Comments 748

Re: Assassin's Creed Shadows Can't Stop the Ubisoft Rot of Star Wars Outlaws and XDefiant

Art_Vandelay

@ShogunRok You're so desperately trying to defend this game's "success" that you're missing the point. Yes, it clearly sold well by some standards (relatively to other AC games or to other titles so far in 2025). But the actual metric that matters is how much money it made relatively to its overall cost. And we all know how bloated Ubisoft is. Afaik, we don't have that number, but judging by this financial report, it doesn't look so good.

Re: PS6 Can't Rely on Cutting-Edge Graphics, Sony Must 'Change Its Way of Thinking'

Art_Vandelay

It's actually a lot more nuanced than that. Graphics could improve dramatically, but not in the brute force way it used to be. CPU and GPU power just does not scale well anymore, but software still can, especially when coupled with custom function hardware.

Path tracing (or full ray tracing) can have a transformative impact in the way games look. And additionally, it has the potential to ease the work of developers, which is another important bottleneck to today's graphics.

More importantly, AI could really advance graphics to the point of offering quantum generational leaps. DLSS/PSSR/FSR4 are the tip of the iceberg. And of course, AI also has a gigantic potential to ease the work of developers, but that coin has two very different sides. If abused, and it will be abused, things could get ugly for a while.

Re: PSVR2 Owners, It's Time to Immerse Yourself in the Headset's Best New Game

Art_Vandelay

@Max_the_German Sony is definitely funding many of those third party efforts. I think it's a fair compromise, as there's simply no business justification to prioritize VR over flat within the bounds of first party.

I would also love an Astro port, but here's the reason it probably won't happen: that game was designed for the dualshock, but PSVR2 cannot track the dualsense controllers.

I'm sure Sony has considered this at some point, but Japan Studio probably said that translating the input from the dualshock to the VR sense controllers would not be feasible. Which I actually tend to agree. It's certainly possible, but that doesn't mean it would be good. Or maybe the game would just have to be thoroughly redesigned, which in turn would bring us back to my initial argument (too big of an investment).

Re: Another Impressive Gran Turismo 7 PS5, PS4 Update Going Live Today

Art_Vandelay

@Glorioso You said "The game is for 0.1% who want a Renault Kangoo". Glad you corrected that absurd.

Now, 100/13 equals 7.7 million copies sold. This is an average, which should take into account that 5 of those 13 games are spinoffs. GT7 is estimated to have sold 14-15 million copies.

Not only is that very impressive, but it easily makes Gran Turismo the most valuable IP in PlayStation's portfolio.

Re: Intergalactic PS5 Game All About Faith, Religion, and 'Being Lonely'

Art_Vandelay

@Oram77 Lol, nice try. I don't want to get into TLOU2, because its controversial nature has been discussed to death, but you forgot the TV show. I guess that "we're communists" line could not, under any circumstance, be considered preachy. And that is just one obvious tinny little example.

Look, the games are good, and the show is good, provided one can overlook the decidedly preachy aspects. And maybe you align with Neil's values and don't even notice these things, but it doesn't mean they're not there.

Re: AMD Hypes Up PS6 Collaboration, FSR 4 Upscaling Tech

Art_Vandelay

The last competitive GPU architecture from AMD before the new one was RDNA2. It was heavily codeveloped with Sony to form the basis of the PS5, and I suspect this had a lot to do with its relative success.

Now, AMD suddenly turns up with another banger, and I'm inclined to believe PlayStation has had its fingers all over it once again. RDNA4 will probably form the basis of the PS6, which is in active development right now.

Re: AMD Hypes Up PS6 Collaboration, FSR 4 Upscaling Tech

Art_Vandelay

@KoopaTheGamer The difference in TOPS between the PS5 Pro and these new GPUs is massive. That probably explains the seemingly better results with FSR4, but I would bet it shares a lot of tech with PSSR. And to be fair, it's still early days for both.

Think of it as the APUs that go into Sony's consoles: it's mostly standard AMD's PC CPU and GPU, but Sony tweaks it to get that maximum console efficiency.

Re: Could the Next Xbox Get a Head Start on PS6?

Art_Vandelay

"this generation has always been expected to run longer due to the disruption caused by the pandemic"

That's not the main reason at all. Generations will run increasingly longer simply by virtue of, well... physics.

Reducing the size of transistors inside a microchip has been by far the biggest driving force that pushes performance and architectural innovations in CPUs and GPUs.

It just so happens that shrinking has a hard limit: the size of the atom. And the more we approach that limit, the harder it gets to shrink nodes.

