AAA games may have had a banner year, but there was a lot to love in the indie scene as well. Developer Giant Sparrow’s newest title, What Remains of Edith Finch, was the best of the bunch. The dev's first title since 2012’s incredible debut The Unfinished Swan, the title tells a terrific tale about a terrifically unlucky family. Visiting her childhood home, Edith wanders through one of the most fully-realised spaces we’ve ever seen in a game. During this exploration, we are treated to a collection of exceptional vignettes that detail the demises of the other members of Edith’s family as Edith works to complete a family tree and scrapbook for her as-of-yet unborn child. It’s the digital equivalent of a collection of short stories, and it’s phenomenal. The writing in the broadest sense is melancholic and quite bleak, but the game isn’t devoid of levity and brighter moments.
Some of the short stories are downright goofy, and there’s plenty of humour to be found throughout. The writing is phenomenal and all of the short stories feel wildly unique and different from one another, culminating in one of the cleverest uses of gameplay to tell a story we’ve seen in ages. It essentially sees you playing two games at once, and is completely unlike anything we’d ever encountered previously.
Even outside of the game’s primary narrative, there’s a lot to love. Never before have we gotten the chance to wander around a house in a game that felt this authentic. Every single item in the entire house feels as if it was placed there with a purpose and by a real person. Nothing feels artificial. The house is dusty, creaky, and very clearly something that was once beloved, but gone to seed.
And every room of every different family member feels distinct from the other. You can get a feel for the personality of each family member before you even start their individual stories by just looking at their rooms, which is a milestone accomplishment. Not only that, but the environment is interesting to explore. Even if you are less inclined to go through the story, the house itself offers boundless treasures and little things to appreciate as you walk through it. And despite the game’s relatively short run-time there’s just so much to love and appreciate stuffed in that it deserves every bit of praise that it has been given across the year.
Were you a fan of What Remains of Edith Finch’s gothic storytelling? Did you enjoy the fusion of mix and whimsy? Explore your family tree in the comments section below.
Comments 29
I still haven't played this, but seeing all this love is making me want to give it a try. I would love to play something like this in VR.
Edith Finch is so good. Play it if you haven’t already.
So I'm guessing the last 3 games covered will be Horizon, Persona and NiER?
Edith finch is the next step of first person adventure genre, you're experiencing the event rather than passively watching event unfold before you in this game. I was hooked the first time I see we can become a shark that rolling around in the highway lol
I might take a look at this if it goes PS+, but I've never been a fan of this style enough to actively purchase one.
Just an awesome game and experience. I bought it near launch and though a short game, I felt like I got my money worth. Each story section had its own unique gameplay mechanic that never outstays its welcome.
@PotatoTheG Niet enough people over at PS tower played Nier, I fear. I'll bet the top 3 looks something like this:
1 Persona 5
2 Horizon
3 Uncharted: Lost Legacy
I'd buy this in the current EU sale but I'm totally and utterly festively skint!
My personal GOTY. It’s like Gone Home meets The Unfinished Swan, which is a dream come true for me. The game felt like a magical dream, I don’t know how else to describe it.
Only three spots left and games like Horizon Zero Dawn, Persona 5, Uncharted: The Lost Legacy, Gravity Rush 2, Nier and Nioh still are not on the list.
Place your bets.
Is there a way to view all the games from this list in one place, so I can easily read all the articles on them? Sorry if it's staring me in the face! I read the site on Mobile, so maybe that's why I can't see it obviously.
EDIT: I've worked it out! I've just clicked on the 'Game of the Year' tag. It shows me the similar articles from last year too which is useful, as I get my brand new PS4 over the next few days so need to see what games to get.
All year this has been my 'I'll buy that when I've got some cash floating about' game. I'll get to it eventually.
Great game. The variety between each room...style and substance...was very engaging.
So is this another walking simulator? Just "played" through Dear Esther, not a fan of the genre. Esther, Ethan, Edith, what's with the letter E?
@sinalefa ha, ha! I know, I noticed that too. Why games of a genre seem to have similar names, I’ll never know. This game would have sold like pancakes if it was called, say ... “What Remains of Penelope Sarkisian?” 🤔
I just finished playing this, and I can now definitely agree with @gbanas92 - a really great game. It's short, granted, but the story is compelling and the scenes for each family member are imaginative and really varied. Well worth a play if you're even vaguely interested
please issue a SPOILER ALERT if youre going to say something like...
"culminating in one of the cleverest uses of gameplay to tell a story we’ve seen in ages. It essentially sees you playing two games at once, and is completely unlike anything we’d ever encountered previously"
Now when i get to this part ill be thinking... Oh that part pushsquare told me about rather than discovering it for myself and not knowing what to expect. Sigh.
Perhaps im over reacting?
#ihatespoilers.
Ps: I still luv you PS
My number 1 of 2017, closely followed by Hellblade.
@glassmusic Yes! Definitely agreed!
@sinalefa Sort of. It is a walking simulator, but it's more of an evolution of the genre. Rather than just "walking around" seeing things, you do get to take an active part in its story, so there's plenty of walking yes, but there's also actual gameplay sprinkled throughout.
@Quintumply Short absolutely, but delightful. I'll take a short amazing game over a longer even pretty good one any day!
@Gmork___ That's my bad! Never even registered as something that I'd consider a spoiler! Talking about the narrative context, it mighta clicked as such. For something like an end of year countdown, talking about what makes games good though, I'd say err on the side of caution a far as spoilers, especially if you wanna play it yourself! We could definitely have prefaced it with a spoiler warning
@Vorlon Right there with ya!
@MadAussieBloke I would absolutely be on board that! I don't need it per se, but I definitely want it!
@Th3solution @sinalefa Don't forget about "The Vanishing of Elliot Fauntleroy" or "Everybody's Gone To The Five-And-Dime". Those both underperformed a bit too!
@gbanas92 oh its alright. Good write up, though i stopped at that part lol. And so far its absolutely incredible and magical!
@sinalefa There's a lot more to this one than Dear Esther. Hard to explain without spoiling it.
I do enjoy a good walking simulator, I consider all telltale games to be in that 'genre' too, personally I found it grossly overrated but still 7.5/10. It's just good, it could probably have been an 8+ if it had a great ending, it didn't.
Just finished it and thought it was exceptional. I certainly much preffered it to the Unfinished Swan (too many vines!). In think it's pretty much my favorite game of the year.
@gbanas92 @get2sammyb
Thanks. I am getting all the games I am missing from the Game Awards winners so I know I will get this one eventually. I did like the Unfinished Swan, very original concept.
@sinalefa The charm and uniqueness that Giant Sparrow showed off in their first game is very much present here! If you liked Unfinished Swan, you have a very good shot of liking this too!
Tap here to load 29 comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...