Problem isn't sequels so much as it's almost exclusively sequels. Exclusively sequels to their most recent lineup on the PS4, and all of them seem to be iterative of the first. None of them are as well regarded as the first either, the closest one being Ragnarok. Why should someone shell out $500 for a game that looks and plays almost identically to the one they already have on PS4? The story? You can watch a long play for that
I like my PS5, it gets way more use than my Switch or PC. But Sony's library for it is very weak. The weakest generation by far, and that's sworn me off getting the PS6 (or any future console for that matter, I'm not impressed with the Switch 2 either).
Expedition 33 will definitely be on there and will almost certainly win. Only other game that could take it is Silksong. As for the other four... Split Fiction seems very likely, Death Stranding 2 does to, it's Kojima and the obligatory Sony pick. Donkey Kong Bananza has a decent shot cause they typically have a obligatory Nintendo pick too. Maaaaybe Mario Kart, but that game's reception went off a diving board (for good reason it sucks) so I doubt it. Last one will either be KCD2 or Yotei due to recency. Can't really think anything else that would feasibly be there, so that's my prediction.
@nhSnork True, there was also that crow game that got dragged for being too close to Hollow Knight. I guess we've been at this point where every Metroidvania is now a Hollow Knight just like every 3D action game is now a Dark Souls
Not surprising. Switch 2 is cheaper in Japan than anywhere else thanks to the region locked model, so I imagine that's where the highest concentration of adopters are. Dragon Quest also does crazy numbers over there.
Aw wtf, that's terrible. I've been playing through the DoA and Ninja Gaiden games and watched his G4 feature just last week. He's a legend and international treasure, sad to see him gone
Nah, I'm moving to PC next year. Sony and Nintendo aren't really offering anything worth investing over half a grand in anymore. PS4 to PS5 has been an era of diminishing returns and I expect the PS6 to follow that trajectory.
Microsoft has been spinning its wheels for over a decade now. Game Pass helped them a lot but I don't think they ever truly recovered from the XBONE fumble. Sony has definitely been running uncontested for awhile now, unless you want to count the Switch, but I would put a big asterisk next to it.
The Playstation's actual competitor is the PC, which more and more people have been adopting (myself included next year). Eventually the price of a console is going to outpace its convenience, and I think we'll be seeing that soon.
I don't think the stories themselves matter, modern Sony games just don't have much identity so releases tend to bleed into each other. If the majority of your output is some variation on an open-world action RPG, people naturally start to see a hazy cloud of similarities as time passes and they forget the minutia of what makes each one unique.
It's why the "PS5 has no games" meme is so pervasive, all they've really accomplished this generation is making sequels or remasters of PS4 games. I'm sure the games still sell decently well, but I wouldn't blame anyone for losing interest in this formula.
As much as I hate Nintendo and think we're witnessing the dying gasps of a headless corporate sludge factory only capable of reselling you the same game you played 20 years ago at premium dollar... At least the games they're reselling come out consistently and are unmistakably distinct from each other. Mario Kart doesn't look or play like Donkey Kong, which doesn't look or play like Pokémon, or Metroid, Zelda, Kirby, Fire Emblem, Splatoon, Xenoblade, so on and so forth. Sony doesn't have an excuse. They're sitting on a dragon's horde of unique IPs, and they can market new ones anytime they want. But I imagine they plan to stay the course so long as their current output is lucrative. Idk, they're REALLY trying to force a successful live service game into the market, so who can say.
@Ainu20 So to clarify, if this game had a less on-the-nose title and /or some tweaks to the main character so she didn't look as similar to Aya as she does now - there'd be no issue to you?
If I have that right, while I don't wholly agree I do understand where you're coming from along with the principle. There ought to be some expectation to make something with distinctness no matter how inspired it is of something else. Despite Expedition 33 having no unique components to it, the way those components are combined and presented gives the game its uniqueness. That being said, I don't have a problem with something being a hardly-legally distinct this or that. Especially in this context where the franchise being copied is almost certainly dead. That seems to be the only point we differ on. I appreciate the response!
