Marvel’s Wolverine is a great video game. If such a thing could be looked up in the dictionary, you’d find Logan and his bared claws staring back.
In fact, I can’t remember a time when our own review scoring policy has described a game better:
"An accomplished experience, these titles excel in crucial areas, mitigating any shortcomings encountered elsewhere. A game awarded this score may have an outstanding gameplay loop or an incredibly compelling story. Other releases awarded this score may be content confidently re-treading familiar ground."

That is exactly what Marvel’s Wolverine is: it swaps the open world structure of previous Insomniac titles for a linear, focused experience all about action. It will take the time to slow down and live in the moment, with quieter scenes of dialogue and character development. It also delivers excellent performances and a nice variety of settings.
However, that’s all in service of fleshing out a title tuned for combat. You play this game to tear enemies limb from limb over and over again — that’s what it leans all the way into and excels at.
It’s the ultimate Wolverine simulator with the mask on; it’s without it where the PS5 exclusive falls short.
Set before the X-Men have been established, Logan is rescued from a life in the wilderness by Nathaniel Essex, a former teammate, to help stop a plot to kidnap fellow mutants. Essex is providing them a sanctuary away from the prejudice of society, so the plot sets up a push and pull of rescuing mutants while trying to end the abductions.
As well as a present-day story, the game also explores Logan’s past. It begins with quick flashbacks and audio logs from optional Nightmare Doors, but becomes more pronounced as the plot develops.

Together, the two storylines merge for a roughly 20-hour campaign full of fast-paced and gory action. Insomniac has embraced the blood and decapitation tied to Logan’s claws by crafting a combat system that revels in the human butchery. Light exploration and traversal break up a lot of the missions, allowing Logan to track scents to notable objects and harness his superhuman strength to jump great distances — but it’s never too long before the claws are out again.
Without a stamina meter to worry about, Wolverine lands cuts and impalements about as fast as you can press the attack button. There are some very simple combos to learn, though most of the variety comes from special attacks that unlock as you progress the campaign. As such, it’s not a Devil May Cry experience where you’re mastering complex attacks and achieving crazy combos; the game remains relatively straightforward and approachable throughout.
Instead, it sources that kind of swagger from takedowns and team combos. Brutal finishing animations sever body parts while Jean Grey uses her telekinetic powers to set up easy kills for Logan.

These deaths add a lot of flair to the combat system, creating nice transitions between the general loop of enemy kills and taking a second for a close-up slow-motion slaughter. They leave environments drenched in blood and guts; the camera never cuts from an especially gory decapitation during both gameplay and cutscenes.
While I found the skill tree somewhat limited, offering only a handful of new moves to learn, the core mechanic is so strong that it comfortably carries the title from start to finish.
Following a mostly linear path through levels, there’ll be short breaks for conversation and side tasks. In reality, though, Marvel’s Wolverine is one combat encounter after another, and that’s what it unquestionably nails.
What it doesn’t is the story binding those scenarios and missions together.
Logan’s quest to help mutants does develop and the supporting cast helps with personal motives, but what it builds to simply isn’t that interesting. Cool set-pieces, chase sequences, and a few twists make the build-up a lot more gripping. However, the pay-off at the end and the narrative taken as a whole never particularly thrilled me.
I’m far more of a Spider-Man fan than Wolverine, so I’ll concede some of the more vague references will have gone over my head. I know the broad strokes, though, and this telling of Logan’s past combined with present-day events was lacking impact for me.
Some pretty poorly presented story elements don't help it either. Up until the second half of the campaign, the plotline revealing Logan’s past is mostly kept to side activities called Nightmare Doors. These are combat and traversal challenges, but finishing them unlocks an audio log describing one of Logan’s memories.
They’re presented as white text on a dark translucent background that Logan reads from — they look borderline unfinished and the reading stops if you exit off the screen. Considering how important these optional logs are, I was surprised to see them so poorly presented. They feel rushed and put together at the last second.

Liam McIntyre at least brings them to life with a wonderful performance that embodies every aspect of the Wolverine character. From the shouting and the grunting to the personal and touching moments, McIntyre nails the extremes and everything in between.
Troy Baker as Nathaniel Essex, Krizia Bajos playing Jean Grey, and Brett Gipson portraying Sabreooth all deliver standout performances too. Despite the story they’ve brought to life not being all that entertaining, their vocals and motion capture are some of the best you’ll experience all year.
The campaign is set across a few different countries, including Canada, Japan, and the fictional island of Madripoor, and within them are varied locations that help each level feel fresh.
You’ll explore a slick and neon-lit Tokyo one mission, and then the next will set itself in ancient ruins near a volcano. There’s a good amount of variety that extends to the set-pieces and vehicle sections; motorbike sequences work and control well, while scenes aboard an out-of-control aeroplane thrill.

The one problem is the on-rails nature you’d expect in these sequences often extends to general gameplay, creating a surprisingly restrictive experience at times.
Marvel’s Wolverine is a linear game that wants to guide you to your next objective with on-screen markers, but sometimes, it will let you explore a slightly larger area. The edges of these places aren’t hidden well; I encountered countless invisible walls that blocked my path when it wouldn’t really make sense. Logan can perform 30-foot jumps in some missions, but then can’t hop over a police car in another.
A few levels also feature fades to black if you stray too far from the objective, despite the fact they could be freely explored only minutes before. I think you just have to accept Marvel’s Wolverine for what it is: a strictly linear experience that demands you play it the way it wants you to.

It's resolute in that commitment, only allowing customisation through Logan’s suits and claws, creating a pretty simple character build via Adaptations, and your PS5 graphical settings.
I played through the game on a PS5 Pro set to the Performance Pro mode, which runs the title at 60 frames-per-second while outputting the visuals of the standard Fidelity mode and then improving them through PSSR (PlayStation Spectral Super Resolution).
There’s also a Fidelity Pro setting providing 30FPS gameplay with advanced ray-tracing capabilities, and base PS5 console players can toggle between performance and graphical optimisations.
Save for a few bugs that required a checkpoint restart, my playthrough ran excellently and was matched with outstanding graphics. At times, especially in the face models, Marvel’s Wolverine represents the best visuals possible in 2026. It looks absolutely incredible.

The framerate keeps pace with the action and retains all the details of a bloodbath Logan leaves in his wake. From day one, the game looks and runs exactly as you’d want it to.
A decent amount of PS5 DualSense controller support makes it more interactive, too. Haptic feedback enhances vibrations and proves effective during pivotal scenes, while adaptive triggers provide a touch of resistance to Wolverine's attacks. It's not the best implementation I've ever come across, but what's there works well.
It all comes together to make Insomniac’s altered vision a reality: the developer evidently wanted to do something different after three open world titles, and Marvel’s Wolverine is exactly that. Warts and all, it embraces combat and designs the entire thing around the next enemy to tear in half. And, at the end of it, the game is yet another sublime superhero adventure — you just have to meet it on its terms.
Conclusion
Marvel’s Wolverine ends the open world streak at Insomniac for an intentional and linear superhuman title that revels in its gory, intense combat system. The campaign structured around it can be overly restrictive and the story quite dull, but as a mission guides you from one fight to the next, it lets the bloodshed do the talking. With superb visuals, amazing character performances, and nice location variety, Marvel’s Wolverine sheds its flaws for an endlessly enjoyable superhero experience.





Comments 283
Hi everyone, if you have any questions beyond what the review covers, feel free to copy me in!
About what I expected for a score. I’m looking forward to it, but I’m glad I went Dawnwalker first.
Basically a disaster so I'm glad I went with MindsEye.
Shame you feel the need to justify the score immediately at the beginning of the review but absolutely understandable. I'm sure everyone will be cool about it...
I'm just glad to hear that this game will make you feel like Spider-man.
For 17yrs Arkham has reigned supreme...it looks like the wait continues for a genuine contender 😐🙂
I'm downloading as we speak.
What a disaster for an insomniac game 6 and 7s from other reviews 70 for this is a joke
what about replay-ability?
is there much of that?
some war room challenges?
story mode playthroughs?
etc etc
Reads like it’s fun. Definitely grabbing it next week.
