Comments 736

Re: Horizon Hatred Simmers Once More As Sony Announces Movie Adaptation

Art_Vandelay

@get2sammyb It is totally fair to separate the Horizon games from the Horizon IP. The two mainline entries are excellent games, but the IP is just not that exciting. If you think this is some wild social media conspiracy theory, you're surprisingly disconnected from the mainstream sentiment.

Do you really want to use games sales as a barometer? Ok, so how well is Lego Horizon doing so far? Do I need to remind you that it has a "Lego" stamp and that it's out on the Switch? This should be making waves, but it came and went like a fart in the wind.

Why? Because the game is just fine, and the IP is not strong enough to carry it.

Re: Talking Point: Is PlayStation Right in Saying PC Isn't a 'Major Risk' to Console Business?

Art_Vandelay

The key words in that statement are "so far". The PC strategy is not proactive. It's a reaction to the ballooning costs of games development and the downstream shareholders' pressure. Anyone who thinks it's not risky is looking at the sprint, but the prospects for the marathon aren't so hot.

Just look at the Steam Deck and think about a screenless high-power variation aimed at your living room. This is the most obvious prediction ever, and it's coming from both Valve and Microsoft.

Sure, it might be a little more expensive than a PS6, but games are cheaper, online is free and it runs "exclusives" from every publisher. What incentive would anyone have to opt for PlayStation besides blind loyalty and inertia? That doesn't last for long.

Maybe Sony simply sees streaming as the inevitable future, so it doesn't really matter at the end. In that scenario, PlayStation would eventually become a games publisher just like Microsoft. But I still think it's way too early to place that bet.

Re: Game of the Year: Best PSVR2 Game of 2024

Art_Vandelay

@MichaelNau I cannot enjoy FPS games on the flatscreen at all. It feels like I'm just controlling a camera, which technically is the exact case. And aiming with the thumb is clunky and finicky, so it never feels immersive. Not to mention the claustrophobic field of view (or the alternative distorted world).

But VR turns all of those issues on their head, and I'm loving every second of many FPSs. Just finished Arizona Sunshine Remake, and I can tell you that nailing headshots on those zombies never gets old.

Also, do not sleep on Synapse. It's easily one of the best VR experiences I've had. And of course, you also don't wanna miss RE4 and Village. Give one of those a try and you won't look back.

Re: Industry Analyst Argues Either Sony or Microsoft Will Need to Exit the Console Market

Art_Vandelay

@Max_the_German Yes, Microsoft has been moving in that direction, but I don't think it can work for the following reasons:

1) Windows sucks, plain and simple, and its heavy legacy makes it impossible to fix.

2) Valve is doing the same, but way better.

3) The Xbox PC will either be too weak or too expensive (or somewhat weak and somewhat expensive).

All in all, it sounds like an idea that is as bad as Game Pass. It's the typical death spiral: a weak market position that leads to a bad idea that leads to a weaker position that leads to an even worse idea and so on and so forth.

Re: Alan Wake 2's Latest Update Tackles PS5 Pro Problems, Includes Toggle for PSSR

Art_Vandelay

I like Digital Foundry's videos as pure entertainment, but I really don't like the increasing need to watch their stuff in order to make a more informed decision as to what modes and settings I should use.

The whole idea of consoles is to be a turn on and play device. Devs and QA should really be doing the leg work here, tailoring the experience to what they judge will offer the best user experience. Sure, having "fidelity" and "performance" modes is fine, but anything beyond that should be reserved for PCs.

Re: Intergalactic PS5's Toxic Detractors Peddling Patently Fake 'Leaked' Story Details

Art_Vandelay

@RoomWithaMoose Aspirational? Not necessarily, that I agree. Breaking Bad is the best TV show ever. But appealing? C'mon, man.

Look, you're entitled to your opinion (obviously). But when your opinion doesn't align with the vast majority of gamers, it makes for very bad business decisions.

Like it or not, games need to sell. If there's one thing that Concord taught us, is that creative intent needs to meet market demand.

The real problem with Intergalactic's lead character doesn't have anything to do with identitary characteristics, and it's not about Joel either. The issue here is that it's pretty stupid for a studio to design a game around a protagonist that comes across as being so damn smug and obnoxious.

