Comments 311

Re: Poll: Are You Considering Leaving PlayStation for PC?

WhoderMan

A LOT of people will stick with current gen if the next gen continues to have diminishing returns on graphic improvements and innovations.

Same or similar games that look about the same and play about the same won't entice people to buy a $1000+ system.

If most of their money is made from live service games that are already on a PS5, how many of those players will want to upgrade to PS6? If the games they love aren't upgrading $1000+ worth for the next gen, then they won't.

Why would a company like Epic bother making a drastically improved version of Fortnite for PS6 when they make the same amount of money without doing that?

Watch live sevice games be the reason gamers don't need to upgrade to next gen. Lol

Re: Poll: Are You Considering Leaving PlayStation for PC?

WhoderMan

The PS6 will be very expensive. The Portable PS6 will also be expensive. Sony will wall up their Garden and PSN Store will be your main option for games. PSN is not particularly good or safe and has terrible consumer protections. PS Plus is required to play online (and an upgraded version is required to trial some games). PS Plus costs $80/year right now. But Sony will raise that price. In the past, when Sony raised the price of PS Plus I don't remember it improving in any way. Sony is not releasing exclusives very quickly. The money they invest in Live Service games will naturally be on PC as well since they require a large audience.

PC is high cost but kind of a pain at times. Has at least 3 places competing to sell you games (Steam, Epic and GOG). NO charge to play online. No subscriptions necessary for game trials. Much better customer service and protections (at least on Steam). Will probably have Microsoft "exclusives."

Compare the value proposition of a Nintendo Switch 2 vs. A PS6 and Portable PS6. Compare the graphics/performance, cost and utility of features. Compare exclusives and cost to buy products for the 2 different platform ecosystems.

For me, a Switch 2 will be in my future. I strongly suspect that a PC may be as well.

Re: 'They Wait for This Storm to Pass': No Chance of Sony Walking Back Its Decision to Kill Discs, Warns Analyst

WhoderMan

The thing is, the PS6 is gonna have a VERY difficult launch year. If angry customers like myself and others abandon them and the vast majority don't have the money to upgrade to PS6 or see value in it (so far it does not seem like a generational leap to me) then Sony's business will hurt. Then thebPS Plus cancellations and the tide turning where people who abandoned Playstation to go to PC proselytize their new platform.

Don't forget that if a console PS6 is about $1000 (or more) to get access to their "innovation" of a Portable unit what is that gonna cost?

The portable unit won't have cartridges or discs so it is all digital. Will they require constant online access to play games on your portable device?

What is the value proposition (cost, performance and utility) between a PS6 + PS6 Portable vs. just a Switch 2?

Re: 'You Will Own Nothing and Be Happy': PlayStation's YouTube Comments Are a Horror Show

WhoderMan

Price, global economic realities for the majority of the world, incremental improvements rather than old-school generational leaps, loss of physical media and a "walled garden" approach to monopolize costs are going to ruin the launch of PS6 compared to launches of other Playstation Consoles.

Players around the world are gonna look at what PS6 costs and what it offers compared to a PS5 and/or Switch 2 that they already have or can get much cheaper.

And if the biggest money makers are still GTA, FIFA and Fortnite and you can play those just fine on older hardware...then why buy a PS6 at launch?

This launch will be toast. Sony will spin it. They will probably manufacture less and claim to sell out creating a false demand/narrative.

The numbers everyone loves to quote are intentionally skewed data. They include purchases for microtransactions in free-to-play titles and dlc purchases alongside full game purchases. Sony and every other digital purveyor take the data and present it to you in a way to make you say "gee golly whiz, I guess the humble, on-our-side giant corporation just didn't have any choice but to go all digital." What they really want is total price control.

Never forget that Sony has already experimented with different prices for different customers...

They are NOT our friends. They do NOT deserve loyalty.

Re: 'You Will Own Nothing and Be Happy': PlayStation's YouTube Comments Are a Horror Show

WhoderMan

If Sony can't or won't change course in time to address customer concerns then they can just lose business, right?

We do not have to care about a company that does not care about us.

Strange analogy, but if you love your partner and they suddenly try to take all the money in your joint account and all the power in your relationship... then you leave them before that can happen.

Sony wants ALL of the power in our dealings with them and ALL of the money from anything available on Playstation.

Re: Sony Already Retraining Staff at PS5 Game Disc Manufacturing Facility

WhoderMan

This is defeatist. Never ever stop pressuring them for their desire to make a walled garden marketplace. Never ever stop pressuring them to make a better online experience. Never ever stop pressuring them to make things that they charge for (like PS Plus and online play) have value for their cost.

Sony and Playstation are NOT your friend and do NOT deserve loyalty. Don't pay them if you want things to change.

I don't expect to buy a PS6 due to price, (probably) a lack of innovation, slow trickle of exclusive games, no physical ownership and a walled garden (virtual monopoly) on purchasing digital games.

Re: Reaction: PlayStation's Reputation Is at Rock Bottom - Where Do We Go from Here?

WhoderMan

The handheld unit could be fine without a disc drive.

