
Hironobu Sakaguchi, the legendary game developer most commonly known for the creation of Final Fantasy, has somehow found himself caught in the middle of a debate about AI on social media.
Sakaguchi himself sparked all of this off when he responded to an AI-generated video on X (also known as Twitter). Said video was making some waves amongst Japanese Final Fantasy fans, as it attempts to showcase what a remake of Final Fantasy 6 could look like.
As is so often the case with AI-generated media, the video seems fairly impressive at a glance, but pay any kind of closer attention to it and it's filled with weird errors. Character faces warp and change as they move, clothing details are a mishmash of nondescript patterns, and backgrounds are packed with visual inconsistencies.
And of course, the art direction is generally just all over the place.
But these problems didn't stop Sakaguchi from enjoying the video. He commented: "What is this?! Pretty awesome, huh?"
Needless to say, his positivity has rubbed plenty of people the wrong way, while also encouraging fans of AI-generated media to jump to the technology's defence.
In truth, the replies are an absolute mess, but one response in particular is gaining a lot of traction — and it comes from fellow game developer veteran and SaGa series creator Akitoshi Kawazu.
Kawazu comments: "No, Sakaguchi-san, please stop after the first line", meaning that he doesn't quite agree with Sakaguchi's opinion of the video being "pretty awesome".
I do kind of feel for Sakaguchi here; I seriously doubt that his intention was to cause social media conflict. He probably just saw what he thought was a cool fan-made thing, punched in a quick reply, and then put his phone down.
But this is also a reminder of just how prominent AI-generated content has become. If even Sakaguchi's being sucked into thinking it's cool, then your average internet user won't even think twice about what they're looking at.
How do you feel about all this? Is it really just harmless fun, or are we heading down a very slippery slope? Please prove that you're human in the comments section below.
[source x.com]
Comments 32
I can understand an old dude seeing something like this online and reposting it without thinking so I'm not like outraged at the guy but personally I will never support something created using generative AI in such large quantities.
How do I feel? Old man is old, young people don't give old man a break for being old, and AI suck.
I mean, there's no obvious harm in some fan"made" AI FF6remake concept video. It's not like Squeenix is doing it. But, ya know, all the institutional and environmental damage AI has wrought pretty much outweighs any neat-factor this might have.
AI should be purely for memes and POC / getting ideas.
Like it's good to ask it stuff or get some ideas bout shiz or to bring an idea to life so you can sanity check, but otherwise nah bro!
Removed - trolling/baiting
Let him think it’s cool. It’s a sad state of affairs that someone commenting on an AI video and then being disparaged is news too.
Look, everyone gets it that a lot of people really hate Gen AI, but this is witch hunt mob mentality.
I feel the same way I felt about DLSS 5.
But it IS cool. You don't have to like AI to admit it can generate some pretty cool content.
Cool doesn't mean perfect. Cool doesn't mean original, non-derivative, or even ethical. Cool means it's interesting in some way - which that clip clearly is.
@Boxmonkey That's a bad take. There are many provable reasons to dislike AI, especially in creative industries.
It's not a press conspiracy. And, even if it was, journalists being replaced by programmably bias AI IS inherently bad.
There's nothing manufactured about it, man. Don't think you're better than anyone else because you'd rather willingly bury your head in the sand...
@RobN Ehh, I'm a little torn there. I think the technology is much cooler than the output. I kinda feel nothing from modern AI art.
I liked it when it was dream-like and uncanny. Now it's just a s*** version of human art. Too proficient to be uniquely its own style, yet too well below an actual artist's standards to be impressive per se. Go watch King Gizzard and the Lizard Wizard's "Iron Lung" to see what I think the peak of AI art is. Also Angel Engine, I guess — but that would've still probably been better with actual artists.
And still, we can say it's cool, but the costs of that minute coolness is hardly worth it.
@Boxmonkey One could argue that hate for online service games is manufactured considering what are the most played games on all platforms
@Oram77 One could argue that all hate is manufactured. That doesn't mean it's an insightful thing to say.
