The end of 2019 is upon us, and that can only mean one thing: Game of the Year. As is tradition, we've all voted for our favourite Playstation 4 games of the last 12 months, and the ten titles with the most support have the honour of being featured in our illustrious Game of the Year 2019 list. Today, we'll be counting down from number 10 to number 6.
10. Return of the Obra Dinn
It might look like an old Mac game with its 1-bit visuals, but Return of the Obra Dinn stands up to any other modern titles from 2019. This is a superb puzzler in which you must decipher the identity and fate of dozens of crew members with limited information. The game’s excellent design means you’ll have to use real detective skills, putting together incomplete facts and making assumptions as you whittle down the list. Small vignettes paint the picture of every death, and you’ll be using these not only to fill out the record, but also to unravel the tragedy of the titular ship. It’s a remarkable game that not only makes you feel intelligent, but involves you in the trials and tribulations of the ill-fated crew. Weaving together story and gameplay in such a unique and engaging way, Obra Dinn is fully deserving of its place on our list.
9. Days Gone
There’s a je ne sais quoi to Deacon St. John’s debut that elevates far beyond the sum of its parts. On the surface this is an aged open world outing, with PlayStation 2-era cut-scene transitions and ropey gunplay. But look beyond its surface shortages and you’ll find an apocalyptic adventure with heart. Its survival aspects work well, and there’s clear care and attention been invested into Oregon as a whole. Sony’s Bend Studio may have been operating in the handheld ghetto for the past decade, but there’s evidence here that it’s ready to play with the big boys in Sony’s first-party stable.
8. Shenmue III
Shenmue III shouldn’t be on this list because, if we’re all honest with ourselves, it shouldn’t exist. This is not one of the best games of 2019, but its background is. Fans maintained hope for a continuation of Ryo Hazuki’s tale of revenge for an eye-watering 18 years, and the end-result is a release that feels like it’s stepped straight out of a time capsule. Decorated director Yu Suzuki stuck to the blueprint that made this legendary series a cult classic to begin with, and while its idiosyncrasies may befuddle casual onlookers, fans got exactly what they’d anticipated for the past two decades.
7. Monster Hunter World: Iceborne
A truly, er, monstrous expansion, Monster Hunter World: Iceborne is a triumph. Better than most full price games released in 2019, Iceborne is one of Capcom's finest creations of the generation, bolstering an already gigantic action RPG with more of, well, everything. Building on what is already an outstanding gameplay loop, it pushes Monster Hunter World to even greater heights with incredible new creatures and a wealth of clever additions. A game that simply never stops giving while somehow maintaining a supreme level of quality across all that it does.
6. Judgment
As soon as Judgment was announced, we knew that we were in for a treat. A Yakuza game where you play as a detective? Sign us up. Not only does Judgment boast one of the best stories of 2019, it's also got some of the coolest characters and combat scenarios. Despite its familiar gameplay, this is an engrossing adventure through the themes of crime and punishment. An obvious choice for fans of Yakuza, but even if you're not up to speed with SEGA's action RPG series, Judgment is still a blast from start to finish.
Do you agree with our Game of the Year 2019 list so far? Tell us about your own top ten in the comments section below. We'll be counting down our top five games of 2019 daily, so be sure to check back.
How we decide our Game of the Year: At the end of November, our editorial team creates a list of nominees for Game of the Year based on our own review scores and a number of other factors. After much discussion, we trim the list of nominees down and ask all Push Square staff to vote on their five favourites using a points-based system. The ten games with the most points by the designated deadline are our top ten PS4 titles of 2019. We then use this same order when writing about each game.
Comments 31
Aww poor Judgment didn’t make the top 5 so this actually shows how good a year it’s been despite the usual grumbling.
Nice to see Obra Dinn on there. Shenmue should be higher, obviously.
Plague of innocence is a top 10 games to me.word up son
Is Judgement like Sleeping Dogs?
