Comments 4,040

Re: The Game Awards 2025 Predictions: PS5 Games, the Muppets, and Geoff Keighley's Shoes

somnambulance

@MichaelNau I think E33 continues on with a proof started with Baldur’s Gate 3 that you can get a very niche game very successful if it caters to that niche very much so. I remember being extremely impressed with how well BG3 sold in spite of being an incredibly niche offering. I believe that, in catering to a niche, you will be able to generate strong word of mouth, which creates free marketing for these types of games. E33 potentially did this even more than BG3 did too, as I just remember such a saturation about E33 earlier in the year.

Re: The Game Awards 2025 Predictions: PS5 Games, the Muppets, and Geoff Keighley's Shoes

somnambulance

@MichaelNau I’ve spent a lot of time considering why this game was so successful, but personally felt it was so average. Most people have told me, “People just have different taste. You can’t like everything that’s a critical hit,” which is true, but, for some reason, I had to rationalize why I might feel that way because, on paper, it should be everything I’d want out of a game and, besides, I already understand what I didn’t like in previous winners. It felt like a game where many people I knew disliked something about the game too where they almost felt bad about being critical and saying something until they were “safe to do so,” as for some reason people are shyer about being critical of this game than certain other games. I mean, even the underdog messaging this game has seems manufactured, as it was heavily marketed by Xbox, almost as if it was a first party game, and was receiving heavy media coverage since it was announced.

I think it’s quite an interesting game for things like that and it’s had a hype train unlike anything I’d seen. The marketing team behind the game is rather brilliant, honestly.

Re: The Game Awards 2025 Predictions: PS5 Games, the Muppets, and Geoff Keighley's Shoes

somnambulance

@Max_the_German In my personal opinion, everything successful about E33 is a reaction against something else established in another franchise and I think that’s why the game may be somewhat more divisive than its internet portrayal. Its turn based nature is certainly a reaction against Final Fantasy. The map design is a reaction against Ubisoft games. The game’s pricing was a reaction against AAA pricing. The game’s length as reported by the team prior to launch was a reaction against other RPGs that boast length as a selling point. And yet it could be argued that the game is a reaction against indie games having funding as well if you want to be cynical. Etc, etc. I suspect this is why some people are enamored with the game whereas others see the game as average and there’s few that outright don’t like the game at all. It’s an interesting game as a meta commentary for trends in the current gaming landscape and what happens when you give a specific subset of gamers precisely what they want.

Re: The Game Awards 2025 Predictions: PS5 Games, the Muppets, and Geoff Keighley's Shoes

somnambulance

@Max_the_German Yeah, I agree. I noticed how differently everyone plays the game after I completed it and watched my family play. My daughter’s 4 and she can enjoy it, which isn’t always the case with even simple games. I’ve showed it off to a lot of people and everyone loves it once they get to that first big open level, and they all seem to get through it in a different approach. The way I see it: if I see that type of enjoyment in so many different people of different ages and backgrounds, casual and dedicated gamers, to me, that’s a game that deserves something, even if it’s not my personal pick.

Y’know, given the holidays, I’ve had the opportunity to talk to more people about games outside my internet bubble and talking about GotY has been fascinating, especially with E33, as none of my family, friends or acquaintances (all of whom spend far less time reading gaming news coverage than any of us on here) thought the game was GotY or was trending towards it. If anything, Silksong was the one that kept coming up. I thought it was sort of refreshing to hear so many voices say Kingdom Come Deliverance 2, Hades 2, or Silksong were obviously going to win (and honestly it was sort of refreshing to get some more critical takes of Yotei, Silent Hill, and E33 too… though it’s so weird how divisive Nintendo feels right now).

Re: The Game Awards 2025 Predictions: PS5 Games, the Muppets, and Geoff Keighley's Shoes

somnambulance

@Max_the_German I loved Bananza. If Astro Bot was Sony telling Nintendo that it can make an attempt to match Mario Odyssey (which I prefer Odyssey, but I’d say both games are a 10), then Bananza is them clapping back big time. My personal GotY is Death Stranding 2, followed by Silksong, but DKB is my #3 (like 2024, it was a year of mostly 6/10 and 7/10 games with 3 big 10/10s to smoothen out the year overall) but I’m rooting for Bananza because I think it does deserve it. It’s a very unique game and a game that literally anyone can play and have a unique experience.

Re: Game of the Month: Dispatch (November 2025)

somnambulance

Calling it now: Marvel Cosmic Invasion wins December… Not saying that’ll be my pick, but it’s my guess. December looks surprisingly solid, but I get the feeling most December games will be buried.

