Comments 25

Re: Mina the Hollower (PS5) - Masterpiece for Many, But Not for Me

Robamuffin

@1970sGamer I like Eurogamer a lot. Probably some of the best games writing out there. People seem to get rubbed up the wrong way about their review scores a lot and time and time again the editorial staff there have said they wouldn't even put scores on their reviews if it wouldn't hurt the site so much now review aggregator sites hold so much power.

Re: Mina the Hollower (PS5) - Masterpiece for Many, But Not for Me

Robamuffin

@get2sammyb I know what you're saying, but don't know if I agree with that fully. I always take Peter Bradshaw as a good example of this. I have such differing tastes to the man, he writes almost contrarian at times I swear. But every time I read one of his reviews I know whether I'll like the film or not off what he says, even if he hates the film and I love it.

As for the link to the past and souls comparisons. They don't quite do it for me, for one the soulslike genre is so big now it's hard to say whether I'll like them or not. I like dark souls, I didn't like lords of the fallen. I liked Lies of P, I didn't like The Surge. I'll end up giving this a go at some point I'm sure. Shovel Knight was good enough that I owe this a chance, I just think the quality of reviews on this site is normally pretty high and this was a prominent outlier for me for what's a decently high profile game.

Re: Mina the Hollower (PS5) - Masterpiece for Many, But Not for Me

Robamuffin

Ah man, no offence to the author or the team at Push Square. I love the site. But this is a really poor review. You say the game's not for you, you admit to breaking the difficulty and mashing the attack button to win. I mean, props to admitting the problem is with you and not the game, but I didn't really come away from the article knowing whether the game's gonna be for me or not

Re: Sony Wants to Make PS5 Matchmaking More Interesting, But It Could Lead to Ads

Robamuffin

I've been online gaming now for close to 20 years. Never while waiting in a lobby for a game to start have I thought I needed more entertaining. That's downtime. You need downtime between matches / games. We've already got increasingly short attention spans we need to be actively fighting stuff like this, as innocuous as it sounds, it's hurting the development of us and future generations.

Re: Halo Confirmed for PS5, Remake of First Game Out in 2026

Robamuffin

Great to see the series coming over, but i always feel, especially with the first game, that the art style was so perfect in the OG release. Every time they tinker it just looks off. For my money they'd be better porting over 1-3 as a 'HD trilogy.' Original games, original graphics, maybe a bit of upscaling but nothing more.