But-but-but itâs the studio founded by the lead developer GTA! Surely that would outweigh dated lack of vision, dated gameplay and non-existing marketing! Or so I was told by other commenters here pre-releaseđĽ˛
Good luck to all the people being laid off. Again underlines the importance of assessing the leadership before accepting a job offer.
Thanks for a timely review! Not a fan of the series, but finishing RE2Remake now and might be interested to try this one later on.
Whatâs your estimated completion percentage (based on achievements unlocked and how many hours did you spend? Is the weapons upgrade system in place? Are there any interesting gadgets Grace uses?
All speculations at this point based on her credentials. Letâs wait and see her vision for Xbox. The green team undeniably lost this generation, despite all their great initiatives. Maybe a radical shake up is what is needed.
I think at the start of 2026 it is a bit premature to make forecasts with any degrees of certainty. Rumours from summer 2027 onwards will carry much more weight.
On the decision itself: I donât think it will be delayed past 2027, as it will have major repercussions for the whole PS ecosystem.
Finally, this is a company that did not pass a chance to release a Pro version although there was much less justification for it than for PS4Pro. I canât see how they can forgo extra $$$ from new hardware and $80 games.
@OmegaStriver surprisingly, Game Informer put a preview on it as well! It also highlights reactions to playerâs choices, but is similarly short on substance.
@OmegaStriver A fellow appreciator of CR! I was hoping it would get mentioned in the latest Xbox Showcase, but alas⌠rewatched the trailer again and thought how it reminds me of Bioshock Infinite!
@Simu001 second that! A bit premature talking about the second part since we donât know the exact status of the first gameâs remake. Can end up like Bloodlines 2âŚ
Only feasible if all new trilogy games are the scale and scope of W1/2, rather than W3 or CP77. Not sure this will align with audience expectations (but I personally would be very happy)
Is âtwo states of the game worldâ mechanic that unique, though? I can remember something similar in the 1st Senua game and Titanfall 2 (and there are many others for sure), and those games did not require SSD for that.
âWith the conclusion of the Final Fantasy VII Remake trilogy, thereâs probably going to be a much wider audience for Final Fantasy as a wholeâ.
That is quite an optimistic take. Just checked the latest figures: FF7 original - over 15 mil; FF7 remake - over 7 mil; FF7 Rebirth - no definite figure, but I would estimate it between 4-5mil.
A lot seems to hang on the assumption that there are millions of players just waiting for part 3 to release and then play trilogy in one goâŚ
@ShogunRok thanks for a timely review! Unfortunate that it is not a more positive one.
Could you please elaborate on the following:
1) open-world aspect, besides it being bad. I feel like it is Mafia-style: moving from one main mission to another, with minimum interaction (like picking collectibles); 2) side quests: any interesting lore / mechanics there at all? Or just dialogue/combat/reward loop? 3) playtime - whatâs your estimate of total game completion in 15 hrs? I read that developers were saying 20-25 hrs for main story, and up to 40 for total completion. Also, if you could tell your difficulty setting please? 3)
I see so many parallels with Cyberpunk 2077: a shift from RPG to action adventure; a supporting character living in your head who is a subject of lengthy boring flashback; and of course that 4/10 score)
Canât wait to fight Sephiroth, Jenova, the Turks, Rufus and a bunch of other characters for the 3rd or 4th time, do long qte sequences and beat Jules again at whatever exercise he fancies that day!
@katamariUK I have not played Nintendo games in a while, but maybe this is because their games are more âgameplay-drivenâ, vs Sonyâs âstory-drivenâ, so it is easier to ignore repetition in stories there?
Canât fully agree about stories, but can feel it in the way they are delivered. It seems that many 1st party releases use the tools of Last of Us to tell their story, without considering how it fits the particular genre/story. These include: slowly following an npc which dumps exposition; a âsettlementâ area where you can eavesdrop on npcâs conversation; pseudo-gameplay sections, which are not technically cutscenes, as you have some control, but in practice itâs just press forward and X; noc notes everywhere. It worked wonders in 2013, but after a decade+ of seeing this, I canât say they are effective in conveying the necessary emotions anymore.
I was just researching Gamepass deals today⌠Well, GP was fun while it lasted) Looks like they donât care about competing with PS Extra/Premium anymore
Amazing animations, but I just donât understand how people can accept this level of ârealismâ in group combat. The last enemy is just standing and watching his mate getting sliced, not even raising a sword!
@wildcat_kickz PS6 must be more powerful than PS5Pro. I canât see how PS6 can be priced cheaper than PS5Pro, and the range you gave will required $150-250 (20-33%) price cut on Pro when 6 is released. Looks remote to me.