@RoomWithaMoose Thank you for the truly whimsical comment...
@RoomWithaMoose As someone with no artistic talent whatsoever (even my stick figures are awful), it's astonishing the quality of "art" you can get from a generative AI prompt.
I don't pretend it's high quality compared to what my artist kid could draw - it's not. I don't pretend it's original - it's not, not really. And I certainly understand the moral questions about training AI on content without the creators' consent, often in blatant violation of applicable copyright laws. And all of that is before you get to any concerns about AI encroaching on anyone's job.
But people sure read a lot into a tweet saying "that's cool" about something that is (as much as a subjective idea like "cool" can possibly be objective) OBJECTIVELY COOL.
EDIT: Sorry, I guess the original quote was translated as "awesome" and not "cool," but the specific word used isn't really my point.
Well, aside from the fact that it's AI slop, it does give an idea of what a high budget FF6 remake could look like and i would like to see it one day.
@Oram77 Thank you for calling it whimsical. No one's ever called me that before.
Wouldn't expect any better from Twitter.
@RobN I mean, yeah. It's a pretty innocent comment.
I don't fault the man for saying it's cool — or awesome. It's just a case of someone being woefully out of their depth and/or not reading the room accordingly.
Don’t really see the issue in all honesty.
Regardless if it’s AI or not, it does look cool 🤷🏻♂️
@Oram77 believe me i know I’m in the minority for wanting to play single player only games. I actually don’t have a huge problem with live service, I have a huge problem with Sony neglecting their fans for going way too far with their live service push.
@Boxmonkey And just like that I 100% agree with you, there will always be room for live service BUT they do need to go back to the PS3/PS4 era whether that's sequels or brand new IP, I think Fair games could be the straw that breaks Sony back (copium)
Like @Nem said, the cool thing about this is it gives you an idea of what a proper 3D FFVI remake would look like - and how incredible it would be to play FF6 on that scale with some proper artistic direction and real artistry behind it.
Leave Sakaguchi be, kids!
@Nei They clearly don't understand they are talking to RPG royalty!!!
Seriously if the worst thing in your life is AI then you are very lucky
>Kawazu comments: "No, Sakaguchi-san, please stop after the first line", meaning that he doesn't quite agree with Sakaguchi's opinion of the video being "pretty awesome".
Really? I read that as "don't do that, people aren't read for this kind of talk just yet".
The blight persists.
Think I’ve finally figured out where I keep going wrong in this whole conversation. I take for granted that typing in a prompt, pumping out an asset and calling it a day just doesn’t even cross my mind as a valid way of using it. No writer would do this and call themselves a writer, or an artist etc. I really believe that creatives intuitively understand the ethical boundaries of using A.I. as a tool because they appreciate the creative process.
Anyway, a person should be able to think their lunch kit is cool for whatever reason they see fit without an army of schoolyard bully’s shouting at them that it’s not.
Genuinely don't see the issue myself it's a bit of fun. I dont like AI when it's taking people's jobs or giving us gaming slop to play. But this isn't doing either. Sakaguchi clearly sees the fun in it as his 2D game has come to life and if he has no problem seeing it then I certainly have no right to complain. It's as I said, a bit of fun.
What do you mean the replies are a mess? I just clicked your link and so many of them are positive!
Even with the help of AI this surely took a lot of work and fine tuning. No wonder the man was impressed at a glance.
Also not everyone is constantly on high alert watching out for everything that might be gen AI.
Surely this is what AI should be used for?
It’s just showing us what could be. It’s not a real thing. It isn’t playable. It’s just showing us a cool concept to give ideas to people.
I don’t like AI in games. But for conceptual stuff, surely it’s acceptable. And the guy didn’t make it, he just commented on it.
I think it looks kind of cool. It's nothing more than a video made for fun, it's not an endorsement for a completely ai generated Final Fantasy game.
I think the video itself is not that bad. Except I have never seen an Ace of Hearts without a big heart in the middle of the card
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...