@nessisonett @Ainu20 @AdamNovice Genuine question, because I've been hearing a lot of this rhetoric for Ananta and other Chinese games recently. How do you parse the endless stream of indie games that wear their inspirations like a badge of honor, sometimes looking and playing exactly like them? Does it bother you that the two highest received games this year are a collection of "stolen" ideas from JRPGs and Metroidvanias of the past? How about established IPs that churn out games that are functionally identical to each other, reusing the same ideas everytime? A lot of these old guard studios are a revolving door of employees, many of the innovators who created the formulas they use are gone now. And typically when new ideas ARE introduced, they come from another studio's game. Does this not constitute plagiarism to you and why?
Finally, can you give me some examples of recent games you think are original? I'm in the camp that we've ran out of original ideas a long time ago, and everything made today is iterative, not innovative. Which I don't think is a problem, but you guys clearly equate some form of artistic integrity to originality. Where does that start and end for you?
PS1 is still the best of the three but I still like what the new one is going for. Not a fan of that like hazy dream filter Reimagined has, the colors are washed-out. 3DS version did a remarkable job for the limitations it had on a handheld, it looks excellent in motion.
So many games coming out in the late September though October period that this one falls short. I don't think Sony's done a good job showcasing this game, maybe the idea was the reception of the first game was meant to sell you on the sequel but idk how effective that'll be. I might pick it up used down the line.
The first game is the scariest, but II is definitely the best one by a wide margin. I really don't like the look of this remake though. For anyone interested, give the original a shot first.
@4fold DQVII is an extremely long game, they're probably planning to trim the fat or at least relegate some of the scenarios to optional content. Like with any remake, I recommend playing the original beforehand, but prepare for a whale of a video game if you do.
@tameshiyaku A lot of these dog ***** shows have 2 season contracts from the start. Almost certainly the case with Tomb Raider too, I doubt it pulled in decent numbers.
@LazyDaisy I don't disagree that there are leagues of goonery between Resident Evil and NIKKE, the point me (and I assume PuppetMaster) were making was that sex appeal has always been a staple for Jill's character design. Ergo why she would be a fit for a game like this, or why Capcom thinks she would be at least.
@PuppetMaster Beat me to it lol, that guy clearly never played a game with Jill in it prior to 3 remake. Revelations has a distractingly low camera angle on her lmao
Resident Evil 2 has a ***** ton of unlockable content, that's basically what achievements were before the 360/PS3 era. Idk about 3, I had it on the Gamecube when I was a kid and never finished it. At the very least I know it's got a lot of replay value like RE 1 & 2.
@get2sammyb Provided they can make raptors as smart and unyielding as the Xenomorph was. A lot of other first person survival horror games just throw you from one railroaded sequence to the next and sprinkle a couple of death walls in the way lol
Comments 242
Re: Sony Accused of Using Generative AI Art for PlayStation Advent Calendar Promo
Ah yes, Great Value AI Sonico, my favorite Sony character to ring out the new year.
Re: Talking Point: Does PS5 Have a Sequel Problem?
Problem isn't sequels so much as it's almost exclusively sequels. Exclusively sequels to their most recent lineup on the PS4, and all of them seem to be iterative of the first.
None of them are as well regarded as the first either, the closest one being Ragnarok. Why should someone shell out $500 for a game that looks and plays almost identically to the one they already have on PS4? The story? You can watch a long play for that
Re: Poll: Five Years of PS5 - How Would You Rate Sony's Console?
I like my PS5, it gets way more use than my Switch or PC. But Sony's library for it is very weak. The weakest generation by far, and that's sworn me off getting the PS6 (or any future console for that matter, I'm not impressed with the Switch 2 either).
Re: Steel Yourselves: The Game Awards Nominees Are Being Announced Imminently
Expedition 33 will definitely be on there and will almost certainly win. Only other game that could take it is Silksong.
As for the other four...
Split Fiction seems very likely,
Death Stranding 2 does to, it's Kojima and the obligatory Sony pick.
Donkey Kong Bananza has a decent shot cause they typically have a obligatory Nintendo pick too. Maaaaybe Mario Kart, but that game's reception went off a diving board (for good reason it sucks) so I doubt it.
Last one will either be KCD2 or Yotei due to recency. Can't really think anything else that would feasibly be there, so that's my prediction.
