BG3 will win but Alan Wake 2 deserves to IMO. Such an incredible game with by far the most originality and big swings on the technical side of things that were knocked out of the park.
Kept having trouble getting away from this game over the weekend. Soooooooo good. Easily my GoTY so far. Nothing, even BG3, comes close IMO. So well designed and unlike anything before.
That perfect 10 score here was spot on! This is how you raise the bar, not only for a sequel but for next gen gaming.
Pretty low on my list right now. I haven’t even finished the first one - started to get bored with the story and repetitiveness. This has been the year of the RPG for me with BG3, FF 16, Sea of Stars, Chained Echoes and Starfield. Add Super Mario Wonder, ToTK and Diablo 3 as well as a few surprises like Lies of P, Hi-Fi Rush and Cocoon and that’s pretty much my year in gaming.
Have a feeling Baldur’s Gate 3 (96 with 131 total reviews on OpenCritic) or Tears of the Kingdom (96 reviews with 151 reviews on OpenCritic) will be taking home most GoTY prizes, but this will probably at least be nominated.
@QuietintheCorner It’s not just you. I’ve seen a bunch of comments here about not wanting to get a game because it’s on GamePass. Judge a game on its merits. Not whether it’s on GP.
I played some on GamePass and can’t wait to try it again with this patch. It had promise but needed some work. Ridiculous that people pass on games because they think they’re “GamePass fodder”. Is Lies of P just “GamePass fodder”? Sea of Stars (also on PS+ Extra) also just “fodder”?
There are some great indie games I’ve played on GamePass so it’s your loss if you don’t want to play a game just because of it. The stupidity of console wars.
Fired this back up and can’t pinpoint exactly what has changed (other than looking through the list). It’s been a while but gotta say it feel great so far.
A shame this is coming when I’m already juggling Starfield, Baldur’s Gate 3, AC 6 and Lies of P!
I don’t know any Xbox player that suddenly thinks the series is “theirs”. They’re just happy to be able to play them on GamePass. Nothing wrong with that.
Sure there’s some good games in there. But since most are at least 2 years old, I’ve played the ones I’ve wanted to play (mostly having grabbed them on cheap sales).
Already played most of these games. A few were on GamePass and already bought a few others (13 Sentinels is a great game). But I’ll give the new Star Ocean a try.
My issue is how large of a price hike it is. I’m in the US and a 35% increase at one time is ludicrous. Honestly was shocked when I saw how dramatic it was.
Actually love this one more the Desperados III. It’s so much more accessible with wonderful writing and lots of different ways to approach each mission.
I kind of disagree with the Diablo 4 criticism. The 25-30 hour main campaign did have a clear end-goal. So I was perfectly good with the original release in the state it was in. Did the post-release content need more thought? Yes, but the main release was fantastic on its own and has very few bugs. Not a game I would call “unfinished” at release.
And there’s still dozens of hours of content I haven’t played!
Not exactly sure where the “rock solid” PC port came from in the header. DF mentioned a ton of problems.
From the Eurogamer article:
“All of these issues give the impression that - once again - a PC port has launched when it's not in a fully polished state.” and “ Sony keeps shipping games with obvious problems at launch.”
I’d give it an 7-8 so far. The opening hours were great but then it slows down to a crawl. I’ve played 12 hours and outside of some boss fights (and those opening hours), I’ve been a bit disappointed after all the hype. Hoping it gets better and I’m just in a lull. That said if it is a lull, then it’s got some serious pacing issues.
Reminds me of Final Fantasy VII Remake where they added too much filler. And I haven’t even done many side quests.
They announced this during this trial but they aren’t blocking it at all. It’s actually past their deadline and they had let it go with just some concerns. And just would continue to monitor it. This story and the headline are inaccurate.
Comments 1,152
Re: All The Game Awards 2023 Nominees Announced, Baldur's Gate 3 and Alan Wake 2 Lead the Way
BG3 will win but Alan Wake 2 deserves to IMO. Such an incredible game with by far the most originality and big swings on the technical side of things that were knocked out of the park.
Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Alan Wake 2?
10! Amazing game and easily my GoTY in a year of fantastic games. Blew my expectations out of the water.
Re: Upcoming PS5 Games for November and December 2023
Where’s Like a Dragon Gaiden: The Man Who Erased His Name?!? That’s my most anticipated game over the next two months.
Re: All PS Plus Members Handed a Movie Discount on Sony Pictures Core
Yeah, the lack of Movies Anywhere makes it a hard no to buy anything on PlayStation. Come on Sony. Even Microsoft participates in MA!
Re: Thirsty Suitors (PS5) - An Authentic, Entertaining Tale of Self Discovery
Sounds fun! Will definitely check this out on GamePass.
Re: Poll: Are You Playing Alan Wake 2?
Kept having trouble getting away from this game over the weekend. Soooooooo good. Easily my GoTY so far. Nothing, even BG3, comes close IMO. So well designed and unlike anything before.
That perfect 10 score here was spot on! This is how you raise the bar, not only for a sequel but for next gen gaming.
Re: PS1 FPS Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster Lands on PS5, PS4 in February
Probably should have mentioned it’s Nightdive doing this remaster. That alone makes it legit worth looking forward to.
Re: Poll: Are You Playing Metal Gear Solid: Master Collection Vol. 1?
Should have included the option “No, I’m just going to play the HD Collection”.
Re: Poll: Are You Playing Marvel's Spider-Man 2?
Pretty low on my list right now. I haven’t even finished the first one - started to get bored with the story and repetitiveness. This has been the year of the RPG for me with BG3, FF 16, Sea of Stars, Chained Echoes and Starfield. Add Super Mario Wonder, ToTK and Diablo 3 as well as a few surprises like Lies of P, Hi-Fi Rush and Cocoon and that’s pretty much my year in gaming.
But it’s all about SM Wonder this weekend!
Re: Marvel's Spider-Man 2 Takes Over the World on PS5 Launch Day
Good for Sony (though it’s Super Mario Bros. Wonder that I’ll be buying and playing today).
Re: PS5's Dead Space Remake Floats onto EA Play Later This Month
@Sakai Ubisoft+ is also available on Xbox. But it’s a joke at $17.99 a month. Even if it includes newer games, Ubisoft game prices drop like a rock.
Re: Sky-High Marvel's Spider-Man 2 PS5 Review Scores Make It One of the Top Rated Games of 2023
Have a feeling Baldur’s Gate 3 (96 with 131 total reviews on OpenCritic) or Tears of the Kingdom (96 reviews with 151 reviews on OpenCritic) will be taking home most GoTY prizes, but this will probably at least be nominated.
Re: Roguelike Warm Snow Gets Heated In Animated PS5, PS4 Story Trailer
Is the snow yellow?
Re: Sony Pictures Core Movie App Launches Today on PS5, PS4 with Exclusive Benefits
Sony Core would have to join MA for me to even think about buying a movie through them.
Re: Cocoon (PS5) - All Killer, No Filler in This Superb Recursive World Puzzler
More GamePass fodder. /s
Can’t wait to play this!!!
Re: The Last Case of Benedict Fox Comes to PS5 in a Definitive Edition
@Shigurui Thanks! I’ll redownload it to check out.
Re: The Last Case of Benedict Fox Comes to PS5 in a Definitive Edition
@QuietintheCorner It’s not just you. I’ve seen a bunch of comments here about not wanting to get a game because it’s on GamePass. Judge a game on its merits. Not whether it’s on GP.
Re: The Last Case of Benedict Fox Comes to PS5 in a Definitive Edition
I played some on GamePass and can’t wait to try it again with this patch. It had promise but needed some work. Ridiculous that people pass on games because they think they’re “GamePass fodder”. Is Lies of P just “GamePass fodder”? Sea of Stars (also on PS+ Extra) also just “fodder”?
