@ImGumbyDammit Final Fantasy is a big name, but it’s not that big of a profit maker. In fact I predict they will claim they are disappointed with the sales of FF16, not because of low sales but because SE is doing some very garbage accounting.
Again, they basically gave away Tomb Rider, thad is not, as you say, a “yahoo”.
@IOI indeed, was just noting that the current market cap itself was above the max spending budget for the entirety of Sony, making it a very unlikely acquisition, at leas in full.
There is also my hypothetical scenario of SE only selling some studios and IP, specifically the Final Fantasy stuff, but I doubt they would want to part with such a household name… then again they basically gave Tomb Rider away for pennies.
I still maintain Square is a bit pointless given how much of theirs is exclusive anyway.
if Square Enix (or just the Square side goes up for sale, Sony will have little choice but to bid on it, as the next owner can likely be less kin to exclusivity deals, or they might actually approach Xbox themselves if they can’t find a buyer.
@Nem Microsoft had never been considered a monopoly in gaming, by any stretch of the word. It only ever was considered a monopoly in the OS arena, back in the 90s, and they used that power to push into the internet browser market.
These days, the OS marker is no longer a monopoly, most consumer computers might run windows but in the overall market iOS and Android give Windows a run for its money. This is a bit of topic though, my point is that MS is using its bank account to expand its gaming portfolio, but not its power in the OS market. A monopolistic power move from MS would be to find a way to force Windows users to buy from the Windows Marketplace and block Steam, yet they do the opposite: sell their games on Steam.
I know it’s not popular, especially around here, that MS is making big acquisitions, but it’s still nowhere near the realm of monopoly concerns.
Personally, I would like it if Sony acquired Square off Enix. Would not mind seeing Sony take responsibility over Final Fantasy, but really would like the Dragon Quest and publishing side to stay independent entities.
Given how Square has been shedding studios and IPs like a gecko sheds tails (first IOI then Edios) I think it’s not entirely out of the realm of possibilities.
But I have a feeling they rather use the capital for more anime industry takeovers. It seems Sony want to get the same grip they have on music over Anime.
@ShogunRok @Snake_V5 Microsoft does not have unlimited money, although it sure can feel like it. As of December 2022, they had $104 billion (cash in hand) and based on the amount on hand on previous years it’s hard to guess if the 69 billion for ABK has been deducted or not.
I am assuming it has not, that would leave them with about 35 billion, give or take as many billions as they have made or lost in the last 3 months. That’s a big chunk of change, but not enough to make another ABK size deal.
@DeathlySW don’t know how Austria works but I’m sure this is equivalent to the US small claims courts, that tend to be designed precisely with the hurdles of legal costs in mind. In the US for example, in such courts lawyers are not allowed for either party.
@rjejr gambling is legal in Austria but very closely regulated, and taxed. I don’t have all the details and didn’t have the time to hunt it down but running a gambling operation in ways that hide from the law likely runs afoul of multiple laws, including tax evasion ones.
@Nem if you think Sony does not have a history of monopolistic practices, you need to do some homework on their behavior in the music industry and their recent steps to devour all anime distribution they can get their hands on.
What's more pathetic, MS has been buying studios and publishers left and right with squat to show for it.
Sorry for the double reply but wanted to reply to this point separately. MS has had nothing to show for it of personal gain yet, but most of those studios have been delivering content since them being acquired, it just happens most of those titles were already committed to be delivered on multiple platforms or locked on deals.
Obsidian: The Outer Worlds, Grounded, Pentiment, and working on Avowed and Outer Worlds 2
inXile: Wasteland 3, Wasteland 1 Remastered, who knows what they working on next.
Mojang: Minecraft Legends, Minecraft Dungeons
Double Fine: Psychonauts 2, who knows what they working on next.
ZeniMax: Deathloop, Ghostwire: Tokyo and multiple ESO and FO76 expansions, Skyrim Anniversary, with Redfall is around the corner and Starfield coming later this year.
Only acquisitions that have not delivered anything since being acquired are:
Undead Labs (technically they been adding content to state of decay 2)
Ninja Theory (they did deliver Bleeding Edge, but that didn't manage to compete with Overwatch)
Compulsion Games (who knows what on earth they are doing...)
My point is, I guess, all these people been working (I do question Compulsion Games), and it can take 5 years or more these days to deliver a Triple A game from scratch, which I guess is what most people refer to when they say "Xbox has not delivered anything with all their studios", other than Mojang, none have been around for long enough to deliver such a thing, and only ZeniMax already had Triple A projects in development at the time of acquisition.
@Gamer83 every case is different, nothing is "as simple as we getting exclusives or not".
Bethesda's case, they were not doing well. The quality of their games was going downhill in a search for MTX to save them, and as of late they were taking money to make games exclusives, something they had never done before. They were struggling financially and would had likely gone the way of the old THQ had MS not swooped in to buy them.
Do you think it would had been better for players, developers, and the industry all if Zenimax simply collapsed and was sold in chunks to random publishers, and have many of their teams simply disappear?
