Comments 1,750

Re: Amidst Sony's Disc Debacle, Capcom Sales Data Is a Brutal Reality Check for Fans of Physical Media

Grumblevolcano

To be fair the only Capcom game releases in April - June 2026 were Pragmata (had physical shortages meanwhile it was digital only on Switch 2) and DMC5 on Switch 2 which was eshop only.

Capcom treating Switch 2 Key Cards as digital sales is an important thing to consider when looking at physical/digital split. Personally I think that's the right way to categorize Key Cards, they require a full internet download to use games so they're not true physical releases.

Re: Fable PS5 Has Run 'Uncomfortably Beyond Budget', Sources Claim

Grumblevolcano

@darylb24 I don't see preorders alone as confirmation of the November GTA6 release date. Rather the combination of preorders and trailer 3 having the November release date.

So until trailer 3 arrives it feels like preorders went live in June solely so Zelnick can boast to investors about crazy high preorder numbers in the August Take Two earnings call meanwhile trailer 3 itself has the potential to announce another delay.

Re: PS5's Next Big Exclusive Dated, and It's Closer Than You Think

Grumblevolcano

@CielloArc That's why I'm leaning more towards no September general SoP. The purpose of the September general SoP is to promote the holiday lineup and reveal news about early on in the following year but:

  • Square Enix prefers to use Nintendo to market stuff nowadays so more FF Resonance and DQ Monsters news is more likely to be in a Direct/Partner Showcase than a SoP
  • Phantom Blade 0 is already getting its own SoP in late summer
  • MW4 will likely have its usual overly long promotion segment at Gamescom Opening Night Live
  • Rest of the year's PS5 lineup is already out by early October because of GTA6

Meanwhile on the early 2027 side of things, you have that plenty of them are potential Geoff event candidates and now Laufey has a February 2027 release date. So it feels like Sony may skip September general SoP, use TGA to heavily promote Laufey and then have their next event being the PS6 reveal in like February/March 2027.

Re: Sony Imposes 'Strictest Ever Social Media Guidelines' on Staff Due to PS5 Disc Debacle

Grumblevolcano

@ShadowRJ I think Sony are expecting the so called aggressive GTA6 summer marketing campaign to make the physical backlash quieten down. But as that hasn't really started yet (Rockstar went straight back to usual GTAO and RDO promo after the preorder announcement), the backlash remains focused on Sony killing off physical.

Hopefully Sony's expectations turn out to be incorrect.

Re: Indie Devs Unfairly Attacked Over Sony Decision to Stop Making Discs

Grumblevolcano

@Shaibaan MK World got a huge digital boost for being $30 cheaper via the Switch 2 hardware bundle, Pokopia boxed release is a Key Card so gets counted as 100% digital by default and the Pokemon Fire Red/Leaf Green ports were eshop only so are 100% digital. Also most 3rd party Switch 2 boxed releases are Key Cards so those are 100% digital.

Taking this into account, I think some of the newly released 1st party games like DK Bananza and Legends Z-A would need to have skewed much more towards physical for the overall balance between physical and digital to be as close as it was.

So I think Switch 2 at the very least is safe regarding physical and if Switch 2's successor has backwards compatibility, I would also expect that to have physical.

Re: 'It's Totally, Totally Irrelevant': GameStop Boss Unfazed by Sony's Physical Discs Decision

Grumblevolcano

@ButteredCrumpet With GAME, they got rid of the things that made it worthwhile going there. Trade-ins, rewards program to save money and ability to preorder games instore all gone in the space of 2024.

You can still do those kind of things elsewhere like CeX for trade-ins and get games cheaper at places like Smyths. For example if you want Wolverine PS5, it's £70 at GAME and the PS Store but £63 at Smyths, Argos, Amazon, etc.

Re: PS5's Physical Disc Debacle Will Attract More Anger if This Xbox Rumour Is True

Grumblevolcano

I don't really see how they'd prevent 2 people using the same license at the same time without reverting back to the original Don Mattrick XB1 "always online" concept where you can't even play disc games offline.

If you can still play disc games offline, you could have the following situation. You play a game with a digital license via this disc to digital setup meanwhile someone with an Xbox console being offline would be able to play the disc without interfering with your digital license.

If they are returning to Don Mattrick's always online vision, I hope Xbox players cause a gigantic backlash.

Re: Sony Ignores the Backlash and Returns to Social Media Almost a Week After Killing Physical Games

Grumblevolcano

I think the only hope for the backlash to remain constant is if Nintendo plays the role of 2013 Sony. Otherwise it'll sadly just fizzle out and people just accept the future Sony has provided.

I truly believe if it wasn't for Geoff Keighley and Sony digging into how horrible Don Mattrick's vision of XB1 was, people would've eventually reluctantly accepted Don Mattrick's XB1 vision as the future of gaming.

Re: PS5 Bug Removes Playtime Tracker from Physical Games Only

Grumblevolcano

@AdamNovice I sadly think they'll use Intergalactic as Sony's first digital only major 1st party release to make people cave in and buy anyway. Kind of like what happened with Pokopia being the first Nintendo 1st party Switch 2 Key Card.