@bowzoid Is Sektori solid? I’m contemplating picking it up soon. It’s on my wishlist.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 609

somnambulance

Honestly, I really want to play something new, but I feel bad about buying anything new right now, given that Metroid is coming this week and I’m about to buy a Steamdeck and will be sinking some money into starting a Steam library very soon. I have to work today, but it’s snow storm weather, so I sort of want to just curl up and play some games. Realistically though, I think I’m just going to plan my early Steam library and play Arc Raiders… but I keep thinking about The Outer Worlds 2 at random too…

I should go back to Yotei and finish that though, shouldn’t I? Or Silent Hill F? Or Hades 2? For some reason, as good as those games are, man, I’m struggling getting back to them.

Re: Video: All the PS5 Games We Think Are 10/10

somnambulance

For me, the 10/10s are:
Elden Ring
Alan Wake 2
Final Fantasy 16
Final Fantasy 7: Rebirth
Balatro
Astro Bot
Death Stranding 2
Hollow Knight: Silksong

So… I half agree with the Pushsquare list! I’d say I’d rank Edith Finch as a 10/10 too, but that’s a PS4 game for me. Might as well say a bunch of PS4 games with PS5 upgrades are 10/10s if that one’s included, you know?

All that said, even the 10s I disagree with, it’s impossible to deny their impact and quality…

Re: Talking Point: Does PS5 Have a Sequel Problem?

somnambulance

I don’t really think it’s a sequel problem so much as it feels like the sequels aren’t as good as the first games. I wouldn’t say any of the PS5 sequels reign supreme over the PS4 originals. I mean, they improve the gameplay a little bit, but the games feel iterative rather than games than go in new dimensions, if you know what I mean. None of them have been a TotK sequel to BotW if that makes sense. Astro Bot could qualify as a solid sequel that was a leap. Death Stranding 2 is about as good as the first one too.

Also, Wolverine and Saros definitely feel sequely to me, even though they aren’t authentic sequels.

Re: Poll: Five Years of PS5 - How Would You Rate Sony's Console?

somnambulance

The console has been solid, but I did have to get mine repaired because the liquid metal in the console dried out. A little bit of a design flaw in the console. However, I love the Dualsense controller 100%. Might be my favorite controller of all time so far.

As far as games go, it’s been a patchy generation. It’s not like there’s nothing to play this generation, far from it, but there’s certainly been fewer essential experiences. Thus far, 2023 might be the only year that truly felt exceptional for the console. I’m not sure Sony’s first party strategy is for me anymore either. So far, Astro Bot and Death Stranding 2 are the only first party games I’d give a 10/10 to. I know a 10/10 is high praise, but that’s definitely lower than any other PlayStation console. The exclusives have carried the console for me, but most aren’t exclusive anymore. It’s been a weird generation where software is concerned.

And I can wait a long time for a PS6. Sony will have to sell the console to me next time, unfortunately. I’m not an insta-buy like I had been for three generations. I’m not sure I’d buy a new gen PlayStation right now and that’s largely because the first party line-up hasn’t been for me. Contemplating to go PC/Nintendo next gen.

Re: Suddenly the PS5 Pro Doesn't Look That Expensive Anymore

somnambulance

@Dogbreath Fair enough, but I don’t think the majority of users here are in the minimum wage bracket, which would account for the squabbling. The users on this site tend to be more adult, so, if the average grocery item is 18%+ more expensive than it would have been three years ago, and if they’ve not received a wage increase to be comparable to the raising costs, that would make an impact to their thoughts of purchasing things in general, even cheaper things.

Re: Suddenly the PS5 Pro Doesn't Look That Expensive Anymore

somnambulance

@Dogbreath I think it’s the fact that everything else is more expensive now in conjunction with wages not raising to meet the standard of those price increases that is making people view price hikes on anything an an enemy. Also, there was no way to socially complain about things back in the day. Lol.

But, I mean, personally I agree with you that gaming is a relatively cheap hobby in comparison to everything else and I do hope it stays that way. I mean, you can get a game for cheaper than you can going to see a movie in a theater with a family of 4 circa 2025 (in my area, at least). Sort of insane you can buy a 100+ hour experience for $70 these days on anything… and that’s without a sale.

But, when groceries cost approximately double what they did 5 years ago and rent has increased significantly as well, that means many are being squeezed out of their hobbies now because the essentials cost more. And I know plenty of people that haven’t gotten a raise in the last two years or have lost their job and had to take a job that pays less due to “market uncertainty.” I think it’s more these factors than anything else. The world just isn’t what it was pre-2020.

Re: When Is The Game Awards 2025?

somnambulance

Rooting for Donkey Kong Bananza since it won critics choice at the Golden Joystick Awards. Death Stranding 2’s my real pick, but man I’d love to see Bananza win just because of all the monkey business, you know?

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 608

somnambulance

@DrVenture69 He really likes walking sims, particularly ones with somewhat “scary” vibes, though he doesn’t like games that are actually scary. He likes the Exit 8 a lot too. I got lucky he’s not Roblox and Fortnite minded as many kids are these days!

I think the themes in Maquette may not click with him, but Talos Principle may be a good shout. I don’t recall if I own it (modern gamer problems, right?), but I’ve never played it. Might be fun to go in blind together!