Reading a couple of reviews and seeing that 78 Metacritic score confirms my expectations, still a fun game but a step down from the Spider-Man games and I really think that being relegated to a Marvel games’ studio is starting to eat away the talent at Insomniac and sadly we unofficially know they’re tied up to do Marvel games for the next decade.
September is busy as heck, and giving money to Sony makes me feel gross right now. I think I'll pick up a used copy in a couple months.
@IllusiveMan ye they need not make another wolverine game now and make spiderman because this game is average reviews are saying
Yeah, while I liked the actor and the approach they chose for the character, I'll skip this one, just like Saros. PlayStation continues to fail to deliver quality and value to its customers.
" * Relatively uninteresting narrative
And it's a SOLO game with this ....!!???
Horizon dawn is a repetitive game, for sure.. but there is a REAL story inside (and for the two episodes...).
I won't touch this game.
I'll just save myself the money and watch a streamer play through the game.
Kind of a shame that the story suffers cause I know Spidey 2 suffered in the story department as well.
Sounds just like what we all expected from recent States of Play... State of Plays... what's the plural here?
Ahem, anyway, sounds good, but not good enough for Day 1 this month, of all months. I'll keep an eye on the price and bite at around £40-50, I think.
Honest question. What do you think this story would have needed to do to really impress you? I feel like gamers and reviewers are always like, "I didn't like the story!" but what is it you expect a video game narrative to actually do to impress you? Where is it not taking you?
A lot of the non-PlayStation affiliated sites are giving lower scores, might be one I’ll wait for a sale considering what else is coming out this month.
Incredible - I'll be buying this Day One
It's interesting that this review is talking about bad story and good gameplay, while plenty of other reviews I read have this in opposite. Weak gameplay, but good story.
Regardless. 78 on MC for studio of Insomniac's pedigree is pretty disappointing. 6 from Gamespot and IGN and only 3/5 from VGC and 2,5/5 from Giant Bomb.
It's clearly isn't slam dunk as first Spider-Man.
@Dan12836666 I actually would like an entirely different game like Sunset Overdrive where they can unleash their creativity without the constraints of comic book characters and storylines.
Yeesh I expect this from push Square so no surprises here. However, that aside, it sounds like this game is genuinely not good.
On top of that, if the less biased reviews are accurate, it has some of the worst handholding and progression design I've seen in a modern game along with the very mediocre combat.
The older I get, the more I actually prefer linear games, so the restrictive nature of Wolverine doesn't bother me in the least. I'm not a big superhero guy though, so I may wait for a sale to pick this up. That said, this actually sounds right up my alley, bub!
I'd recommend watching skill up's review for a lot more of what's wrong with this one. It seems insomniac is regressing in game design for wolverine.
Honestly kinda glad I’m avoiding this. Not that I’m a huge Marvel guy anyway.
Sounds fun, but not desperate for it - exactly what I expected. Shame the story isn't too strong though, and the combat is fun but basic, I was hoping for a modern Max Payne like experience - strong, gritty story with exciting action.
That review leaves me thinking It's not worth £70, which I find fair.
@KundaliniRising333 ye i was hoping it was good but if most reviews are all saying the same thing there must be truth to it i live insomniac gmaes as well every game as been day one up to now
The review reads like a slightly dumbed down version of my kind of game (looks very good/has good combat) tbh but I am not that into Marvel.
@Godot25 Game always looked phoned in, shoe horned because they have a Marvel contract and just have to do it because. I even suspect Push[] would've given a 6 or 7 were it not exclusive.
IGN gave it a 6/10 and now everyone is like "See! IGN gave it s 6/10!"
But when IGN gave Veilguard a 9/10 everyone said IGN can't be trusted lol.
This just all sounds so mediocre... X-Men is my favorite Marvel IP, which makes me sad to say that I'm glad I cancelled my preorder
I expected this to be a 7/8 type of game since it's more linear and a bit more limited. Still excited to play it next week because it seems like a fun time. I do assume it will sell extremely well because it is Wolverine and a lot of people just want to kick ass as him.
I am excited for Insomniac's next game whether that is Venom or the next Spiderman. I know some people don't like their character design's or story sometimes but they know how to make a hell of a fun game and are always consistent. One of the top AAA studios regardless if you don't like Marvel games(which I can understand if it's not your cup of tea).
But Please Insomniac give me another Ratchet & Clank & Rivet game please lol. Rift Apart was sooo good.
Dear God, people. You're acting like it's a 4/10. The hate for anything and everything Sony is reaching levels that shouldn't even be possible.
It's clearly a good game.
@Deadlyblack cant think of anything worse than watching a streamer play a game, im i n my mid 40s and grew up with atari, spectrum, commador nintendo, sega, playstation, xbox and we played games for fun, not watching others play, no offence but cant think of anything worse in a gaming sense than watching someone else play a game, even when we were around our m8s and someond was playing and not me that felt weird 🤣. Obviously times have changed and no offence intended, but i play games for fun not to watch others play.
Liam here shows 20 hours of gameplay where as others I’ve read/watched are closer to 10 hours or so. I don’t mind a game that’s a super quality shorter run time but in this economy I’d maybe hope for some more meat.
@LiamCroft Weird question ... is there a graveyard/cemetery etc. location in the game at all?
@Dan12836666 there's 59 reviewers who gave it an 8 or above. 22 that went with 7 or 6.
@Zuljaras Nope, not that I can remember!
@KundaliniRising333 I feel like you consider "less biased" reviews to be reviews that lean to your bias lol.
@naruball Yeah people acting like a 7/8 out of 10 game isn't a good game kind of makes me laugh sometimes.
The fact that the game is 10-20 hours or so makes it worth the $70 to me and I feel like everyone will have a different take on the story.
It will probably be one of the best selling games of the year and it's a good game. Some people just want to hate this game for a lot of reasons.
@AhmadSumadi Everyone knows IGN can only be trusted when their score lines up with your own agenda.
Too much in tbe backlog and a ton out or upcoming much more interested in. Im good for a while on this, narrative being boring and characters being what they are are a huge turnoff
It’s been a long time coming, really looking forward to this. Only a few more days to go.
Looks like Sony won't be getting a GOTY nomination this year then. Yet again, trying to beat out BRAZILIAN DRUG DEALER BEFORE 4: DEMONS FROM THE PORTAL TO HELL I OPENED ARE STILL IN THE FAVELA AND NOW I HAVE TO SAVE MAMADAS FROM RONALDO was always going to be an impossible task so I shouldn't be too harsh.
77 so far on MetaCritic. Had honestly thought it would be mid-80s. But it still sounds fun enough and I’ll pick it up at some point. Just not a must have day one kind of game.
It really looks like a 7/10 nothing special game.
I don't understand who thought this was a good idea.
@AhmadSumadi IGN can never be trusted, no matter what score they give.
Yeah, this is kinda what I expected. Not a disaster by any means but the story elements in the trailers didn’t grab me at all so hearing that the finished game is similar doesn’t shock me. If it’s a fun enough romp for 10 hours or so then it’ll be worth playing when it hits PS Plus. I think the Spider-Man games honestly have some of the same downsides but traversal being that good really makes up for those, replacing that with invisible walls and such is bound to be more polarising.
@AhmadSumadi i mean for sonys exclusives thats not great
@AhmadSumadi cute but no. I mean reviewers that don't consistently review certain platforms or developers games higher on the range due to influences that are outside truly evaluating the game.
Not for me, linear and invisible walls are a turn off straight from the off, add to that I'm not a super hero fan either I think I'll pass. Will probably be on Extra or Premium at some point so will play it then.
So it's reviewing around the same as Crimson Desert then. Sounds good enough to me.
A 10-15 hour, linear, fun games is what I wanted from Wolverine. 20 hours sounds great. I'll be putting this one away for Christmas alongside Ocarina of Time and the lego PS1 set.
@naruball @QBGaming12
I remember the internet being delighted to see Days Gone "fail" when it came out too. Wolverine is reviewing higher than DG though so I'm sure in a year or two when the sequel doesn't get a greenlight we'll all be up in arms. Right?
This is a sad day for Sony Computer Entertainment. Physint, and now this.
