Comments 839

Re: Poll: What Are Your Thoughts on Bloodborne, 10 Years Later?

StrickenBiged

For me, Sekiro has to go on top as From Software's best game. That combat was just so dialled in, it had a story that you could actually follow, and because it focussed on a single weapon your options for cheesing hard fights were more limited ('git gud' actually means something in Sekiro).

Bloodborne is second - the setting and trick weapons were incredible.

Not sure where I'd place everything after that. Probably Dark Souls 1 is third for the interconnected world.

Re: Assassin's Creed Shadows (PS5) - Striking Open World RPG Is a Real Cut Above

StrickenBiged

80 hours... eeeeeehhhhh...

I enjoyed playing Mirage last year, but I had platinumed that after around half of this estimate. 80 hours seems far too big.

I really regret this larger RPG version of AC, and that some of my most anticipated settings for AC games (Ancient Greece, Vikings, and now Feudal Japan) have been wasted (from my perspective) on this format of game.

Re: Sony Confirms PS Portal's Status as 'DadStation' in Accurate Ad

StrickenBiged

Since getting my Portal, I love it when Mrs wants to watch a show that I have zero interest in, and I can say "that's fine honey, I'll just noodle about on my Portal".

They've nailed the use case with this ad as far as I'm concerned.

But no way am I just handing over a game in progress to some idiot kid to screw up for me. My saves are mine, get your own.

Re: The Last of Us-Themed PS5 Controller Available to Pre-Order Now

StrickenBiged

@PrincessPeach11 No need to go into the store to test for stick drift. You can test your controllers with various apps on your phone. Pair the phone with the dualsense via bluetooth and a diagram of the controller on the phone screen will tell you which buttons you're pressing and where it thinks the sticks are (which can be useful for diagnosing drift).

On iOS the one I use is called "Game Controller Tester Gamepad". https://apps.apple.com/us/app/game-controller-tester-gamepad/id1497587957

Re: As War on AI Rages, Two Zenless Zone Zero Stars Say They Were Replaced Without Prior Notice

StrickenBiged

I refuse to believe that there isn't some amount of money which would be fair compensation to licence someone's voice to use with AI.
The VA get's a reduced paycheck compared to giving all the lines their personal touch and the benefit of the performance, while the studio benefits from reduced overheads.
But importantly, the VA gets their time back to go and do more lucrative VA work, for the studios that are interested in an actual performance, and not just having words read off the page.
It should go without saying that this should require a bespoke contract covering the use of someone's voice with AI. I don't think it's moral or fair for studios to train AI models on voice recordings which were not made for that purpose.

Re: Death Stranding 2 Puts Early Access Incentives Under the Microscope All Over Again

StrickenBiged

Let's face it, "early access" release day is the true release day now, and games cost c. £100 or whatever they charge for these "early access" versions. And what was formerly the release day is now the day on which you can buy the game at a discount.

The publishers just found a way to increase the retail price of games beyond the new-normal of £70 without most people noticing or getting upset about it.

Re: Sony Expands Its PS5 Console Rental Service to the UK

StrickenBiged

This would only make sense for short term rentals. Anyone looking at the 3 year option would do much better to explore buying the console on credit.

But to get hold of a device cheaply without a long term commitment, to blast through a particular game like GTAVI or something when it comes out, I can see there maybe being a market for something like this.

Re: Epic Games' War on Fortnite Cheaters Continues, Fraudster Exposed

StrickenBiged

It's a shame that it's fallen to Epic to do this. I dunno about the USA, but here in the UK those would be criminal allegations. With the vast majority of crime being online these days, law enforcement really needs to get with the times.

And when are people going to get the message and stop re-using passwords and enable 2FA.

Re: Could the Next Xbox Get a Head Start on PS6?

StrickenBiged

It would make sense for XBox to try and get a head start. They forwent a mid-gen 'pro' model this time, so don't have a model on the market which is the new-hotness. But if they do launch something next year, it won't be meaningfully different from the PS5 Pro without being dramatically more expensive (assuming they don't want to make it a loss leader).

With millions more PS5s on the market, one has to wonder to what extent developers would support any higher-end features that the NeXtBox would offer, or whether PS5 would remain the standard SKU targeted by developers looking to release on console.

Re: Find Your Next PS Plus Game with Innovative Discovery App

StrickenBiged

One of my eyebrows became firmly cocked when I saw the list of who they consider to be 'experts'. No one who's tastes I'd trust, and several who I know do not align with my own tastes.

But good luck to the project. I agree there's a big problem with game discovery so it's good to see someone trying to take that on.

Re: Call of Duty Confirms Use of Generative AI in Blockbuster PS5, PS4 Franchise

StrickenBiged

@Markatron84 It depends on what they were trained on. For instance, ask ChatGPT to produce an image of a glass of wine filled all the way to the brim. It can't do it, because the vast, vast majority of images of wine glasses are either completely empty, or only filled to a normal-drinking amount. ChatGPT will even tell you that the image shows a glass of wine filled all the way to the brim when getting this wrong.

In the case of hands, it's because hands are very complicated bits of anatomy, with lots of variation in poses among the training data and individual elements. These models don't understand what a 'hand' is, they just know they look sort of like this. But they have no concept of how many fingers a hand should have, or where the bones go and how they function, that the fingers typically only bend in one direction, etc.

Re: Talking Point: Has the Market for AA Games on PS5 Really Disappeared?

StrickenBiged

What's the difference, to the players, between AA and indie any more?

Sifu, Hades, Kunitsu Gami, PoP: The Lost Crown, Stray, Kena, Hollow Knight, Concrete Genie... I'd put all these in the same bucket of "smaller but still substantial titles". I think Shuhei is right that, from the consumer's perspective, there is not really a difference between a good indie game and a smaller project from a large scale publisher.

And from Sony's perspective, they don't just think "will we make a profit if we spend our development dollars here?", they also have to think "... but would we make more profit with the same development dollars if we put them over here?". And when you ask that second question, being in the "AA" space doesn't really make sense these days.

Re: GTA 5 Sells an Utterly Ludicrous 210 Million Copies

StrickenBiged

Some of those will be people who bought the game on separate console generations. But even assuming (for the sake of argument) that everyone who is interested in GTAV has triple dipped on the 7th, 8th and 9th generation versions of the game, that would still be something like 70 million unique players.

How big this behemoth of a franchise is truly boggles the mind.

Re: Rocksteady Lining Up New Single Player Batman Game After Suicide Squad Disaster, It's Claimed

StrickenBiged

Leave Batman to rest for a while, IMO. They nailed it with the Arkham games, and those are still very playable on modern hardware.

Explore some other DC characters. Green Arrow has some name recognition after the TV series. Cyborg was in the JL movies, and provides an obvious route into RPG upgrade mechanics.

Or just move away from the traditional superheroes. Go more adult. Preacher is a DC imprint, and has a wider fanbase thanks to the TV show. John Constantine is another (albeit it's been a while since that movie). The Sandman is probably a no-go given the allegations against Gaiman... Watchmen is pretty well known at this point too.

Ideally, let the Rocksteady that exists today take some time to brainstorm and pick what they want to work on next. If that's Batman, then so be it, but I'd personally see that as a missed opportunity.