Re: Talking Point: Is PSVR2 Worth Buying In 2025?

Art_Vandelay

@NeonPizza That's the thing, PSVR2 was my entry point into VR, hence that "magic". Imagine loading up Thumper on the first day and going "wooaaah, what the hell is going on?!" (pardon the pun).

And frankly, VR still amazes me two years later. I still get that tickle at the "3, 2, 1... boom, GT7 switches from the virtual screen to VR mode" when entering a race. This game with a good racing rig on PSVR2 is my child's dream come true.

And regarding Astrobot, yeah... I mean, they've got to bring it over at some point, right? Right??

Re: Talking Point: Is PSVR2 Worth Buying In 2025?

Art_Vandelay

Buying a PSVR2 at launch was the most magical moment I've had with gaming probably since the Sega Genesis. I've been gaming for 40 years now, and one eventually gets to a point where everything feels like "been there, done that". But VR came to the rescue and totally flipped gaming on its head to me.

I played VR exclusively for almost two years, and now I've been alternating with flat on and off. I still very much love VR, but these last couple years off flat-screen gaming have been great to refresh my love for gaming in general.

To sum it up: I strongly recommend it. It's not the new way to experience games, but it's an awesome alternative.

Re: Xbox Plots a Catalogue of AI Games, And It'll Probably Use Tech on PS5

Art_Vandelay

It's embarrassing how clueless Satya is when it comes to gaming. His enthusiasm to push AI in the most absurd ways is sickening.

AI is undoubtedly the kind of disruptive tech that will cause a deep societal restructuring, maybe even deeper than the internet did. But the technocrat looks at it and immediately sees all kinds of really bad use cases.

For now, generative AI is transformative as a tool for quick prototyping, just like chatGPT is quite useful for initial document drafts. But to imply that "soon" these models will be employed to generate the final game (or even parts of it) is the perfect recipe for absolutely soulless games.

Re: Sony's Pricey PS5 Pro Is Now Being Outpaced by PS4 Pro Launch Aligned in the US

Art_Vandelay

I own a Pro, but I've always been super skeptical that Sony would even release this mid-gen upgrade simply because AMD couldn't provide a meaningful hardware bump.

And while I did get one, because I'm an enthusiast, I have to say it's been quite underwhelming. Is it worth it? For the vast majority of users, no. Again, the performance upgrade is tiny. Is it worth it for me? Yes, because I like to know I'm getting the best experience possible.

And the improved motion reprojection in GT7 on PSVR2 is the icing on the cake. But that tidbit also goes to show how niche this thing really is.

Re: Reaction: Xbox Publishing More Games on PS5 Than Sony Is Not a Gotcha, It's Just a Sign of the Times

Art_Vandelay

@viktorcode C'mon, mate. Let's try to be honest here and compare apples to apples.

There are bad cancelations and catastrophic cancelations. It is always a "stop loss". The earlier you cancel, the better. But what really needs to be analyzed here is the reason why those Sony games were canceled, when they were cancelled (Concord), and the size of the investment ("Factions", Bungie).

It was obvious from the start that this trend chasing towards live service games was a fool's errand. Sony bet too high on the wrong horse. Just look at Nintendo: they've stuck to their guns and ended up as the most successful of the big three this generation.

Diversifying one's portfolio is fine, but calibrating your bets is paramount.

And negative sentiment in fanbase means nothing? Really? Alright, then.

Re: Reaction: Xbox Publishing More Games on PS5 Than Sony Is Not a Gotcha, It's Just a Sign of the Times

Art_Vandelay

@LogicStrikesAgain Two things can be true at the same time.

While Astrobot is great, it's a project on a much smaller scale than the likes of GOW, Horizon, TLOU or Ghost. Make no mistake, the aforementioned bad decisions inevitably have an impact on Sony's output, and first-party has been meager as of late.

And please, don't mix "exclusives" with first-party. We both know they're not the same thing.

Re: Reaction: Xbox Publishing More Games on PS5 Than Sony Is Not a Gotcha, It's Just a Sign of the Times

Art_Vandelay

Sure, Microsoft is bigger. But the negative sentiment among PlayStation fans has nothing to do with that. Sony's slow output of late is the result of sheer incompetence, plain and simple, and it shows. Do I need to remind you of how much investment has been recently burned by a ton of horrible decisions from PlayStation Studios?

Naughty Dog wasted years on its online service game.

Concord sucked a truckload of cash only to be cancelled post release.

Then there's Bend, Bluepoint and so on.

