Comments 253

Re: Video: All the PS5 Games We Think Are 10/10

Matthewnh

I have just discovered something odd.

Push Square review scores for:

The Last of Us (PS3) 10/10
The Last of Us Remastered (PS4) 10/10
The Last of Us Remastered (PS5) 8/10

The Last of Us Part II (PS4) 10/10
The Last of Us Part II Remastered (PS5) 9/10

This seems rather inconsistent. But I suppose there are good reasons for this.

Re: Talking Point: Does PS5 Have a Sequel Problem?

Matthewnh

I think that whether or not a game is new, or is a sequel, I think that is irrelevant.

What matters to me the most is “Am I enjoying what I am playing?” And “is this a good story?”

Mind you, I certainly looking forward to the inevitable sequel to Hogwarts Legacy. And sometimes, more of the same can be a good thing.

Re: PS5 RPG Where Winds Meet Makes a Strong Start with Two Million Players

Matthewnh

I installed this, and played it for a few days.

I thought it might like an interactive version of the movies “Crouching Tiger” or “House of Flying Daggers”.

A lot of the game does not seem to make sense to me, and I was finding it just impenetrable. Too complicated for its’ own good, with the plot moving at the pace of a tired snail.

Given up, and deleted it. I might have the patience for it one day. But it was beautiful to look at, though.

Re: Xbox, PC Sci-Fi RPG Starfield Won't Be Revealed for PS5 Until Next Year

Matthewnh

Played through Starfield three times on Series X.

It is an enjoyable experience, yet it is hardly revolutionary. It is definitely a fun time, whilst you are playing it, but I feel that it is nothing special.

I have also noticed that none of the decisions you make throughout seem to have actual consequences. And the game only seems to end one way.

Re: Sony Plans to Start Shooting Horizon Movie in 2026, with 2027 Release Planned

Matthewnh

I just cannot see how this could possibly work as a blockbuster movie.

A live action “Horizon” movie will need tons of cgi and “bluescreen”. This film will be almost 100% computer generated, I feel.

And the development cycle seems far too short, considering it took Cameron three years to film Avatar (2009), and likely years of work before filming even took place.

I also believe the movie will not actually interest people who have not played the game. The dialogue will probably be totally impenetrable to those not already familiar with the story.

The Uncharted film actually was not that bad. To make Horizon into a proper cinematic experience, that will require something truly special.

Re: Sony Puts PS5 on Sale for Once, a £90 Saving in the UK

Matthewnh

@sanderson72

Nice. You’ve got yourself a real bargain.

I paid just over £250 for a 2TB SSD, in January 2022. And it still sells for the same price now as it did then.

If I ever manage to upgrade my PS5, I will not forget the SSD. I do not want the hassle of having to reinstall everything.

Re: 'Sony Seeks an Impermissible Monopoly on Genre Conventions': Tencent Fires Back Over Horizon Rip-Off

Matthewnh

This all seems to me as though Tencent have been caught red-handed.

They tried to develop an obvious rip-off of a well-known title. And are now trying to save their necks.

One could argue that Black Myth WuKong is a rip off of Enslaved:Odyssey to the West. They both use the same book as inspiration, after all. Wu Cheng’en wrote A Journey to the West, which is also known as “Monkey”.

The trouble is, where is this going to end?

You only need to look to modern cinema, and realise that a lot of creators and developers are intellectually lazy, and have no original ideas of their own.

Re: $200 MGS Delta Collector's Edition Ridiculed Over Temu-Esque Snake Figurine

Matthewnh

The only Collectors edition game I had was the original Watch Dogs.

I have a 12inch tall Aiden Pearce statuette, that is still in the styrofoam box. Never been on display.

This seems to prove that some expensive collectors editions are good value, whereas others are simply a rip-off.

I shall let you all decide which category this one falls under.

Re: Ambitious Open World RPG Crimson Desert Delayed to 2026

Matthewnh

So the headline implies that the game is perhaps TOO ambitious.

But I agree with the general sentiment here, that we all have enough to keep us occupied for the time being.

So let Pearl Abyss improve and perfect Crimson Desert. Besides, I would always prefer that development teams release their games when they are finished, and not beforehand.

After all, we are customers, and not playtesters. If software developers want us to all test their games for them, then they ought to pay us to do it.

If it truly is that good, it is going to be worth waiting for.

Re: PS3's Store Has Been Restored, After Fans Feared the Worst

Matthewnh

I am surprised that anyone has a PS3 anymore.