*goes off to play Dice a Million
@KundaliniRising333 I haven't been influenced by anything. I thought Marvel's Wolverine was a great game so I gave it an 8/10 score.
@KundaliniRising333 without proof that is just conspiratorial assumptions or defamation. You might be right but it certainly isn't factual.
8/10 is a great score but somehow some people in here acting like it's not worth to play. Gosh, some of you are sad 🙄
Anyway. I expected the campaign around 10-12 hours long but 20 hours? That's quite long for a linear action game.
Not a Day 1 for me anymore, but will still be getting it some day. I just wanna play as Wolverine!
Kundalinirising33 Burden of proof is on the one who is accusing or whatever the saying is
Just as I expected a 8 is a good score.word up son
Not a game im interested in as its more Marvel junk, but glad it turned out well for Insomniac, literally carrying this gen on their backs! But I really need them to go back to making games that aren't super-hero related, a new IP a new Ratchet, just something!
you are literally the only site giving this game a score higher than 6/10
Kudos to insomniac, Sony’s lifesavers.
I appreciate you not giving it a 10 just because it's first-party. From the review, it's exactly what I expected it to be. Though for me it'd be a lower score because I cant get even slightly hyped for what's basically an on-rails beat 'em up.
Removed - inappropriate
If this is not a huge red flag for Sony, as they are the “experts “ on first party single player games, don’t know what else is.
Leadership needs to change.
Soul searching needs to begin.
@AhmadSumadi
Apart from Sony PlayStation affiliated websites (who rated 8/10), other websites rated without sentiments etc (6-7/10).
Meaning.. I rather trust the 7/10.
No offense.
@HairyBizRat Its Metacritic score is 78 based on almost 100 reviews so this review is as close to the average as it could be.
Its Metacritic score is 78. It will probably finish within the 75-80 range. Obviously this isn’t the end of the world, I like Metroid Prime 4 more than most, but I expected the review scores to be much higher than this.
Thank you for the insight as always
@HairyBizRat absolute nonsense, you clearly haven't checked meta or open critic.
@ShadowRJ Well, scores would be higher than this if the game was better than this.
@KundaliniRising333 so everyone who disagreed with you is wrong and deluded? Don't let the door hit you on the way out.
PS Plus in 2 years then. I will play Spiderman 2 through at some point but it's an okay game that looks great so far.
An 8/10 is actually a bit of a disappointment coming from this studio. That's a bummer.
I think the Eurogamer review excerpt they have on Metacritic sums up what I expected this to be and why I wasn't looking forward to it.
"Jump, punch and slash, move on. Over and over again. Back in the day, if done well, that was all a straightforward action game needed. It's certainly worth some praise that Wolverine stays true to this goal. The action is direct, clearly defined, and brutal. Which is cool. For an hour in the evening."
Looks like a good game but not to the pedigree of Insomniac, I really wish they would take a break from these Marvel games 🫤
@HairyBizRat

https://opencritic.com/game/17842/marvels-wolverine/charts
@Shepherd_Tallon Oh I think we get a sequel and it's a X-Men game down the line. Since the new X-Men movie comes out in 2 years that gives Insomniac time to make a X-Men game. I also think this game sells well.
I do remember all of the hate/love around Days gone but to me that game had enough flaws to not warrant a sequel unless Sony Bend proved that they could make it way better.
I definitely think that if given the chance to make a sequel to Wolverine and it's a X-Men game(I hope) Insomniac will knock it out the park. I just think this is the first game in a series and it's just a bit too limited hence why the reviews are all over the place.
I can definitely see a Open World X-Men game in about 3-5 years.
@Daleaf 53, and couldn't agree more. But my kids watch em. Modern life. 😕
@Dorkthrone Narrative can detract from a good game. Bad characterisation, dialogue, pacing or just a boring/dumb plot. Not everyone cares about narrative, and not every game needs a strong one, but let's not pretend there isn't a range of quality.
Removed - trolling/baiting
@Leinad7 not offended at all. I wasn't getting the game either way. I'm more a fantasy RPG kinda guy.
It seems exactly as expected, like one of those action films you enjoy and don’t think too much about. I’ll pick it up after finishing Dawnwalker which is awesome fun.
“8 is a bit high compared to clueless IGN and review-bombed aggregator sites!! 😡”
Disappointed but not surprised about the writing. And the part about Jean Grey "setting up kills" for Wolverine..... face palm... Still gonna play it at some point but it's not high on the list unfortunately.
Just saw skill up review. The amont of hand holding in this game is like none other. This is baffling in 2026 that any developer still continue to do this.
@QBGaming12 No I absolutely agree with what you're saying there. I was just being sarcastic and a little bit smarmy with my previous comment.
This game for me has all the feels of a 4 issue mini-series before the main narrative arch kicks off, and absolutely the next game will be an X-Men title (which I can't wait for).
As for Days Gone, just so I'm on the record, I loved it as a perfectly good 7/10 game but never felt it warranted a sequel.
@ATaco I politely disagree. Whilst Insomniac have been carrying the first party exclusives this gen, an 8/10 by them is absolutely fantastic still.
They have a portfolio of solid titles all of which I would put at highest an 8/10. None of them are generation defining titles though. 10/10 games go to things like Elden Ring, Baldur's Gate 3 etc as examples off the top of my head.
I know it's all down to personal preferences but I wouldn't personally put Spiderman (as an example) up there with those games.
Gotta be honest, 77 metascore has me thinking maybe I’ll wait on a sale.
I want an X-Men '97 game. No "Original Universe Do Not Steal" version either.
Not buying this until Sony clarifies if my physical copy will be playable on PS6. I'm also hoping the critical reception will be a catalyst for Insomniac to break free of the Marvel sweat factory.
Well damn!! LOL i was not expecting the review scores from other outlets. I was holding off on getting the new Onimusha game for this but looks like id rather get that instead of wolverine
Since when was an 8/10 disappointing 😂.
Dear God, what did they do to Jean Grey?
Some of the footage looks absolutely ridiculous with its level design and player interaction. It's like PlayStation took their normie gamer pandering obsession to an extreme.
I watched SkillUp video. Game looks so bad, daamn.
This is the highest score I've seen. Crazy
@Daleaf I mean, good for you? I watch the streamer regardless and they're going to play Wolverine. Besides I'm busy playing Onimusha at the moment. Not sure it matters what I do for entertainment.
i see 6 from IGN & Gamespot, does sony shutter Insomniac now? wouldnt be like them!
It seems like Insomniac caught lightning in a bottle with the story/narrative on Spider-Man 2018, and sadly it appears that they do not have inspired/competent writers.
@Shepherd_Tallon I was totally agreeing with you about the "hate" for Days Gone and stuff. Most of my comment was mainly so that other people see it and realize this is the just the first game in a series.
I do agree that Days Gone was definitely a good 7/10 and didn't need a sequel.
The hate on this game has been ridiculous for so many reasons from the design choices to other issues lol.
I do believe that you let Insomniac make a Open World X-Men game and they let you play as several X-Men(Cyclops, Wolverine, Jean, Storm and Rogue etc) that combat will kick ass and the story. Insomniac/and gamers just have to get through Wolverine and then you get the big game after.
Game looks very mid, graphics look bland. Bring on gta
The Skillup review is absolutely brutal on this! Dont think i've heard him so annoyed at a game before, ouch!
Shame it seems like its not quite up to insomniacs blockbuster history, despite such a good IP.
But that being said, I do think its a game I will enjoy and I do intend to pick it up. It may not be everyone's cup of tea, but many of my favourite things sit in that category, and that's OK.
I do hope Insomniac get a chance to design a game that's not confined to the Marvel universe - they are too talented to be confined to such a genre..
@QBGaming12 I get you.
And yeah I'm pretty excited to see what they do with the X-Men game.
I'm trying not to picture it too much in my mind because I want to take it as it comes, but the idea of being able to swap between multiple X-Men and their powersets makes me drool.
Insomniac have always been comic book and super hero fans too, so if anyone can do the X-Men justice I'm sure it's them.
@PaperAlien The Dragon Age Veilguard review he did covers much the same ground. Its depressing that Wolverine seems to have alot of the same design philosophy littered through it.