Whats the point of this article? I think we all know Death Stranding is going to be the PushSquare GotY lol😁
@playstation1995 glad im not the only one. Couldnt even vote for it on the goty thread
@Nyne11Tyme. Yeah that game is amazing way better than return of obra dinn.word up son
@get2Sammyb , it sounds like you really enjoyed Shenmue 3. I don’t get why articles keep more or less saying “now, objectively, it’s a not a great game” when no such thing exists. It sounds like a great Shenmue game. You enjoyed it, you were engrossed by the storytelling, and overall talk about it like a great piece of art. And at the end of the day, I think that’s all that matters. If you felt more drawn in by it and like it spoke to more as a piece of art, I think that absolutely puts it above other games. Sometimes the whole is more than the sum of it’s parts.
@Jaz007 I agree, but it's always worth stressing that it's definitely not for everyone. And that's fine, but worth keeping in mind.
@delukze Sleeping Dogs is GTA in Hong Kong (I actually like it better than GTA personally), whereas Judgment is based heavily on the 'Yakuza model' which is a much more contained experience within an extremely dense map. There are passing similarities between the two titles, but they're only similar in the most superficial ways (like being set in Asia and being third person for instance). Yakuza has always had a deeper, more intimate storytelling experience, and it's just slower and more refined altogether. Sleeping Dogs is more of a rock 'n' roll experience by comparison.
I think you summed up days gone almost perfectly in that paragraph. Only thing is it's in my personal top 3 for 2019. It's glitchy, buggy, repetitive at times, etc. but if you can look past all of that, it is truly a diamond in the rough. I hope there is a more polished sequel, although with the way it ended, I really don't know how they could make a storyline for a sequel...
@PunkRx_Lockly Thank you, I've never played a Yakuza game, I bought Yakuza 0 recently for $10 on PSN which I'll play after I beat Days Gone
Guys. This is a PlayStation site. We all know it’s going to be Death Stranding.
Hopefully Death Stranding doesn't make it on here. If the gameplay is described as tedious and it takes 10 hours for it to become good, than it fails as a game.
@delukze Yakuza zero is awesome it provided good entertainment and took itself seriously when it needed to but outside of the main story was a great deal of side content that was so varied and fun honestly was easily a goty contender and for some players I am confident it was their game of the year.
so far so good. want to see devil may cry and sekiro in the top 5 now
@delukze Anytime. I'm sure you'll have fun with it. Easily one of the best Yakuza games if not the best.
i think this is the only website that has put judgement on a game of the year list.
@NYJetsfan123 what do you mean they have so many avenues they can go for a sequel especially with that stinger of an ending. I can’t wait for the inevitable sequel I loved days gone def in my top three of the year
@Akurusu what does that have to do with anything? Death Stranding is leading in goty wins right now so it’s not like it would be weird if that’s what won here
@koaeinferno yeah just no lol
Got judgement to play after i finally finish death stranding, hopefully will finish it today or 2morrow on chapter 10 atm at around 60hrs playing time. Cant wait to play judgement, played yakuza 0 and kiwami so far and loved them,also got kiwami 2 on the backlog so might pop that after judgement or outer worlds. The yakuza games are amazing though some of the side missions are crazy, well worth playing if you never played them, although will say it took me around 2hrs for yakuza 0 to click with me, found it pretty slow to start with but once it clicked was hooked.
@dark_knightmare2 A PlayStation exclusive winning on a PlayStation site? Nothing unusual here. And itt’s only leading by user reviews, I think one site had the user reviews botted votes. I’ll trust professional critics before users.
A bit of a weak year for games.
If I spoke/read Japanese I would easily have said Persona 5 Royal GOTY!
So … lemme get this straight.
Shenmue III was placed as one of the top 10 games of the year because people really really really wanted it to be made?
@dark_knightmare2
I stand corrected... Just did a little research on the ending. After the credits rolled I stopped playing. But apparently if you talk to 'that guy', after the credits, it does pave the way nicely for a sequel. I'm glad I looked into that.
@NYJetsfan123 yeah I’m super excited with that ending and the possibilities it brings
@Akurusu Sekiro only has two more critic wins than Death Stranding which also has more user wins and is leading overall so what point are you trying to make besides letting your obvious hate for Death Stranding show?
@dark_knightmare2 Typical, mistakes criticism and calling out what’s true for hatred. Not every PlayStation game is a masterpiece. And like I said Death Stranding user votes were said to have been botted.
@Akurusu no they weren’t botted lol that’s just haters looking for any reason to hate on the game smh.
@dark_knightmare2 Do some searching and you’ll see. Nothing to lie about.
Tap here to load 31 comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...