
Platinum Trophy #2: The Witness
Date Earned: 21st February 2016
Dopamine Index:
Something I've only just thought of: I never earned a single platinum Trophy before I started writing for Push Square. It was only after I became involved with this website that my interest in Trophies started to really take hold.
Fun fact: The Witness was the 12th game I ever reviewed, which isn't a particularly significant number, but putting things into some sort of perspective, I'm approaching 400 as I write this. That feels mad.
Anyway, this game remains extremely memorable for me. I loved every second of it — even the abstract story stuff and those esoteric monologues you could listen to. Everything, from the setting to the design of the puzzles and the strange atmosphere across the island, built up this evocative sense of place and mystery that I found irresistible.
I really love The Witness (there's a reason it's my avatar on the site), and I sometimes think about playing it all over again. Replaying games is something I've largely left behind, but I definitely wouldn't mind relearning all this puzzler's strange rules.
I actually played more of this game than I needed to, and that was in order to complete the Trophy list. Each major area of the island ends with you activating a laser aimed at the summit of a mountain, and doing so unlocks a Trophy for each one — but you don't need to do them all to progress to the game's ending.
Fortunately for me, I wanted to see and do as much as I could. I was truly enamoured with the way the game wordlessly teaches you how to solve it, and wanted to learn everything I could by playing as many of those line puzzles as I could handle.
So, working towards the platinum was pretty natural, but as anyone who's delved deep into The Witness will know, there's a challenge that acts as a sort of finale, one that really tests your knowledge of every puzzle mechanic.
It's a gauntlet of puzzles you have to complete within a strict time limit, and it's tough. You don't even get an on-screen timer telling you how long you have left, but you'll get a feel for it thanks to the music.
Classical pieces Anitra's Dance and In the Hall of the Mountain King play one after the other, and I quickly learned to judge my own performance in the challenge based on how far through the music I was.
This music is now so intrinsically linked to The Witness in my head that, as I write this, I can hear it playing in my mind's... ear? Is that a thing? A mind's ear?
I don't know how many attempts I had to make before I finally conquered the challenge, but I'm sort of glad of that. The main thing is, I did it, and I have the platinum to prove it.
Cheers, The Witness.
Do you have the platinum Trophy in The Witness? Let us know in the comments section below.





Comments 28
That final challenge is so memorable, glad I managed to secure the platinum. There hasn’t been any game quite like The Witness since. I’d love a sequel.
I haven't played this game much at all but I remember when it was annouced at the PS4 event right after I think Infamous Second Son. Once again, love the article Stephen. Bring on Plat #3!
This is my most proud platinum by a long long way. That final challenge I finally did at about 4AM after a million tries. Nothing has pushed me that far in terms of puzzle solving and I’d love to play it again.
I got so far then got stuck. I've tried to go back but having lost the knowledge I'd built up I just can't work out what to do it where to go.
Congrats to anyone getting the platinum. A real achievement.
Easily on my list of favourite games ever - it elevated the idea of the maze puzzle to art. So many vivid memories from this game are burned into my mind forever. Even just wandering around the island and noticing little clever details hidden in the scenery - like one whole section of the island, when viewed from the boat, looks like a woman lying on her side, for example. It really challenged your perceptions.
Beating that final timed challenge was incredibly satisfying. But perhaps even more satisfying was getting the true ending and discovering that my early guess about the nature of the island was correct. Wonderful game.
Ah, dang, 1/2 with Stephen. Fun while it lasted.
The Witness is on my platinum backlog, but I haven’t found the focus to just not give up on a puzzle. Hopefully this next year I’ll catch up on it.
My wife had to help me with this game. She has much better puzzle solving skills than I do. Lol
I have this platinum and I I solved 99% of the game without guides.
Best puzzle game alongside Portal and Talos Principle.
Couldn’t be bothered with this one. It was a pretty game (first game I tried HDR on on PS4 I think), but puzzle games can easily bore me. If I could play it in VR I might have stuck with it just for the visuals, but there’s only so far flat games can entice me in that sense.
In terms of Platinum trophies, I’m not really interested in them for pure puzzle games as you can always just use a guide. It makes them mean nothing. And if you cared about it there would always be that temptation…
I've tried last challenge about 10 times, but never managed to complete it. I barely remember you had to solve 3 random puzzles, but I managed to make 2 at best. I remember once, I'm 100% sure, I made all three in time, but it (somehow) didn't count (I think last few seconds of music are off limit) so that frustration made me to stop trying again.
Yep, I got this plat too. Fantastic game. I fell into it hard, I played it at release and didn’t play anything else until I had unlocked all its secrets, including all those audio logs and the hidden hexagon media things, which I watched fully. I remember sitting with graph paper and pencils to figure out some of the harder puzzles. Loved every second of it, it’s one of those games that I wish I could forget so that I could experience it fresh a second time.
