Comments 282

Re: 'The Plan's the Plan Until It's Not the Plan': Xbox All Over the Place on Future PS5 Ports

Matthewnh

That expression sounds like gobbledegook to me.
“The plan is the plan, until the plan is not the plan”.

Is this their way of saying “we are just making this up as we go”?

I would very much like to see Xbox succeed, because healthy competition is good for business, and for customers.

I would also love to see Xbox continue to produce hardware. Because I want to see what that they, and Sony, both come up with next.

Re: Larian CEO Swen Vincke Sticks His Foot in It Again, Thinks Game Reviewers Should Also Be Reviewed

Matthewnh

The answer is quite easy.
People ought to stick with reviewers they trust.
That trust has been earned over time, by simply giving fair and accurate reviews.

I think we are all regulars here at PushSquare (and PureXbox, as well in my case) because we know this site gives fair, accurate, balanced reviews.

Very occasionally I will read people’s opinions on amazon also, although that is hardly the most reliable source sometimes.

I learnt quickly that player reviews on Xbox Live store can generally be ignored.

“Ignored”. Perhaps that what IGN stands for?

Re: Talking Point: Did ANTHEM Deserve the Hate?

Matthewnh

I enjoyed Anthem, while it lasted.

The world was interesting, and the flying was fantastic. It just felt so good. The actual combat was repetitive, and the loot was sparse.

I liked the backstory, the history of the world they created. I just seem to recall there being far too few missions, and all becoming samey.

I felt it was odd, that BioWare should actually create a game without any kind of narrative.

But what was there, I enjoyed playing.

Re: Sony May Be 'Planning Its Entire Calendar' Around GTA 6, Says Jason Schreier

Matthewnh

I can understand everyone being excited for GTA6, and other developers being wary of the reported release window.

But, let us be honest, GTA6 is just going to be more of the same, and hardly groundbreaking. Yes, it will be great fun, but we know exactly what to expect by now. Sure, more of the same is good, but how about invention, or originality?

And making a satire of modern life seems somehow redundant at this point.

Re: Future Sports Series Speedball Resurrected on PS5 This Month

Matthewnh

This is a blast from the past.

I remember playing the original game on the Amiga, as well. I also recall not being very good at it.

It was obviously inspired by Rollerball, which in turn presumably inspired the game in Alita :Battle Angel. Motorball?

The Amiga had some fantastic games. I am sure that I played Frontier (Elite II) the most, though.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 612

Matthewnh

Just started a new playthrough of Red Dead Redemption 2.

Played the new remaster of the first RDR (its barely a remaster, but it looks nicer). So now starting the sequel. Still on the prologue, so very early days.

And, yes, I know. Technically, I am playing the story in the wrong order. But I don’t care.

Re: Star Wars: Fate of the Old Republic Announced, from Mass Effect Director

Matthewnh

I never did manage to play KOTOR, but this sounds great.

But I think I need to reserve judgment until some more solid news arrives. I shall wait, and see.

But, with this one, and Drew Karpyshyn’s new game Exodus, hopefully coming along next year, it is a good time for us science fiction fans.

Still awaiting more definite news on the next Mass Effect. There was a poster, and a sort of teaser clip, but that was a long tine ago now.

Re: 'We Might as Well Dissolve the Team Right Now': Like a Dragon Boss Won't Bend to Overseas Popularity

Matthewnh

The headline is very good news.

I think everyone here realises that making Yakuza appeal to a more mainstream/western audience would totally destroy the very thing that makes these games unique.

By trying to make games that appeal to everybody, they would actually end up with games that appeal to no-one.

Sometimes the variety, from the serious tone pivoting to the utterly ridiculous is actually what these games appealing. Sometimes you just never know what to expect.

That, for me at least, is why they are so much fun.

Re: Preview: Avatar PS5 Is Transformed in Third-Person, Expanded in From the Ashes DLC

Matthewnh

I got so used to this game being in first-person perspective, that I am certain playing it in third-person is going to feel very weird. Horizon is third-person, and Avatar being in first-person sort of made it stand out. I found it to be much more immersive.

But mostly, I want to try this new DLC, and see what the Ash Clan are all about.

Edit: I have just now realised that this batch of DLC is not included in the season pass, whereas all of the other pieces were. I wonder why? That seems odd.

