
A world without Red Dead Redemption 2 isn't one we'd want to live in, so there is at least one benefit to the cancellation of the single player DLC that Rockstar had in the works for GTA 5: it let the developer make the western open worlder.
As part of a wider interview with Lex Fridman on YouTube, the studio's co-founder Dan Houser shared some details on the scrapped expansion. It was set to feature Trevor as a secret agent, and it was roughly 50% complete before it was cancelled. Houser describes the add-on as "cute", but it "never quite came together".
The silver lining, though, is if "that had come out, we probably wouldn't have got to make Red Dead 2", said Houser. "So there's always compromises." Widely considered one of the greatest games of the PS4 generation, you'd argue Rockstar made the correct decision behind the scenes, if its cancellation did affect development of Red Dead Redemption 2 so dramatically.
Work on the DLC got far enough along to where Trevor's voice actor, Steven Ogg, had even recorded voice lines for the new content, but they never materialised in-game.
While it's still not official, reliable reporting claims a native PS5 version of Red Dead Redemption 2 is in the works. It's not known exactly when the upgraded port will be announced or released, however.
Are you happy Rockstar decided to make Red Dead Redemption 2 instead of persisting with GTA 5 DLC? Let us know in the comments below.
[source youtube.com, via thegamer.com]





Comments 26
Tangent: Where is October's game of the month poll?
@Oram77 They probably decided the poll wasn’t necessary and just gave it to Ghost of Yotei.
@Elfuggingjefe This is the hottest take of all takes 😬
“ Are you happy Rockstar decided to make Red Dead Redemption 2 instead of persisting with GTA 5 DLC?”
No, I’m not into old west GTA - can’t stand the setting/time period. western has to be one of the most boring themes next to medieval
Trevor as a secret agent sounds like a terrible idea to start with.
@Oram77 These polls are pretty useless imo as very few gamers would have played more than one of the games released each month anyway. Many will have played none. Making it a popularity contest rather than a fair comparison.
Trevor would fit right into the Red Dead universe, crazy guy.
@themightyant I think you were just bitter that Silksong lost to Silent Hill f it's just a bit of fun that's all
Are you happy Rockstar decided to make Red Dead Redemption 2 instead of persisting with GTA 5 DLC?
Are you kidding? It's the best decision possible.
And I'd rather they start working on RDR 3 instead of making any DLC for GTA 6
Yep one of the greatest games ever made!
@nomither6 so it means you're missing this, TW3, KCD2, Skyrim etc...wow just wow!
It’s surprising that the resources needed to finish 50% of the DLC would have prevented RDR2 from being made.
Worked out for me. I don’t even play GTA much anymore. RDR2 is my favorite game ever made. So i won that decision. Thanks Rockstar, now can i get RDR2 with 60 fps.
RDR2 at the cost of a Trevor DLC feels like a lottery win. Not a small one, either.
@TheArt Pretty much. I’m missing all of em, unless they’re like the original God of War games if that counts; the greek god of war games are an exception, and doom the dark ages 😂
@Oram77 Scarred for life from that travesty!
Can't be unseen
@Elfuggingjefe I dont' understand the glazing of this game. Even people who like it admit that your main character controls like a freaking forklift in this game. The gameplay is disgustingly bad. Yes, the graphics, atmosphere, story are top notch. But I thought gameplay was king?
When somebody says a game uses a dated engine and it looks like crap, then they get blasted and told "gameplay is all that matters, who cares about graphics?"
But here is the opposite. The presentation is above and beyond and the supposed most important aspect, the gameplay, is like total dogmeat. Yet this game gets totally glazed. hahaha
I personally desperately wanted GTA V single player DLC (ideally two packs like GTA IV) and was bitterly disappointed by the focus on online rubbish instead.
The truth is they'd rather milk the credit cards of fools than make proper expansions. I'm not buying the RDR2 explanation/excuse at all.
Personally I'm not a fan of RDR2 anyway. It's clunky, sluggish and fully of unnecessary busy work that doesn't add to the experience. Prefer the original.
I'd take the GTA V expansion thanks.
@StitchJones 100%.
RDR2 has many great qualities, but take the gameplay in isolation and it is utter horse manure.
The second-by-second third person gameplay is atrocious. As you say, it controls like a forklift on a sand dune!
Imagine if MindsEye had identical gameplay. Reviews that score by category would give gameplay 4/10.
Stick the Rockstar and RDR badge on it, and add some pretty graphics (on XSX and PC at least) and suddenly it's game of the century.
@Elfuggingjefe Glazing basically means "going out of ones way to constantly hype, talk up, claim that something (in this case a videogame) is like the GOAT, or amazing etc" Usually egregiously or nonstop. I didn't say you were glazing. I said that the gaming community has a knack to glaze the crap out of RDR2 since it came out. The most recent big time glazing is ARC-Glazers. The amount of youtube posters glazing this game is cringey at this point
I replayed RDR2 earlier this year and just spent my time mostly exploring and filling in Arthur's journal. It was goddamned beautiful!
@Shinnok789 I have a feeling GTA6 is going to be an evolving world. With perhaps add ons and expansions. They gonna milk this one REAL good. Our wallets also
Personally Id much rather have more RDR than GTA. Tried the GTAs a few times over the years but sadly I just find them boring. But RDR however, totally different story. I racked up over a 1000 hours on RDR2 when it was released on PS4 an am still to this day regularly replaying both RDR and RDR2 again and again. So yeah in my opinion doing RDR2 was the better choice. And I sincerely hope to see RDR3 some day too.
Back then I'd have much rather had dlc for GTAV, as I never really got on with the sluggish controls and some of the tedium of RDR2's open world.
That said, these days I don't really enjoy replaying GTAV either
We've known this for years.
@Elfuggingjefe Oh yes totally agreed. Especially on youtube. As you know, youtubers make their money off of ads. The more views the more and better ads you get. And they might even get some funds chucked their way by the product's company that they are glazing. And it obv doesn't start and stop with video games. This applies to any product
@LiamCroft where's the ps5 version?
Boy you guys are gullible
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...