Game patch 1.02:
@LiamCroft Apologies if you said this in your review or not as I have just started it while typing this
Would you suggest to wait and play it on a later date? Asking as next week also sees another game that I am anticipated in playing, and judging the reviews I've seen so far, it does seem disappointing (IGN & Gamespot).
Haven't seen Skill Up's review, but it did appear in my recommendations and honestly...I'm not a fan of super negative reviews
I've said it before and ill say it again. How did this basic ass game cost like 300 million to make? The gaming industry is in serious trouble if budgets for short linear games cost this kind of money and take this long to make. I mean is there any justification I am missing here?
@dwayne91 @PaperAlien
Oooh, yeah, SkillUp didn't pull his punches, did he? Very disappointing, and he's a reviewer with whom I align very often.
Revised my buying price based on that down to £35 or so.
@Shepherd_Tallon Yeah I'm excited about seeing the follow up to this. We know they are making a Venom game(probably) and another Spider-Man game which will sell like crazy and we assume they'll take the critiques from SM2 and Wolverine and make both games better.
We just need to wait and see how they improve from SM2 and Wolverine to the next level of their Marvel games. People also need to cut down on the negativity about them doing Marvel games. They are improving the formula in how they make them(Wolverine was just a tad different and limited) and we know Insomniac and can make top AAA games. Wolverine for them is just the stepping stone to something bigger(X-Men hopefully), it was never going to be like Spider-Man out the gate.
I do want another Ratchet & Clank & Rivet game though.
@TDHorizon Agreed, Insomniac seems to be staying in the same lane and mostly doing it well. Highly polished, fun action games. I don’t think that’s a bad thing. Sometime I actually just want an arcade experience.
Wolverine been my favourite since I started reading comics as a kid, so ill definitely be getting this. I dont think the 78 on metacritic is gona do much damage to casuals buying this
@LiamCroft I don't have any questions, sorry, but I wanted to say I thought it was a good review. Read like an 8, got an 8 at the end, what else do people want? And thank you for putting the 20 hours right at the beginning, it's a factor for myself and others. 👍
@SuperSilverback Totally agree. I think most people will see Wolverine kicking ass and most major sites giving it 7 or 8 and buy it. Casuals will have fun and Wolverine fans.
@AhmadSumadi
Ikr. The same IGN who gave the awesome God Hand a 3/10, Alien Isolation a 5.9/10, and Doom 2016 a 7.1/10. But somehow, now some people trust IGN scores lmao.
I love the fact this "review" doesn't mention the full hand holding this game does. You have a constant line to the exit. Every collectible and resource has a giant "look at me" sign with audio clues. This game was clearly made for 3 year old's.
I’m surprised you didn’t say nothing of new game plus 👀
@StrickenBiged I like his reviews usually but also once in a while he does give the odd review and seems to get hung up on things, like FF16 which I actually quite enjoyed. I’ll give Wolverine a spin, seems like something that’s not going to be a huge commitment.
@StrickenBiged Yeh he's one of the few Platform agnostic reviewers I trust, and is probably the most "well known" reviewer on the net, so for a devastating take down like his, ooft!
Was going to play this 1 day when it hits the bargain bin as I am not really a Marvel fan, but after watching skill ups review, dont think I will bother even if its free.
Some insane design decisions by Insomniac, who are usually a great developer. Wonder if they are all Marvel'd out at this point, cant really blame them.
RIP Sony and Playstation. It was a good run
I hadn’t yet preordered the game as I was waiting for reviews first. Now I see it sitting on a metacritic rating of 78 I’m in two minds on whether I should just go ahead and order it, or instead go for Dawnwalker, which has a 83 rating 🤔
Wait, every first party game this generation has been packed to the seams with accessibility options, like Ghost of Yotei, which allowed the player to tailor the experience they wanted. You mean I can't turn all the visual ***** off? What?
@QBGaming12 I'd love to see more Ratchet & Clank & Rivet too. I'm sure we will eventually. They wouldn't just introduce two new characters and then go awol on that one.
I get that the core fanbase want to see them off of Marvel games too, but to hear the Insomniac folks talk about it, they just love making comic book games 🤷
I've never watched skillup but I am curious as to why so many put his reviews on a pedestal. Not trying to be disparaging, like I said just curious.
77 on metacritic very disappointing for a game that had this much hype..
@naruball Clearly high budget, not necessarily good. Not everyone hating on this are anti-Sony shills, just like not everyone liking it are Sony shills.
Approachable is usually a polite word for primitive.
I wonder how much the hack effected the game's development. A lot of stuff might well have had to have been discarded or completely changed.
@Nightcrawler71 Dawnwalker I’m currently playing , if you’re not bothered by the timer and just explore it’s pretty awesome.
Nothing about this review makes the game sounds even a little bit fresh or inspired. Sounds like a very polished beat-em-up with a popular license grafted on.
When IGN, a site that gave MixTape a perfect 10, gives your game a 6, it's time to take a long hard look in the mirror, bub.
I'll buy it when it's 50 or 70% off
@Daleaf why would he care what you or anyone else thinks?
Sounds like it will be a blast but there are too many other games ahead of this one but I will definitely get it at some point.
Hmm, I was holding out my preorder until the end of the week... and reading and listening to various outlets and reviewers that I trust, yeah, it's a pass. If not for the egregious handholding I might've stuck with it, but I've gotten so tired of this generation of AAA games assuming that the player has the attention span and problem-solving capacity of a goldfish.
I'll do as I did with Spiderman 2 and play it when it lands in the Game Catalogue in a couple of years, the next month or so is so busy with releases that this just doesn't make the cut.
@VenomUK She got hit by the Sony stick probably, lol.
I’m really craving a highly polished, simple and straightforward old-school action game right now, which this sounds like it is but at 20 hours, I’m pretty disappointed to hear that the story is so lacking. That and memorable boss fights are the saving grace for this type of experience. I’m on the fence now.
As long as the gameplay is fun I'm in. Some of my favourite games lately have had weak story and that I'm not bothered about following. Doom dark ages, Ninja Garden 4, Saros and I would say Onimusha isn't the best. There's probably loads more. DMC 5 another one
Skill up does not recommend. Thats surprising tbh.
@StrickenBiged yea I don't always agree with what he likes about games but his dislikes are usually the same things I would find annoying. Wolverine is hard to argue with the things he pointed out.
So as good as let's say... Assassin's Creed Shadows, and a little better than Concord and Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League (both 7) according to this site.
@Llamageddon he's thorough and the negatives he lists on this one are going to be hard to argue against or ignore unless you just enjoy really simplified bad game design.
As expected for a Sony affiliated site... regarding the 8...
Most of other reviews talk about repetitive combat, poor variety, corridor like levels with annoying gps like indicators on direction that kills all the exploration sense.
Easily skip for me.
I want Sony PS4 era....
The review doesn’t read like the game really actually excels anywhere, it’s just good in some areas. A bad sign when you have to bust out the score descriptions because it doesn’t come out in the actual review’s writing.
@TheDarts That is what I am feeling too. Lately I just can't seem to justify $70 on a game.
I'm in my late 40's I have literally 100's of games in my collection many I never finished, or many I never played a lot of that I can just pull out and play. Not to mention 1000's of games that I can emulate, or the many many steam games that are a lot of fun and cheap.
A game like this, like Spiderman, in a year or two will be on sale for $35, it will also be patched and complete if they add anything.
I'm glad the game comes with an adventure line, I wouldn't want to get lost in a linear game.
@dwayne91 thanks for the response, I might have to check out his reviews for some of the upcoming games I'm interested in (I won't watch the wolverine one as I wasn't interested to begin with).
Hand holding doesn't bother me so much as it means my wife can probably enjoy the game too. My gaming priorities have shifted as I do enjoy sharing my hobby with her where possible. My 'hardcore' days are well behind me, lol.
I'm another Skill Up (and ACG) viewer as my two most trusted. I like Angry Joe too.
Skill Up is often called Shill Up for over-rating games. I've rarely seen him not recommend a game where it wasn't justified.
I've only disagreed with him where he has recommended games I didn't like.
He usually brings receipts and shows what is wrong, where publisher restrictions allow it of course. Angry Joe is also good at that. He backs it up by showing you.