Activision is a different situation, but at least we know they wont be taking CoD away from anyone, in fact, this whole thing will bring CoD back to Nintendo platforms.
It's not like MS is going out there and forcing publishers to sell either, or doing hostile takeovers. The publishers they have gone for so far are ones that wanted to sell. Who else would be able to buy ABK in whole? And also want to do so? Only one I can think of is Tencent, and although Tencent would likely keep every game multi-platform, that would be a true monopolistic threat. Tencent is too large already on the game publishing arena.
I do think post this it would be very sketchy for MS to buy yet another publisher... but at the same time, if the option is between MS buying Ubisoft, or Ubisoft going the way of THQ... I think I would prefer it be acquired in whole by someone that will keep them running. I do hope somehow the company [Ubisoft] can recover, though. I think we all have heard that they been trying to sell themselves off, with no success.
I don't quite get the relevance of all this. It's not Sony acquiring Activision. Sounds like Microsoft just wants to make a show of it.
The FTC case against the merger is basically 99% based on arguments made by Sony in opposition of the merger. As such, for their defense in the case, MS has requested everything they feel is relevant to prove or disprove Sonys legal claims.
The judge has agreed with Microsoft that most of the requests are indeed relevant, while denying the relevance of a couple of requests.
Funny how Misrosoft acquiring a company has the FTC up in arms, yet the FTC let's Disney run amok and acquire almost every television and movie IP in existence.
Different administrations. The current FTC leadership has an anti-big-corporation mindset. Not making any personal judgements on thad being good or bad, but it’s why Disney went through its equally big Fox acquisition. Had Disney attempted that this year, they likely would had faced similar reaction from the FTC. Similarly, had the ABK Activision been done in 2020, or hell even 2015, it would had likely gone through uneventfully (in the US).
@Snake_V5 so they can likely bring arguments like Sony using its market leader position in anti-competitive ways, using that weight to secure more favorable contracts that harm competitors, and stuff like that. Also to reinforce a history of blocking features and content or access to GamePass presence even being negotiated.
Given Sony claims so much feature parity in, and access to, tentpole titles is so vital, it would help Microsoft’s case if they find proof of Sony making contracts that deny Microsoft said content.
@Snake_V5 details on the FF7 remake deal might not included. This will likely be based on when the deal was signed, not the date of the game release, and these deals are usually signed years in advance. It’s possible any deal done for the Intergrade release is there, unless it was signed before FF7 even released, something that is not out of the realm of possibilities.
Think this is why Microsoft wanted to go all the way to 2019, so they could get details on any game releases in the last 5 years.
I'm interested in the game, FF is no longer what I used to love (thankfully that role has been filled by Persona and Like a Dragon 7) but I still enjoy the tropes that are still carried over. I do love that Yoshi P is bringing a lot of things back, like moogles (still annoyed that FF7 Remake only "reference" to moogles was a kid on a suit...)
I wont be buying it day one, will most likely wait for a sale. Got plenty on my backlog to keep me busy the entire year already, so I likely can wait for a Black Friday sale. Then again... I remember feeling the same way about Final Fantasy 12 and succumbing on my drive home from work, stopping on a store and buying a copy day one... that I didn't play for perhaps 7 years...
@Titntin the story, as far as I heard, is that Square Enix (as usual) was not happy with the sales of the first Tomb Rider reboot entry and were not going to develop a sequel without outside investment. MS paying 100 million was not to make it exclusive, they basically co-financed the development without demanding full exclusivity, but they did demand timed exclusivity.
Chances are not insignificant that the game would had not been made at all without MS paying that 100 million.
We have seen at least Capcom information upon their leak, and Nintendo paid "only" 6 million to make the latest entry of Monster Hunter timed exclusive to the Switch, and Monster Hunter is one of the biggest selling IPs out there. Paying 100 million for a sequel to a game with disappointing sales sounds like a very poor investment, unless said game was never going to be made to begin with.
Tangent 1: Is Square ever, ever, not disappointed with their sales numbers?
Tangent 2: In that old article SE stated a goal to "profit" from game development window, before the game even is made. I guess the answer the article was looking for ended up being: finding platform holders that are willing to pay for the development costs.
Edit:
Personally, I don't mind exclusivity when we get to know the game would had not happened at all without that financing, but we rarely if ever get to find that out. When we find out, it tends to be years later due to leaks and behind the scenes talks.
Perhaps FF7 Remake would had not been a thing at all without Sony paying a lot of money to make it happen. Or perhaps they just money-hatted it, we wont ever know... or will we? (There is that FTC document request thing, and those documents might leak...)
FF16 was a game that was definitively going to be made, with or without outside investment.
As for paying for extra content, I am skeptical. I doubt they would hire additional developers just to make that content, so at the end of the day, the extra content took some time from development time from the core game content. If you are going to go that route, better give me some platform-fan service (like having the Master Sword on the Switch version of Skyrim.)
Switch is the worst though. Only shows the last 20 played games and rounds up to the nearest 5 hours (ie 20 hours played, 25 hours played etc).