There are some great indie games I’ve played on GamePass so it’s your loss if you don’t want to play a game just because of it. The stupidity of console wars.
Re: UK Sales Charts: Surprise Hit Lies of P Makes an Impressive Third Place Debut
FWIW, I know many people, including myself, who are still having a blast with Starfield. But surely commenters on a PlayStation site know best.
Splitting my time between it and BG3 on my PS5. Great times for RPG fans!
Re: Poll: Are You Playing Cyberpunk 2077 Update 2.0?
Played a bit at launch and was taken back at how much better it felt, particularly in combat.
Re: Full Cyberpunk 2077 2.0 Patch Notes are Here, Massive Update's Out Now on PS5
Fired this back up and can’t pinpoint exactly what has changed (other than looking through the list). It’s been a while but gotta say it feel great so far.
A shame this is coming when I’m already juggling Starfield, Baldur’s Gate 3, AC 6 and Lies of P!
But definitely will go back and finish this.
Re: Preview: Like a Dragon, SEGA's Once Embattled Yakuza Series, Has Never Been Better
I don’t know any Xbox player that suddenly thinks the series is “theirs”. They’re just happy to be able to play them on GamePass. Nothing wrong with that.
Anyway, excited for both of these!
Re: Poll: Are You Playing Lies of P?
Playing on GamePass. Enjoying it so far!
Re: UK Sales Charts: Hogwarts Legacy Stops The Crew Motorfest from Topping the Podium
@DefiledViper Yeah because 25+ million have access to it via GamePass. It’s impressive that it’s on the list at all.
Re: If It Wasn't Obvious, The Elder Scrolls 6 Will Skip PlayStation
I don’t care about console wars but when the f*** did an 83 become a bad game?
Also, it’s 86 on OpenCritic which combines PC and Xbox (87 on MetaCritic for PC FWIW).
86 is closer to what the game truly is overall. Pretty close to the 87 on OpenCritic for FF 16.
And I love both games!
Re: If It Wasn't Obvious, The Elder Scrolls 6 Will Skip PlayStation
The amount of toxicity here is truly sad. Have enjoyed Sony exclusives, but am also loving Starfield. Next to Oblivion as my favorite Bethesda game.
Am lucky to have both systems but when it comes down to it I’m just a gamer.
Re: Rumour: Wild Hearts Support Is Being Slashed Just Seven Months After Release
Maybe release it on EA Play and see if it finds a better audience? Might not hurt at this point.
Re: 20 PS Plus Extra, Premium Games Coming Next Week
Sure there’s some good games in there. But since most are at least 2 years old, I’ve played the ones I’ve wanted to play (mostly having grabbed them on cheap sales).
Re: Rumour: Six PS Plus Extra Games Leaked Ahead of September Announcement
Already played most of these games. A few were on GamePass and already bought a few others (13 Sentinels is a great game). But I’ll give the new Star Ocean a try.
Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? - Issue 492
Switching between Starfield, Sea of Stars and Baldur’s Gate 3. What a time to be an RPG fan!
Re: Reaction: Has Sony Put Together the Worst PS Plus Month Ever?
My issue is how large of a price hike it is. I’m in the US and a 35% increase at one time is ludicrous. Honestly was shocked when I saw how dramatic it was.
Re: PS Plus Essential, Extra, Premium Price Increases Announced by Sony
I’m set through 2/25 but will probably drop Extra at that point.
Re: Shadow Gambit Team Mimimi Forced to Close Over Rising Genre Costs
Sad news. They made some great games. Their latest, Shadow Gambit, may end up being one of favorites in the strategy genre.
Re: Sea of Stars (PS5) - PS Plus Extra's Retro-Inspired RPG Is the Whole Package
What’s funny is that this is one of the lower reviews. It’s got a 94 on OpenCritic so far. Can’t wait to play it!
Re: Armored Core 6: Fires of Rubicon (PS5) - Great Mecha Action at Times Feels Stunted
Playable on Series X already and I’m absolutely loving it!