Basically, you would put your disc in a Playstation device (like your PS5 or PS4) and connect it to your PSN account. Then you would be allotted a certain amount of time to play it digitally. Maybe 2 weeks to a month. You would re-verify the game when time runs out and you want to continue to play it on your handheld PS6

That is not perfect or ideal for many, but it is an easy enough workaround, I think.

Re: Just 15% of All PS5 Software Was Purchased Physically Last Quarter

WhoderMan

@Fyz306903

I haven't really used Steam but they seem more consumer friendly. They allow returns pretty easily and I think you can lend out digital games. On top of that, they have competition on PC with Epic and GOG.

Sony is working towards a closed ecosystem of digital sales that all go through PSN. Which means they track all of that data and will have no competition aside from physical sales of download codes (which will inevitably stop if they get their way). Which means digital sales will be less and less of a discount.

Re: PS6 Will Be a Digital Console, And Sony Has Huge Questions to Answer About Backwards Compatibility

WhoderMan

@Vertere

That would be ideal and could go some way to make me want a PS6, but it would be better if it had memory card slots and accepted UMD and Vita carts (I realize that this is a pipe dream that will never happen). A fully backwards compatible way to use the PS6 would at least be a nice goodbye to physical media (again, it won't happen).

Anyway, I just ordered a PS5 Disc Drive and will start shopping for a PS5 Pro. That may be my last Sony console.

Re: PS6 Will Be a Digital Console, And Sony Has Huge Questions to Answer About Backwards Compatibility

WhoderMan

Well, if there is no disc drive option for PS6 then PS5 will be my last console with Sony. Unless I find a PS5 Pro and a disc drive, then that will be my last.

There will still be physical games made by small boutique kinds of places for PS5 I assume. But that will die out over time.

My incentive to buy a digital only game at launch is 0. Maybe if it was multiplayer but that isn't my main interest.

So... if I can only get a game I want digitally, it is back to the backlog until that game goes on a deeeeep sale. And even then, I probably would just invest in a PC where there is far more digital competition for pricing. Sony just wants to hold a monopoly over game pricing and for that they can lose my business.

I have plenty of physical games to last now through retirement.

Re: Review in Progress: The Adventures of Elliot: The Millennium Tales (PS5) - A Delightful Revival of Classic Action RPGs

WhoderMan

I really wanted to like this game. It has a lot that I love about it.

But just playing the prologue demo (which I would highly recommend for anyone interested in this), I decided against it.

Mainly, the story felt very weak and the dialogue and voices were irritating and much longer and more frequent than necessary. The side quests in the prologue were lame and the dungeons seemed to have no visual flair or identity.

I did enjoy the retro combat, movement and art VERY much. But this is a crowded time for videogames, the backlog is intense, the economy sucks and at some point ya gotta pick and choose where your time and money goes.

I may decide to get it later on down the line, but the demo effectively sold me against it for the time being, at least. Again, for anyone interested, try out the demo and make sure you like it! Just my 2 cents...

Re: Sony 'Hopes' to Launch PS5's God of War Laufey in the First Half of 2027

WhoderMan

Personally, I found the dialogue in the demo of Laufey to sound dumb and kind of for the youtube audience. But I also haven't played Ragnarok yet. C'est la vie. The dialogue in Christopher Nolan's new Odyssey movie also sounds dumb to me.

To each their own I guess, but it isn't complaining for the sake of complaining. That's just a poor response to people with different opinions.

On the flip side, the dialogue in Space Marine 2 ALWAYS sounds like what you should expect from a Warhammer 40K property. And from what I can remember of it, the dialogue in Witcher 2 and 3 always sounded appropriate. I would assume that the dialogue in a GTA, Red Dead or Deliverance also sounds appropriate.

As a final point, I have been a fan of God of War since the beginning and have played all of them but Ragnarok and the new Sons of Sparta. It is 100% possible to be a fan of something, enjoy it, and still have things about it that you can criticize. Nothing is perfect.

Re: Fable PS5's Innovative Life Sim Loop Has Me Smitten

WhoderMan

@JbumiSandra

Actually, I am gonna have to wait for more confirmation that the full game is on the disc. IGN probably was just talking about different versions, i.e. standard, deluxe and collector's editions. I think that they were using their default reporting when they stated that the base game is on the disc.

Re: Fable PS5's Innovative Life Sim Loop Has Me Smitten

WhoderMan

@get2sammyb

Man, I used to really enjoy the Fable series. But I am also a physical collector and prefer preservation of media. If this has the game onndisc then I'll buy it. Outer Worlds 2 didn't and I intend that to be my last empty disc purchase.

Something publishers should know, is that with physical media getting scarcer, fans like me will buy a game on disc at launch (full price) because we are afraid it won't be available later (i.e. Evil West was very hard to find physically after a while).

Whereas I personally have 0 reason to pay full price for a digital game unless I want to support the devs and/or play it immediately. Otherwise I will wait for a deep, deep sale on digital. Or buy it when I know I will play it.

As an aside, it feels like the PSN store is not doing the deep price cuts that it used to. Or not as often. I don't have any data for that, just a feeling.