Skill Up is notorious for detail.
Happy to play some more linear games tbh. I’ll get this at some point
@PuppetMaster Yes to all of that. Ever since Alien Isolation got bombed by McCafferty (he put it on hard and then complained throughout his review) I've not trusted them for any sort of review.
In addition, their headlines and articles are always rife with spelling and grammar errors, and that is coming from their own editors!
I don't patronize any site that can't get basic spelling and grammar correct. I guess that is a sign of younger generations testing lower than all the preceding generations. Awesome. They don't care that they look inept, ignorant, and incompetent. They must assume their readers are the same.
@Killionaire its not that i care, i just find it strange watching someone else play a game, as i said no disprespect to him he can do what he wants just not what i would do, and times have changed to when i was younger.
@Deadlyblack it doesnt matter what you do m8, as i said i just find it strange, just from a different era i supose. I just like playing games and not watching other ppl play
It's not for me, but I am more annoyed by "streamlining" than most.
I’ll pick it up in the 50% off bin.
@Dogbreath if you like that style, check out Mortisimal. Guy is just chill, and none of the culture war BS on his channel.
Eight, great. I'm happy for Insomniac either way, I did think it might be a nine, but it's all subjective and I like those Pros. I just need to free up the time to play it properly. Also the picture with the claw through the man's head, I wasn't ready for that. I'm still glad they are staying faithful to the violence, it's part of who and what he is. Or rather he's what they made him (the people behind the program) The invisible walls do sound a little annoying, I'll just see how it goes.
@Daleaf my friend one time remarked that he could not understand how I could watch someone else play a game. He was wearing an NFL jersey...
@Daleaf Granted I'm 32 and the guys that I watch are all in their upper 30's-40 lol, so it's not that big of a difference in an age gap.
@ArthurFan1998 I think it's a game worth playing through; it's a great time. However, if there's something else you're particularly excited about that it clashes with, then I don't think you're missing out on quite that much if you opt to wait on Wolverine.
Was going to get it day one, but my enthusiasm for the game has slowly disappeared the more I have seen.
The combat looks great if a little repetitive. But hand holding, invisible walls, boring story, extremely linear, and unfinished looking parts means I'll play on ps plus.
I do wonder with a $305 million production cost, plus marketing how many copies at full price they'll need to sell just to break even.
@Shepherd_Tallon Oh yeah I do think that they make another Ratchet & Clank game in the next few years(the mobile game thankfully isn't theirs lol).
I have no problem with them making Marvel games because they've shown that they have the chops to do it and do it at a high level. Wolverine is just a rough start of their X-Men journey which I assume and figure that they will greatly improve given the feedback/reviews they've seen(reasonable ones not the outlandish takes lol).
And yeah I agree with you about them enjoying making Marvel games, during the interviews and dev stuff they always seem to be beaming about it which is cool. Always fun to work on stuff/work with material you love.
I hope they go back to Ratchet and Clank games...those were fenomenal.
Enough of these cinematic driven story gamesof latest Sony. Ok Uncharted, ok the Last of us, but that is enough for my tastes.
Review scores from the gaming media mean nothing anymore. We all know it and so do they. You can predict the scores years before the game even releases.
The way many people are reacting to these reviews is almost as if this Wolverine game is Gollum bad or Redfall bad. I understand the many crap decisions PlayStation have been doing of late or linear games ain't for everyone or Marvel games ain't for everyone or it doesn't have punishing Elden Ring Dark Souls like combat for someone to drool over giving it a 10. Insomniac are not responsible for PlayStations decisions ending physical media or cancelling the Kojima game. Insomniac made it clear a while ago this will be a linear game and are obviously not known for having anything to do with soulslike combat. Insomniac Spiderman open world got criticised and now the opposite of open world linear gets criticised. Myself and nearly all of us haven't played Wolverine but I already know without playing it for myself that this Wolverine game will be nowhere near as bad as many are trying to make it out to be
I was never really excited for this game because I don't know anything about Wolverine and everything I've seen from it looks kinda boring. I'll get it at some point though, mainly because it's relatively short and I like slicing people up.
Can you turn off on-screen markers and the sense trails?
I honestly forgot Wolverine was even coming out. Hahaha!
I think I'll stick with Marvel Cosmic Invasion. Definitely more my cup of sprite based tea.
This is what I expected. A brawling game with simple combat, intense violence, and lacking narrative. Not that any of those are bad. I hope Wolverine fans enjoy it. It just isn't for me. Maybe I'll give it go on deep sale in a year or two. Regardless, I admire Insomniac and hope they do well with this one.
Hmmm sort of reminds me of Transformers Devastation - a solid 6 or 7, but if you liked your OG Transformers it was more like an 11. Unfortunately, I am not a Marvel fan, but no doubt this has an audience!
@naruball Im extremely pissed off with Sony just now but agree with your comment.
I preordered because Insomniac but if I could, I would refund my preorder. I think it looks worse than 2022 SM2. 15hrs is way too short for a 80€ game.
GTA6 will be my last preordered game I guess. You can’t even count on PS Studio titles these days
Got the Deluxe version pre-ordered and downloaded. Can't wait.
Looks cool. I was a massive Wolverine fan in 5th and 6th grade, but I stopped following as middle school progressed, sadly. That was the early 1990s.
This is a game that I will likely pick up in a year or two on a sale.
Now dropped to 77 on Metacritc.
@Vertere I’m not too bothered about the timer. Have heard that it just affects the story - whether you save your family or not - and apparently you can still carry on playing anyway after the 30 days. I generally prefer open worlds so will probably pick Dawnwalker over Wolverine. I think in Wolverine the combat will get repetitive. Also it doesn’t sound like it should have been a £70 game.
Day one. My Wolverine Dualsenses are arriving on monday so in good time before the game releases / unlocks.
A bad story AND unattractive characters? I'm so out
@Schonks Metawho? Ah that site that you can buy scores on, well none cares about them.
It’s official. Sony doesn’t have a GotY contender this year and is likely going to be skiing on Ubisoft Slopes for a while.
Now we wait to see if how badly internet smacks Sony for being just merely good. I can see people skipping this one with that Metascore.
@somnambulance I think it will be more great than good, but the wolverine dualsenses is the real GOTY for me. I love the look on them!
Sony will be back releasing their single player games on PC sooner than expected at this rate.
Sounds decent but not reaching high expectations and that's okay... I'll wait till December and see if I can pick up for £30-£40 on disc.
@Nightcrawler71 yeah Wolverine was as mediocre as expected so I got Dawnwalker instead.
I was a bit disappointed at the start as I couldn’t compete all the prologue quests before it ran out of time and forcibly cancelled them.
Hoping that doesn’t happen elsewhere in the game because I’ve made up my mind to do what I want and ignore the time.
Not regretting my choice of game. Characters and writing have been good. I’ve seen enough Wolverine footage to know it ain’t for me.
I think the developers knew Wolverine wouldn’t be well received outside of the usual allied, industry adjacent outlets, given their narratives and tactics over the past weeks.
@Zeke68 I’m just a commentator rather than someone that has interest in the game, but the cumulative release scores are weak for a Sony first party title. I suspect the game will be great if you think a Wolverine game is great and good if you don’t care about the character.
@Schonks well that changes everything, I might just give up on gaming completely 🙄
@Icey664 "A bad story AND unattractive characters? I'm so out"
Were you planning to sleep with the characters? 😳
@somnambulance I read the comics when I was really young, I'm 57 now so that was like eon's ago I have no problem with thecharacter and I like the idea of a brutal Wolverine game. I think I will like it, I can tell you more after I played it. I don't judge it before I played it like many does...
I had a feeling this would land around 7.5/10. As of now, it is 77 on Metacritic, which is particularly low for an Insomniac game and a Playsation 1st party game.
Poor story writing with reasonably fun action combat gameplay.
Insomniac needs to try something else beyond Marvel now, as it has gotten a bit stale.
It's fair to say Insomniac will be having a few sleepless nights.
@darylb24 I think the story got affected by the hacking of Insomniac and that leak, they tried to salvage what they could but I guess that put a dent in things overall. Just my guess. It can still be a fun game though.
