Reviews for Ghost of Tsushima went live a little earlier today, and it seems Sucker Punch has delivered once again. Verdicts are largely positive for the samurai open world title, which impresses with its gorgeous open world and fluid combat. Between this and The Last of Us 2, Sony is sending off PlayStation 4 in brilliant style. Read on to see what various critics have to say on the adventures of Jin Sakai -- but check out our review first, yeah?
Push Square - 9/10
Ghost of Tsushima is a joy to play and a joy to behold. Sucker Punch has crafted one of the most memorable open world games of this generation, buoyed by an immensely satisfying combat system and an engaging, dramatic story. Unlike many of its open world peers, it's a refined and focused experience -- gripping and immaculately presented at its best. A fitting first-party swansong for the PS4.
Game Informer - 9.5/10
Sucker Punch borrows from other open world games, but ultimately charts an original and creative course to craft a samurai epic of tremendous breadth and beauty.
IGN - 9/10
Ghost of Tsushima is an excellent action game and its open world is one of the most gorgeous yet.
GamesRadar+ - 4.5/5
It would be understandable for developer Sucker Punch to feel nervous about releasing a game so close to the critically-acclaimed The Last of Us 2, and as PS5 glimmers on the horizon, but it shouldn't. This is a worthy swan song for the PS4, and a tribute to the Japanese culture it so clearly reveres.
USgamer - 4/5
Sucker Punch's first stab at a stealth action adventure hits the mark. The island of Tsushima is a beautiful backdrop for this tale of revenge and honor and the environmental art is a visual treat. Combat and stealth are largely solid, though there are issues with the camera and hitting the right targets. The biggest stumble comes with the Japanese vocal track, which isn't synced correctly with the character's lips, a shame for a game like this. Ghost of Tsushima isn't the most innovative way to end a generation, but it is a fun one.
GameSpot - 7/10
The game hits a lot of fantastic cinematic highs, and those ultimately lift it above the trappings of its familiar open-world quest design and all the innate weaknesses that come with it--but those imperfections and dull edges are definitely still there. Ghost of Tsushima is at its best when you're riding your horse and taking in the beautiful world on your own terms, armed with a sword and a screenshot button, allowing the environmental cues and your own curiosity to guide you. It's not quite a Criterion classic, but a lot of the time it sure looks like one.
VG247 - 3/5
It has its moments, but like Jin Sakai in the opening hours, the past holds it back. It’s Open World: The Video Game. It’s far too easy, too – the lack of consequence for failure makes it feel like you’re just going through the motions. If you’ll excuse the wind-based pun, it’s a breeze. While playing it, I often found my mind wandering. By the third and final act, I just wanted it to be over. Like the samurai, Ghost of Tsushima feels like a relic of a bygone era.
Comments 59
I just want to pet the fox...
The VG247 review comes across as he or she was forced to play the game without a say in the matter😂. Never the less though this game looks absolutely amazing, interesting straight forward trophy list and one I’m 100% confident I’m going to enjoy this one. It’s good to see Sony’s studios reaching out different game ideas!
@Its_Carl_Y-all Yeah, doesn't it suck out loud when people have opinions?
@jamberino93 it does seem off. Everyone is entitled to their opinion of course and who knows we might agree with them lol though i do think the reviewer wasnt fond of this type of game. 'A relic from a bygone era' just doesnt seem right looking at this game
GameSpot gave it a 7/10 and two of their negatives were:
Such game breaking problems we know.
Sony's A teams have been knocking it out the park this gen.
Sounds good! The negatives I have seen feel like I could put up with. Only two more sleeps till it can be played!
Not sure why, but the VG247 review makes me angry.
I feel like the reviewer missed the point of the game or something. For me, games aren’t about challenge, they are about experiences, storyline and “the feels”.
I have always wanted to BE a Samurai. This game looks the closest to fulfilling that dream.
Yes, I know it is their opinion, but meh.
I am interested to give this game a go. Kinda surprised with the gap between the high and low reviews. Seems like some didn't enjoy the specific open world features and the combat. Maybe it is tied to how many open world games you have played? For instance, someone that has played all of the recent open world titles is burnt out on them, but someone that has been playing other games enjoys the direction they took.
'It’s Open World: The Video Game'
Haha its poor criticism like you would read in IGN comments or idk
I still find reviews so confusing The writing never matches the score they give.
I randomly read one on metacritic, they said the world looks amazing but everything else is just sub par and its not enough for an open world game in 2020- Score. 8.5...how can a review being so negative still give a score as high as an 8.5?