Re: Palworld Dev Is Publishing a Metroidvania Action Game with Strong Silksong Vibes on PS5, PS4
@nhSnork True, there was also that crow game that got dragged for being too close to Hollow Knight. I guess we've been at this point where every Metroidvania is now a Hollow Knight just like every 3D action game is now a Dark Souls
Re: Palworld Dev Is Publishing a Metroidvania Action Game with Strong Silksong Vibes on PS5, PS4
Hollow Knight didn't invent dark caves, this looks distinctly like its own thing. People are brain broken by Palworld discourse
Re: Poll: How Would You Rate State of Play for November 2025?
There were a couple of cool things but this didn't need to be a whole presentation.
Re: State of Play Announced for 11th November, Focus on Japanese PS5 Games
They made this specifically for me
Re: In Japan, Switch 2 Retail Sales Are Already Closing on PS5
Not surprising. Switch 2 is cheaper in Japan than anywhere else thanks to the region locked model, so I imagine that's where the highest concentration of adopters are.
Dragon Quest also does crazy numbers over there.
Re: Poll: Is PS Portal the Biggest Surprise Hit of the PS5 Generation?
2023!? Jesus, I didn't know this thing existed until this article
Re: Final Fantasy 7, Expedition 33 Prove There's Only Love Between RPG Rivals
Final Fantasy VII original >>>> Remake and Rebirth
Re: Monster Hunter Wilds Doing So Badly That's It's Been Outsold by MH Rise, Devil May Cry 5
Boring game anyways, no wonder it's struggling to have legs
Re: Poll: Will You Be Buying Halo: Campaign Evolved on PS5?
I'll stick with the original
Re: Survival Horror Sequel Tormented Souls 2 Out Today on PS5
First one was decent, I'll definitely grab this.
Re: Poll: Are You Playing Ninja Gaiden 4?
On my DoA/ Ninja Gaiden series playthrough I'm currently just out of the first DOAX and onto Ninja Gaiden Black.
So still a ways to go. But definitely sooner than later.
Re: Ninja Gaiden 4 (PS5) - A Bloodthirsty Action Game Ripped Straight from the PS3 Era
@dskatter I saw Ayane is in the game but idk if she's playable or not
Re: Ninja Gaiden, Dead or Alive Legend Tomonobu Itagaki Has Passed Away
Aw wtf, that's terrible. I've been playing through the DoA and Ninja Gaiden games and watched his G4 feature just last week.
He's a legend and international treasure, sad to see him gone
Re: Talking Point: PS6 In 2027 - How Do You Feel About Sony's Next-Gen Console?
Nah, I'm moving to PC next year. Sony and Nintendo aren't really offering anything worth investing over half a grand in anymore. PS4 to PS5 has been an era of diminishing returns and I expect the PS6 to follow that trajectory.
Re: Rumour: American Civil War Assassin's Creed Game Cancelled Due to Fear of Controversy
Cowards.
Not that I'd expect them to handle anything without a dose of titanium cringe
Re: Dead Space's Isaac Clarke Is Now in Skate, And He Costs More Than His PS5 Remake
"We have Isaac Clarke at home" looking ass
Re: PS6 May Go Uncontested as Rumours of Next-Gen Xbox Cancellation Spiral
Microsoft has been spinning its wheels for over a decade now. Game Pass helped them a lot but I don't think they ever truly recovered from the XBONE fumble. Sony has definitely been running uncontested for awhile now, unless you want to count the Switch, but I would put a big asterisk next to it.
The Playstation's actual competitor is the PC, which more and more people have been adopting (myself included next year). Eventually the price of a console is going to outpace its convenience, and I think we'll be seeing that soon.
Re: Talking Point: Are You Getting Sick of Sony's Supposedly 'Samey' Approach to Story Telling?
I don't think the stories themselves matter, modern Sony games just don't have much identity so releases tend to bleed into each other. If the majority of your output is some variation on an open-world action RPG, people naturally start to see a hazy cloud of similarities as time passes and they forget the minutia of what makes each one unique.
It's why the "PS5 has no games" meme is so pervasive, all they've really accomplished this generation is making sequels or remasters of PS4 games. I'm sure the games still sell decently well, but I wouldn't blame anyone for losing interest in this formula.