Might I recommend Exophase.com? They hook up to Nintendo's public API and show you exactly how much time you spent on the games, without rounding. Do note that their API didn't come into effect until, I believe, 2019, so it wont show you older play times unless you at least launch those games to force a sync.
@themightyant Funny enough, I started doing this tracking because I felt I was not spending enough time playing games, instead spending too much time on volunteer development projects, and wanted this year to have some more me-time, so I started time tracking. At some point I might either find some free-ware time manual time tracker, or code my own, but for now tracking everything since 1/1/23 (only gaming time, not tracking work time on that thing.)
The save system helps with cloud but it predates it by a long run, it's been there since the 360 days. It was basically the result of them incorporating OneDrive technology into the console. I am very unlikely to ever play a game on PC if its on a console, any console, so I have never tested if XBox cloud saves actually work on the PC version. Did get a Steamdeck recently, no much use yet but might start changing my stance on PC games a bit.
@Titntin I wanted to have two TVs side by side in the living room to be able to play “couch coop” with without split-screens my partner on any game that supported online play, but they were having none of that. At the end it did give me room to get a way way way bigger TV for my personal gaming room.
@themightyant @get2sammyb @LiamCroft i don’t trust any time tracker 100%, Xbox also can have issues tracking. I don’t think the tracker works on cloud streaming sessions, for instance.
This year I took the extremely obsessive practice of keeping an actually manual gaming diary. It’s a simple spreadsheet where I write the title name, platform, play session start time and end time. Plan to code something at some point to generate nice tables and summaries, but for now, through the entirety of this year, I can find exactly what games I was playing at exactly what times and date.
As for the topic of the article, I play my third party games on Xbox mostly because of quick resume and the auto-syncing of save files. I have multiple rooms I can play games at, and it’s almost miraculous to see files sync as I launch a game without me having to remember to download them, as I must on the PlayStations.
this is sad news , playstation was never a third-party machine
PlayStation is where it is today mainly due to third party exclusives and marketing deals. Almost every highlight from the PS1 and PS2 era were third party exclusives.
It was not until mid-PS3 generation that first party exclusives started to do some heavy lifting.
Odd that he thinks “turn based” is a negative connotation…
I can’t think of a time when I associated JRPG with teens or anime. That’s what Weeb games is for. JRPG, in my opinion, always stood for very epic story driven RPGs with heavy emphasis on character development and… yes, turn based.
It was necessary to distinguish them from the terribly boring and yanky western RPGs, that were terrible (sorry Ultima fans, those games sucked.)
He should be glad his regional RPG flavor is not called “Eurojank”
@Titntin anyone that is early in production right now that still decides to make their game an exclusively live service game, deserves the failure that is coming to their way.
It’s cool if service is a side element that can be ignored (who buys Resident evil games for the mercenaries content?) but exclusively service?
@cragis0001 they didn’t use to have that policy during the 360 era, hell they didn’t even own Gears of war until after the xbox one launched.
Most publishing deals signed earlier in the Xbox one Gen, or before launch, we’re not owned, but later, tiles like Ori became xbox property even if the studio itself was not acquired.
My PS3 is still hooked up, so I’ll boot it up to make sure I get the update applied.
I still got a big of a backlog of PS3 exclusives that I been itching to play like Heavenly Sword and {3D Dot Heross, but want to at least beat Persona 4 first.
Maybe they changed their policy, but I understand at some point mid last Gen Xbox changed its policy so that they would own any game IO they finance and publish. If so, it’s very unlikely this will come to PlayStation.
It would be a bit odd, though, that if this was the case, Xbox would just green light IOI doing a blog reveal. So… I’d say this is 75% likely Xbox exclusive (assuming the Microsoft publishing rumor is true.)
I never cared enough to install this plugging before but installed the Dislikes in Youtube extension on Edge, and went through a few of the uploads for this video. Here are some of the up/down votes:
IGN: 9.5k👍| 26k👎
GamePot: 4.3k👍| 12k👎
PlayStation: 1.6k👍| 7.2k👎
Warner Bros. Games: 0.475k👍| 1.5k👎
So... the reactions are not good at all, and they know it.
@get2sammyb need to hunt this down but I seen some use some plugin that re-exposed downvotes in YouTube videos (it seems what YouTube did was hide the element, not eliminate the code behind it.)
Google's "kind of" objecting but without any specific claims
They had one claim, that supposedly Xbox is slowing down the performance of xcloud on Chrome browsers. For me that does not make much sense given how the two main platforms XBox is targeting for Game Cloud Streaming are iOS and Android.
It does make sense that Google would be against it, given they fear the ability of King establishing a third party app store in their mobile ecosystem, but that's not exactly the concern that will win them sympathy with any regulatory agency.
@get2sammyb I mean, Sony did start their gaming life by buying one of the largest European publishers at the time. Obviously they dimmed it necessary to buy an established publisher to break into the global game publishing market, and catch up with Nintendo and Sega's long-standing publishing arms.