That won't fly in 2026 or so, pardon the pun.

Re: Intergalactic PS5's Toxic Detractors Peddling Patently Fake 'Leaked' Story Details

Art_Vandelay

@JustMyOpinion I get that, but let's face it: it's not that simple. If you're a fan of videogames, a new ND release used to be one of those rare special moments worth of savoring.

To see the studio descend into a dark path of bad business decisions is quite depressing, to be frank. There is an ongoing cultural shift that will leave many behind, and it worries me that one of Sony's crown jewels might be among them.

Re: Naughty Dog Turns Off Intergalactic PS5 Trailer's Comments As Discourse Turns Nasty

Art_Vandelay

@glennthefrog You're right, and the fact that comments were disabled from the beginning is quite telling. ND is aware that the character is controversial, and afraid of the public's reaction. But they're willing to double down on it anyway.

Sure, they have every right to do whatever they want from a creative standpoint. But from a business perspective, it's a decision that fails at reading the room temperature, whether you agree or disagree with the "far right haters".

Money talks.

Re: PS5 Pro Update on Its Way to Black Myth: Wukong, Arriving Tomorrow

Art_Vandelay

@Rich33 At first, I had the same thought. But note how they worded it:

"The input response has been improved in Performance Mode."

The performance mode is really bad on the base PS5 because it uses FSR3's frame generation, which adds a lot of input latency. Maybe they leveraged the extra GPU power on the Pro by simply removing frame gen, which could actually be pretty great considering what kind of game this is.

It remains to be seen how well it performs, though.

Re: PlayStation Growth Boosts Sony Shares to Record Closing High

Art_Vandelay

@The_Wailing_Doom "It seems like Sony shareholders are not concerned with the treasonous felon's tariffs in the U.S."

I guess the market speaks louder than any pushed narrative. "Trump trade" predicted the elections.

This is literally not Trump's first rodeo. He is a businessman first and foremost. Tariffs are leverage, plain and simple.

Re: Astro Bot Blasts Past Elden Ring, Currently 2024's Highest-Rated Release

Art_Vandelay

I'm sorry, but the fact that a 3D platformer and a DLC are the top two games of the year is proof enough that, yes, 2024 was kinda weak.

Don't get me wrong. Astrobot and Erdtree are fantastic, but they're not that "generation-defining" kind of title. 2024 has nothing up there in the Pantheon of history's greats such as Red Dead 2, GTA IV, The Last of US, God of War 2018, Bloodborne, or Elden Ring itself. It's not even close.

And the fact that two of the aforementioned games came out in 2018 along with Spider-Man gives you a good point of reference of what a strong year looks like.

Yes, 2024 is full of great titles. But it does feel weirdly empty all things considered.

Re: PS5 Handheld Device in the Works at Sony, New Report Claims

Art_Vandelay

I can see how they would match PS5's GPU power by simply running the games at a low ~800p resolution. But it's just not possible to match PS5's CPU on a handheld, and there's no easy way to automatically scale it down.

The only path I see is to require explicit support from devs. It's not exactly the same as the Vita, which required a separate SKU, but something more along the lines of the PS5 Pro (although in the reverse direction).

Re: Silent Hill 2 Patch 1.06 Fails to Fix PS5 Pro Problems

Art_Vandelay

@DonJorginho "Consistency in dev implementation is the issue."

It's not that simple. Dev implementation is only one of many variables that could explain the issue:

1) SDK version has been reported to make a difference. First-party studios might have early access to newer versions.

2) Input resolution has also been pointed out. Sony's games seem to be implementing 1440p > 4K, while others are rendering natively at much lower resolutions and are getting worse results with PSSR then they were getting with FSR2.

3) And lastly, PSSR seems to be causing graphical glitches when combined with certain raytracing effects such as ambient occlusion.

Now, these patches shouldn't have been released in the first place, but I'd bet there are contractual obligations at play here. And most of what I described above is actually on Sony's side.

Finally, I don't think there is much to worry about at the end of the day. DLSS was pretty bad when it first launched, which is par for the course when it comes to AI upscalers. Machine learning is resource intensive and time consuming. PSSR will get better with time.