@darylb24 Are you suggesting that Insomniac will be full of insomniacs?
@Zeke68 Insomniac’s Marvel games don’t do anything for me. Spider Man was a 7/10 to me, so I mean, that’s where I come from. I just really am more interested in the metrics with these games than anything else. This game, Marathon, Tokon, they’re more interesting in an abstract analysis perspective for me. I get it. I’m weird with that! 😂 These games are more discussion points rather than something I’ll play. I’m happy with my Capcom games this year instead. I’d be happy to read your thoughts when you play it though!
Well after seeing reviews i changed my mind on the digital preorder got Ominishi way of the sword instead.Will pick wolverine up on sale at some point.
@somnambulance Fair enough. As long as we find fun / great games to play I don't mind what anyone plays, as long as we get more games coming.
@Zeke68 Absolutely. Thank you for providing me positive internet discourse. We should hold a class on having decorum with disagreeing on things! 😄
@somnambulance Yup lol, too many "need to hate a game" instead of like whatever they like personally. It got way out of hand, we can dislike things or not agree but we can't tell others what to like / dislike. We should just accept that 99% here loves to game whatever they like. But too often if, for an example I say I look forward to this game (just an example as I said, could be Rise Of The Ronin - Push Square 6/10 Zeke 9/10) this hatewagon comes in because no disc no buy or whatever crap. And that always make me wonder: does these guys/girls even play or do they just make internet drama all day long. Noone here cares about reading 1000 comments about that when we should be talking games and so on. IF they want discs to stay, contact Sony and tell them, nothing else helps imho. Same with this Wolverine hate, it already got old.
@Zeke68 @somnambulance
As a reader im disappointed, I feel like you two should at least throw around a racial slur or two so the moderation team can put food on the table!
@species LMAO!! I better throw in a "maddafakka" here and there then
@For-Kier And Ghost of Yotei wasn't even $70. It came out before the price hike. It was $60, which I feel like was a more reasonable full price risk for consumers
Had a feeling this would be a "pick up on sale" game. I'm usually a day 1 for insomniac games but there was something quite off when seen in action.
Shame.
@dwayne91
Just watched it, and it's hilarious. They put a GPS, in a linear game. They are taking the handholding, too the extreme 🤣
wasn't that keen based on trailers, then the skillup review just killed any remaining interest. good thing, too many games to play anyway!
@Johnathan1987 Obviously not!
Good review. Score seems fair but I'll wait and see what the gamers here actually say about it as I trust their opinions more than the PS reviewers. I'm still not paying £70 for a game no matter how great it is.
Hmmm, I guess I'm waiting for a sale. Til then it's back to xmen origins wolverine.
@darylb24 .. with fun gameplay for several hours until it gets repetitive.
@species You’re right. We should probably get political for no reason to spice things up for the likes too!
@Zeke68 As someone that enjoys goofy games, we’re seeing totally eye to eye. To a T’s reviews broke my heart because I knew the studio was going to suffer from the low reviews when I knew I liked the game. That one sticks out like a sore thumb in my mind for some reason. And, hey, on the topic of Sony first party games, Concord was average but it wasn’t the bane of existence bad. People acted like a 6/10 game was a 2/10 for the fun of it. You know I could actually go for a 2/10 tier game once in a while though. There IS entertainment to be had in that too. 😂
@Matroska yes that’s true but most reputable sites like Eurogamer/DF, ign, gamespot etc are giving it 6/10
Glad you had fun, Liam. I can't wait!
The review here, coupled with the DF tech review I have just watched, are plenty proof for me - Day 1 purchase on Pre-order.
Review scores are a baseline only, to be used in conjunction with your own personal preferences.
@VenomUK
She looks like a department store mom.
I don’t know about these accusations of a smear campaign- there was a vocal drop in interest after the gameplay video released and that happened long before Sony cancelled Hideo’s game and before the disc-less announcement. It could very well be an average game that is getting more negative attention because of Sony’s current PR nightmare.
@LiamCroft
Enjoyed your review - between this and the DF review (the key points of which you had already covered), I have pre-ordered.
Out of interest, and without giving too many spoilers, how frequent / common are boss fights?
@Rich33 There are a handful of boss fights, but they're not very frequent or anything. Maybe five or so in the whole game?
@LiamCroft
Thank you. That is a shame - its probably not that easy to add in a huge number (due to characters / source material / story etc), but it sort of felt like Insomniac were leaning into at least trying to include more boss fights, based on SM2, and I thought they may go further here.
In regards to the conversation with Skill Up as I am currently watching his review. And man, I can see why he's not a fan.
I don't think he is saying it is as bad as some people seem to imply/think it is. However, I can 100% understand where he's coming from.
I would honestly suggest to watch it for context. I just hope there is an update that has an option mode for the hint system it has, as that is what the complaint comes down to. Even as someone who plays on Easy mode or does like using hints, the hints in the game do seem a bit too much.
Expected review score from a PS site, I truly understand. But honestly what happened to Insomiac? All of their PS5 games are great, except this one. They should make this game about X-men to have gameplay variety than to concentrate with Wolverine alone.
@Dorkthrone "What do you think this story would have needed to do to really impress you?"
I guess the answer is pretty obvious: good writing. Insomniac has been bad in that department for a while now. In fact, Spider-Man 2's writing was atrocious.
If you've played Red Dead Redemption 2, you'll know what good videogame writing looks like.
@IllusiveMan The most annoying part is that Sony seems to have no interest in having them make more Ratchet & Clank games even though Rift Apart was the best R&C game they've made in a long time. The game also left it open for several possibilities for new games, like Rivet getting her own game.
As much as I enjoy the Marvel games, they do seem to be going down in quality with each one. A R&C game every so often would still be much appreciated.
Based on the reviews it's even worse than I expected. Sony these days.... <sigh>
Watching gameplay and reading all these reviews. This game is a mindless button-masher that overstays its welcome.
The Arkham games never had this problem. The old Rocksteady team was one of a kind.
We should’ve gotten a Cyclops game instead of Wolverine, I mean I’m a Sony pony who acknowledges that we’re the master platform but I had to wish for this game’s downfall for our continued success.
@Dorkthrone they can't say it. At this point in time, almost everyone is frustrated with sony so this will affect the reviews and opinions. If the same game was released back in 2017, you would have seen much more excitement and higher review scores, imo
@Dan12836666 if you let peoples opinions influence if you like a game or not maybe you should start forming your own opinions just my 2 cents.
i’ll wait for the pc version then
Watched Skills Up's review and then read this review and this game is a massive skip for me. I'm a massive comics guy but sounds like all the issues from Spider-Man 2 are back and even worse, exacerbated by the linear structure
@KundaliniRising333 If you really expected Push Square to fail here why are you here? But anyway. Review sounded quite scathing after that intro. Surely it being a linear game means it being restrictive is kind of the point. But the negatives sound quite galling. I think I'll prefer Spiderman but I'm all in for blood and guts and something I can actually complete before GTA6 takes over my gaming life.
A spiderman reskin with uncanny valley characters. Hard pass
Sounds good to me, can't wait for Tuesday.
Thanks Liam 👍
Of course Liam would love this. 😂
@darylb24
"It's fair to say Insomniac will be having a few sleepless nights."
Ha, I see what you did there. Good one.
Skill Up review showed me everything I needed to see. Appreciate the second opinion and different perspective from Liam, but this one is not for me.
I don't mind linearity at all in itself. In fact, I find linear games refreshing. But can't handwaive the excessive signposting and simplistic combat in a game that also happens to be linear. For me, that's not a minor annoyance, that's a fundamental design failure.
I see that this game would really resonate with some people, but yeah, not my flavor of bubble gum.
@UnlimitedSevens whats a skill up?
@Toot1st
He's a fairly respected YouTube game reviewer who I find matches my personal taste pretty closely, most of the time. He's pretty fair and balanced I think. Check out the review, he does a really good job and illustrates his points well and without veering into outrage for outrage's sake if that makes sense.
You've got guns in America haven't you?
This is a game I would like to play eventually, but seems to be worth waiting maybe a year or two when Insomniac hopefully remove some of the hand holding aspects of the game.