A rather stupid quote from someone I heard recently is they dont take aspirin for headaches because they dont have a headache due to aspirin deficiency. Sure, they dont, but aspirine can fix the headache. Similarly, XBox's international performance is not poor because of lacking ABK, but owning ABK can likely help their issue.
On the topic of the market share point, bringing it up is one of the first things anyone does while discussing regulation and anti-competitive practices. If their market share is small enough, it's very hard for a single acquisition, even one this big, to put them in a position where they push anyone out of the market.
@TommyNL if it comes to that, it can become extremely complex and businesy. There are many odd things they can end up donig, like actually buying the entirety of ABK, but spinning off CoD into its own entity, something that would allow the full 70 billion deal to go through.
In such a move, they would still own a large stake on said company, very likely, but it's likely they would be limited by conditions on how large of a stake they would be allowed to retain.
Also, I dont think MS has ever said they dont care about CoD, they have stated CoD is not the main reason they are pursing the deal for.
@TommyNL I have a feeling that should they be absolutely forced to divest from CoD, and nothing else, they would still want to go through as they get a lot out of the other Activision IPs, Blizzard and King. The question should be instead if Activision Blizzard's investors would accept the restructured deal, it would certainly not be for the full $70 billion dollars, and they would be stuck with at minimum 3 studios and the CoD IP.
What If the commission feels Microsoft has done enough without Sony signing up, will that mean no more COD on PlayStation???
Doubtful, Xbox would not win much if PS is the only platform out there without CoD. The worst I see happening is Xbox saying "well... you turned down the contract that had parity... so now Zombies mode is exclusive to those platforms that agreed to the deal."
I don't think they will. What's the purpose of this 10-year deal if Microsoft means what they say about not taking games away?
The purpose is so that regulatory agencies can see they are not just making promises, but legally forcing themselves to keep those promises. Valve agrees with you, as they refused the deal on philosophical reasons (they don't want to hold anyone hostage) and the fact that they trust Xbox to keep their word without contracts.
I agree with posters saying all these games should be available for sale and not locked down behind the service. A lot of people complain that Game Pass will lead to a future where we can’t big games, but they sell everything in their service. It’s Nintendo and Sony selectively forcing rental-only for some games.
@NEStalgia even if we ignore the platform loyalist arguments, there is also the opinions like "the business model is terrible for the industry" as if somehow the success of Game Pass would mean that no one can buy games anymore.
All games in Game Pass can also be purchased. All music in Spotify is also available for purchase (most likely all in iTunes and Amazon, or some other storefront.) Hell, you can still buy vinyl (interesting vinyl outsold cd sales last year in the UK.)
Back to games... both things can be true: Game pass exist, ownership exist. I feel like some of these people would stand in front of a Blockbuster store and protest that those renting movies and games don't "own" anything...
Comments 1,015
Re: Sony Has Approximately $5 Billion Left for Acquisitions and Investments
@ImGumbyDammit Final Fantasy is a big name, but it’s not that big of a profit maker. In fact I predict they will claim they are disappointed with the sales of FF16, not because of low sales but because SE is doing some very garbage accounting.
Again, they basically gave away Tomb Rider, thad is not, as you say, a “yahoo”.
Re: Sony Has Approximately $5 Billion Left for Acquisitions and Investments
@IOI indeed, was just noting that the current market cap itself was above the max spending budget for the entirety of Sony, making it a very unlikely acquisition, at leas in full.
There is also my hypothetical scenario of SE only selling some studios and IP, specifically the Final Fantasy stuff, but I doubt they would want to part with such a household name… then again they basically gave Tomb Rider away for pennies.
Re: Sony Has Approximately $5 Billion Left for Acquisitions and Investments
@NomNom
As of this writing, Square Enix Holdings Co. Ltd market cap is $5.58 billion.
Re: Sony Has Approximately $5 Billion Left for Acquisitions and Investments
@IAmAshCohen17
if Square Enix (or just the Square side goes up for sale, Sony will have little choice but to bid on it, as the next owner can likely be less kin to exclusivity deals, or they might actually approach Xbox themselves if they can’t find a buyer.
Re: Sony Must Share Details of Exclusivity Deals with Microsoft in FTC's Court Hearing
@Nem Microsoft had never been considered a monopoly in gaming, by any stretch of the word. It only ever was considered a monopoly in the OS arena, back in the 90s, and they used that power to push into the internet browser market.
These days, the OS marker is no longer a monopoly, most consumer computers might run windows but in the overall market iOS and Android give Windows a run for its money. This is a bit of topic though, my point is that MS is using its bank account to expand its gaming portfolio, but not its power in the OS market. A monopolistic power move from MS would be to find a way to force Windows users to buy from the Windows Marketplace and block Steam, yet they do the opposite: sell their games on Steam.
I know it’s not popular, especially around here, that MS is making big acquisitions, but it’s still nowhere near the realm of monopoly concerns.
Re: Sony Has Approximately $5 Billion Left for Acquisitions and Investments
Personally, I would like it if Sony acquired Square off Enix. Would not mind seeing Sony take responsibility over Final Fantasy, but really would like the Dragon Quest and publishing side to stay independent entities.