@Kienda that’s just how things go. As long as we’re comparing hot takes, I personally think Sekiro is the worst samurai game of the generation. But hey, opinions are like A-holes. Everybody has one, and mine is objectively superior to yours.
Reminds me of horizon zero dawn release, good start for this new IP
@IronMike People don’t like GameSpot unless the review is what the player wanted it to be. Take IGN for example.
IGN gave Death Stranding a 6 and they were ridiculed for it, but they just gave gave Ghost of Tsushima a 9 and now they’re loved. Then GameSpot gave the same games a 9 and 6 respectively. Now everyone hates them. See what I mean?
@Oh_fiddlesticks You will be better off reading the reviews and not looking at the scores. Like you said, they don’t always match up and that’s very true.
@Oh_fiddlesticks
Because 8 and above is handed out like candy on Halloween these days. Best to read the whole review and ignore the number at the end. I still prefer the 'buy,' 'rent,' 'don't bother' scale but I understand why most places stick with numbers or stars.
Sounds like I’d give it a 6 or a 7. Largely stale genre, it would take a lot to keep me interested. No disrespect to @ShogunRok (you twonk) but he’s someone who has played and enjoyed PS4s worst game (Dragon Age Inquisition) multiple times and I have, through great pain and suffering, come to terms with the fact we’re on different wave lengths. And that’s ok, he can’t get it right every time.
@kyleforrester87 Pffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffft
Great! now that they got this game out of their system.... is it too soon to ask them to go back to Infamous?
@ShogunRok I bet you didn’t even earn a black belt in ninjitsu before you reviewed this game, you amateur.
@IronMike. Gamespot is 🗑 trash.i never trust theyre reviews.polygons is horrible too.word up son
@Kienda exactly, like RDR2 or GTA were challenging
@jamberino93 Where exactly in the VG247 review does it sound like they were "forced" to play the game against their will? I've read over it several times now and I'm not quite seeing it 🤔
I trust my own review. "Looks like my kind of game". Buy.
I'll find out about the rest as I play.
My issue with the more critical reviews is less they have those problems but more that these "problems" will appear in the new AC this year and Far Cry next year and these very same reviewers will gush over them. Honestly as long as the game is fun to play and the word has me engrossed i don't really care if the gameplay isn't original, Days Gone and Horizon follow the typical open world rulebook but because the world and gameplay was so fun i never once cared. End of the day what exactly were reviewers really expecting? Breath of the Wild may be an amazing open world game but its style would be hard to put into a game like this and TW3 was a massive RPG. From my understanding Ghost is more about the world and combat and less about having totally original gameplay, AC Odyssey was hardly original gameplay wise but its still one of my favourite games this gen with one of my favourite open world.
The game is scoring better then Days Gone but i bet its going to be one of these cases where players are going to be enjoying this way more then critics.
@MUG3NHC best sort of review my man. I also like the look of it and apart from the review on PS i dont feel i need to read any to realise that it looks gorgeous, i love samurai and feudal Japan, its made by SP and the combat and stealth look right up my alley. If i turn out to not like it then so be it.
Man it seems gamespot and vg247 just bored at games in general. On others side, it seems most gaming youtubers like skillup, yongyea, acg, easy allies, and others really like the game.
Can't wait to preload this game tomorrow
@SuperKMx
Think they mean this one
http://www.digitallydownloaded.net/2020/07/review-ghost-of-tsushima-sony.html
Dreadful it's not a review it's just clickbait and woke nonsense which the reviewer doesn't care about this issues they go on about its just about clicks and there own ego
Comes of more like a essay about how inaccurate the game is and little on the game itself, personally I play games to.escape reality
sometimes wonder if VG247 even likes gaming hate the site sorry to say. reminds me of the Guardian think they are more important than they really are.
@ShogunRok Dragon Age Inquisition was my favorite RPG this generation so I get how you feel 🙂
@Kienda
It's Vga247 they hate games and fun.
@Tchunga I don’t mean it like they were literally forced but in a way where they didn’t want to play the game from the get go! I often found my mind wandering. ((By the third and final act, I just wanted it to be over. ))
Remember Days Gone had lower scores then this but so many have grown to love it.
Sony has Story Driven single player games down to a science. It is one after another every year.
We are doing pretty well now in New York - but this weekend will be 100% at home lockdown/social distancing for me 😅
So either decent or amazing. And gamespot scores are strictly for clicks i feel like.
@Its_Carl_Y-all I thought that about GameStop giving last of us 2 an 8. Then I played it. Hoping for the best with ghost.
