Comments 1,015

Re: Microsoft Can't Deny Xbox Game Pass Cannibalises Software Sales

Rimebreaker

@Rob_230

My suspicion has always been that each download or 'engagement' with a game will count as a 'sale'[...]its just how i have always assumed it must work to make it profitible enough for devs

Long time ago I listened to an interview with Phil Spencer where he went on about the deals they make. He stated there was no one model, they work with every publisher and every deal slightly differently. At the start they tried to just offer an engagement fee/share (similar to how Spotify pays musicians based on song plays) but many publishers were skeptical of this model and didnt start jumping on board until they started also offering a flat up-front fee.

At the time, he noted they might still do either or a hybrid, or some other things (not specified.)

Sadly I don't remember what podcast I listened to that interview on so its hard for me to track it down again without simply looking up every interview available out there and listen to every single one again (that's how I originally bumped into it, as I was jumping to the Xbox ecosystem and philosophy and wanted to hear more about Xbox's vision before actually jumping on board.)

But at the end of the day: there is no one single model, and they negotiate with every single publisher, for every single addition.

Re: Microsoft Admits Xbox Game Pass Is Harming Software Sales After All

Rimebreaker

@NEStalgia

I think you're coming at it from a strong "I hate Microsoft" and "I don't trust new business models" bias.

I think it's mostly the former than the later. Lets face it, if (when?) Sony added all their games day one to their service (likely the Extra tier) all these same individuals will praise it as the greatest thing in the planet and "the true best deal in gaming."

Any time XBox gets something that can be seen as a strong selling point, they feel the need to do all they can to stomp on it and argue why its bad, as highlighted with all the Skyrim/Fallout fans that, post Zenimax acquisition, went on a campaign about how terrible all Bethesda games are at launch, and recently have insisted that HiFi Rush is a bad looking game, and what not.

At the end of the day, though, the more people buys all these headlines (game pass is bad, we lose money, we have no games) the narrative will just help the Activision deal go through, so I welcome this take.

Re: Rumour: Sony Suspects Skyrocketing PS5 Sales as New Model Hits in September 2023

Rimebreaker

@KaijuKaiser

They only sell 4k in stores and have been for years. If you play games you have a 4k TV.

I just checked Walmart, Target and Best Buy. They all sell both, 1080p and 720p TVs. They are extremely cheap options for a family with a limited budget, something very common these days.

Largest 1080p TV I saw at Best Buy was 43" for $150, definitively what I would buy for a child's bedroom even if I was to go crazy and buy them a PS5.

Getting a PS5, especially this next year, is about games that are just not sold for PS4, not to mention the fast loading times.

Re: UK Determines Xbox's $69 Billion Activision Buyout Could Harm Gamers

Rimebreaker

@UltimateOtaku91

This isn't about sony trying to block the deal it's about the CMA and FTC coming to their own conclusions with their own findings and research.

Not exactly, these findings are based on their inquiries and feedback to and from other interested parties. Without Sony’s claims, it’s likely they would had not reached this conclusion.

Either way, this is a procedural report that does not take into account any remedies suggested by Microsoft. Now they actually enter the negotiation phase, where Microsoft will not only officially put forward their commitment to keep the game on other platforms as they done with Minecraft, but also listen to CMAs own suggestions on potential remedies, that is always a part of these procedures.

There won’t actually be a block unless they can’t reach an agreement, something that is possible. CMA might be happy with Microsoft’s proposed remedies, or they might demand more extreme ones, like spinning off the entirety of Call of Duty into an independent entity. MS might not agree with more extreme solutions CMA might demand.

Re: PS Plus, Xbox Game Pass Aren't Big Enough to Impact Business, Says Take-Two Boss

Rimebreaker

@get2sammyb PSN+ is very different than GamePass. The main reason most people get into PSN+ (and Xbox live gold) is to play games online, and that’s just a subset of the established console user base.

I don’t think that numbers is a good pointer of how far the game pass model can go, especially when game pass is not bound to a single console (also works with pc games and mobile via streaming) and it’s mostly about a big number of single player games. Regardless of potential it will take years for the model to give us a hint at the real brick wall.