Given how Square has been shedding studios and IPs like a gecko sheds tails (first IOI then Edios) I think it’s not entirely out of the realm of possibilities.
But I have a feeling they rather use the capital for more anime industry takeovers. It seems Sony want to get the same grip they have on music over Anime.
Re: Sony Has Approximately $5 Billion Left for Acquisitions and Investments
@ShogunRok @Snake_V5 Microsoft does not have unlimited money, although it sure can feel like it. As of December 2022, they had $104 billion (cash in hand) and based on the amount on hand on previous years it’s hard to guess if the 69 billion for ABK has been deducted or not.
I am assuming it has not, that would leave them with about 35 billion, give or take as many billions as they have made or lost in the last 3 months. That’s a big chunk of change, but not enough to make another ABK size deal.
Re: Sony Must Share Details of Exclusivity Deals with Microsoft in FTC's Court Hearing
@Nem your statement to me could had been better phrased then:
That final “not so much Sony”, in that context, sounded like Sony has never abused its influence on any field, while they actively do it to this day.
Re: Sony Ordered to Pay Refunds As Austrian Court Declares FIFA Gambling
@DeathlySW don’t know how Austria works but I’m sure this is equivalent to the US small claims courts, that tend to be designed precisely with the hurdles of legal costs in mind. In the US for example, in such courts lawyers are not allowed for either party.
Re: Sony Ordered to Pay Refunds As Austrian Court Declares FIFA Gambling
@rjejr gambling is legal in Austria but very closely regulated, and taxed. I don’t have all the details and didn’t have the time to hunt it down but running a gambling operation in ways that hide from the law likely runs afoul of multiple laws, including tax evasion ones.
Re: Sony Must Share Details of Exclusivity Deals with Microsoft in FTC's Court Hearing
@Nem if you think Sony does not have a history of monopolistic practices, you need to do some homework on their behavior in the music industry and their recent steps to devour all anime distribution they can get their hands on.
Re: Sony Must Share Details of Exclusivity Deals with Microsoft in FTC's Court Hearing
@Gamer83
Sorry for the double reply but wanted to reply to this point separately. MS has had nothing to show for it of personal gain yet, but most of those studios have been delivering content since them being acquired, it just happens most of those titles were already committed to be delivered on multiple platforms or locked on deals.
Only acquisitions that have not delivered anything since being acquired are:
My point is, I guess, all these people been working (I do question Compulsion Games), and it can take 5 years or more these days to deliver a Triple A game from scratch, which I guess is what most people refer to when they say "Xbox has not delivered anything with all their studios", other than Mojang, none have been around for long enough to deliver such a thing, and only ZeniMax already had Triple A projects in development at the time of acquisition.
Re: Sony Must Share Details of Exclusivity Deals with Microsoft in FTC's Court Hearing
@Gamer83 every case is different, nothing is "as simple as we getting exclusives or not".
Bethesda's case, they were not doing well. The quality of their games was going downhill in a search for MTX to save them, and as of late they were taking money to make games exclusives, something they had never done before. They were struggling financially and would had likely gone the way of the old THQ had MS not swooped in to buy them.
Do you think it would had been better for players, developers, and the industry all if Zenimax simply collapsed and was sold in chunks to random publishers, and have many of their teams simply disappear?
Activision is a different situation, but at least we know they wont be taking CoD away from anyone, in fact, this whole thing will bring CoD back to Nintendo platforms.
It's not like MS is going out there and forcing publishers to sell either, or doing hostile takeovers. The publishers they have gone for so far are ones that wanted to sell. Who else would be able to buy ABK in whole? And also want to do so? Only one I can think of is Tencent, and although Tencent would likely keep every game multi-platform, that would be a true monopolistic threat. Tencent is too large already on the game publishing arena.
I do think post this it would be very sketchy for MS to buy yet another publisher... but at the same time, if the option is between MS buying Ubisoft, or Ubisoft going the way of THQ... I think I would prefer it be acquired in whole by someone that will keep them running. I do hope somehow the company [Ubisoft] can recover, though. I think we all have heard that they been trying to sell themselves off, with no success.
Re: Sony Must Share Details of Exclusivity Deals with Microsoft in FTC's Court Hearing
@Nem
The FTC case against the merger is basically 99% based on arguments made by Sony in opposition of the merger. As such, for their defense in the case, MS has requested everything they feel is relevant to prove or disprove Sonys legal claims.
The judge has agreed with Microsoft that most of the requests are indeed relevant, while denying the relevance of a couple of requests.
Re: Sony Must Share Details of Exclusivity Deals with Microsoft in FTC's Court Hearing
@Kriandis
Different administrations. The current FTC leadership has an anti-big-corporation mindset. Not making any personal judgements on thad being good or bad, but it’s why Disney went through its equally big Fox acquisition. Had Disney attempted that this year, they likely would had faced similar reaction from the FTC. Similarly, had the ABK Activision been done in 2020, or hell even 2015, it would had likely gone through uneventfully (in the US).
