Forums

Topic: Films The Critics Hated...

Posts 1 to 20 of 26

hypnotoad

...but you loved.

For me, Alien 3.

Your turn.

hypnotoad

hypnotoad

Added to my op, I thought it was a vastly underrated film, not worthy of Fincher turning his back on it.
And RIP Brian Glover.

[Edited by hypnotoad]

hypnotoad

nessisonett

90s Adam Sandler movies, Nic Cage action movies, quite a lot actually. My pick has to go to The Lake House, an incredibly sappy movie with Keanu Reeves and Sandra Bullock which apparently has 35% on Rotten Tomatoes. It isn’t good but I quite like it.

Plumbing’s just Lego innit. Water Lego.

Trans rights are human rights.

hypnotoad

Dredd.

Not that Stallone abortion but the 2012 version.

How this wasn't a major hit... I'll never know.

hypnotoad

hypnotoad

@Jimmer-jammer You'll love it, mate. One particular scene too.
And it has the ever brilliant Brad Dourif.

[Edited by hypnotoad]

hypnotoad

nessisonett

@Jimmer-jammer Happy Gilmore, Billy Madison and Mr Deeds are classics. The rest… not so much.

Plumbing’s just Lego innit. Water Lego.

Trans rights are human rights.

nessisonett

@Jimmer-jammer Yeah, I think the only one from that slightly later time period that I actually enjoyed was probably 50 First Dates. Mostly because him and Drew Barrymore are great together. I also somehow missed out The Wedding Singer which is also a classic!

Plumbing’s just Lego innit. Water Lego.

Trans rights are human rights.

Ralizah

Transcendence. Movie got panned hard, but most of the reviewers seemed like they failed to understand it to begin with.

Escape Room. The premise is, admittedly, pretty dumb when you find out what's going on, but I found it to be fairly engaging and effective. Looking forward to seeing the sequel soon.

The Majestic was fantastic, but critics didn't like it for some reason.

Modern classic Japanese indie horror film Suicide Club apparently wasn't rated very highly either. What the hell!

And yeah, Alien 3 is great. The last actively good movie in that franchise.

I'm sure there are a lot of others, but those are what come to mind.

@hypnotoad lol Never seen Dredd, but the Stallone one is one of my favorite bad movies. I watch it every time I come across it on TV. I won't list it with the others, though. I recognize it's a terrible film.

[Edited by Ralizah]

Currently Playing: Metroid Prime 4: Beyond (NS2); Corpse Factory (PC)

PSN: Ralizah

graymamba

@hypnotoad yeah Exorcist 3 was class!

Fight Club was initially panned by critics (particularly Roger Ebert), one of the best films of all time!

Temet Nosce

Divergent95

The most iconic one is definitely The Butterfly Effect.
The rest follow:

  • Venom
  • X-Men Apocalypse
  • Wonder Woman 1984
  • Alien 3 + 4 aka Resurrection
  • AVP
  • Event Horizon etc.

Divergent95

PSN: DivergentGuyy

hypnotoad

Henry:Portrait Of A Serial Killer.

Panned on its release but as time went by, seen as a horror classic.

hypnotoad

PSVR_lover

Blade Runner was not well liked by critics origonaly. But over time, it was recognized as a true classic.

The PSVR is the best VR system on the market today.

JohnnyShoulder

@PSVR_lover Funny, I was just thinking of that! Although I've kinda gone in reverse and the more I see it the less I like it.

Life is more fun when you help people succeed, instead of wishing them to fail.

Better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak and remove all doubt.

PSN: JohnnyShoulder

hypnotoad

The Thing.
Slated by the moron critics but one of my fave films of all time.
John Carpenter at his finest.

hypnotoad

nessisonett

@Kidfried I love that Ebert just went by his own opinion though. He loved a lot of ‘bad’ movies and so gave them glowing reviews, same as he gave ‘good’ movies middling reviews. They’re always well-written enough that you can understand why he gave movies the rating he did as well. Especially the Fight Club review that echoes a lot of my own thoughts on the movie.

Plumbing’s just Lego innit. Water Lego.

Trans rights are human rights.

johncalmc

Mine is basically just '80s and '90s action movies because I have a special love for them.

Die Hard With A Vengeance. I love this movie and think it's legit nearly as good as the first Die Hard. It's a proper '90s action movie and I have no idea why critics were lukewarm on it.

Independence Day. This is an all time classic in gung ho American nonsense. I love it. The President gets in a fighter jet and starts shooting down alien ships. And that's like half way through. How can this not be like a 100% on Rottentomatoes?

Con Air. Nic Cage ridiculousness + John Malkovich + Ving Rhames + Steve Buscemi = glory.

Out For Justice. Steven Segal walks into a bar to get information on a lunatic murderer he needs to catch. People don't want to given him information. So Steven Segal flattens everyone. Then he walks to another bar and repeats. This is basically the whole film. Also he's called Gino Felino in it.

Robin Hood Prince of Thieves. Alan Rickman is the Sheriff of Nottingham and steals every scene he's in by being absolutely ridiculous. Plus for bonus points you can practically see the moment when Kevin Costner just couldn't even be bothered to try and do an English accent any more.

Universal Soldier. Jean Claude Van Damme is a Vietnam soldier who is killed in battle when his commanding office Dolph Lundgren goes rogue and murders the squad. Then scientists bring him back to life using science. But they also bring Dolph Lundgren back. And then they end up fighting in the future or like the present. Except it was the '90s so it's the past now. I don't know.

johncalmc

Bluesky: johndoesntdance.bsky.social

nessisonett

@johncalmc Con Air’s just a good movie, I don’t get how anybody could not enjoy it. Nic Cage’s dreadful Southern accent is hilarious as well. Untitled

[Edited by nessisonett]

Plumbing’s just Lego innit. Water Lego.

Trans rights are human rights.

ralphdibny

The remake of Ghostbusters. Admittedly I watched it many years after the hype/hate died down but it wasn't nearly as bad as everyone said it was.

Otherwise most of my suggestions have already been said and tbh I didn't realise some of these films were poorly received. Die Hard 3 is awesome. Alien 3 is decent, it's a bit like what Chronicles of Riddick is to the original Pitch Black. Except CoR is trash. I love Fight Club and Universal Soldier.

I don't really rate the first Blade Runner but I think the second one is genuinely amazing. It's one of my favourite modern sci fi films along with The Martian and Interstellar.

This topic has been archived, no further posts can be added.