As much as I hate Nintendo and think we're witnessing the dying gasps of a headless corporate sludge factory only capable of reselling you the same game you played 20 years ago at premium dollar... At least the games they're reselling come out consistently and are unmistakably distinct from each other.
Mario Kart doesn't look or play like Donkey Kong, which doesn't look or play like Pokémon, or Metroid, Zelda, Kirby, Fire Emblem, Splatoon, Xenoblade, so on and so forth.
Sony doesn't have an excuse. They're sitting on a dragon's horde of unique IPs, and they can market new ones anytime they want. But I imagine they plan to stay the course so long as their current output is lucrative. Idk, they're REALLY trying to force a successful live service game into the market, so who can say.
Re: Poll: Are You Playing Ghost of Yotei?
Way down the line. Not a priority right now.
Re: PS5's Ghost of Yotei Gets Glorious Illustrated Famitsu Cover
@ShogunRok REALLY like that one! Intense
Re: PS5's Ghost of Yotei Gets Glorious Illustrated Famitsu Cover
@Eduard_Brenton Lmao that's the first thing that popped into my head too
Re: Square Enix Ain't Going to Revisit Parasite Eve on PS5, But This Chinese Dev Sure as Hell Is
@Ainu20 So to clarify, if this game had a less on-the-nose title and /or some tweaks to the main character so she didn't look as similar to Aya as she does now - there'd be no issue to you?
If I have that right, while I don't wholly agree I do understand where you're coming from along with the principle. There ought to be some expectation to make something with distinctness no matter how inspired it is of something else. Despite Expedition 33 having no unique components to it, the way those components are combined and presented gives the game its uniqueness.
That being said, I don't have a problem with something being a hardly-legally distinct this or that. Especially in this context where the franchise being copied is almost certainly dead. That seems to be the only point we differ on. I appreciate the response!
Re: Square Enix Ain't Going to Revisit Parasite Eve on PS5, But This Chinese Dev Sure as Hell Is
@nessisonett @Ainu20 @AdamNovice Genuine question, because I've been hearing a lot of this rhetoric for Ananta and other Chinese games recently.
How do you parse the endless stream of indie games that wear their inspirations like a badge of honor, sometimes looking and playing exactly like them?
Does it bother you that the two highest received games this year are a collection of "stolen" ideas from JRPGs and Metroidvanias of the past?
How about established IPs that churn out games that are functionally identical to each other, reusing the same ideas everytime? A lot of these old guard studios are a revolving door of employees, many of the innovators who created the formulas they use are gone now. And typically when new ideas ARE introduced, they come from another studio's game. Does this not constitute plagiarism to you and why?
Finally, can you give me some examples of recent games you think are original? I'm in the camp that we've ran out of original ideas a long time ago, and everything made today is iterative, not innovative. Which I don't think is a problem, but you guys clearly equate some form of artistic integrity to originality. Where does that start and end for you?
Re: Pragmata Devs Explain Why the PS5 Game Has Taken So Long to Make
Hope for the best but keep those expectations low. Capcom makes a lot of big games but they're very hit or miss as is.
Re: Romeo Is a Dead Man Gives Wolverine PS5's Gore a Run for Its Money
Looking forward to this one
Re: Preview: We Played Anime Open World Ananta, and It Could Change Everything
@nessisonett I know right. Can't believe Spider-Man for the PS4 just blatantly copied Spider-Man for the PS2. Get an original idea already.
Re: Poll: How Would You Rate State of Play for September 2025?
Biggest reaction out of me was for Soulcalibur III lol. Saros looked cool. Wolverine was a movie trailer, no gameplay no care.
Re: Wildly Promising GTA-Style Open World Scraps Character Gachas Completely
This is a game by crackheads for crackheads and that's precisely why I'm going to play it.
Re: Dragon Quest 7 Remake Graphics Comparison Shows Just How Far This Classic RPG Has Come
PS1 is still the best of the three but I still like what the new one is going for. Not a fan of that like hazy dream filter Reimagined has, the colors are washed-out.
3DS version did a remarkable job for the limitations it had on a handheld, it looks excellent in motion.