Re: Sony Must Share Details of Exclusivity Deals with Microsoft in FTC's Court Hearing
@Snake_V5 so they can likely bring arguments like Sony using its market leader position in anti-competitive ways, using that weight to secure more favorable contracts that harm competitors, and stuff like that. Also to reinforce a history of blocking features and content or access to GamePass presence even being negotiated.
Given Sony claims so much feature parity in, and access to, tentpole titles is so vital, it would help Microsoft’s case if they find proof of Sony making contracts that deny Microsoft said content.
Re: Sony Must Share Details of Exclusivity Deals with Microsoft in FTC's Court Hearing
@Snake_V5 details on the FF7 remake deal might not included. This will likely be based on when the deal was signed, not the date of the game release, and these deals are usually signed years in advance. It’s possible any deal done for the Intergrade release is there, unless it was signed before FF7 even released, something that is not out of the realm of possibilities.
Think this is why Microsoft wanted to go all the way to 2019, so they could get details on any game releases in the last 5 years.
Re: Sony Wants to Make PlayStation the Best Place to Play Third-Party Games
@Shredderlovespizza Not trying to argue... but there are no laws against hooking up a console to a monitor, in a desk. 🙃
I do can see it being an issue in a household where the console is shared among multiple users.
Re: Poll: How Do You Feel About Final Fantasy 16?
I'm interested in the game, FF is no longer what I used to love (thankfully that role has been filled by Persona and Like a Dragon 7) but I still enjoy the tropes that are still carried over. I do love that Yoshi P is bringing a lot of things back, like moogles (still annoyed that FF7 Remake only "reference" to moogles was a kid on a suit...)
I wont be buying it day one, will most likely wait for a sale. Got plenty on my backlog to keep me busy the entire year already, so I likely can wait for a Black Friday sale. Then again... I remember feeling the same way about Final Fantasy 12 and succumbing on my drive home from work, stopping on a store and buying a copy day one... that I didn't play for perhaps 7 years...
Re: Sony Wants to Make PlayStation the Best Place to Play Third-Party Games
@Titntin the story, as far as I heard, is that Square Enix (as usual) was not happy with the sales of the first Tomb Rider reboot entry and were not going to develop a sequel without outside investment. MS paying 100 million was not to make it exclusive, they basically co-financed the development without demanding full exclusivity, but they did demand timed exclusivity.
Chances are not insignificant that the game would had not been made at all without MS paying that 100 million.
We have seen at least Capcom information upon their leak, and Nintendo paid "only" 6 million to make the latest entry of Monster Hunter timed exclusive to the Switch, and Monster Hunter is one of the biggest selling IPs out there. Paying 100 million for a sequel to a game with disappointing sales sounds like a very poor investment, unless said game was never going to be made to begin with.
Tangent 1: Is Square ever, ever, not disappointed with their sales numbers?
Tangent 2: In that old article SE stated a goal to "profit" from game development window, before the game even is made. I guess the answer the article was looking for ended up being: finding platform holders that are willing to pay for the development costs.
Edit:
Personally, I don't mind exclusivity when we get to know the game would had not happened at all without that financing, but we rarely if ever get to find that out. When we find out, it tends to be years later due to leaks and behind the scenes talks.
Perhaps FF7 Remake would had not been a thing at all without Sony paying a lot of money to make it happen. Or perhaps they just money-hatted it, we wont ever know... or will we? (There is that FTC document request thing, and those documents might leak...)
FF16 was a game that was definitively going to be made, with or without outside investment.
As for paying for extra content, I am skeptical. I doubt they would hire additional developers just to make that content, so at the end of the day, the extra content took some time from development time from the core game content. If you are going to go that route, better give me some platform-fan service (like having the Master Sword on the Switch version of Skyrim.)
Re: Sony Wants to Make PlayStation the Best Place to Play Third-Party Games
@Titntin Now I wonder how native time tracking behaves when jumping from XBox to PC....
Re: Sony Wants to Make PlayStation the Best Place to Play Third-Party Games
@jrt87
Might I recommend Exophase.com? They hook up to Nintendo's public API and show you exactly how much time you spent on the games, without rounding. Do note that their API didn't come into effect until, I believe, 2019, so it wont show you older play times unless you at least launch those games to force a sync.
Re: Sony Wants to Make PlayStation the Best Place to Play Third-Party Games
@themightyant Funny enough, I started doing this tracking because I felt I was not spending enough time playing games, instead spending too much time on volunteer development projects, and wanted this year to have some more me-time, so I started time tracking. At some point I might either find some free-ware time manual time tracker, or code my own, but for now tracking everything since 1/1/23 (only gaming time, not tracking work time on that thing.)
The save system helps with cloud but it predates it by a long run, it's been there since the 360 days. It was basically the result of them incorporating OneDrive technology into the console. I am very unlikely to ever play a game on PC if its on a console, any console, so I have never tested if XBox cloud saves actually work on the PC version. Did get a Steamdeck recently, no much use yet but might start changing my stance on PC games a bit.