I suspect some of the issues are too ingrained into the design of the game that it can't be changed but if they can make enough improvements I think it'll be worth my time.
Sony rapidly lost its touch in the PS5 era.
@Dorkthrone
The problem is that PlayStation fans expect a certain high-standard for a first-party PlayStation game which costs $70. It will be compared to God of War, The Last of Us, Ghost of Tsushima, Marvel's Spide-Man, Alan Wake 2, Resident Evil Requiem and other contemporary 3rd person action games.
In linear AAA games with a high cinematic production budget, the expectations are especially high for the story if the gameplay (combat and navigation) is fairly standard. The Wolverine's story might have been fine for a game released in the mid 2010s, but game stories improved since then and people expect more.
Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy is a similar game which released just a few days ago. It has a more cohesive, polished, and emotionally sophisticated script - at $ 60. When Sony is saying that experiences like Marvel's Wolverine are "only available on PlayStation" then they also need to make sure that those experiences are also better than other games.
@AhmadSumadi meaning it’s so bad they can’t even try to lie.
I mean I got a £30 off voucher, so I have this pre-ordered for £32.99, and as long at the combat is good (which it does seem so), I am sure I will get the money's worth.
I just hope that Insomniac can get out of developing just Marvel Games, 3 is enough, let them cook something else please.
Even IGN couldn't give this terrible Wolverine 'game' more than a 6/10, there's more gameplay and less yellow paint in Mixtape than in this £70 'experience'. Insomniac, what happened?
@UnlimitedSevens agree! he's probably the best and most honest reviewer out there, far more articulate, conscientious and trustworthy than most of the so-called industry sites and professional reviewers.
Imagine relying on reviews...😂😂😂😂😂😂
Watch on the 15th when fans get their hands on this game... They all gonna love it... Magazines aint been credible since the source gave lil Kim 5 mics.
I'm an X-Men fan so I'm tempted to give this a shot eventually, but it's likely going to be sat on the wishlist for a while. I get the feeling that the linear/simplistic nature of the game would have been a little easier to forgive if this had been an X-Men game rather than a Wolverine game. Swapping out the character every so often with different mechanics and more movement in the plot could have been a big plus. Oh well.
@Serialsid Marvel probably got a lot for the license of that money
Unhinged. Do not look to this website for recommendations on how to spend your money.
To me if feels like I've basically play it already with X-Men Wolverine Origins back on the PS3
@Dorkthrone
"What is it you expect a video game narrative to actually do to impress you? Where is it not taking you?"
You're acting like it's the plots people have a problem with. It's the questionable characterization, the terrible dialogue, the stale "humor" and the redundant tropes that need to be fixed.
Everything has become same-y Reddit sludge and it seems to be getting worse before it gets better, probably because that's the only type of material an LLM can reliably produce.
Honk shoo. Gonna be skipping this one.
@Daleaf I get this except for one game, for some reason AOE II is super fun to watch. A lot less stressful than it can feel to play.
@naruball "The hate for anything and everything Sony is reaching levels that shouldn't even be possible."
Let's be fair here. We do expect first-party exclusives to be a cut above the rest. Not the case with this one.
Also, Insomniac's output has been clearly declining in quality since 2018's Spider-Man.
Put that together with the anemic Sony's overall output over the past few years and there's legitimate reason for concern.
These are pretty undeniable facts that should not get entangled with the cringy anti-Sony campaign.
I'm not here to criticize but this is another example that bolsters my feelings that Sony have just lost that something that makes them great, I remember when Spider-Man was announced and I got it for PlayStation 4 Pro that sensation just hasn't been there this generation.
@wildcat_kickz
“The older I get, the more I appreciate linear games.”
Totally agree. Give me a solid story without all the fluff. I’ve got time for—maybe—one open world per year. I’ll save that for Red Dead 2-or Zelda-level masterpieces. Even then, those take me years to truly “finish.”
I’m looking forward to something like this. Action. Pause. Sleep. Come back tomorrow.
@Silenos
Yeah, his reviews have saved me from some bad purchases. I think it all registered for me with Veilguard tbh, which was widely celebrated by mainstream reviews. I was about to get it, then I watched the Skill Up review, and I frankly found it hard to believe the issues he raised were not brought up nearly anywhere else. And in retrospect, they were glaringly obvious issues which eventually dominated the entire conversation about that game, and lasted well past the initial spurt of positivity.
It dawned on me my interests are completely unaligned with the modern gaming press. I don't pretend there is any malign influence or "agenda" with mainstream reviews for the most part, it just became clear to me I'm just not the intended audience. For example, what Liam here looks for in a game is completely incompatible with what I look for.
We joke about video game reviewers not being good at games / rushing through / etc. and I think that's not exactly true, but when they play games for a job instead of for fun, I feel like that moves the needle of how they assess a game over time. Hence the disconnect. Ease of play and accessibility are unduly emphasized for people playing games on a strict time crunch. Actually completely understandable.
And I suppose that's alright. Different strokes, different folks. Probably best to just find a specific reviewer you gel with and stick to their assessments if you are really making purchase decisions off someone else's opinions.
Some gaming mags back in the day had this cool idea where three separate reviewers would review a game, and they would average their separate scores. I think PSM did that? Unsurprisingly, some games had some crazy variance in scores through this method, based on the individual. And that was actually fun to see.
Probably not feasible though to have three people review the same game. But hey, at least it wouldn't just be one reviewer taking all the heat on a review! Anyways, that's my two cent rant.
Out of 67 critic reviews on OpenCritic, only 8 rated it lower than a 7. 44 scored it at an 8 or higher. So 88.1% rated it 7.0 or higher & only 11.9% rated it 6.9 or lower. 98.5% rated it 6.0 or higher. Only ONE of the 67 reviews scored it lower than a 6. ONE. Yeah, sounds like complete trash of a game. 🙄
@naruball the problem with this one is it was supposed to be even better than the Spider-Man games. I'm gonna play it shortly after launch, though not being 8.5+ out of 10 is quite something asking $70 USD right after yelling to the world no more discs for future games. Being only 20-25 hours to completely platinum the game without hardly any replay value? Sony isn't selling the all digital future with this release.
........ btw my game is already on its way, so I'll be able to play it this weekend.
@AhmadSumadi IGN also gave the film "Onslaught" a 9/10, and that movie straight up had no climactic fight.
Enjoy your average seventy pound exclusives PlayStation 'fans'
Looks like a lot of fun but I’ll probably wait a while until I can get it on sale
@UnlimitedSevens brilliant feedback and as time is limited for us adults/parents, simply playing and having fun is what counts. Game on 👾🕹️👍🏻
@thebizniznizbiz that’s probably what they’re gonna do. Is that gonna annoy you?
@thebizniznizbiz So an almost 8/10 is average? Gtfo. It's sitting at a 79/100 on OpenCritic. "Average", my ass. Only one of the 79 reviews gave it lower then a 6. ONE.
@Almost_Ghostly good comments and the game looks fun! One day when my kids return my PS5 they pinched, I’ll get to enjoy the wolverine. Gotta say, the Marvel Cosmic Invasion is ace playing as Wolverine 😎
As far as Uncharted with Ratchet 2 for the 'vehicle segment' in the gameplay footage prior. I like linear games, I found Spiderman 2018+ very boring, God of War very boring and many others. I just dropped off them. Horizon to me world wise interests me, but gameplay wise bored me.
Only Sunset Overdrive, Gravity Rush and Infamous Second Sun appealed to me of open worlds, that's it. I play linear games, I buy and learn genres/gameplay mechanics, even story driven genres like FMV games enjoying and writing wikis for, if that doesn't so I can't get behind story even though a gameplay type, I don't know what is.
But yeah this game probably has the presentation people are looking for, but gameplay/story, who knows.
Fair blood effects, fair costumes, fair plot. Not much to the characters (other then to be there but no gameplay benefits just 'be there on screen because dialogue reasons, but if they were they'd just be removing parts of the world, not being more beneficial, I don't care whether licensed characters or not, gameplay is gameplay potential underused regardless) by the looks of things, not much claw interactivity for level design navigation and just a combat with ok linear layouts it seems 'fine'.