It will take Xbox actually realizing some first party games to continue feeding the “day one” incentives, though.

Re: Hogwarts Legacy (PS5) - A Harry Potter Dream Come True

Rimebreaker

@danlk1ng also, the character creator is very ambiguous. There is no “male” or “female” voice, there is “voice one” and “voice two” and you get to change the pitch of either selection. You never pick gender. The closest thing to a binary choice is deciding what dormitory you will be sleeping in, so there is just actual flag the player can pick to base pronouns off.

It would had actually been a nice thing, for everyone, to further allow customization by selecting your own pronouns, but that then that goes into the stuff you mention about re-recording several lines multiple times. As it is, the usage of they/them is good enough.

Re: PS2's Best-Selling Console Crown in Jeopardy As Nintendo Switch Passes PS4

Rimebreaker

@NEStalgia

Man, I remember being on NL when "NX" was announced amidst WiiU drama, all the naysayers were ranting about how it would fail horribly, it doesn't come close enough to PS4's power, PS 4 would destroy it, NintenDOOMED!!

Nintendo has an interesting history of industry over-reaction. Do you by any chance remember when the Wii U was announced, and both, PlayStation and XBox scrambled to try to come up with a software-based solution to offer second-screen gaming? You can still download the PS4 Second Screen app off the iPhone App Store. Dont remember what Microsoft called their offering, I dind't care much about XBox at that time.

Both companies just barely managed to offer their response to motion controls, and here came Nintendo with this second screen "innovation" that was about to destroy their hopes... and it crashed and burned like a building made out of coal bricks.

To this day I think some games still have features (that no longer work) locked behind these Second Screen smartphone app solutions.

Re: PS2's Best-Selling Console Crown in Jeopardy As Nintendo Switch Passes PS4

Rimebreaker

@get2sammyb

I actually don't think the Switch Lite has done that well for Nintendo in the grand scheme of things, but you're right of course. Like I said in the article, you're more likely to have multiple Switches per household than any PlayStation (though there will be exceptions, of course!)

Hard to know world wide but Japan does report model sales. Last week's charts listed:
Switch OLED Model – 28,787 (3,816,361)
Switch – 12,564 (19,150,623)
Switch Lite – 9,757 (5,185,166)

This means, at least in Japan, the lite accounts for 18% of total unit sales. That boost, in Japan alone might make the difference between the Switch outpacing the PS2 or not.

On the multiple console per household thing, though... I had 4 PS4 consoles in my house, gave away one when I got a PS5.

Re: Talking Point: Should Sony Be Worried by Live Service Implosion?

Rimebreaker

I Don’t play multiplier games outside classic MMOs (mostly FFXIV.) I know they claim this investment on service games won’t hurt their single player offerings, but this year we only have Spider-Man 2 in the calendar. They can try to pad the year(s?) with exclusivity deals like FF16, but that is not a replacement for actual first party games.

Re: Hogwarts Legacy (PS5) - A Harry Potter Dream Come True

Rimebreaker

@theGoodChap I read that before, it’s far from a comprehensive take on the topic. Tangentially, I find the burning/destroying/etc things they love and already own is an absurd practice, regardless how problematic a creator involved on it might be. Self-depriving of things you already own does nobody any service.

Anyways, there is plenty more out there if you care to actually find out, but I can tell you the article you list (intentionally or accidentally) didn’t bother showing most of Rowling’s anti-trans statements.

Re: Hogwarts Legacy (PS5) - A Harry Potter Dream Come True

Rimebreaker

@Westernwolf4

I am glad the game is good-it looks like Avalanche did a good job. I will pick it up during a sale and have some Hogwarts fun. I do not like the way JK Rowling has been using her vast and in no way incumbered by this review platform, so I will make a donation to a group that advocates for human rights when I do.

I wish I could heart your comment multiple times.

Re: Hogwarts Legacy (PS5) - A Harry Potter Dream Come True

Rimebreaker

As I stated on Pure Xbox: I for one am very glad Pure Xbox and Push Square have opted not to ignore the issues at hand. If Rowling gets to use her platform to spread hate, it’s fair to use this game reviews to spread awareness.