Re: Latest Ghost of Yotei Trailer Is a Quick Hit Before PS5 Launch
So many games coming out in the late September though October period that this one falls short. I don't think Sony's done a good job showcasing this game, maybe the idea was the reception of the first game was meant to sell you on the sequel but idk how effective that'll be. I might pick it up used down the line.
Re: The Best and Scariest Fatal Frame Is Getting a PS5 Remake Early Next Year
The first game is the scariest, but II is definitely the best one by a wide margin. I really don't like the look of this remake though. For anyone interested, give the original a shot first.
Re: An Unthinkable Amount of Mega Man Is Coming to PS5, PS4 in New Star Force Collection
Very nice.
The only series they have left is Legends then they'll officially be out of Mega Man games to resell us...
until Mega Man GB collection, Mega Man & Bass, Battle & Chase...
...***** Mega Man Soccer
Re: Dragon Quest 7 Returns in Reimagined Form, Out for PS5 in February 2026
My now most anticipated game of 2026 alongside Fire Emblem.
Re: Dragon Quest 7 Returns in Reimagined Form, Out for PS5 in February 2026
@4fold DQVII is an extremely long game, they're probably planning to trim the fat or at least relegate some of the scenarios to optional content.
Like with any remake, I recommend playing the original beforehand, but prepare for a whale of a video game if you do.
Re: Preview: Teamwork Is the True Terror of Little Nightmares 3
Guess I'm playing solo then. Hope the uh... "tension" is worth the lack of options.
Re: Tomb Raider's Anime Will Wrap Up with Season 2, Due Out on Netflix in December
@beltmenot SpongeBob and Beevus & Butthead are also anime since words don't mean anything anymore.
Re: Tomb Raider's Anime Will Wrap Up with Season 2, Due Out on Netflix in December
@tameshiyaku A lot of these dog ***** shows have 2 season contracts from the start. Almost certainly the case with Tomb Raider too, I doubt it pulled in decent numbers.
Re: Preview: Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds Already Feels Like a Respectable Rival to Mario Kart World
CrossWorlds doesn't look great but definitely looks more fun than MKW. Fingers crossed that it's good but if not at least Air Riders looks promising.
Re: Stellar Blade Dev's Saucy Smartphone Shooter NIKKE Will Add Another PlayStation Fave Soon
@LazyDaisy I don't disagree that there are leagues of goonery between Resident Evil and NIKKE, the point me (and I assume PuppetMaster) were making was that sex appeal has always been a staple for Jill's character design. Ergo why she would be a fit for a game like this, or why Capcom thinks she would be at least.
Re: Stellar Blade Dev's Saucy Smartphone Shooter NIKKE Will Add Another PlayStation Fave Soon
@PuppetMaster Beat me to it lol, that guy clearly never played a game with Jill in it prior to 3 remake. Revelations has a distractingly low camera angle on her lmao
Re: Highly Rated Square Enix RPG Triangle Strategy Out Now on PS5
Top tier game btw, high recommendation. I never finished it myself, need to get around to doing that.
Re: Poll: How Would You Rate Gamescom Opening Night Live 2025?
All the best stuff was during the pre-show. Thank god I waited a bit so I could skip through all the live service sludge
Re: Resident Evil 2, 3 PS1 Ports Disappoint with No Trophy Support on PS5, PS4
Resident Evil 2 has a ***** ton of unlockable content, that's basically what achievements were before the 360/PS3 era.
Idk about 3, I had it on the Gamecube when I was a kid and never finished it. At the very least I know it's got a lot of replay value like RE 1 & 2.
Re: Annapurna's Mad Creature-Collecting Roguelite Morsels Finally Has a Release Date on PS5
I was disappointed when this didn't show up in February, glad to see it finally has a date. It looks sick!
Re: Jurassic Park Survival Is Shaping Up to Be a Dream PS5 Single Player Game
@get2sammyb Provided they can make raptors as smart and unyielding as the Xenomorph was. A lot of other first person survival horror games just throw you from one railroaded sequence to the next and sprinkle a couple of death walls in the way lol
Re: Jurassic Park Survival Is Shaping Up to Be a Dream PS5 Single Player Game
Fingers crossed it features deeper gameplay than 'avoid patrolling dinosaurs while touring reference city', I'd really like this one to be great.