I think the scores in reviews need to drop down 2 points out of 10 on average. When OK seems to be a 7/10 it does not leave a lot of room at the top for separating really good games. I'm not sure why this has happened in gaming. When you look at other media TV/Movie/Book/Music all seem to be viewed more critically. A really good movie will average out around 7.5, So will middle of the road games
The GameSpot comment about it not being quite a Criterion classic. It shows my love of games is above my love for films when I immediately think of Black and Burnout upon hearing that.
Hey, not every game can be a 10 out of 10. These are solid review scores, and I really look forward to getting my pre order copy. I normally don't like open world games, but there are a few exceptions. Breath of The Wild, Horizon Zero Dawn, and now this one. The world just looks incredible, and I am a massive Kurosawa fan. This looks like my kind of game.
I would like to play this, but I will just wait and play on a PS5 (hopefully) without the jet engine sound and instant loading etc
@suikoden Ah, I see. I'll be honest and say that I don't even have to click that link. I've visited that site more than a few times in the past and am familiar.
I'm going to take a guess. 8,000 words. Lots of comparisons to movies/directors. Paragraphs of being insulted at how "American" the game is and how insulting it is to Japanese people (or in this case, I imagine, to real Samurai.) Words italicized for no real reason. A generous feeling of "you don't know as much about videogames or Japan as me, reader" running all the way through it.
Am I close?
I think SkillUp did a great review of the game. I think it's a mix up with this sort of game. It probably ranges from a 7(you are not the biggest fan of open world games and samurai) to a 9(like open world games and samurai).
Not mentioned here, but Eurogamer couldn't even be bothered to give it a recommended! "Sony open world game? Nice horsey bits but clunky, derivative & empty open world MEH!"....as opposed to derivative Ninty Switch sequels which had this been Ninty published game would've had essential & glowing praise!
They weren't kidding when they said greatness awaits.
I was going to wait until a PS5 version but I cant...just bought it..
I wouldn't go as far as saying they are as sharp as a samurai's blade. There are an unexpected amount of 60's and 70's to really say that. With that said, it's still doing just fine with reviews overall, and I could care less in the end. I have it pre-ordered and I'm really looking forward to getting to play it. It still should be a fitting end for the PS4 era, at least from Sony.
Stop caring those US big game site reviews long time ago..
For website, I'll only read from PushSquare & GamesRadar.
For Youtube, it's gonna be ACG & SkillUp
Another reason why Sony is number one when it comes to games.
"If you creep up behind a man who’s crouched, he will politely stand up so you can stab him in the neck and play the animation out."
Guardian 3 stars out of 5
Review scores are personal opinions. Just because someone gives a game a lower score than someone else doesn't mean they are wrong, its right to them. You don't need to feel hurt or angry that not everyone likes everything that you think looks good. They are opinions.
There will always be variations in review scores as even reviewers have differing desires as to what they would like the game to be. Some feel that high scores should be those that push the boundaries and experiment (successfully) with new concepts and ideas whilst others just want what is tried and tested but polished to the point that you can brush your rear molars.
The poor lip-syncing for the Japanese Dub is a big annoyance for me though and one likely to break immersion as I notice these things and can never stop noticing. And no way I'm going to play a game set in Japan, during the Samurai Era, with a lot of Japanese cultural and historical references in anything but the Japanese dub. Unfortunately I doubt that is something that can be patched in.
I think, RDR and AC Odyssey killed me on this genre. Open world fatigue is real and I have it. Though, I could see myself playing it in a couple of years, or so.
I love me some open world games, I’m one of the people that loves the UBisoft formula (and all I read this game might as well be an assassins creed game,) but watched some videos and... looks wonky. AI can be baffling, and the character seems kinda dead...
I’ll still get it, eventually (still waiting on official info about PS5 upgrades for first party games,) but this feels like another Days Gone situation.
@Gamer83 I don't even read reviews anymore. I look at the genre, the settings, the dev team, and the quality of some gameplay vids. Then just judge how much value that game has to me personally, then wait for it to reach a suitable price.
@Richnj
That's also a perfectly fine approach to making purchasing decisions.
@Kienda i just read one from the face, a magazine and it seems like they were also made to play a video game they didn't want to
@jamberino93 It sounds to me like the the reviewer felt the game was too bloated in terms of content, which doesn't seem all that outlandish. Bloat is an issue that often plagues many (if not most) open world games. Idk, Seems like a pretty fair criticism to me 🤷🏼♂️
"It’s far too easy, too – the lack of consequence for failure makes it feel like you’re just going through the motions"
This is what I was worried about. Looks great visually but after my disappointment with Death Stranding I'm gonna give this one a pass.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...