Comments 2,551

Re: Xbox Planning Major Layoffs Next Month, Could Involve a Studio Closure

MrPeanutbutterz

@11001100110zero It's an Xbox thing and not a Sony thing because Xbox made the main hook of GamePass "all our biggest games on GamePass day one, at no additional cost to the consumer". They've also baked the words "GamePass" into every inch of the Series OS. They've conditioned their audience (obviously not all of them, but a lot of them) that this is how Xbox operates, and GamePass is part of the brand's identity, ergo big games day one on the sub is how the platform operates.

One need only look at the Xbox and GamePass subs on Reddit to see that yes indeed, a lot of users don't except to ever pay for their games.

Re: Sony 'Exploring New Ways' to Deliver PS Plus Games

MrPeanutbutterz

@Deadlyblack

It feels like it's a sneaky way for Sony to get people to keep their subs going by making them wait for the game they want to play.

It really doesn't. What you've described (someone with a sub about to expire who wants to play one of the monthly games, but that game isn't arriving until after the expiry) is a super niche scenario.

You can't seriously believe that Sony has rejigged the release schedules in its main markets to capture a number of users that's so small that it amounts to a rounding error.

Re: 'It Looks Amazing and It's Coming Along Well': The Elder Scrolls 6 Is Making Progress

MrPeanutbutterz

@SMJ

Surely denying XBOX and Nintendo fans the opportunity to play Spider-Man is just as downright cruel.

Ah this ol' chestnut. Marvel shopped Spider-Man to Microsoft about a decade ago to make a game, and they went "wubbalubba, we don't recognise the appeal of one of the biggest comic book characters of all time, but we are busy trying (and failing) to build a portfolio of games for our game box, so we'll pass".

Then they shopped it to Sony, and here we are.

Re: Reaction: Mealy-Mouthed Microsoft Takes Us Back to 2023 with Mixed Messaging on Xbox Exclusivity

MrPeanutbutterz

It's to placate the frothing diehards, nothing more. The brand is already poisoned (which gave me a chuckle when I saw that toxic green 25th anniversary Series X LE).

As it stands, the handful of Microsoft games I'm interested in (mostly Doom), I'll be picking them up on steep discounts. If they want to treat PlayStation users as second class customers, then I'm happy to treat their games as second class products.

Re: Future Xbox Exclusivity Will Be 'Case-by-Case', PS5 Ports Will Be Revealed Alongside Release Dates

MrPeanutbutterz

@ilyn Absolutely. The majority of people buying consoles aren't dorks/whales like us who know what's up. It's the casual players, and also parents for their kids (AKA high street shoppers).

When you walk in to buy a device, and the shelves are stacked with content for two of them, but not the third, you're at least partially swayed towards one of the two with a presence.

Of course the irony there is Microsoft went in hard on GamePass, which means part of their diminished visibility is of their own construction.

Re: Gears of War: E-Day Is Not Coming to PS5, Xbox Confirms Console Exclusivity

MrPeanutbutterz

@ElectricWizard You seem to have a different memory of the 1990s than I do.

Sega cut themselves off at the knees - the 32X releasing not long before the Saturn and having bugger all support. The Saturn arriving with a convoluted architecture that was inferior to the PS1 (for 3D games, which was you know, kinda the whole point of the 32-bit era). Then Sega suprise launching the Saturn in the west - the result was retailers weren't ready, the games weren't ready, and more to the point the customers' wallets weren't ready. And the big one - the whole Sega America vs. Sega Japan thing. The company dug it's own grave, Sony hastened it by having the audacity to offer a superior product.

As for Nintendo with the N64, they stuck with the cartridge, which meant a lot of developers couldn't make the games they wanted for it. They also came to the market years later with far more expensive hardware and games. So any ground they lost was their own doing.

The big difference you seem to miss is whatever Sony pulled back in the mid 1990s was clearly welcomed by the public. The PS1 didn't become the first console to top 100 million sales by accident. It's also seen as pivotal moment for gaming, that helped it shed its image of a hobby for kids in their bedrooms, effectively becoming the start of the modern era.

Now, compare that with Microsoft - they were already in the market two decades, by all accounts have always finished last, so they wanted to destroy the opposition by using the only asset they have, namely vast amounts of money. They tried to gate off multiple beloved franchises for themselves in the hope that people would not just flock to their ecosystem, but also pony up for their "pay in perpetuity to own nothing" subscription. And wouldn't you know people have soundly rejected them and their toxic BS.

To wit - Sony were welcomed with open arms with their moves and made the industry better, Microsoft were met with utter disdain and made the industry poorer. So no hypocrisy here... but I take it you're not able to read nuance much?

Re: Future Xbox Exclusivity Will Be 'Case-by-Case', PS5 Ports Will Be Revealed Alongside Release Dates

MrPeanutbutterz

@Deadlyblack They're being torn apart at the tills. My local gaming store says if they could give away their Xboxes they'd still sell more PlayStation and Switches.

My local secondhand store is full to the brim with PlayStation and Nintendo games. They have a green shelf for sure, but it's mostly 360 games. Their Series X Inventory is almost nonexistent.

There's a whole host of territories where it's next to impossible to find an Xbox at retail (which is Microsoft's own tacit admission of "pack it up boys, we ***** up").

Customers do win when there's competition, but it has to be competent competition. Xbox hasn't been that since the late 360 days, so I'm not sure why people are saying Sony has no competition from them now.