Will it cover a lot of Wolverine as a character, fair story, fair costumes and more, sure, but gameplay wise it looked been there done that (in some good ways in some bad) and level design was basic to navigate which isn't very exciting but whatever.
I'd say I'd go for the new Plague Tale over this and even then I found it's combat parry system a joke, but the puzzles and story telling seem fair. But I am saying 'I'd go for' not that I am. Sure those around me are playing it and the footage/trailers looked good. But even Warlock had fair ideas but could be bad, who knows and i hate RPGs (unless a decent dungeon cralwer of old or tactics games, but how they are done differs). Turn based it varies and real time (both usually) are busy work quests/worlds I never find fun, just boring to navigate, dialogue, bland quests, etc.
Action adventure games have varied over the years and more simple ones aren't 'bad' just make the level design or gear interesting. If not well not worth my time.
Uncharted paced puzzles, combat and platforming despite being a treasure hunter with not much gear unless Golden Abyss. So sure. It can work and be fun, but not all are that way of balance and a general character.
So to me I'm not very impressed with many modern games but i haven't for the past few years not buying many AAA at all and the past decade or more been unimpressed with 'flashy' but superficial gameplay, just 'presentation and story'. So basically boring games.
Easy to not spend money on them then.
This is the kind of game I could get behind, but it just doesn't have much gameplay compelling. The rest is fair to have, but eh.
It's like Midnight Suns could have been good but was so basic and boring no amount of Marvel stuff to it would save a repetitive basic tactics game that oversimplified. Even then XCOM clone tactics games the west likes to copy aren't very appealing and the east has done better with them cutting elements I hate in western ones (unless Mario Rabbids which was good). No idea if Rainbow Six's new one is good, not played the 3DS Tom Clancy tactics game or many others.
Still.
@Art_Vandelay To me it has since 2013, but I liked Sunset Overdrive and I prefer it's ideas regardless of their first open world and hated 2016 Ratchet (it had good points but a lot bad) and I hated Spiderman 2018 so to me my preference is more so 2015. Song of the Deep was good but only by so much. But sure I get it many would say 2018 Spiderman and Miles Morales had it's moments of things it fixed over 2018 so who knows what people were looking for there when plenty of Far Crys and other games had small stand alone. Infamous First Light even. But depends who wanted 'big scale' and trashes the smaller scale ones I guess. I think they are fine sometimes.
But I'm the one that doesn't mind when Polyphony did the small scale games as well so I have that small scale appreciation sometimes. Among few others that have done them.
@TrollOfWar What are people expecting then for story, gameplay, presentation? I've played many 2010s games and many with abilities there are gone by PS4 era, so to me I find it backwards when large scale worlds and gameplay possibilities got dumbed down and that really annoyed me. Been collecting and exploring genres since 2017 so to me I went what happened? Accessibility or casualifying, and only hardcore get access to 'stats' or not even optional areas just the whole game is casualified, sounds kind of disappointing really the more I see it.
Ghost of Tsushima's combat had fair ideas. The Yotei flashbacks I was like eh and not a flashback 'world' but I can see why they did it and it didn't need to be a Link to the Past light/dark world. I thought it would be cool but I retracted that as they made fair responses as to why they didn't and only used the flashbacks for particular purposes. Even if would have been a fair idea.
Presentation/story and that's it. Kind of makes games really limiting and when seeing videos where casuals go oh I thought you could do more yeah but even less then you could a decade ago as well yes. XD But some paths are still 'confusing what to do' no matter how oversimplified a game is. I have family that are gamers, and some that aren't and the ones that aren't still get lost. So I don't think companies are really solving much of anything. PS3 or PS5 eras.
The same 'I see an opening to escape in the intro' in Last of Us 1, can still be the same people have in any PS5 game AAA, AA, whatever the case of linear games. XD I just find it hilarious I see it, other players may, devs don't.
To me my gameplay preferences and genre exploration has been brewing since 2017 and still going today. Story? What are people wanting? Gameplay has been oversimplified or over complicated with 'stats' then with with gameplay abilities, skill trees then with items in the world. So to me what are people after then?
Artstyles? Character models? What do people want?
I mean it's like when I look back at people going oh GT4 had bad car sounds yeah and it used how much of the PS2 double layer disks but no one looked at the size limits of them and 700 cars. So to me I can't take the 'oh high quality' mentality over the limitations or other goals.
I think Wolverine would be ok but yeah even the vehicle segment was very Ratchet 2 in 2003 to Uncharted of 2010s.
Not much claw or other interactivity in level design, even God of War for 2000s or many other games adult or family friendly did that but isn't as much a thing in some games. Whether combat moves/executions, using abilities in the world for all sorts to climb, throw objects, 'get creative' which they just don't.
Sure it's Marvel so I get it lore/character limits to fit into, but even many other games just 'don't' like how far can humans, or animals walking on 2 legs get of 'too far' and acrobatic humans or animals able to have all sorts of abilities be 'too far' as the animations, programming and more effort is just so simplified and bland or 'not believable' aka they are lazy devs, it's not budget it's pure laziness.
So devs that make games 'suitable' for audiences or 'look good and artists/animators' still over spend time on perfection. The games seem to still be a joke in some areas really.
I'll wait a bit before buying. I just have too many games in the backlog and a few of them are JRPGS.
Removed - inappropriate
@SuntannedDuck2 It's a bit difficult to read through your opinion, but I think I agree with you. From what I've seen and read, the game is dumbed down to such a level that it's insulting to the player.
People want a story which resonates and sticks with them even after finishing the game. Something like Alan Wake, Metal Gear Solid, The Walking Dead, Citizen Sleeper, The Last of Us or Final Fantasy 7.
And if the story is not good, then at least the gameplay should be engaging enough for 10-15 hours (like with Ninja Gaiden, Vanquished, Resident Evil 4, Devil May Cry, etc.). The gameplay needs to have some depth and mastery.
Fart my gas?!? On today of all days?
Any chance of changing that headline since you lambasted it in the review?
I'll wait until it's on PlayStation+
Game is fun. Possibly not $70 fun, depending on how much the hand holding annoys you. But it's fun.
I kinda miss when games were fun, so I say it's a win.
Also kinda sad that people think a 7 or an 8 score for a game means it sucks. That's really unfortunate. But hey, people will spend their money the way they want, and these reviews will ensure many of them never give it a chance.
Side note: one of my favorite games of all time was rated a 1 by Gamestop magazine back in the day. It was Way of the Samurai, and I still tell stories about that game to this day.
I mean, this is not that at all, but my point is that reviews don't necessarily speak to your potential enjoyment of a thing, they just set vague expectations.
@thebizniznizbiz
I very much am, thank you. You're so sweet!
@LiamCroft to save some face on this review, please comment on the issues that have been documented pertaining to the (now famous) motorcycle chase where you survive no matter what. It’s also apparent in other parts of the game. That’s a deal breaker right? If not, please clarify so we know that type of hand holding in games is your preference. Which is fine, but it’s just not ok for a lot of gamers.
@naruball it really is a 4/10.
@symmetrian you are correct, reviews are one persons opinion. but i like to follow a few reviewers who rate games similar to what i would and then i know we have similar likes/dislikes. I think wolverine, haven't played it, but based on what i've watched and a few reviewers opinions that i follow, is probably a decent game and you nailed it, probably better on sale.
I enjoyed poorly rated games like Days Gone and The Order 1886 amongst others.
@HairyBizRat
Healthy way to decide what to try, I think. I was VERY put off by reviews for Wolverine, but then my very first comic book I purchased when I was about 12 years old was a trade paperback collection of Frank Miller's Wolverine run, and it made me a fan for life. No way I'm not playing a Wolverine game.
But yeah, in my experience, it would have been a fantastic $50 game.
The Order 1886 was done so dirty. I would have LOVED to see that become an actual franchise.
I thought this was a site i could trust. But guess i was wrong. Looks like you guys got paid off for your review. I rather play wolverine on the ps3. Than touch this. From what i saw people playing this game. Where PSW when you need them.
Push Square is one of the outlets that got the review right. It's not a perfect game, but I platinumed Wolverine and enjoyed the whole thing. It is a quality, well-made game.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...