scoobdoo

But how are the graphics worse than the 30-year-old original

Hands down, GOTY. Makes a mockery of the 5 minute wonder that was new Zelda.

Wo Long!
Biggest disappointment: Ryza 3…can’t believe Nintendo Life gave it 9/10

The lack of PS5 exclusives is a disgrace

The last three AC games sold more than ever before, so not sure who wants the series to return to its roots.

I just wanted a female protagonist, or at least the choice, not this bro boy that’s forced upon us.

10/10 GOTY an absolute stunner

Desperate for Nioh 3

Not a HP fan but bought this the moment the good reviews came in and, hands down, it’s my GOTY. Stunning world, perfectly realized.

@GProsciutto we found the *****

Absolutely obsessed with the game. Hands-down my GOTY. Can't see anything even coming close to this one.

I'm am playing it, loving it, obsessed with it. A true breath of fresh air. I do, however, have to call into question an 8/10 rating for Dead Space with its early PS4-era graphics. That game is the true bomb of the week.

@Constable_What no you're not being too critical, it looks muddy and early PS4-era if we're being completely honest

@Michael2008ish you're quite mad if you think Demon's Souls could be released as-is on the PS4

@NB-DanTE couldn't agree more...if you go through the efforts of a remake it better look as good as Demon's Souls, this is early PS4-level graphics

I refuse to get this because I'm still obsessed with Forspoken

@NEStalgia what engine is being used for FF16?

Outrageous this placed above Pathfinder

It's also a disgrace that Asterigos isn't on this list –– hell, you haven't even reviewed it yet!!

@LiamCroft if Pathfinder isn’t on your radar you need different people doing the RPG best of list.

Ok so am I crazy or is this actually still not back? On PS+ right now and only Monstrum Nox is listed.

@BuGGy2DaB see you in 3-4 years then

@AFCC you're letting an outlier review sway your purchase decision? Wow.

@thefourfoldroot they didn't; this reviewer is literally the only one out there who isn't gushing about the writing

Literally every other review has praised the combat and story — Kotaku alluding to this being a GOTY contender — and here those are negatives. Interesting....