I can’t believe it’s almost 10 years since this came out. I never got the platinum, but I loved it. One of those games that made you feel smart at it’s best, and frustrated the hell at it’s worst (“What do you want me to do!?!). My most pervading memory was of the video of the guy walking backwards and forwards for about 5 minutes. I remember thinking, “Is this deep?”, nope it’s just nonsense, but I still loved the game. Maybe one day…
Got the equivalent of the platinum on Xbox, and at the time it was incredibly satisfying. I beat the game while avoiding the temptation to look up guides. There were times I felt stuck, but always managed to solve it. I probably wouldn't be able to beat it today, since I get bored easily now with this type of games.
I got the platinum on The Witness and mostly enjoyed my time with the game. But there were some moments that were infuriating after trying over and over again without even the slightest nudge in the right direction. Some puzzles felt like they truly didn't give enough information to solve some portions of some puzzles. The vast majority were fine but the few that were needlessly vague made me think back to the description annoyed, "This game respects you as an intelligent player and it treats your time as precious."
@DrVenture69 I have no idea what they were trying to get at with that guy walking. You couldn't even fast forward it to see what was to come. I watched it all just because I went all that way to see what it was about but it feels like a troll.
Fair play to anyone getting these to platinum grade! Puzzlers just ain’t my bag but I respect you if you have the patience to do this genre. I’d take any souls/borne platinum run over these personally but I still love you all for doing it 😉😁😂. Nice one ☝️
Yep. Got this too. I'm 2 for 2 so far. Deciding to have the music be the timer in that final challenge was a stroke of genius. It's one of the most memorable bits of audio in any game, ever in my opinion.
Last challenge is tough but isn't as difficult as is often made out. I found that people who looked up answers or used guides for parts of the game really struggled with the last challenge because they hadn't built up the knowledge of how to do the puzzles. Those that didnt rely on having the solutions given to them I found didnt tend to struggle all that much in the final challenge.
Never happening but i'd love a sequel.
I love puzzle games but I just couldn't get my head around what The Witness was asking of me and gave up early on. I've never been one for using guides so I just left it. Since then, whenever I hear the game mentioned, it niggles away at my conscience.
This article has made me want to give it another go. It's going on my new year's resolutions list. Great reads these @Quintumply, keep them coming and get one of your colleagues to have a go once you're done
Well done! There's a few on this list that are super frustrating. I gave up on the Platinum, wasn't having fun anymore.
Loved the witness and the final challenge was one of the hardest trophy’s I’ve ever done. Took me quite a while to finally get the platinum
Couldn't ever get that last trophy.. the time limit makes it tough
@3Above I tried really hard to gel with this game and couldn't get near 20% trophies- I'm really dumb at most puzzle games. Infamous: Second Son was my first ever plat funnily enough
I have this platinum, but it comes with a shameful admission: I exploited a bug to get it.
I don’t know if it’s still the case, but when I did the final challenge it was possible to make the timer irrelevant and let you solve the final puzzle at leisure. I did that. I’m not proud of it, but I wanted the real ending and “In the Hall of the Mountain King” was driving me insane after a few dozen attempts.
Loved the game for what I played. I didn't want to get help, and so abandoned it. Going back now feels daunting.
Portal is still the peak of 3D puzzle gaming in my opinion, but The Witness is no less a pretty fascinating concept. It's good to jump between puzzles knowing that you can back out and return to others on the island if you get stuck. Also pretty cool that the game has basically zero verbal or written clues on how to solve the puzzles, and you can quite easily intuit the rules of every one.
@KidRisky
I'm in the same boat as you. I just could not do that trophy of doing the final challenge which was a timed thing. I had to rely on that exploit as well.
I also looked up a small handful of puzzles when I got super stumped, but overall I'd say I did like 75% of it. So yeah, a little controversial for me already on the second edition of this installment! But I'm still enjoying it, keep it coming!
Speaking on the game itself, I enjoyed it a lot but found myself a bit frustrated and impatient at times (hence looking up a few solutions). I think I like puzzle games, but I could never for the life of me figure out the "boundaries" and the "rules" of The Witness. It seemed to be about figuring out patterns in the area, or environmental clues, or etc. Sometimes it was easy, other times, I was stumped. I was looking all over the place, sometimes crazy far away from the puzzle pedestal, trying to find something "out of place" in the most mundane things. I just didn't know how far the game needed me to search for the clues, and that's when I got impatient. "There are five tiles here, but one is cracked. Is that the clue?" Or "is the other half of this pattern in the tree branches? If so, is it these branches, or the ones way over there?"
So yeah, I had a mixed time, but still a beautiful game overall.
When I got the platinum in this game it took me like eight hours to do the finale puzzle - the randomised one. It melted my brain. My girlfriend kept coming in every now and again to see me sitting on the edge of my seat, beads of sweat on my brow, intense concentration followed by utter dejection on my face.
Eventually I got it, cheered like I'd scored the winning goal in the world cup final, and all was right in the world.
One day later I received a message on PSN asking for help on the puzzle, so I spent however long it takes to write a detailed message using the PS4 controller explaining how I approached the puzzle and what to watch out for. I instantly got a reply back saying that no, they meant would I do it for them if they gave me their log in details, and they'd pay me $5 for it.
Pretty sure that was the day I set my PSN to offline and blocked my trophies.
Only 4 games I've ever bothered to platinum:
The Witness
Horizon Zero Dawn
Spider-Man
Shadow of the Colossus
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...