Re: Mini Review: Shadow Gambit: The Cursed Crew (PS5) - Pirate Strategy Will Shiver Your Timbers
Actually love this one more the Desperados III. It’s so much more accessible with wonderful writing and lots of different ways to approach each mission.
Re: Armored Core 6: Fires of Rubicon (PS5) - Great Mecha Action at Times Feels Stunted
Wow. Think that’s the first perfect score on Eurogamer since they changed to the new system.
Edit: Forgot that Dave the Diver also got 5/5.
Re: Armored Core 6: Fires of Rubicon (PS5) - Great Mecha Action at Times Feels Stunted
@KaijuKaiser Now up to an 88 on OpenCritic, lol. They’re going in the right direction. Can’t wait to get my hands on this!
Re: Armored Core 6: Fires of Rubicon (PS5) - Great Mecha Action at Times Feels Stunted
@KaijuKaiser It’s still got an 85 average on OpenCritic currently. I don’t think people are going to be disappointed with review scores in general.
Re: PlayStation Portal Is Sony's PS5 Remote Play Handheld, Priced at $200 / £200
Not sure how this is different than having a phone with a controller.
Re: Mini Review: Quake II (PS5) - A Remastered Classic with Real Bang for Your Buck
FWIW, the game still has a 90 on OpenCritic even after including this site’s score (which is the lowest, of course).
https://opencritic.com/game/15352/quake-ii
Re: Poll: Is 'Live Service' Becoming an Excuse to Release Unfinished Games?
I kind of disagree with the Diablo 4 criticism. The 25-30 hour main campaign did have a clear end-goal. So I was perfectly good with the original release in the state it was in. Did the post-release content need more thought? Yes, but the main release was fantastic on its own and has very few bugs. Not a game I would call “unfinished” at release.
And there’s still dozens of hours of content I haven’t played!
Re: Shadow Gambit: The Cursed Crew Launch Trailer Provides Hearty Gameplay Overview
There’s a two-hour trial available with PS+ or the same trial on Xbox without a sub.
Definitely gonna try this after the stellar reviews it’s been getting.
Re: PS5 Pulling Ahead in the UK Thanks to Sony's Summer Sale
A few backward compatible Xbox games on the list with the server fixes that occurred. Kind of interesting how they spiked after that.
Re: Final Fantasy 14's Free PS5, PS4 Trial Expands to Include Stormblood
Also finally coming to Xbox…
Re: Told You So! Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart Really Wouldn't Have Worked on PS4
Not exactly sure where the “rock solid” PC port came from in the header. DF mentioned a ton of problems.
From the Eurogamer article:
“All of these issues give the impression that - once again - a PC port has launched when it's not in a fully polished state.” and “ Sony keeps shipping games with obvious problems at launch.”
Re: Oxenfree II: Lost Signals (PS5) - Solid Sequel Feels Finely Tuned
Sounds good. Probably play it on my iPhone via Netflix.
Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Final Fantasy 16?
I’d give it an 7-8 so far. The opening hours were great but then it slows down to a crawl. I’ve played 12 hours and outside of some boss fights (and those opening hours), I’ve been a bit disappointed after all the hype. Hoping it gets better and I’m just in a lull. That said if it is a lull, then it’s got some serious pacing issues.
Reminds me of Final Fantasy VII Remake where they added too much filler. And I haven’t even done many side quests.
Fingers crossed that it improves!
Re: Canada Joins UK, US in Blocking Microsoft's Activision Blizzard Buyout
They announced this during this trial but they aren’t blocking it at all. It’s actually past their deadline and they had let it go with just some concerns. And just would continue to monitor it. This story and the headline are inaccurate.
https://gameranx.com/updates/id/469898/article/canada-had-objections-to-microsoft-activision-deal-but-didnt-act-on-time/
Re: PS Plus Essential Games for July 2023 Leaked Early
I own all of them (well, AW on Series X) but acknowledge that it’s a good month.