"Oh, games are cancelled all the time!" Yeah, right.

Re: PS5, PS4 Attracted the Most Players in PlayStation History in December

Art_Vandelay

@PuppetMaster You know what? You're right:

https://www.pcgamer.com/gaming-industry/new-report-says-pc-games-are-outselling-console-games-calling-pc-gaming-a-bright-spot-in-a-troubled-industry/

I'll make it easier for you: title reads "New report says PC games are outselling console games, calling PC gaming a 'bright spot' in a troubled industry".

Further down: "Compared to the previous console generation, the current Microsoft and Sony console lines had, after 49 months, sold nearly 7 million fewer systems.
PC gaming, meanwhile, has only continued to grow. 'While console has stagnated since 2021,' Epyllion says, PC gaming revenue 'has grown 20%.'"

Have a good day yourself too, sir.

Re: PS5, PS4 Attracted the Most Players in PlayStation History in December

Art_Vandelay

@PuppetMaster Mate, I love these conversations, but I'm a little short on time here. I could search for the data, but so could you. Or you can take my word for it. Or better: observe how Sony and Microsoft are behaving. Why the sudden interest in PC gamers?

Now, regarding the Switch: yes, it's obviously a major success, but its 150 million mark just does not compare to PS2's. It's way more common for households to have multiple Switches than it was to have more than one PS2. The Switch is primarily a handheld, so it's not a fair comparison.

Anyway, you're confining your analysis to the short-term. Demographic shifts take decades to consolidate. Consoles have been gradually becoming specialized PCs, which frankly saddens me. But I won't pretend I don't see the trend because I don't like it.

Re: PS5, PS4 Attracted the Most Players in PlayStation History in December

Art_Vandelay

It's neither here nor there. PlayStation is doing just fine, but the increase could easily be explained by the shrink in players numbers over at Xbox. Overall, consoles do seem to be on a very slow decline, driven by two major factors:

1) Gamers are flocking to PC, which is growing at a faster pace than PlayStation.

2) The younger generation isn't as interested in consoles as the previous one.

If these trends continue, the traditional console business model will be at risk in a few years. PlayStation has a lot of momentum, and this has been driving its good numbers. All is well in the rearview mirror, but the mid to long-term future is uncertain indeed.

Re: Abby's Muscles Less Relevant to HBO's The Last of Us Adaption

Art_Vandelay

The first season was pretty good but I'm really, really worried about season 2. I just don't see a way they could tackle the game's story, even if tangentially, without the show ending up as a train wreck.

And look, I'm not even craping on TLOU Part 2. It has its merits and its issues. It's bold and it's divisive for a reason. But it's evidently much harder to translate than the first game. Unless they deviate greatly from the source material, which I don't think egos would allow.

Re: Spider-Man 2's Looking Like Another PC Own Goal from Sony

Art_Vandelay

@naruball Exactly. The problem is that Sony shares this vision that consoles will eventually be replaced by 'consolized PCs'. Which might the case, but it kind of feels like a self-fulfilling prophecy. Every platform holder starts porting their games to PC because they fear obsolescence, then eventually consumers start flocking to PC.

Now, one justified reason I can see is the following: if Microsoft releases their games on every platform, they'll naturally sell much better. Which in turn allows for bigger budgets and thus potentially better games, leaving Sony in an awkward position with comparatively weak exclusives.

It's a tough nut to crack, although I fully agree that they should stick to their guns like Nintendo.

Re: Ex-Sony Boss Says Xbox Can Find Multiplatform Software Success, Just Like SEGA

Art_Vandelay

Yeah, but Sega's revenue is about 3 billion a year, while PlayStation brings in about ten times as much. Going the multiplatform publisher route is a mere survival strategy. It's very hard to foster a loyal community of fans without a box to parade around.

Sure, Microsoft Games will be massive considering they own the likes of Minecraft and COD, but this obviously wasn't the original strategy when they started acquiring other publishers.

Re: Capcom Seems Sold on Using AI to Help Out with Game Development

Art_Vandelay

It's funny how most opinions on AI are on exact polar opposites. Either it's the greatest human invention or the beginning of the end when, in fact, the truth is usually in the middle.

Just look at the internet as a parallel example. It's certainly one of humanity's greatest achievement, but it's also the cause of many, many issues. This pattern will probably repeat itself with AI and with every disruptive new technology.

In games development specifically, it will be successfully used as a productivity tool by many, and it will also be abused to the detriment of many games and studios. Some will turn out great, while others will certainly be soulless disasters. The market will be the judge of that, as usual.