable or artistically valid.
Re: 'Have Fun in the Festering Slop Pit': Hideo Kojima Underfire for Generative AI Short
To hear the director of great, passionately made films like Bronson and Drive say this prattle to justify AI trash is so disheartening.
I know Kojima will get most of the backlash, but I think Refn's involvement offends me more. It's disgraceful.
Re: Dragon Quest 12 Renamed and Re-Revealed After Development Restart, First Gameplay Shown
@TartarusBlack That last sentence killed me. 😂
Re: Dragon Quest 12 Renamed and Re-Revealed After Development Restart, First Gameplay Shown
Besides the really bland looking protagonist, this looks magnificent.
I'm so happy they changed direction for this, because I've been a little nervous about the much darker original vision they had for this with "choice-based" story design. But this much brighter and more traditional vision is way more my jam. Can't wait!
Re: Can Season 2 Turn Bungie's Marathon Around?
I'll throw my hat in the ring on "no, I don't think it will". Unless those experimental PvE modes are game-changing things that attract an enormous number of consistent players, I think the die is already cast.
Re: Capcom Is Sitting on a Goldmine of PS5 Announcements - But When Are They Coming?
I'm still waiting on the next Ace Attorney 😫
Re: Rumour: Dragon Quest Has Multiple Major Reveals Lined Up for Its Big Day This Week
I would lose my **** if a DQ8 remaster got revealed.
Re: The Next Kingdom Come Game Is a Lot Closer Than You Think
Even if it's a quarter of KCD2's depth and scope, I'll gladly accept that if it means the project pipeline is more manageable and fast.
Re: Bungie Is Not Making Destiny 3, Dev to Be Rocked by 'Significant' Layoffs
$3.6 billion well spent
Re: Talking Point: Sony, Don't Re-Reveal Fairgames at the Next State of Play
@AdamNovice There's a big difference between "not every game is for everyone" and "eye-rolling waste of time that will actively piss off your core audience". Fairgames (Break In, now, maybe, I guess) is clearly in the latter category.
Re: Talking Point: Sony, Don't Re-Reveal Fairgames at the Next State of Play
Now PlayStation will do it just to spite you, Sammy.