Re: Video: All the PS5 Games We Think Are 10/10

Matthewnh

I have just discovered something odd.

Push Square review scores for:

The Last of Us (PS3) 10/10
The Last of Us Remastered (PS4) 10/10
The Last of Us Remastered (PS5) 8/10

The Last of Us Part II (PS4) 10/10
The Last of Us Part II Remastered (PS5) 9/10

This seems rather inconsistent. But I suppose there are good reasons for this.

Re: Talking Point: Does PS5 Have a Sequel Problem?

Matthewnh

I think that whether or not a game is new, or is a sequel, I think that is irrelevant.

What matters to me the most is “Am I enjoying what I am playing?” And “is this a good story?”

Mind you, I certainly looking forward to the inevitable sequel to Hogwarts Legacy. And sometimes, more of the same can be a good thing.

Re: PS5 RPG Where Winds Meet Makes a Strong Start with Two Million Players

Matthewnh

I installed this, and played it for a few days.

I thought it might like an interactive version of the movies “Crouching Tiger” or “House of Flying Daggers”.

A lot of the game does not seem to make sense to me, and I was finding it just impenetrable. Too complicated for its’ own good, with the plot moving at the pace of a tired snail.

Given up, and deleted it. I might have the patience for it one day. But it was beautiful to look at, though.

Re: Xbox, PC Sci-Fi RPG Starfield Won't Be Revealed for PS5 Until Next Year

Matthewnh

Played through Starfield three times on Series X.

It is an enjoyable experience, yet it is hardly revolutionary. It is definitely a fun time, whilst you are playing it, but I feel that it is nothing special.

I have also noticed that none of the decisions you make throughout seem to have actual consequences. And the game only seems to end one way.

Re: Sony Plans to Start Shooting Horizon Movie in 2026, with 2027 Release Planned

Matthewnh

I just cannot see how this could possibly work as a blockbuster movie.

A live action “Horizon” movie will need tons of cgi and “bluescreen”. This film will be almost 100% computer generated, I feel.

And the development cycle seems far too short, considering it took Cameron three years to film Avatar (2009), and likely years of work before filming even took place.

I also believe the movie will not actually interest people who have not played the game. The dialogue will probably be totally impenetrable to those not already familiar with the story.

The Uncharted film actually was not that bad. To make Horizon into a proper cinematic experience, that will require something truly special.

Re: Sony Puts PS5 on Sale for Once, a £90 Saving in the UK

Matthewnh

@sanderson72

Nice. You’ve got yourself a real bargain.

I paid just over £250 for a 2TB SSD, in January 2022. And it still sells for the same price now as it did then.

If I ever manage to upgrade my PS5, I will not forget the SSD. I do not want the hassle of having to reinstall everything.

Re: 'Sony Seeks an Impermissible Monopoly on Genre Conventions': Tencent Fires Back Over Horizon Rip-Off

Matthewnh

This all seems to me as though Tencent have been caught red-handed.

They tried to develop an obvious rip-off of a well-known title. And are now trying to save their necks.

One could argue that Black Myth WuKong is a rip off of Enslaved:Odyssey to the West. They both use the same book as inspiration, after all. Wu Cheng’en wrote A Journey to the West, which is also known as “Monkey”.

The trouble is, where is this going to end?

You only need to look to modern cinema, and realise that a lot of creators and developers are intellectually lazy, and have no original ideas of their own.

Re: $200 MGS Delta Collector's Edition Ridiculed Over Temu-Esque Snake Figurine

Matthewnh

The only Collectors edition game I had was the original Watch Dogs.

I have a 12inch tall Aiden Pearce statuette, that is still in the styrofoam box. Never been on display.

This seems to prove that some expensive collectors editions are good value, whereas others are simply a rip-off.

I shall let you all decide which category this one falls under.

Re: Ambitious Open World RPG Crimson Desert Delayed to 2026

Matthewnh

So the headline implies that the game is perhaps TOO ambitious.

But I agree with the general sentiment here, that we all have enough to keep us occupied for the time being.

So let Pearl Abyss improve and perfect Crimson Desert. Besides, I would always prefer that development teams release their games when they are finished, and not beforehand.

After all, we are customers, and not playtesters. If software developers want us to all test their games for them, then they ought to pay us to do it.

If it truly is that good, it is going to be worth waiting for.