Because I replaced mine with my first PS4, when they came out. Which is eleven years ago. The PS3 was first introduced in 2007.

Sorry to be rude, but honestly it is time to move on. I feel that making consoles “backward-compatible” basically hamstrings them, preventing the technology from reaching its full potential.

And nostalgia is not what it used to be.
As other commentators have pointed out, it is time to let go.

Re: UK Citizens Using the Photorealistic Death Stranding 2 on PS5 to Bypass Porn Blocks

Matthewnh

I have been reading some of the comments, and although I understand the government’s point of view, in this regard I am very much libertarian.

I say, less government interference, and let consenting adults do as they please.

The kind of content that goes far beyond “erotica/pornography” is already illegal. For good reasons. But that does not stop people from accessing it if they desperately want to.

As other commenters have said, anybody with the slightest knowledge of computer networking could likely get around this ban by using a VPN.

The “British government” have their priorities all wrong.

The British government sends weapons and equipment thousands of miles so that a group of psychopathic racists can slaughter their neighbours in peace. Then attack and arrest anyone with enough compassion to stand up for the basic human rights of those people being slaughtered.

And at home, the British government refuses to arrest a large network of people abusing children, because to do so would appear racist.

Utter Hypocrisy.

I am not sure this comment will actually get posted, and I apologise for my rant. But I am naturally frustrated by the state of the world at the moment, as any right-thinking person should be.

Re: Massive PS5 Failure MindsEye Delays Promised Hitman Level

Matthewnh

I remember the review score for “Gollum” being really very low.
So I went back and checked.

Gollum received a review score of 2/10, compared with Minds(Black)Eye receiving a 3/10.

So there is at least ONE game that is objectively worse than MindsEye. Faint praise, I suppose.

But I still think the best thing is to simply give it a miss. And I had actually had high hopes for this one.

Re: Avatar PS5 Game Gets a Third-Person Mode, New Game+ in Huge December Update

Matthewnh

Absolutely love this game.

Not sure how it will play in third-person, but it will be interesting to find out.

Will it make the game easier, or not? Will third person mode just end up feeling like tomb raider? Or Uncharted?

It might prove useful, so hopefully you will get the option to toggle it on or off.

For me, not being able to see your created character was not a big deal, and I found the first person point of view to be really immersive.

I thought it was odd that your character is not actually an Avatar, though.

Re: Ubisoft Reckons Microtransactions Make Games 'More Fun'

Matthewnh

So UbiSoft’s message to their customers :

“Here is our brand new game.
It is £75.00, on the latest and most advanced hardware
We have purposefully made sure that is no fun at all.
If you would like the fun version, please pay us more money”.

Except, in french, I assume.

These people really need to work on their PR.

Re: Live-Action Assassin's Creed TV Show Still Happening, Netflix Green-Lights

Matthewnh

I never particularly liked the very first AC game. And did not play any more of them, until AC Origins. Which I love, due to the attention to detail, the historical accuracy of Ancient Egypt.

Not having the same interest in the later, new time-periods, I have actually skipped all of the other new games. So Origins remains the only AC game I have played, and I have done so several times.

Perhaps this is the reason that I really enjoy the movie, because I have little interest in the convoluted backstory of AC lore, and because game-wise, I only wanted to enjoy exploring Egypt at the time of the Pharaohs.

Actually, I think that one of the stuntmen on the movie might actually hold a world record, for the longest continual swan-dive. A free-fall of 125 feet, lasting four seconds.

Re: Reaction: Game Key PS5 Discs Are a Disgrace, and Sony Should Put a Stop to Them

Matthewnh

We have all known for some time that game discs are basically a physical copy of the license to download the game.

Which is ironic. Or is that “moronic”?

But that said, I will add two things.

1. I will always prefer to have disc copies of games, over downloads, wherever possible.

2. I will flatly refuse to ever buy a console that does not possess some form of disc drive.

This might very well mean that the PS5 is the last PlayStation that I shall own.

Re: GTA 6 Trailer 2 Is Finally Here, PS5 Graphics Are Jaw-Dropping

Matthewnh

This looks incredible.

Sure, it is video….and not actual gameplay, but considering what Rockstar managed to accomplish last time, this will be awesome.

Especially as we now know that there is still a year to go. The attention-to-detail in RDR2 was just astonishing. But this looks vastly superior to even those high standards.

Re: Until Dawn Game Writers Aren't in the Movie's Credits, and Some Aren't Happy About It

Matthewnh

I am not particularly interested in this Until Dawn movie. I just do not see the point in it. The interactive experience, the player’s decisions, are what actually matter.