Re: Silent Hill 2 PS5 Pro Issues Are Being Worked on, Dev Confirms

Art_Vandelay

These issues have seemingly been caused by an older version of PSSR. Which is par for the course for brand new hardware, especially considering it employs a piece of tech that gets better with time by definition (machine learning's gotta learn).

A clear indication of this is how Sony's first party implementations have been stellar. It's expected that Sony would give its studios early access to the latest versions of its SDK.

Granted, this is not great for people who got the Pro on day one, but it's also expected that early adopters would have to endure some troubled waters. It's also not a great look for the console, but these things do tend to be quickly forgotten provided the issues are ironed out in due time.

The silver lining here is that Sony is getting an important head start in the console race by being the first to deploy AI-based upscaling. This tech should be an important foundation of the PS6, and it will be very mature by the time the next-gen console comes out.

Re: PS5 Pro Enhanced, PS Store Situation Devolves into Confusing Mess

Art_Vandelay

There has been a lot of discussion around the industry about how to grow the user base, how to beat competitors, how to grab the attention of the newer generations and so on.

Even though these are all valid concerns, it is bewildering that Sony can't get the fundamentals right. This Pro enhanced confusion is the tip of the iceberg when it comes to how bad the PlayStation Network user interface is. Especially the web front-end.

I have experienced numerous times the unforgivable issue of using the search function for a particular game and coming out with no results, or with suggestions that have nothing to do with what I was looking for. And that often happens even when I type the exact word match. Sure, it doesn't occur with big games, but it's incredibly common with smaller titles, especially VR which I search a lot.

How can this be?

Re: Dead Rising Remaster Adds PS5 Pro Support, Casual Mode

Art_Vandelay

@SJBUK Yes, the potential for VR is enormous. On flat-screen games, the benefit of the Pro can be limited in cases where the CPU is the main bottleneck. But in VR, you're almost always limited by the system's GPU. The benefits will be especially noticeable when PSSR works with VR, since many games render at a resolution that is quite a bit lower than the OLED panels'.

Re: Australia's Planned Social Media Ban to Include PSN

Art_Vandelay

Oh, the classic example of taking a real problem and using it as an excuse to impose draconian measures. This is so incredibly naive, unthoughtful and ill conceived, that I struggle to understand where these people have their head at.

This is a super complicated issue. And in such situations, government overreach is almost always the wrong direction.

Re: PlayStation Has Swiftly Solved Its Profitability Problem

Art_Vandelay

Whoa, not so fast. One quarter alone is just a picture, but what matters at the end of the day, is the film. Even with this quarter's good results, the trend still points downwards.

Sure, the overall situation is probably not as dire as some may have led us to believe, but one good quarter is by no means a conclusive indication that the industry challenges are fully addressed.

Re: PS5 Pro Pre-Orders Are Stronger Than PS4 Pro, But Scalpers Are Losing Money

Art_Vandelay

The Pro is not just about selling more consoles. It's about having an option with the "world's most powerful console" stick on it. Even if a buyer ends up getting the standard model, the halo product strongly influences that decision by virtue of brand image alone.

It's a similar situation to PSVR2. Having a VR headset accessory ends up weighing in a person's decision to buy a PlayStation rather than an Xbox, simply because it's nice to have the option down the road. The machines are too similar this generation, so any bullet point in the box can sway people in either direction.

Microsoft only has Game Pass to show for it, and even though the value proposition is sound, it's just not sexy enough.

Re: Sony Boss Says It's 'Learned a Lot' from PC Player Pushback

Art_Vandelay

"we understand PSN isn’t officially available in every country"

That is a total bs excuse for the fake online rage. I live in Brazil, where there was no PSN back in the PS3 days. And that has never stopped me from creating a US (or whatever else) account and buy my digital games from there. All I needed was an international credit card, which is also something anyone can easily get.

Re: Sony Comments on Concord Disaster, Says Game Should Have Been Tested Earlier

Art_Vandelay

@get2sammyb I'm afraid I disagree, Sammy. To me, Sony sound a lot like they have their heads buried in the sand. There's so much that went wrong with Concord that is not being alluded to here.

I know, I know... to a hammer, everything looks like a nail. The culture war can get tiring, but culture might as well be all that matters at the end of the day, because it permeates everything whether we like (or see) it or not.

The tidal shift is too big to ignore at this point.