Comments 236

Re: Poll: Is 007 First Light a Game of the Year Contender?

NerdyPaul

Pokopia is my GOTY so far, with Trails Beyond the Horizon and Pragmata close behind. I do love that a visual novel (Schrödinger's Call) is the top rated game on Opencritic at the moment though. I hope the "MiXtApE iSn'T a ReAl GaMe" mob are thoroughly annoyed at that one

Re: Sound the Alarm: Tomb Raider: Legacy of Atlantis Partially Developed Using AI

NerdyPaul

No pitchforks for me because I am capable of forming a somewhat nuanced view of AI and its use in game development.

The transparency is good, the fact that any AI generated assets were temporary placeholders and removed before release is good, the fact AI tools would appear to have been used more to make the lives of the people working on the game rather than replacing their human creativity is fine by me.

Online discourse around the use of AI technology is in dire need of some nuance.

Re: Mina the Hollower (PS5) - Masterpiece for Many, But Not for Me

NerdyPaul

@Exerion76 People making a game or a genre of games a part of their identity is a massive red flag about what that person is like. A perfect illustration is the online discourse around Crimson Desert not receiving perfect reviews earlier in the year. It actually got kind of scary.

At the end of the day we all like different things in a game and we all evaluate games based on our own biases, and reviewers are no different because we are all human and thus imperfect.

Re: Mina the Hollower (PS5) - Masterpiece for Many, But Not for Me

NerdyPaul

A lot of people here don't seem to realise that all reviews are just one person's opinion. If you don't like this person's opinion, go seek out some other opinions. God knows there are no shortage of reviews out there for this game. The reviewer even acknowledges that a lot of people will love this game even if they did not which is fair enough. No point getting offended by an opinion.

Side note: it is the highest rated game on Metacritic for 2026 so far which you love to see from an indie.