As for the game, I’m actually glad it turned out good. I’ll likely give it a shot at some point in the future, even if there was nothing making me feel dirty about spending money on it, I refuse to pay $70 for games I’m not 100% hyped about. But I’ll likely play it, eventually.

Re: PS5's Market Share Is Expanding Significantly in Xbox's Backyard

Rimebreaker

@Intr1n5ic fair enough, my reply was very much in the topic of US sales since that’s the theme of the article. Even then I feel not even discounts will change the perception for Xbox in the UK or Japan. For the console to gain additional momentum in those markets, Xbox needs strong highly desirable exclusives. The lineup so coming this year might help in the UK but doubt it will do anything in Japan.

Mind you, I don’t expect Xbox to even get close to overtaking PS in any market other than potentially the US, provided they deliver games in the next few years and can stock up in the US.

Re: PS5's Market Share Is Expanding Significantly in Xbox's Backyard

Rimebreaker

@jcvandan Bethesda will start delivering for Xbox this year. They already delivered Tango’s HiFi Rush, Arkane‘s Red Fall is coming next, and then there will be Starfield, all this year. The years of waiting for the acquisition of ZeniMax to delivering are over, now we are talking about months.

That alone might not be enough to push the needle competition wise, other studios need to start delivering, but as far as the topic of Zenimax goes, we no longer talking about years.

For what it’s worth, I was a PS4 first player, I own 166 physical PS4 games, and this Gen I have gone Xbox first for all things. I did get a PS5 but I only use it for exclusives, and those I only buy when they go on deep sales.

Re: PS5's Market Share Is Expanding Significantly in Xbox's Backyard

Rimebreaker

@GamingFan4Lyf both, the series s and x are sold at a loss, but I think we can safely assume the S is sold at a lower loss.

Your point of ads and discounts, though, is a bit mute. For one I disagree on ads, almost every Xbox series ad i seen advertises both. As for discounts, the series X does not need discounts to sell, it needs stock.

Re: PS5's Market Share Is Expanding Significantly in Xbox's Backyard

Rimebreaker

In the US, it’s all about supply, both consoles still sell ridiculously fast, even the Series S sells relatively well, although it might take a few days to sell out of stock after resupply.

Hell, the statement quoted in the article itself states it’s all about supply in the US.

What is interesting, if anything, is that last summer Series X was way more available than PS5s, but that has shifted. MS seems to be having a hard time supplying Series X, this last Christmas it was easier to bump into a PS5 than a Series X, and Microsoft heavily relied on Series S to sell units.

Question is: why? Is it a poor cost saving decision on Microsoft’s part? Did Sony use the price increase on PS5 to flip the tables on MS outbidding for supply? Or did MS simply predict they would not be able to move the Series X in higher numbers without first party Triple A games, so held back on manufacturing?

Re: PS5 Powers PlayStation to Record Breaking Financial Results

Rimebreaker

@carlos82 what? I’m not sure what you mean by “into their stride”, but Uncharted 2 is still the highlight of the series, and TLOU 1 on the PS3 was the moment the Sony brand became basically synonymous with Cinematic Experiences.

Now if Sony would stop remastering PS4 games that we already can play and would work on remastering the top tier PS3 games…

Re: Disappointment as DualSense Edge PS5 Controller Sports Smaller Battery Lasting Six Hours

Rimebreaker

@ShogunRok Right now the only way I can see the "does more" justification work is because they wanted to keep the same size but needed the room for the back paddle hooks, so the battery had to be smaller, that's not exactly the story implied by the wording they used. I think everyone assumed it would simply need to consume more power (something I think made no sense to anyone then.)

Re: Poll: Did You Buy Forspoken?

Rimebreaker

Despite what I have read, I will likely buy it once its on a decent physical sale. The cringy sit-com humor that some reviewers have criticized is actually right down my alley, if I'm in the right mood. But given the performance issues, I'll likely wait until there are a ton of patches and for a Black Friday sale.

As for how it will sell... I think it will be a disaster and will push Sqaure-Enix in some sort of emergency mode. I want to see who they blame now, they can no longer claim it's the fault of poor performance by western studios they will then sell off, or of a third party (Platinum) doing a poor job. This is all in-house, by the FF15 team.

