Comments 105

Re: Disc-Based PS5s Now Warn Buyers About the Impending Death of Physical Games

asdfghjklz

@Almost_Ghostly Very small minority indeed! They are 10 to 15% of the playerbase and looking at Japanese sales figures, the physical market there is dead except for Nintendo.

Sony is not a museum or a charity. If people want to preserve games for future generations, discs are not the way as those decay over time. They can do so much more easily with digital files (assuming they have a crack for the DRM, which is also present on discs).

Re: Could Xbox Get Its Revenge on PS6 by Supporting Physical Games?

asdfghjklz

Xbox doesn’t even support games on the disc as is! Their discs for first party games force you to download the game anyways and the discs are just a license.

Also, the digital-only Series S and X have been dramatically outselling the disc X.

Suggesting they will support discs for Helix is pure delusion.

Re: Early Data Suggests Unspectacular Start for Halo on PS5

asdfghjklz

@Blaze215 They’re not wrong. The devs had to expect that people like you would concern troll over “but what about being able to kill women??? the outrage!!!” and it would have amused them greatly!

Evidently you’ve never played a GTA game where children are prevented from being killed because society generally condemns violence against children, just as it generally condemns violence against defenseless women.

Re: Japan Studio Couldn't Keep Up with Sony's Push for Games That Would 'Drive Hardware Sales'

asdfghjklz

Indies cannot replace first-party output because they lose access to the valuable IP that makes their games moderately successful. For example, a Patapon clone is never going to sell as well as a real Patapon game, and people can tell the difference between a knockoff and an original.

So cutting off an indie studio is pretty much a death sentence. Much of the former Japan Studio staff will be forced to leave the industry permanently when their studios struggle with sales, and take their creative ideas with them.

Highly-skilled creative talent, especially at the level of a creative director, is not fungible, meaning you cannot simply hire an average college graduate to replace the vision of someone who has been laid off.

Shame on Sony for betraying what made their consoles unique.

Re: 'It Will Not Disturb the Industry Much': Major Publisher Doesn't Believe PS5's Disc Debacle Will Change Anything

asdfghjklz

@Nem Did you read the article or just leave a comment based on the subtitle?

He’s suggesting that removing the need to support physical discs via a disc drive will lower the cost of the console, making the console accessible to a wider spectrum of buyers. And that is undoubtedly true.

It’s not like Sony priced the PS5 higher than the PS5 Digital because they wanted their install base to be smaller, it’s just manufacturing economics.