Naughty Dog games lean towards 1st half of the year nowadays (TLoU in June 2013, Uncharted 4 in May 2016, TLoU 2 in June 2020) so if GoW Laufey is 1st half of 2027, I think Intergalactic will be 1st half of 2028.

Re: Poll: $1,000 and No Disc Drive - Is PS6 Dead on Arrival?

Grumblevolcano

I think both PS6 and Helix will only be purchasable via the platform's own stores with both being very niche. PS6 being Playstation Direct exclusive and Helix being Microsoft Store exclusive much like how Valve's more recent hardware can only be bought via Steam. I don't see retailers supporting a new generation that's fully digital only, they'll use that space for Switch 2 instead as Nintendo still cares about physical media.

Re: PlayStation's Plan to Kill Physical Games Has Spawned Not One But Many Online Petitions

Grumblevolcano

It's very promising that so many people are speaking out against this horrible decision by Sony to kill off physical media, hopefully something will come of it.

The big Switch 2 Key Card backlash did actually increase the number of true physical Switch 2 releases from 3rd parties this year. Even Bethesda chose to release 2 fully on the cart games (Indiana Jones and Oblivion Remastered) which were Key Discs on PS5.

Re: PS6 Will Be a Digital Console, And Sony Has Huge Questions to Answer About Backwards Compatibility

Grumblevolcano

My concerns about the future of physical on PS soared when there were heavy rumours of a PS6 handheld considering you can't fit PS4/PS5 discs into a handheld. The choices were:
1. Handheld digital only while the home console remains disc based (downside is that you can't play disc games on the handheld so library is split)
2. You use carts for next gen games (downside is it doesn't solve the problem of backwards compatibility)
3. Everything is digital only (downside is the death of physical media and you don't own anything)

Nintendo chose option 2 with Switch of which their backwards compatibility solution was that there wasn't any (library started from scratch).

Turns out Sony chose option 3 which is the worst option.

Re: Rumour: PS6 Costs Sony Almost $1,000 to Make Right Now

Grumblevolcano

@twitchtvpat No but I think it's more about Sony's change in communication strategy. Sony did a very good job in showcasing PS4 was alive and well in the lead up to PS5. Meanwhile while there are plenty of games incoming for PS5 in the lead up to PS6, it feels like Sony's relying heavily on GTA6 and so Rockstar's silence becomes Sony's silence.

Re: Rumour: PS6 Costs Sony Almost $1,000 to Make Right Now

Grumblevolcano

@Bizzy There likely will be another Switch 2 price increase but I doubt it'll be anywhere near the same extremes as PS/Xbox. I could see prices at the end of 2027 being something like the following judging by current trajectories of price increases:

  • $550 - Switch 2
  • $800 - 512GB Series S (1TB model gets discontinued)
  • $1100 - PS5/Series X (disc models get discontinued)
  • $1500 - PS6/Helix (requires standalone purchase of disc drive for PS6, no disc drive at all for Helix)

Re: Rumour: PS6 Costs Sony Almost $1,000 to Make Right Now

Grumblevolcano

I think what will happen is both Sony and Microsoft release next gen in November 2027 at obscene prices and then at some point supporting Switch 2 becomes a priority for both companies as Nintendo's the only platform holder that's actively trying to keep hardware pricing affordable.

Re: GTA 6 PS5 Disc Hopes Seemingly Dashed by Rockstar Source

Grumblevolcano

@somnambulance Between the complete silence about the game itself and this mess regarding the boxed copy, I'm kind of getting the feeling it's going to be the next Cyberpunk 2020 launch.

The big difference being boxed copy being code in box and the GTA+ subscription preorder bonus sounds like all refund requests would be void if GTA6 is a buggy mess at launch.

Re: GTA 6 Confirmed to Be an $80 Game

Grumblevolcano

Really grim future ahead. $80 game that's a code in box and puts you into an auto-renewal subscription (GTA+) which will trick lots of unsuspecting players.

All while other companies choose to copy Rockstar because GTA6 will no doubt sell insanely well.

Re: Kingdom Hearts 4 PS5 Release Date Hopium Hits New High

Grumblevolcano

Their approach for FFVII is the only thing that makes me think 2027 is possible:

  • January 22nd 2026 - FFVII Remake
  • June 3rd 2026 - FFVII Rebirth
  • Spring 2027 - FFVII Revelation

Revelation is around 9-12 months after the Switch 2 release of Rebirth. Allows you a good amount of time to play the first 2 parts with the 3rd part not being too far away.

So if you were to use a similar approach to Kingdom Hearts, maybe it's a PS6 launch day game? Though I'd be leaning more towards early 2028 for KH4.

Re: Sony 'Exploring New Ways' to Deliver PS Plus Games

Grumblevolcano

So Sony has Sonic out earlier perhaps to hype up an upcoming Sonic Central stream (with the mystery of the Frontiers for Switch 2 rating still unsolved, SEGA's likely got a stream around Sonic's birthday) and then the rest is later than normal because Sony wants all attention on FF16?