Sony and PlayStation Studios are often criticised for their "samey" video games. The argument goes that titles like God of War, The Last of Us: Part II, and Ghost of Tsushima — three defining exclusives of the PS4 generation — are all too similar to one another. However, we've never really understood this mindset. Yes, they're all third-person action games, but anyone who's played them can surely see that they each strive for very different stories, gameplay, and atmospheres. We reckon that it's a bit of a reductive argument to make.
And it seems as though PlayStation Studios head Hermen Hulst agrees. Speaking to Games Industry, Hulst states that he wants to prioritise games that are "distinct and diverse".
"I am very interested in creating a diverse slate of titles," says Hulst. "Actually, the shape or form that they come in are less interesting to me than the fact that they are differentiated, diverse, and distinctive."
"I think that the games that we make are as distinct and diverse as they can be," he comments. "From Sackboy to Astro Bot to Dreams to these kind of games that you're referring to, like The Last of Us Part 2 and Ghost of Tsushima. And you can bet that we will carry on making these games, because they are the heart and soul of what we do here at PlayStation Studios. But at the same time, we are just as committed to making these quality experiences as we are to experimentation and to coming up with fresh ideas."
Hulst's comments may be something of a response to recent reports that Sony is only interested in making and publishing safe blockbusters — games that it knows will sell especially well without having to take creative risks. But as we've already discussed in a dedicated Soapbox, we don't think this supposed obsession with PS5 blockbusters aligns with reality.
Hulst goes on to talk about how passionate and ambitious teams of developers are the lifeblood of PlayStation. "We tend to work with teams that do have something in common, which is that ambition that the Firewalk team has," referencing Sony's newly announced partnership with said studio.
"But also the fact that [Firewalk] is a very strong, autonomous and, I would say, fiercely daring team... culturally, that's a really good match. So I seek those factors before I go into narrowing it down to genres or gameplay modes." Hurst reiterates: "It is more about the experience being differentiated and unique."
[source gamesindustry.biz]
Comments 53
Excellent, gamepass is getting better and better...😉
This entire week is basically "Sony's PR Course Correction Triathalon"
They're literally doing everything to make people forget about that Bloomberg article lmao
Of course, seeing is believing at the end of the day
Please bring Gravity Rush back
Sony is killing it on their backtracking game
Talk is cheap. When I see what the PS5 exclusives library looks like after a couple of years, then I'll decide whether or not to believe it.
Man, that’s a long ass headline 😂
And there it is.
I think insomniac games will play a huge part in this, after ratchet ps5 I hope they make new resistance (first person shooter) for ps5. And maybe sony should contact claphanz for new ps5 golf games and level5 for new jrpg, that will be nice. Oh, and remake wild arms 1 and 2 with beautiful 2D graphics
The "samey" argument is probably the dumbest thing I've heard. That's like saying id is too samey cause all they make are FPS's.
Sounds like a lot of damage control is going on today.
I'd be happy with more AA games. It seems like a majority of games are either huge AAA games or indie games. I really like Sony's AAA games but they take longer and longer to produce. I'd like the AA games to play in the mean time.
@TheFrenchiestFry
Should have read you first. ;0
@charbtronic I don't see how this is a backtrack? That Bloomberg article wasn't put out by Sony it was just a report by someone who as much as they are an insider won't ever have the full picture. This can't really be backtracking if Sony haven't ever come out and said "We only want to make blockbusters"
@TheFrenchiestFry Returnal is a great first example of that Bloomberg article not really painting an entirely accurate picture in my opinion.
Especially seeing as we now know the game is really good.
And Nintendo games look a like itself.i dont mind aaa games.but i do wish sony will bring back sly cooper.give me a sly cooper collection.word up son
Most games are samey because theres only so many genres. They all borrow bits from somewhere, some more than others. They can still be good and, If a games good, well, thats enough for me.
@get2sammyb I'm just here for your "I told you so" but apparently you're a bigger man than I.
where's project awakening?
where's that one man devil may cry ish game?
People say "samey" because the majority of the things that did release was all open world games. Did they all play different? absolutely but when you look back, they vast majority was flat out open world games.
The same could literally be said of the other platforms though. If you want a certain experience, just go for the platform that actually has it.
So long as the devs are doing what THEY want, this isn't a problem.
PlayStation has always been dedicated to pushing the medium forward in diverse ways and easily takes more risks than any other platform. Hope it continues.
If this is true then they have to accept that some games will not sell as well as others and they need to consider that all their projects as a whole should support each other. Obviously, if a game is a real stinker then that's a different matter.
they always have been diverse in gaming like people just say stuff now & pretend it is reality.
I think pretty much sony calmed everything that has happened to them since sony japan closing, didn't they?
Now state of play please.
Hugh those 'reports' were debunked as blown out of proportion by the famous author himself so maybe stop bringing that up.
@LordSteev Damage controlling the perceived damaged narrative.
Sony’s lineup has always been very varied tbh ...it’s just sad they needed to point it out after the last weeks: they launched with Demon’s Souls and Astrobot as the first ps5 exclusives, c’mon!
That said I wouldn’t oppose a triple A JRPG from Sony, you know, just to prove a point or two
@playstation1995 I never played sly. Are they as good as ratchet and Jak and Dax?
Guess Playstation is going on Jason Schrieir's Twitter block list.
Oh wow. PushSquare crowd is though.
No news it's outrage time but when we get news it's damage control or whatever to downplay.
Jeez people
@Royalblues It turns out portraying the human struggle interlaced with great gameplay is the culprit here. So sue them.