A rate instance when I completely agree with PS on the score completely! An absolutely balanced and well-written review, again highlighting that even âmidâ games might have redeeming qualities which might justify a playthrough.
Good for Sony, but I hope these (or more up-to-date) data points will be used in the inevitable discussions about ÂŁ80 first-party PS6 games. But I am sure even then there will be plenty of people defending Sonyâs decisionâŚ
Would be nice if Sony added their 1st party games on a consistent basis: 1 year after release, as EA does, would be great. Most of high-profile 3rd party games were heavily discounted already (or even given away for free) by the time they joined PS Extra.
@Chupa_loyzer It was fun, I donât deny that, but PW used the same concept and actually moved it forward. And that was 3 guys + composed and some outsourced help - vs a full studio (a modest one, but still).
I hope the game designers played and learned from Project Wingman. I enjoyed AC7 a lot, but it was very much ps2/3 game in all aspects apart from graphics.
Comments 174
Re: Out Today: Marathon's PS5 Launch Puts Sony's $3B Live Service Gamble to the Test
Looking forward to an honest, measured and polite discussion in the commentsđĽ˛
Re: MindsEye Studio Laying Off More Staff as It Doubles Down on Conspiracy Theory
But-but-but itâs the studio founded by the lead developer GTA! Surely that would outweigh dated lack of vision, dated gameplay and non-existing marketing!
Or so I was told by other commenters here pre-releaseđĽ˛
Good luck to all the people being laid off. Again underlines the importance of assessing the leadership before accepting a job offer.
Re: Flop FPS Highguard's Stats Show Steam Concurrents Are Just One Piece of the Puzzle
@carlos82 Good spot! I imagine this info will be quoted a lot in the coming days;)
Re: The Witcher 3's New Expansion Really Does Exist, Says Reliable Insider
A shadow drop is imminent, right after the Sands of Time remakeđ
Re: Resident Evil Requiem (PS5) - Two-in-One Horror Not Quite an All-Timer
Thanks for a timely review! Not a fan of the series, but finishing RE2Remake now and might be interested to try this one later on.
Whatâs your estimated completion percentage (based on achievements unlocked and how many hours did you spend?
Is the weapons upgrade system in place? Are there any interesting gadgets Grace uses?
Re: Original Xbox Creator Shares Brutal Opinion of New Leadership, Believes This Is the End of Xbox
All speculations at this point based on her credentials. Letâs wait and see her vision for Xbox. The green team undeniably lost this generation, despite all their great initiatives. Maybe a radical shake up is what is needed.
Re: Sony Considering PS6 Delay to 2028 or Even 2029, New Report Says
I think at the start of 2026 it is a bit premature to make forecasts with any degrees of certainty. Rumours from summer 2027 onwards will carry much more weight.
On the decision itself: I donât think it will be delayed past 2027, as it will have major repercussions for the whole PS ecosystem.
Finally, this is a company that did not pass a chance to release a Pro version although there was much less justification for it than for PS4Pro. I canât see how they can forgo extra $$$ from new hardware and $80 games.
Re: There's No Stopping Multiplayer Sensation ARC Raiders, Reaches 14 Million Copies Sold
@Oram77 looks somewhat optimistic to be me, but will test your prediction soon enough!
Re: PS Plus Extra Games for February 2026 Leaked
Nice! I am seriously considering resubscribing now for a month (or three), if Sony offers me a good discountđ
Re: Judas PS5 Dev Spent 5 Years Perfecting Its Core Mechanic
@OmegaStriver surprisingly, Game Informer put a preview on it as well! It also highlights reactions to playerâs choices, but is similarly short on substance.
Re: Judas PS5 Dev Spent 5 Years Perfecting Its Core Mechanic
@OmegaStriver A fellow appreciator of CR! I was hoping it would get mentioned in the latest Xbox Showcase, but alas⌠rewatched the trailer again and thought how it reminds me of Bioshock Infinite!
Re: Monster Hunter Wilds Sells 11 Million in Just Under a Year, But May Lack World's Momentum
As usual, kudos to Capcom for being transparent about their sales numbers!
Re: Amazon's PS5 MMORPG New World: Aeternum Delisted, Will Be Shut Down in 2027
I quite liked its cartoon in the Secret Level. F
Re: The Witcher 3 Really Could Be Getting a New Expansion on PS5 in 2026
Looks like something blown way, way out of proportions. Whatâs the previous track record of this insider?