Re: Don't Expect Intergalactic PS5 to Launch Until at Least 2027

somnambulance

That’s a bummer. I know I’m a little bit of an anomaly with Sony next year in comparison to most on here, but there’s nothing first party right now outside this I’m looking forward to. I know it was wishful thinking for this one to be 2026, but still… could really use more Naughty Dog-esque games in the industry right now.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 608

somnambulance

I played through Portal yesterday with my son. That was fun. It’s always interesting to share an ancient artifact with him and see what he thinks. He could see the influence in other games he likes such as The Stanley Parable, Superliminal, and The Witness. Not bad observing that for an 8 year old.

Outside that, I’m contemplating jumping on a Black Friday sale for something. While, yes, I still have Yotei and Silent Hill F to complete, I sort of feel like I’m having a hard time pushing myself to play either of them and Portal felt like a breath of fresh air. A friend of mine really wants me to start playing Arc Raiders too, so maybe that’s the answer. I didn’t have time for games for a while, but I think that’ll change a bit this week. Just not sure how yet.

Re: Quick Thinking from Sony Should Shield PS5 from RAM Shortages for Now

somnambulance

@REALAIS Bill Gates himself said recently in interview that AI will solve a lot of global issues and result in people being able to work less and spend more time doing the things they enjoy. On Jimmy Fallon, he waxed on about how humans could enjoy a 2 day workweek in the future. These suits are literally telling us that AI will make life easier and create more abundance for everyone. I know it’s a lie, you know it’s a lie. They know it’s a lie. AI is already consuming far more energy and water than most people realize. Scarcity is going to continue skyrocketing from AI burning through resources. I’m commenting on the narrative we are being fed. Even here, Microsoft is being pictured as the fool and Sony as the victor, but in reality Sony prepared for the small term when the larger impact is likely still going to affect them as well

Re: 75+ PS5, PS4 Games to Buy in PS Store's Black Friday Sale

somnambulance

@get2sammyb It’s a rare type of game that doesn’t feel quite like anything else. It reminds me a lot of early 3D gaming where developers didn’t know what worked or what people would like, so they created something experimental. It feels like a strategy game mixed with hack n slash, but it’s also got that classic Capcom DNA as well. I didn’t complete the game, but enjoyed my time with it. The campaign was lengthy and the gameplay loop is addictive and first, but it does get a little repetitive, which is why I dropped off.

Re: Arthurian Action Game Tides of Annihilation Stuns in Staggering PS5 Boss Fight Trailer

somnambulance

@rjejr I think you’re right that we need more color in games. A new Dragon Quest would feel absolutely refreshing right now because it’s so colorful and is… dare I say it? Fun! I feel like this current era has totally forgotten what fun feels like. A lot of games are downtrodden and don’t even have the ability to inject humor into it. Elden Ring, for all its darkness, at least has a dark humor to it and has characters with names like “Dung Collector.” It feels like there’s just been this huge wave of humorless, over serious darkness.

But you’re totally right about it being partly the Chinese games thing. I hate to generalize a country’s output, but yeah… these Chinese games are all going for a similar vibe. They all play sort of similar in being Souls, but not too.

And it feels like Jennifer English is the next Troy Baker, as her voice feels like it’s in all the big games now. Not saying she’s a bad voice actress. She’s a good voice actress. But her voice has a vibe to it that matches that aesthetic and I dunno…

The whole darn industry is getting typecast into dark fantasy pout dreams. Lol

Re: Expedition 33, Ghost of Yotei Have Started Scooping Up GOTY Awards

somnambulance

@AgentGuapo I loved Bananza, personally. I wouldn’t call it GotY though, but it definitely feels like Nintendo clapping back at PlayStation for Astro Bot to me. Fantastic visuals, gameplay, and it feels like Donkey Kong, but also something else entirely.

For me:
1. Death Stranding 2
2. Silksong
3. Donkey Kong Bananza

Not sure where I’d rank E33, could be around #20-ish

Edit: just expanded my personal list from a top 10 to a top 20 and I’d put E33 at exactly #20, but I’ve still yet to rank Silent Hill F or Arc Raiders of games released this year since I’ve yet to invest any time into them.

Re: Arthurian Action Game Tides of Annihilation Stuns in Staggering PS5 Boss Fight Trailer

somnambulance

@rjejr Yes! So much yes! I loved Elden Ring. It’s a contender for being the best game this decade already and it’s still so early, but in its wake, there have been such a Souls saturation, whether it’s games that play like Souls or look like Souls. It’s not really unique anymore and I’m tired of it. And yes E33 falls into that boat hard as well. Could be part of the reason why I feel E33 is a contender for most overrated game ever made.

But it’s not just that it’s dark and black. Alan Wake 2 is dark and black, but it hits different. It just feels like so many games are going for such similar vibes with the mixture of surrealism and medieval fantasy and a little steampunk to loop it together. It reminds me of that time a little over a decade ago where almost every game had zombies for a little while.