Comments 1,642

Re: CD Projekt Red Confirms Ciri Recast for The Witcher 4 on PS5

DonJorginho

@LifeGirl I think the difference of our opinion comes down to you seemingly (correct me if I’m wrong ) thinking it’s been a bait and switch and fans are right to be unhappy that they can no longer play as Geralt.

Where as I’ve always known this would be an eventual move in the series, especially after TW3, and reading the books the games are based on, this was always the end goal more or less, so I just don’t understand how fans can feel aggrieved by this change unless they didn’t understand the story enough or didn’t do their research.

Re: CD Projekt Red Confirms Ciri Recast for The Witcher 4 on PS5

DonJorginho

@LifeGirl Like I said, the game had always been setting this up pretty outwardly, and the books were always about Ciri, it’s not the developers fault those people weren’t paying attention.

Also it’s pretty repetitive that the same two female protagonists are always used by those who are now critical of female protagonists, it screams “I have black friends”, just because men liked two women in media now means that it’s not them that are the issue but the evil western developers! The fact you’re using very words like “cope” proves you’re going down a very narrow path with your argument.

Geralt hasn’t left the game, he’s in TW4, if fans don’t want to play as Ciri they can just say that, not make up excuses saying “she’s not a Witcher” which exposes their lack of comprehension skills.

When you say backlash, 99% of people who are behind said backlash are being laughed at because they’re clearly coming from a disingenuous place, if you’re part of the 1% who aren’t disingenuous then fair, but for the user I called out, their whole argument being “Ciri isn’t a Witcher” is a pretty poor excuse.

Re: CD Projekt Red Confirms Ciri Recast for The Witcher 4 on PS5

DonJorginho

@ChimpMasta No conspiracy theory needed, some people are just too immature to accept a female protagonist, which is even more hilarious in this situation given The Witcher has always been about Ciri and TW3 literally set this up for Ciri to take the reigns, if you were expecting another game with Geralt as the lead you only have yourselves to blame.

Re: Round Up: What Was Announced at The Game Awards 2024?

DonJorginho

@ATaco Druckmann literally cited Akira, Blade Runner and Cowboy Bebop as inspirations for this game, it's a retro futuristic aesthetic, brand placement is a huge part of 2/3 of those inspirations.

You can make an argument about not wanting a game that takes inspiration from those titles, but to say it's just corporate slop with product placement is highly reductive imo.

Re: Naughty Dog's New PS5 Game Is Finally Announced, Sci-Fi Action Title Intergalactic

DonJorginho

I'm beyond excited for this, Akira/Cowboy Bebop vibes with ND doing the story, Sony providing the budget, and Trent Reznor & Atticus Ross doing the score? With an amazing cast on top of that?

DAY ONE. The usual suspects will cry over a bald female protagonist but I'm sure the game itself will do the talking, seems like they're really gonna level up the open ended design and melee combat loop from TLOU2!

Re: Physical Media Just Can't Catch a Break Right Now

DonJorginho

@elvisfan1 It definitely isn’t cheaper lmao, for the 10% of great digital prices, most games are priced 20/25 pounds more than their physical counterparts.

But the ease of access is still a big appeal, it’s why i go with digital/physical on a by game basis.

Re: Horizon Rip-Off Light of Motiram Will Actually Come to PS5

DonJorginho

Hence why I never backed people saying Sony should sue, it’s an obvious rip off but as long as it’s not actually ripping off one for patents and designs then it’s fair game.

If the game is good nobody but console war fanatics will actually care, and if it sells well on the PS Store then Sony certainly won’t care.