Comments 1,712

Re: PS5 Fans Vote Jak & Daxter As Their Most Wanted PlayStation Revival

wildcat_kickz

To be honest, of the five IP that were in the poll, I've only beaten Killzone Shadowfall, but the idea of Resistance coming back seems coolest to me. I love that alt-history stuff.

I just don't think the PlayStation fanbase is there for more platformers, but I'd be happy to be wrong. Astro Bot may have won GotY, but I don't think it sold more than a couple million. A great success, to be sure, but I don't know if it warrants a return to a focus on platformers. Astro with a side of Ratchet seems plenty, to me (at least from 1st party).

Re: No One Noticed Intergalactic's Hidden Naughty Dog Easter Egg

wildcat_kickz

@DadJKP You sniffed it out? Are you serious? How could you possibly glean that from a single trailer? Yeah, she's cocky. Just about every protagonist is until they're presented with substantial conflict where they're humbled by circumstance. It's called "a character arc."

Listen, man - there's no guarantee that this game will be good or great, but there's no guarantee that it will suck either. Past performance is the greatest predicter of future success. Even if you didn't like TLOU2's story (I didn't love it), that's one out of the last 7 games that wasn't an absolute banger.

Re: No One Noticed Intergalactic's Hidden Naughty Dog Easter Egg

wildcat_kickz

@DadJKP I really don't understand the "girl boss" angle. Does Sony have too many recent first party games with female leads? Maybe, but that's at a macro level. It doesn't really have anything to do with an individual game's quality or promise.

You not wanting a game with a strong female lead is whatever, but pretending that you speak for the majority of people is far from accurate.

Re: Lies of P Dev Is Making Headlines, But Not for Reasons Anyone Wants to Hear

wildcat_kickz

@RoomWithaMoose Yeah that's perfectly fair. I didn't articulate my position very well. I don't think what we consider ethically acceptable should change based on where the product is coming from, but I think the way that AI is talked about does change. In Korea, or even more so in China, they'll more openly talk about using various types of AI because there's less cultural stigma. Plenty of Western companies are using AI as much or more so than these Eastern examples, but are more cagey about it because they know they'll get backlash to it. I'd rather have it out in the open, personally.

I do still think that the anti-AI vitriol, as you call it, does devalue the argument though because it just creates more noise that you have to cut through to get to the actually cogent arguments. "AI is evil" is just lazy and does a disservice to many of the technologies that fall under that umbrella.

Re: Lies of P Dev Is Making Headlines, But Not for Reasons Anyone Wants to Hear

wildcat_kickz

@RoomWithaMoose Corporations will say whatever they need to to satiate their shareholders, so I don't really put any stock in Nintendo's statements, but we can put that aside.

Regarding the ethics of generative AI, I largely agree, but only to a point. This entire article is about a single job posting. No mission statements saying that Round 8 will integrate gen AI into their shipped product. No information about how extensive or intrusive the position will be. I read the job posting and some of it seems fine and some of it is stuff I wouldn't want, but I didn't see anything egregious.

My main issue is that people are so trigger happy to scream "doom" over every little thing that has "AI" in the name without learning about any of the context. It's exhausting.

The more people flip every single time AI is mentioned, the more devalued that outrage will be when it really matters.

Re: Rumour: Rayman Legends Remake May Be Announced This Summer

wildcat_kickz

@The_ghostmen Even so, that doesn't seem like enough to warrant a remake. The art-style isn't something that ages the same way a 3d game would, so I can't really see a new version looking "better." You could easily make changes to the things you brought up without needing to do the whole game over.

Re: Lies of P Dev Is Making Headlines, But Not for Reasons Anyone Wants to Hear

wildcat_kickz

Something to keep in mind that the article doesn't mention is that broadly speaking, there isn't a cultural backlash for companies to openly embrace AI in the East. It's seemingly a uniquely Western stance to be very much against gen AI.

As I'm Western, it should come as no surprise that I'm typically against gen AI, but I try not to hold it against Eastern companies, where there just isn't the same cultural pushback.

Re: Poll: Uncharted 4 Turns 10 Years Old, But Is It the Series' Peak?

wildcat_kickz

I love them all, but 4 is definitely my favorite. The supernatural angle of the earlier games always felt a little off, so I appreciated them ditching it for 4. The gameplay in 4 is also top tier with some of the best action sequences of any game, period.

Uncharted 4
Uncharted 2*
Uncharted Lost Legacy*
Uncharted 3*
Uncharted 1

*All basically tied

Re: The Sinking City 2 Only Months Away, Survival Horror Gameplay Revealed

wildcat_kickz

@Ken_Kaniff The first game is more dialog-driven and detective sleuthing - it's earie, not scary. For 2, they made the decision to pivot to survival horror in the vein of Resident Evil. It's definitely a bold choice because the combat in the first game is really rough, but they're really focusing on tuning it up this go around.

The jank isn't going away; it's a small team based out of Kiev, but they really love the Cthulhu mythos and I think they do a better job than most in replicating that atmosphere in video games. The only other example I can think of for a dev doing it really well is The Call of Cthulhu game by Cyanide.

Re: MindsEye Saga Hits a New Low as Mass Layoffs Cripple PS5 Flop's 'Comeback'

wildcat_kickz

There's no scenario where this game gets turned around. Even if the game were to miraculously become a competent product, the studio's and the game's names have been so damaged that no one wants to touch it with a ten foot pole. I would say that Leslie Benzies should be finished in the video game industry, but we've seen people fail upwards time and time again.

Re: A Nail in PS4's Coffin, Call of Duty Will Finally Ditch Last-Gen Console

wildcat_kickz

@Northern_munkey The lack of destructible environments actually can be viewed in a positive light. Standard CoD MP is at a much smaller scale than Battlefield and they put a lot of time into making sure the maps flow well. Adding a ton of destruction would change the flow of the maps and make them feel less balanced and fun. In Battlefield, the "flow" of a map isn't as important on a micro-scale because the maps are so big and have so many players on them. Regarding the weird skins, I'm not bothered as long as the art style remains consistent. If Messi headshots Snoop, that's fine, but I just don't want cell-shaded stuff in the game.

I still have the opinion that CoD gunplay (especially Infinity Ward) runs circles around Battlefield.

Re: Lords of the Fallen 2's Idea of Female Armour Is Downright Embarrassing

wildcat_kickz

@LiamCroft I know a lot of people are dogging on you for this, but, respectfully, some do have a point. Eastern games use the skimpy trope all the time and it's never called "low effort" on this website. I personally find this design philosophy groan-worthy, but there is a legitimate double-standard seemingly applied here.

I don't recall any articles on Push Square ragging on Dragon Age for making really blatant decisions to appeal to a very progressive audience. I'm a liberal and even I found it beyond the pale.

Edit: To be clear, devs have the right to make any game they want with any message they want, but it does sometimes feel like an "emperor has no clothes" situation.

Re: Lords of the Fallen 2's Idea of Female Armour Is Downright Embarrassing

wildcat_kickz

Don't really understand what DEI has to do with revealing clothing, but whatever, I guess. Conservatives have completely removed all meaning from that term. Now it's just a blanket term for things they don't like.

Regarding the outfits, I don't really understand the all-or-nothing approach. Why not have some skimpy outfits and some practical ones? The same goes for the dudes' armor sets, too.