Re: Sony Wants to Make PlayStation the Best Place to Play Third-Party Games
@Titntin I wanted to have two TVs side by side in the living room to be able to play “couch coop” with without split-screens my partner on any game that supported online play, but they were having none of that. At the end it did give me room to get a way way way bigger TV for my personal gaming room.
Re: Sony Wants to Make PlayStation the Best Place to Play Third-Party Games
@themightyant @get2sammyb @LiamCroft i don’t trust any time tracker 100%, Xbox also can have issues tracking. I don’t think the tracker works on cloud streaming sessions, for instance.
This year I took the extremely obsessive practice of keeping an actually manual gaming diary. It’s a simple spreadsheet where I write the title name, platform, play session start time and end time. Plan to code something at some point to generate nice tables and summaries, but for now, through the entirety of this year, I can find exactly what games I was playing at exactly what times and date.
As for the topic of the article, I play my third party games on Xbox mostly because of quick resume and the auto-syncing of save files. I have multiple rooms I can play games at, and it’s almost miraculous to see files sync as I launch a game without me having to remember to download them, as I must on the PlayStations.
Re: Sony Wants to Make PlayStation the Best Place to Play Third-Party Games
@nomither6
PlayStation is where it is today mainly due to third party exclusives and marketing deals. Almost every highlight from the PS1 and PS2 era were third party exclusives.
It was not until mid-PS3 generation that first party exclusives started to do some heavy lifting.
Re: Naoki Yoshida Is Not a Fan of the Term 'JRPG'
Odd that he thinks “turn based” is a negative connotation…
I can’t think of a time when I associated JRPG with teens or anime. That’s what Weeb games is for. JRPG, in my opinion, always stood for very epic story driven RPGs with heavy emphasis on character development and… yes, turn based.
It was necessary to distinguish them from the terribly boring and yanky western RPGs, that were terrible (sorry Ultima fans, those games sucked.)
He should be glad his regional RPG flavor is not called “Eurojank”
Re: Rumour: Shin Megami Tensei 5 to Be Announced for PS5, PS4 in May, But There's No Real Evidence
Hopefully this game gets ported to all modern platforms (Xbox Series X|S and PS5) plus PC and not just PS4|XBOne.
Re: What Year Is It? There's a New PS3 Firmware Update Out Now
@Olskeezy I hoarded tons of controllers, but I got good news for you! There are two good alternatives out there right now if you willing to spend $45.
First, there is Retrofighters releasing this beauty:
https://retrofighters.com/our-collection/defender-wireless-playstation-1-playstation-2-playstation-3-playstation-classic-nintendo-switch-pc-video-game-controller/
If you prefer a more first-party controller, though, then this might be for you:
https://www.brookaccessory.com/products/wingmanxe2/index.html
It will allow you to use a PS4, PS5, or even a Switch Pro Controller, hell even an Xbox Controller on your PS3.
Re: Hitman Dev Confirms Online Fantasy RPG, But No Mention of PS5
@Titntin anyone that is early in production right now that still decides to make their game an exclusively live service game, deserves the failure that is coming to their way.
It’s cool if service is a side element that can be ignored (who buys Resident evil games for the mercenaries content?) but exclusively service?
Re: Hitman Dev Confirms Online Fantasy RPG, But No Mention of PS5
@cragis0001 they didn’t use to have that policy during the 360 era, hell they didn’t even own Gears of war until after the xbox one launched.
Most publishing deals signed earlier in the Xbox one Gen, or before launch, we’re not owned, but later, tiles like Ori became xbox property even if the studio itself was not acquired.
Re: What Year Is It? There's a New PS3 Firmware Update Out Now
My PS3 is still hooked up, so I’ll boot it up to make sure I get the update applied.
I still got a big of a backlog of PS3 exclusives that I been itching to play like Heavenly Sword and {3D Dot Heross, but want to at least beat Persona 4 first.
Re: Hitman Dev Confirms Online Fantasy RPG, But No Mention of PS5
Maybe they changed their policy, but I understand at some point mid last Gen Xbox changed its policy so that they would own any game IO they finance and publish. If so, it’s very unlikely this will come to PlayStation.
It would be a bit odd, though, that if this was the case, Xbox would just green light IOI doing a blog reveal. So… I’d say this is 75% likely Xbox exclusive (assuming the Microsoft publishing rumor is true.)
Re: The Response to Rocksteady's Suicide Squad Has Been Abysmal
I never cared enough to install this plugging before but installed the Dislikes in Youtube extension on Edge, and went through a few of the uploads for this video. Here are some of the up/down votes:
So... the reactions are not good at all, and they know it.
Re: The Response to Rocksteady's Suicide Squad Has Been Abysmal
@get2sammyb need to hunt this down but I seen some use some plugin that re-exposed downvotes in YouTube videos (it seems what YouTube did was hide the element, not eliminate the code behind it.)
Re: Sony Somehow Screwed Up The Legend of Dragoon on PS5, PS4
So glad Sony charges extra money to be able to support these amazing emulators!
Re: Maximalist JRPG The Caligula Effect: Overdose Is Getting a Native PS5 Release
@Arnna the PS4 version was the remake, this is a PS5 enhanced version (that they will likely still charge everyone for).
