(PlayStation 3)

Mugen Souls Z (PlayStation 3)

Game Review

Mugen Souls Z Review

Europe PAL Version

Posted by Mat Growcott

The questionable quest for cute

There aren’t many games as unusual as Mugen Souls Z. Its main character is a young goddess who carries around a coffin, not for any reason in particular, just because the writers needed some kind of container and that seemed to make sense. That’s not the weirdest thing that you’ll see either. Charged with “cuteness” and a little too risqué for its own good, this is a game that’ll leave you feeling a little creepy. Earning the Platinum may get you put on some sort of list.

Starting the game is something of a chore. It follows on directly from Mugen Souls, the first title in the franchise, and the ruler of the universe, Lady Chou-Chou, is tired of the little piece of space that she spent her last adventure obtaining. She decides to take over twelve more planets, but her plan quickly unravels when she’s accidentally transformed into a powerless chibi version of herself. Yes, this is the actual plot. More surprising, it takes up to two hours to get to the basic gameplay. This Metal Gear-busting figure includes countless cutscenes, a few tutorials, and a music video, but it’s by no means the end of your learning experience. You’ll keep being introduced to new ideas for a long time.

This is funny, because the mechanics themselves are actually fairly simple to grasp. The battle system is standard, although still enjoyable, and most of it is controlled via self-explanatory menus. The vast tutorials are presented almost as a parody of other JRPGs, but as is so often with titles of this type, the developer falls into the trap of doing exactly what it's satirising. “Look at us,” the company screams, “forcing you to read this 15 page how-to on changing underwear – isn’t that so JRPG?” Yes, changing underwear. Let’s build up to that one.

There’s a whole host of characters to learn about, and it happens a little too quickly to make sense. This is the biggest problem with the game's plot. It devotes pages of dialogue to grunts and moans, to little reactions or anime rants, but when something of substance comes along, it’s dealt with as quickly as possible. The game is based around Moe – the Japanese fad for liking cuteness, usually in women – and boy does it try to tick that box as often as it can. Every female character lives up to the Saturday Morning Anime stereotype, and it sounds like they were voiced by the same cast as well.

It’s hard to judge the quality of the dub when it comes to something like this. The acting is supposed to be over the top, just like the vast majority of consumer anime. Purists will complain that it’s not as good as the Japanese voice over, and that’s probably true, but so long as you go in expecting something silly, you’ll get exactly that. If you can’t stick the quality of the writing or acting, you may as well give up – after all, most of what you’ll be doing is sitting and listening.

When you’re not wondering how long it’ll be until the main characters just stop talking, you’ll be exploring or fighting. There are a number of worlds to discover, each specifically designed and with quite a bit to see. There’s nothing on the scale of some of the major RPGs, but with puzzles and loot to find all the same. These areas are well designed, but not especially striking visually, and the frame rate will drop so badly while you're walking around that it'll sometimes hurt your eyes.

Battles are vaguely tactical, with some nice ideas added to prevent things from getting stale. You move around your party, positioning them for maximum damage. Each arena has a set of crystals, which, when activated, grant boosts or have negative repercussions. These allow for a certain level of cleverness on the player’s part, meaning that you can position yourself in such a way to literally cut damage in half while also boosting your own magic power – it’s simple but effective. Grinding is still a pain if you choose to do it, but a basic playthrough probably won’t become too dull.

There’s another system on top of this one, and that’s where things begin to get a little creepy. Your main character can switch “jobs” – or fetishes – on the fly, and the goal of this is to convince monsters to like you. These fetishes range from Graceful and Hyper to Sadist and Masochist, and when you’re dressed as that particular role, that’s how your protagonist will act. The more monsters that you convince to like you, the more powerful your ultimate attacks will become. It’s a lot of effort, and not one that feels like it pays off, especially when you have to sit and watch as your player character leans over, panties showing, and utters lines like “Do you like my behind?” and “I’m so sexy."

The entire cast is left intentionally ageless – the game probably wouldn’t have got released otherwise. They speak, look, and act like they’re no older than 13 or 14, with occasional pendulous breasts added onto pre-pubescent bodies in an attempt to hide the obvious. It plays into the whole Moe thing – the appearance of being cute and youthful – but when you’re talking fictional characters that are beyond just acting out that trend, it’s hard to suspend your belief. These aren’t adults pretending to be children like some Japanese women might in real life – nowhere in the game does it imply that, and often it’s quite the opposite – but fictional gods, therefore inherently without age and fair game.

If for some reason you’re not convinced of how weird this is, consider that a bathing minigame had to be removed before the release could be rated. Look that one up on YouTube if you fancy a culture shock.

This on-the-line sexuality goes into every system in the game. You can dress up your characters to affect stats, with everything from cheerleader uniforms to sexy ninjas on offer. The first piece of armour that you’ll unlock is underwear, and you’ll be able to accrue others as you play. Even the dialogue is all too often a cause for concern, with one older gentleman accused of “liking little girls". Alas, it’s alright, because these are gods and heroes and demons – definitely not children.