Why bother making a mediocre movie, based upon a clever game? A game that was openly influenced by far better movies.

But I agree entirely, that not giving credit to the original creators of the work is awful. Is it a money issue? Royalties?

But this happens a lot in Hollywood, doesn’t it? How many films are remakes of previous work, and do not acknowledge the original writers?

For instance, did Martin Scorsese and William Monahan credit the writers of Infernal Affairs, when they wrote The Departed?

Re: Indiana Jones and the Great Circle Download Size Is Still Massive on PS5

Matthewnh

All that this suggests to me is that Bethesda has done a fairly basic port. I get the sense that very little attempt was made to actually “optimise” the PS5 version.

My internal SSD still has 520GB of free space. And I imagine that more people will invest in an SSD expansion as games get larger and more complicated.

But after all, if I was really interested in Indiana Jones and the Great Circle, then I would have undoubtedly bought the XBox version by now.

Re: Dodgy List of Most Influential Games Ever Puts 2-Month-Old RPG in the Top 10

Matthewnh

People who voted for the new Kingdom Come Deliverance II, clearly do not understand the meaning of the word “Influential”.

These lists prove to me that either people have short memories, or I am getting old. Maybe both.

For me influential games are things like -

GTA 3
Broken Sword
Monkey Island
Duke Nukem 3D
Eye of the Beholder
Elite

As in, actually having had some influence on subsequent releases.

Re: Sony to Turn Horizon Zero Dawn into a Movie, Not a TV Show

Matthewnh

The trouble is that I believe the only people who would be interested in seeing a Horizon film adaptation are those people who have enjoyed the games.

I also feel that condensing the lore and the story into a film that was at most three hours long - it would make it a complete muddle. Watering down the convoluted plot of a forty-hour science fiction archaeofuturist game into a movie length experience, seems like an impossible task.

And making that plot into a feature film that the general public (those without experience of the source material) want to see?

I fear that to me this all sounds like a waste of time.

A perfect parallel would be the recent Dune films. A monumental epic of a novel, made into a pair of films that are over six hours long. And they still took liberties with the plot. And if you have not read the book, then large portions of dialogue (specialist terminology) just sounds like gibberish.

Re: Remaster Specialists Are Ready to Target the PS3 Next, And We Can't Wait

Matthewnh

Resistance Fall of Man was just fantastic. Would like to give those games another go. An updated edition of the whole trilogy sounds like an excellent idea.

Especially considering I missed out on the third one.

I would also love to see the Dragon Age games given an update, even if it is only the first two. But that won’t happen, will it?

The trouble is that the original Dragon Age games use a completely unique engine. Too bad there is no-one left at BioWare that knows how to use it.

How about some more Mirrors Edge? Or a rebuild of the PS3 original?

Re: One of the Strangest Games Ever Made Appears to Be Coming to PS5, PS4

Matthewnh

There was that side quest in the first Judgment game, about a guy that stole panties from washing lines. Gave him superpowers!

This weirdly seems to take that idea, and turn it into an entire game.

What is it about Japanese culture? Half of it is brilliant, creative, inventive, and the other half is just plain crazy?

I think that I will give this game a miss, thankyou very much.

Re: The Order: 1886 Honoured in Today's New Astro Bot PS5 Level

Matthewnh

I played through The Order, more than once. I thought it was a really good game.

Yes, it was short, but at least you actually got to see the end of the story.

The visuals and the artistic style were just gorgeous, at the time. For an early PS4 game.

If not a sequel, then how about a remake?

I would like Ninja Theory to remake Heavenly Sword, as well. That was another great-looking fun game.
Hopefully somebody will do a remake, with PS5 visuals.

Re: Horizon Online Snaffles Bungie's Design Lead As Guerrilla Builds All-Star Team Around Live Service PS5 Game

Matthewnh

I do not like the idea of “live service” games, in particular.

I cannot actually understand how Horizon could function as a “live service”. Perhaps they are trying to go down the route of “co-operative” play, like Monster Hunter? And have no story at all?

But “live service” will always make me think of Concord, and Anthem. Two huge disappointments.

Re: Poll: How Long Does It Take You to Beat a Big RPG?

Matthewnh

I have played the Dragon Age games, and the Mass Effect series many times. I replay the games in order to see what consequences my choices have.

I do like to see as much of these games, as much of the story as possible.

I have also replayed Hogwarts Legacy several times, but was disappointed that there is only one ending.