Re: Star Wars: KOTOR 2 Remake Is Also on the Cards, Includes Cut Content
@Simu001 second that! A bit premature talking about the second part since we donât know the exact status of the first gameâs remake. Can end up like Bloodlines 2âŚ
Re: This RAM Crisis Is Looking Like a Nightmare for the PS6
What a convenient excuse for ÂŁ700 ps6đ
Re: Octopath Traveler 0 (PS5) - Perfectly Fine JRPG Action
@Neonix @ Exerion76 can I join your club, guys?
I am very tempted to try this franchise due to its aesthetic, but 100+ hours is just too muchâŚ
Re: The Witcher Dev Still Wants to Release Ciri's Whole Trilogy Within Six Years
Only feasible if all new trilogy games are the scale and scope of W1/2, rather than W3 or CP77. Not sure this will align with audience expectations (but I personally would be very happy)
Re: Prince of Persia Remake Might Finally Launch in the Next Six Months
I finished the original a couple of months ago. I hope they do something about balancing combat encounters - those dragged for too long!
Re: One of Ghost of Yotei's Most Unique Features Was Meant to Be Much Bigger
Is âtwo states of the game worldâ mechanic that unique, though? I can remember something similar in the 1st Senua game and Titanfall 2 (and there are many others for sure), and those games did not require SSD for that.
Re: Call of Duty: Black Ops 7's Single Player Campaign Is Being Torn Apart
It seems that lessons from Black Ops 4 were not learned at all)
Re: Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth Was to Get DLC at One Point, Scrapped for the Third Game
âWith the conclusion of the Final Fantasy VII Remake trilogy, thereâs probably going to be a much wider audience for Final Fantasy as a wholeâ.
That is quite an optimistic take. Just checked the latest figures: FF7 original - over 15 mil; FF7 remake - over 7 mil; FF7 Rebirth - no definite figure, but I would estimate it between 4-5mil.
A lot seems to hang on the assumption that there are millions of players just waiting for part 3 to release and then play trilogy in one goâŚ
Re: Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines 2 (PS5) - A Disastrously Paced, Technical Mess of a Sequel
@ShogunRok understood, thanks for detailed answers!
Re: Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines 2 (PS5) - A Disastrously Paced, Technical Mess of a Sequel
@ShogunRok thanks for a timely review!
Unfortunate that it is not a more positive one.
Could you please elaborate on the following:
1) open-world aspect, besides it being bad. I feel like it is Mafia-style: moving from one main mission to another, with minimum interaction (like picking collectibles);
2) side quests: any interesting lore / mechanics there at all? Or just dialogue/combat/reward loop?
3) playtime - whatâs your estimate of total game completion in 15 hrs? I read that developers were saying 20-25 hrs for main story, and up to 40 for total completion. Also, if you could tell your difficulty setting please?
3)
Re: Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines 2 (PS5) - A Disastrously Paced, Technical Mess of a Sequel
I see so many parallels with Cyberpunk 2077: a shift from RPG to action adventure; a supporting character living in your head who is a subject of lengthy boring flashback; and of course that 4/10 score)
Re: Final Fantasy 7 Remake Part 3 'Will Be Loved by Everyone', Says Director
Canât wait to fight Sephiroth, Jenova, the Turks, Rufus and a bunch of other characters for the 3rd or 4th time, do long qte sequences and beat Jules again at whatever exercise he fancies that day!
Re: Final Fantasy 7 Remake Part 3 'Will Be Loved by Everyone', Says Director
@Darude84 Rebirth on Steam: 77% overall, 71% recent positives. GOTY material.
Re: Black Ops 6 Trial Will Let You Play the Full Single Player Story for Free on PS5, PS4
Thatâs the kind of competition wars I like! Not interested in zombies or multiplayer, but will power through the campaign over the weekend.
Re: 'Told You So': Ex-FTC Chair Lina Khan Is Having the Last Laugh Over Xbox's Activision Acquisition
@Neither_scene I was looking for a comment like yours - absolutely valid points that are often ignored in this discussion.
Also, gamepass did (and still does) bring value to customers. It is not our job to worry whether it was sustainable or not.
Re: Talking Point: Are You Getting Sick of Sony's Supposedly 'Samey' Approach to Story Telling?
@katamariUK I have not played Nintendo games in a while, but maybe this is because their games are more âgameplay-drivenâ, vs Sonyâs âstory-drivenâ, so it is easier to ignore repetition in stories there?
Re: Talking Point: Are You Getting Sick of Sony's Supposedly 'Samey' Approach to Story Telling?