Re: Suicide Squad Requires an Internet Connection Even in Single Player
It’s official, as far as I care this game does not exist.
Re: Xbox Series X|S Is Getting Trounced by PS5, Microsoft Weirdly Reveals
Nintendo not existing is just Xbox playing by Sonys semantics.
Re: Xbox on Charm Offensive to Push $69 Billion Activision Acquisition Through
@NEStalgia
They had one claim, that supposedly Xbox is slowing down the performance of xcloud on Chrome browsers. For me that does not make much sense given how the two main platforms XBox is targeting for Game Cloud Streaming are iOS and Android.
It does make sense that Google would be against it, given they fear the ability of King establishing a third party app store in their mobile ecosystem, but that's not exactly the concern that will win them sympathy with any regulatory agency.
Re: Xbox on Charm Offensive to Push $69 Billion Activision Acquisition Through
@Loftimus
EU stated that Microsoft never promised such a thing, and they never demanded it either. FTC's statement that such a promise was made was a lie, or giving benefit of the doubt, misinformed.
The FTC has been making a ton of bogus decisions as of late.
Re: Xbox on Charm Offensive to Push $69 Billion Activision Acquisition Through
@Loftimus
The EU openly stated that MS never lied, and it was the FTC that lied.
Re: Xbox on Charm Offensive to Push $69 Billion Activision Acquisition Through
@get2sammyb I mean, Sony did start their gaming life by buying one of the largest European publishers at the time. Obviously they dimmed it necessary to buy an established publisher to break into the global game publishing market, and catch up with Nintendo and Sega's long-standing publishing arms.
A rather stupid quote from someone I heard recently is they dont take aspirin for headaches because they dont have a headache due to aspirin deficiency. Sure, they dont, but aspirine can fix the headache. Similarly, XBox's international performance is not poor because of lacking ABK, but owning ABK can likely help their issue.
On the topic of the market share point, bringing it up is one of the first things anyone does while discussing regulation and anti-competitive practices. If their market share is small enough, it's very hard for a single acquisition, even one this big, to put them in a position where they push anyone out of the market.
Re: Xbox on Charm Offensive to Push $69 Billion Activision Acquisition Through
@TommyNL if it comes to that, it can become extremely complex and businesy. There are many odd things they can end up donig, like actually buying the entirety of ABK, but spinning off CoD into its own entity, something that would allow the full 70 billion deal to go through.
In such a move, they would still own a large stake on said company, very likely, but it's likely they would be limited by conditions on how large of a stake they would be allowed to retain.
Also, I dont think MS has ever said they dont care about CoD, they have stated CoD is not the main reason they are pursing the deal for.
Re: Xbox on Charm Offensive to Push $69 Billion Activision Acquisition Through
@get2sammyb
Cant they do both?
And ABK was the one looking for a buyer, MS was the only one with deep enough pockets and interest to go for it.
Should ABK instead be forced to break up and sell every IP and studio individually?
Re: Xbox on Charm Offensive to Push $69 Billion Activision Acquisition Through
@TommyNL I have a feeling that should they be absolutely forced to divest from CoD, and nothing else, they would still want to go through as they get a lot out of the other Activision IPs, Blizzard and King. The question should be instead if Activision Blizzard's investors would accept the restructured deal, it would certainly not be for the full $70 billion dollars, and they would be stuck with at minimum 3 studios and the CoD IP.
Re: Xbox on Charm Offensive to Push $69 Billion Activision Acquisition Through
@Splatmaster
Doubtful, Xbox would not win much if PS is the only platform out there without CoD. The worst I see happening is Xbox saying "well... you turned down the contract that had parity... so now Zombies mode is exclusive to those platforms that agreed to the deal."
Re: Xbox on Charm Offensive to Push $69 Billion Activision Acquisition Through
@TheCollector316
The purpose is so that regulatory agencies can see they are not just making promises, but legally forcing themselves to keep those promises. Valve agrees with you, as they refused the deal on philosophical reasons (they don't want to hold anyone hostage) and the fact that they trust Xbox to keep their word without contracts.
Re: New PS1 Classics Can Be Bought Off the PS Store
I agree with posters saying all these games should be available for sale and not locked down behind the service. A lot of people complain that Game Pass will lead to a future where we can’t big games, but they sell everything in their service. It’s Nintendo and Sony selectively forcing rental-only for some games.
Re: Microsoft Can't Deny Xbox Game Pass Cannibalises Software Sales
@NEStalgia even if we ignore the platform loyalist arguments, there is also the opinions like "the business model is terrible for the industry" as if somehow the success of Game Pass would mean that no one can buy games anymore.
All games in Game Pass can also be purchased. All music in Spotify is also available for purchase (most likely all in iTunes and Amazon, or some other storefront.) Hell, you can still buy vinyl (interesting vinyl outsold cd sales last year in the UK.)
Back to games... both things can be true: Game pass exist, ownership exist. I feel like some of these people would stand in front of a Blockbuster store and protest that those renting movies and games don't "own" anything...