Re: Microsoft Summons Sony to FTC's Activision Blizzard Court Hearing

Rimebreaker

@thefourfoldroot1

I would say they can’t offer the same insane value because they don’t have the money to run a loss maker

This subscribes to the idea that because a game is day one in Game Pass, it just does not sell a single unit, something that is very easy to prove to be wrong. You can simply go to XBox store list of top paid games and see that Minecraft, Among Us, High on Life, Skyrim, Forza, and Ark are all on the first page, and that is way past their prime.

Its the conundrum of adding games day one:
A) You face the risk of "no one" buying the game, but everyone subscribing to the service and giving you $10 to $15 a month for a whole year....
B) Or just a handful of people subscribe and you still sell a ridiculous number of copies of games...
C) Or something in between.

It was easy for Xbox to do this because at the time they started, they were basically rock bottom, so they had less to lose if things went south.

PlayStation is at its peak, and they are terrified of disrupting things in a way that might give them even a single bad quarter.

Re: Microsoft Summons Sony to FTC's Activision Blizzard Court Hearing

Rimebreaker

@CielloArc

Yeah yeah, sure Windows is not a monopoly on PC.
Try running all of your productivity software on Linux or Mac, let's see how it goes.

Easier than you would think. There are ways to run windows software inside Linux, and there are also plenty of native alternatives, it all depends what you are doing and what tool you want to use, but there are likely ways to do it. I still personally choose to run Windows myself, but this is not 1998 anymore, Linux is a viable alternative.

But that's nitpicking, its rare for the common person to go buy a laptop with Linux pre-installed. But you know what you can buy easily? A laptop with Chrome OS or OS X, or a Steam Deck running Steam OS.

Edit: According to Stat Counter, these are the current OS market shares:

44.6% Android
28.41% Windows
17.29% iOS
5.53% OS X
1.88% Unknown
1.11% Linux

Normalized to remove mobile OS:

76.93% Windows
14.97% OS X
5.09% Unknown
3.01% Linux

Edit 2
At the end of the day, Windows did not become the dominant OS via acquisitions. The go-to apps that everyone needs either were already "first-party" (Microsoft Office) or multi-platform (Photoshop, etc.)

Windows became dominant because they were the only OS producer to have a relatively open license for its OS. While Apple was trying to sell every Mac OS device themselves (and still do) Windows gave other manufacturers the chance to sell computers and compete with IBM without having to create their own OS. THAT is how Windows became dominant, by partnering with anyone that wanted to make compatible hardware. Hell, users could just buy parts off the shelf and put together their own frankenstein custom PC and then buy a copy of windows to throw in there.

Re: Microsoft Summons Sony to FTC's Activision Blizzard Court Hearing

Rimebreaker

@NEStalgia

There's all this talk about the "nascent subscription market"

This is possibly open for interpretation, but for me, that argument gets to my nerves. A business model does not create a whole new "market". A business model is simply the way you choose to participate within a market. Selling, vs renting, you still in the game distribution and game platform markets.

If we go in the direction of "subscription services" being a market, how you start narrowing it down? Because PSN basic is larger than Game Pass. Sure, it only gives you random games every month, but its still a subscription service that gives you games. Things don't have to be clones of each other, else you are being extremely stubborn about what separates markets from each other in an attempt to gain some sort of favor (like pretending that Nintendo is not part of the gaming market 🙄)

Re: Microsoft Summons Sony to FTC's Activision Blizzard Court Hearing

Rimebreaker

@Toypop

Sony fighting this benefits no one and only damages both parties and the industry. They should have just accepted Microsoft’s ten year deal or however long it was.

To be fair, they don't have to accept the deal. Microsoft plans to honor it regardless if anyone sings it, so why make things easier on Microsoft?

Re: Microsoft Summons Sony to FTC's Activision Blizzard Court Hearing

Rimebreaker

@UltimateOtaku91

Good luck with that bit, this deal harms sony in a major way with the amount of titles they will lose such as diablo, crash, spyro, potentially in the future call of duty games and overwatch 3.