Canât fully agree about stories, but can feel it in the way they are delivered. It seems that many 1st party releases use the tools of Last of Us to tell their story, without considering how it fits the particular genre/story. These include: slowly following an npc which dumps exposition; a âsettlementâ area where you can eavesdrop on npcâs conversation; pseudo-gameplay sections, which are not technically cutscenes, as you have some control, but in practice itâs just press forward and X; noc notes everywhere.
It worked wonders in 2013, but after a decade+ of seeing this, I canât say they are effective in conveying the necessary emotions anymore.
Re: PS Plus Looks Better Than Ever After New Xbox Game Pass Price Rises
I was just researching Gamepass deals todayâŚ
Well, GP was fun while it lasted) Looks like they donât care about competing with PS Extra/Premium anymore
Re: Worried Fans Can Rest Easy: Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth Is 'Doing Very Well' on PS5, PC
Would have sounded much more credible if they disclosed sale numbers, as Capcom habitually does.
Re: Octopath Traveler 0 Has You Covered for 100 Hours of JRPG Action
Glad I am not the only one fatigued by 100+ hrs RPGs (and games of other genres)!
Re: Dual Katanas Are Lethally Fast in Ghost of Yotei's Latest PS5 Gameplay Clip
Amazing animations, but I just donât understand how people can accept this level of ârealismâ in group combat. The last enemy is just standing and watching his mate getting sliced, not even raising a sword!
Re: 8 PS Plus Extra, Premium Games for September 2025 Announced
WWE is part of Humble bundle this month.
LoK:D was fun, but I never finished it.
Have no idea what most of the rest of the list is aboutâŚ
Re: PS5 Price Increases Confirmed for USA, Effective 21st August
@Don if the release is delayed till 2029 - maybe)
Re: PS5 Price Increases Confirmed for USA, Effective 21st August
@wildcat_kickz PS6 must be more powerful than PS5Pro. I canât see how PS6 can be priced cheaper than PS5Pro, and the range you gave will required $150-250 (20-33%) price cut on Pro when 6 is released. Looks remote to me.
Re: PS5 Price Increases Confirmed for USA, Effective 21st August
@QBertFarnsworth đ
Re: PS5 Price Increase Confirmed for USA, Effective 21st August
Good luck to all those still hoping ps6 will cost under $700 or equivalent.
Re: Senua's Saga: Hellblade 2 Enhanced (PS5) - Cinematic Spectacle Offers Little Else
A rate instance when I completely agree with PS on the score completely! An absolutely balanced and well-written review, again highlighting that even âmidâ games might have redeeming qualities which might justify a playthrough.
Re: PS5's Profit Margin Problems Are a Thing of the Past as Division Tops $1 Billion Operating Income for Q1 2025
Good for Sony, but I hope these (or more up-to-date) data points will be used in the inevitable discussions about ÂŁ80 first-party PS6 games. But I am sure even then there will be plenty of people defending Sonyâs decisionâŚ
Re: Devil May Cry 5 Sales Spike After TV Show, Even DMC 4 Outsells Monster Hunter Wilds in Q1
Awesome news for DMC and I hope it means the sequel has at least been greenlit!
Separately, much praise to Capcom for being transparent about sales, unlike some other fellow Japanese publishers
Re: Highly Rated City Builder Frostpunk 2 Gets PS5 Port This September
@JB_Whiting fair, but when there is a noticeable discrepancy between critic and user scores, would have been nice if it was mentioned in the article.
Re: Highly Rated City Builder Frostpunk 2 Gets PS5 Port This September
75% user score on MC, 75% on steam (66% recent) does not exactly scream well-regardedâŚ
Re: 'We're Just Getting Started': Sony Marks 15 Years of PS Plus with Future Pledge
Would be nice if Sony added their 1st party games on a consistent basis: 1 year after release, as EA does, would be great. Most of high-profile 3rd party games were heavily discounted already (or even given away for free) by the time they joined PS Extra.
Re: New Ace Combat Game Teased in 30th Anniversary Message
@Chupa_loyzer It was fun, I donât deny that, but PW used the same concept and actually moved it forward. And that was 3 guys + composed and some outsourced help - vs a full studio (a modest one, but still).
Re: New Ace Combat Game Teased in 30th Anniversary Message
I hope the game designers played and learned from Project Wingman. I enjoyed AC7 a lot, but it was very much ps2/3 game in all aspects apart from graphics.
Re: Stellar Blade Thrives on PC, 1 Million Copies Sold in 3 Days
The multiplatform strategy is working - nice!
Re: Classic D&D RPG Neverwinter Nights 2 Is Being Revived on PS5 Next Month
Liked both the base game and MotB expansion. Just hope people donât expect BG3 level of interactivity from them.