Re: Round Up: All the PS5 Reveals from the Xbox Showcase 2026

MrPeanutbutterz

@BigMike22 Well I think there's an element of "okay don't have my money then". And I get that as Xbox's flip-flopping is so damn tiring to listen to.

Personally I feel like Gears has ran its course. I dabbled with 1 back in the day, enjoyed 2, 3 was decent as well. Controversially, I enjoyed Judgement the most. 4 and 5 were just tired (particularly the open world sections in 5).

So it very much peaked back on the 360, and we're now very far removed from it. So even for Xbox fans I don't see this game generating much hype - certainly not enough to sell €600 consoles that are almost six years old (and for what it's worth, as someone who has played the living daylights out of the Uncharted series, I'd have zero interest in an Uncharted 5 too).

Re: Future Xbox Exclusivity Will Be 'Case-by-Case', PS5 Ports Will Be Revealed Alongside Release Dates

MrPeanutbutterz

@Deadlyblack They're getting torn apart because they themselves don't seem to know what they're doing. And it's not like this is a one-time blip, they've been flip-flopping about this stuff for years now.

They're getting torn apart because they've spent the last few years slowly killing the Xbox brand as a console, now they're pivoting back to it. But they're not really because they're still releasing more multiformat games than exclusives.

They're getting torn apart because even some of their most diehard fans have ditched them due to their mixed messaging yet are still standing around with their collective thumb up their asses.

They're getting torn apart because they bought a sizeable chunk of the multiformat industry and the threat of a lot of those games being locked to their platform still looms.

Absolutely none of that is equivalent to what Sony has done with PC.

Re: Round Up: All the PS5 Reveals from the Xbox Showcase 2026

MrPeanutbutterz

@BigMike22 My point is I don't know why you're surprised at the userbase of a site that historically didn't have proper (bar the Reloaded release of the original game, but you know what I mean) access to Gears of War being nonplussed about not having access to Gears of War going forward.

A lot of people back in the late 00s were given a choice between the hoo-rah dude-bro military glorification drabness of Gears, or the Saturday matinee colour of Uncharted. Guess which website the people who went with the latter frequent?

I'm also pointing out it's a bit rich of you to be calling out people here being toxic about a game while you yourself are being toxic about the people posting.

Re: Gears of War: E-Day Is Not Coming to PS5, Xbox Confirms Console Exclusivity

MrPeanutbutterz

@Questionable_Duck But I'm not a blind Xbox hater. I had the original - great console. I had a 360 that red ringed. Then another. Then another. And by the time they released a console that didn't crap its own pants after being powered on for more than five minutes, they were pivoting to Kinect waggle controls that I had no interest in. Then they came out with the One which had mandatory Kinect. Then they spent all of that generation with their thumb up their ass wondering why no one wanted their ***** console (hint - their game output sucked).

They introduced and normalised paid online. They tried to introduce physical games that you couldn't resell. They also tried to introduce a frequent mandatory online check in to play your own discs. They bought a massive chunk of the multiformat industry for themselves because they went almost an entire generation and forgot their game box needed games.

So no, my hatred of Microsoft isn't blind, it's entirely justified.

And I'm not some blind Sony fanboy. They're a ***** company too. As are Nintendo. Sony just so happens to be the most tolerable of them.

Re: Gears of War: E-Day Is Not Coming to PS5, Xbox Confirms Console Exclusivity

MrPeanutbutterz

@ElectricWizard You mean all the third party exclusives that the Saturn couldn't run and couldn't fit on an N64 cart?

Also, the whole reason the PlayStation exists is because of how Nintendo dicked Sony over, so let's not pretend that Sony were looking to cause trouble for the sake of it. Heck, upper Sony management looked at gaming with disdain and it took Ken Kutaragi some serious PR spin just to convince them to give it a shot.

But hey, I see you're another person that can't tell the difference between strategic studio acquisitions (that's been happening since the dawn of time and they all do it) and buying entire chunks of the multiformat industry because heyyo you forgot that your gaming box needs games.

Re: Gears of War: E-Day Is Not Coming to PS5, Xbox Confirms Console Exclusivity

MrPeanutbutterz

@Questionable_Duck I called it an ass platform because it's an ass platform. I sold my Series X after playing Starfield on it and being sick of having adverts slapped on my dashboard.

But yes, I'm such a big Sony shill that a lot of my most recent comments here are about how they're losing me as a customer because I'm bored of their homogeneous game output, how they're afraid to take chances, and they're not the same gaming company I've been with since 1997.

But by all means, keep digging, champ.

Re: Rumour: Gears of War: E-Day Was Coming to PS5, Xbox Cancelled Port Very Recently

MrPeanutbutterz

@Questionable_Duck Ugh yeah this point again. I see it's gone right over your head though.

Did you miss the part that they literally said they were going to spend Sony out of business? But couldn't because their ass platform is so toxic and unappealing that even after buying the likes of Fallout, TES, Doom, Call of Duty no one wanted it? So they pivoted to multiplatform because they had Nadella honking about a return on investment that was never going to happen on their platform?

Oh you did? Okay then.

Re: Rumour: Gears of War: E-Day Was Coming to PS5, Xbox Cancelled Port Very Recently

MrPeanutbutterz

@Questionable_Duck Yeah it's lame. You know what is massively lamer? Buying two of the biggest (including the actual biggest) multiformat publishing houses to keep for yourself (Microsoft literally said at the time they wanted to spend Sony out of business) because your platform, first party studio output, ergo your whole suite of overpaid managers sucked harder than a top of the range Miele.