@KayOL77 Definitely personally the Sly series is my favourite of the 3 ^__^
@Keyblade-Dan is there a sly collection on PS3? I need to get me a PS3. 🤔
It's nice to know that Sony sometimes knows when things have gone too far in the negative direction. Before Monday it really felt like Sony were going full speed in the 2013 Don Mattrick XB1 direction.
Unfortunately these backtracks were too late to save Japan Studio though.
It's almost as if they are saying Sony games are to good you need to stop doing it. NO Thanks keep up the great work Sony I Love it!
@KayOL77. Ratchet and clank is my favorite follow by sly cooper and jak and daxter.word up son
@KayOL77 if you have access to PSnow the whole collection is on there
PS5 sly cooper revealed...
@KayOL77 Yes there is a Sly collection for the PS3 ^__^
@Royalblues What seems to be happening in general that a story of a dad and child is becoming sickening?
@playstation1995 I love ratchet and I platted first jak. So if sly is up there I’ll definitely give it a go 🤣
@BamBamBaklava89 I have psnow but I’m sure these games will belt along at 60fps on native hardware. Ps5 has really spoilt me for 60fps goodness 🤣
@JohnKarnes Sony’s games are (compared to the competition) too good. It is a problem, but I’m not entirely convinced it’s Sony’s. 🤣
@KayOL77. Sly cooper is like a platformer version of uncharted Nathan drake.his jokes and charm and his a thief just like nathan.and you got your friend murray and bentley helping you.amazing games.word up son
@playstation1995 That does sound like a match made in heaven 🤣. I don’t know why I never gravitated toward it.
@KayOL77 It’s just what they keep giving us. This narrative Hollywood crap.
@Nalverus The Last of Us and the Uncharted Games are linear experiences, God Of War is very lite metroidvania at best, Bloodborne is Soulsborne game, The Last Guardian is linear, the only, Ratchet and Clank was linear, Days Gone, Horizon Zero Dawn, Ghost of Tsushima and Spider-Man were open world but it's far from the majority. On Ps5 we've got a 3D platformer (Sackboy), a Rogue like (Returnal), a Souls Game (Demon's Souls), etc etc I do not think it is fair to say that the majority of Sony's output has been open world games
Sony has a new AAA exclusive coming out in a week. It's getting a lot of praise in early previews of the review code. They just announced in the last month, 4 or 5 new exclusive titles being developed. Meanwhile, gamepass is good, but overrated like i have never seen. I have it and a Series X. MS has not made or shown off one next gen game. Not one. Everyone is up in arms about them shutting down part of Sony Japan, yet barely anyone bought any Sony Japan games.
@KayOL77 - Sly Cooper is a platformer with Collect-a-thon elements but the levels in the first game are mostly linear with some occasional variety in challenges. Sly 2 & Sly 3 totally switch up the formula (For the better IMO), each level is now Open World and you complete missions, with each level concluding with a Grand Heist of some kind, often resulting in a Boss Fight with that Level's main antagonist, each antagonist also plays a big role in the overarching story (Well not so much Sly 3 but Sly 2). You can pickpocket enemies for loot to buy new moves, collect Clue Bottles to unlock a secret move, you have multiple playable characters; Murray being the Muscle & Bentley being the Brains (Sly 3 adds 4 new Playable Characters), the dialogue & jokes are top-notch, and all three games have pretty good stories and variety of missions.
If you like Ratchet & Clank and Jak & Daxter, you'll most likely enjoy Sly Cooper as well, though I will say this; the first game kind of suffers from what Ratchet & Clank and Jak & Daxter suffer from, by which I mean the first game is IMO the weakest because of how much improved the sequels are, still good games though.
@Coltaine22 - Agreed but everyone gives them a pass solely because of GamePass, nothing wrong with GamePass of course, just that people accept it as being enough (Which maybe it is if you're new to gaming). I mean 20+ Studios and STILL the XSX/XSS hasn't got a new First-Party game from any of them? While I agree new games take time to make, I recall Sony getting a lot of flak for their 'sparse' offerings from 2013 - 2015 with the PS4, but now that the roles are reversed, people don't want to acknowledge the sparse offerings of First-Party games from Xbox, it's these type of double standards that drive me up the wall.
@Royalblues besides The Last of Us and God of War 2018 what other sad dad games can you name that Sony has made? what other sad dad games in general can you name? I don't think there's enough notable sad dad games out there for it to be a genre in itself I think that's an over-exaggerated criticism
@BambooBushido Buzzwords like "sad Dad" are just used to push a negative narrative. Why else would anyone call game of the year multi million copy games "sad Dad". All the while most PlayStation fan are very much looking forward to the Next God of War!!
Tell that to Days Gone and Gravity Rush
@Coltaine22 Japan Studio + Clap Hanz = Everybody's Golf. I think that sold a few on multiple generations...
In the meantime Clap Hanz have moved onto Apple Arcade, I suspect due to Sony's actions.
Hi there fellow gamers.
Like some have already mentioned, the PS line up is vast with different kinds of games. Quantity, variety and quality, at least in my oppinion.
Games like Final Fantasy VII Remake, The Last of Us Part 2, Dreams, Sackboy: A Big Adventure, Horizon: Zero Dawn,
Demon´s Souls, Astro´s Playroom, Gran Turismo 7, Rachet and Clank: Rift Appart, Returnal. The list goes on and on.
And I cannot wait for the last three examples I just gave, as well as Deathloop, Forspoken and kena: Bridge of Spirits to name a few.
Soooooo yeah. What exactly people are complaining again? 😉
Cheers, stay safe folks and happy gaming to us all
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...