Even Sony themselves have made it clear they only care about CoD. I would myself argue that was a mistake, and they should had always included everything else in their complaints, but they only ever complained about the one game, giving MS the very easy path to just say that that one IP would remain on all competitor's platforms the same exact way they have kept Mine Craft IP on all competing platforms.

such as making zombies an xbox exclusive mode or having all dlc xbox exclusive etc

They already promised parity, but hey, if XBox survived in the past when Zombies mode was exclusive for a year on PlayStation, I don't think that reasoning would hold up in court.

At the end of the day, yes, it makes sense for Sony to be against the acquisition, but that making sense has nothing to do with what is legal.

Re: Microsoft Summons Sony to FTC's Activision Blizzard Court Hearing

Rimebreaker

@Perturbator

The focus of this acquisition shouldn't be on Sony as the victim, but rather putting a stop to huge corporations like MS gobbling up big publishers like Activision Blizzard.

This is unlikely to ever happen. You need to first understand what you are asking for. There wont be a law like this made for any specific industry, it would be a nation-wide law that applies to all corporations.

The way modern capitalist economies work, you create a company, likely take it into public trading, and make it grow as much as possible before you find further significant growth is no longer likely, at that point you try to find a buyer that finds value on growing their own market coverage.

The only way this can occur, past certain size, is by allowing even larger corporations the ability to buy you out.

Right now, Activision shareholders feel they reached the point where they want to sell, before they find themselves in a position similar to Ubisoft's (where potential buyers laugh at your face when you approach them.) The only ones with pockets large enough to acquire them are mega-corporations like Microsoft, Apple, Google, Tencent and Amazon... unless Saudi Aramco decides to diversify away from petroleum and natural gas into gaming...

So, no, it's unlikely you will ever stop large companies from being acquirable by even larger ones, and even less likely to see a law that specifically targets Microsoft simply because they happen to already have a presence in gaming.

Based on US laws, the only way to stop this is if they find actual competition issues, and that is rarely doable if, within the relevant market, we are not talking about the biggest or the second biggest companies (MS is conveniently third place here, its going to be hard to legally stop this acquisition in the US.)

Re: Site News: Where's Our Forspoken PS5 Review?

Rimebreaker

@NEStalgia oh I forgot about the two year deal. How many of these failures has Sony forked money for this generation? Babylon Fall (turned out to be a lifetime-exclusive I guess) and Forspoken, they also forked money for Spider-Man exclusive in Avengers. Not a Square game but they also forked money for Godfall.

I feel Sony went way too aggressive on money-hatting these experiments.

As far as DQ goes, I doubt they care much for it either. It’s not big outside of Japan, and Sony has basically abandoned “Japan niche” games.

Re: Site News: Where's Our Forspoken PS5 Review?

Rimebreaker

@Ooccoo_Jr Opinion around the web is they intentionally gave review codes early only to sites they saw as the most likely to give them the most favorable coverage. If even so the best they got is a 6, it’s going to be ugly once everyone else gets their word, and I doubt any of these sites is going to be knocking points simply because of getting review codes late.

Re: Rumour: New PS5 Bundle Includes Two DualSense Controllers

Rimebreaker

If the price differential is the same, I would much rather have an extra controller bundled in than a game. Dual Sense controller battery life sucks, and for me a digital code to a PS game is worth less than the paper it's printed on since I will regardless, sooner or later, buy the physical copy of that game (perhaps already did.)

Re: Square Enix Commits to Business Consolidation in 2023 as Sony Buyout Rumours Start Again

Rimebreaker

@Uncharted2007 Destiny wont be exclusive, but they will be making more games, and I dont expect any of them to be showing up on XBox or Nintendo platforms.

They are also being tasked with helping every other Sony service game be good. What is SE going to bring to Sony? NFTs? the FF IP? Lessons on how to make one good service game and thousand bad ones?

I do personally agree that Bungie was overvalued, but still can see why Sony would rather buy them.

BTW my earlier 6-7 billion price tag on Square-Enix is based on current market cap of 5.5 billion, any acquisition is likely going to be way higher than the market cap if it expects investors to depart with their stock. I think I'm still lowballing it.

Also, I do think it makes sense for some to buy SE, just not Sony, not the way they do business. If they did buy SE, they will slaughter it to pieces and only keep DQ and FF alive. That would be a very sad outcome.