If this doesn’t bother you, and you enjoy the premise enough to keep playing, there’s a lot of extra content on offer. You can level up your characters insanely high, and there’s no cap on damage, so a single move can hit for loads of HP. If you love grinding – experience points, we should clarify – then look no further.

Conclusion

Mugen Souls Z is, on the surface, a shallow but agreeable JRPG that hides a deeper, heavier set of systems for genre fans that care to search for them. It also has a darker side, one that goes beyond merely being a little bit naughty. Many titles have messed around with morality systems – but simply picking up this package is a grey choice in itself.

More Stories

Game Trailer

User Comments (11)

MadchesterManc

#1

MadchesterManc said:

This is probably the first time Ive disagreed with a review on here for the past few years, not the score or anythin, but the general body of the review. Ive been playing the game myself this past week and at least half of the games feature set isn't even mentioned at all. Peon recruitment that allows you to create your own party members, levelling them in battle & even fuse them to create more powerful ones? Weapon customisation & enhancements? Ticket mode for bonuses? battle techniques like Blast off that allows to to send enemies flying across battlefields into other enemies, delaying turns and destroying crystals? Coerce mode that gives temporary boosts in battle when following Symra's orders? Damage carnival limit-breaker style moves? Ultimate soul skills that increase in count the more gods powers you aquire? or even the G-Castle battles that are directly incluenced by the amount of peons you acquire with the captivate mode by boosting its stats? and thats just some that aren't mentioned & they all appear within the first 8 hours of the game. The review seems to read more opinionated than informative

MatGrowcottStaff

#2

MatGrowcott said:

@MadchesterManc I appreciate that there's things I had to leave out, but there's only so much you can cover in a review without ending up spending as much time as the game does in explaining every feature.

The majority of those things unfortunately get pinned under the title of "systems," and I think in all fairness we've covered the bases with that - there's a lot to see and do if you can get over the wordiness of the plot and sexual content.

I feel those are more important issues for somebody trying to decide whether to buy this game than the exact nature of certain additional features that could easily be better explained by a marketing team on the official website, or by checking out the chatter on the official forums.

MadchesterManc

#3

MadchesterManc said:

@MatGrowcott I do reviews myself, so I know that it can be a balancing act when it comes to reviewing a game that can be packed with features. The issue is that in the main body of the review your singular focus on the games sexualised apsects has created a more opinionated piece. Take weapons/armour for example. Instead of talking about how they can be levelled up/customised & enhanced, you chose to focus solely on how they are named. People reading the review wouldn't know about the customisation aspect & may be puzzled at this depth you mention in the conclusion. This singular focus has created an opinionated review that reads along the lines of "This game creeped me out...and here's why" instead of being as informative as possible to the reader. There's nothing wrong with highlighting the games sexualised aspect obviously, I just feel it could've been balanced a little more in the main body of the review

MatGrowcottStaff

#4

MatGrowcott said:

@MadchesterManc

There's just over 200 words on the sexualization in the game, plus a couple of hints earlier on. Considering how deeply rooted it is in both content and design, I think that's fair. It's not a case of me finding it creepy, it's a case of it being inarguably questionable to say the least - that's an important point and one that needs to be sufficiently dealt with.

We'll just have to agree to disagree on where the balance has to lie. It comes down to who you feel would be the target audience of the review would be. I reckon we've got to presume it's somebody coming to Mugen Souls Z completely blank, and someone of that description will want to know about basic systems with mention of a further depth as you continue to play.

@ErnisDy

It's by no means a perfect JRPG, as mentioned in the review. It's a passable one with plenty to do if the characters, design, writing, graphics and focus don't put you off.

Cloud7794

#5

Cloud7794 said:

@MatGrowcott To be honest, the over-sexualization is what pushes me away from this game. It's also what pushed me away from ever picking up the first game, as when I asked a friend if it was any good (he's one of the types of guy these kinds of games are marketed to after all; the ones with Hatsune Miku posters and Haruhi figurines), the first thing he said was "It's pretty fun, but I hate that they censored the bath scene." That told me what I needed to know, that the game wasn't bad, but wasn't for me. Not that I can't play games with sexual content - I even have Catherine in my top 10 games list of last gen - but when a game is so rooted in it I just can't enjoy playing it. Same reason I can't play Monster Monpiece; though I find the premise of a JRPG card-battle game extremely appealing, the presentation turns me off right away (pun intended?).

There's no doubt this game has a lot of meat to it, and is likely very fun as well. But I feel there's nothing wrong with someone turning away from the game based on its use of imagery. I also find nothing wrong with the game itself for containing it. I commend that they stuck to the formula and released such a niche game anyways, and I'm sure the fans are happy for it. This obviously doesn't help pull in new people, but the people who would buy this game likely already bought the first one and know what they're getting into. For newcomers though, this level of Moe would likely turn them away pretty quickly. Whether for cultural reasons, personal reasons, or both (like my case), this won't appeal to most people, but it's not supposed to.

@MadchesterManc A quick second review done by you wouldn't be bad. What aspect of the game sticks out best to you, and what score do you feel it deserved?

Heiki

#6

Heiki said:

Seems good enough to me. I'm probably one of those people this game is marketed to after all. Say what you want, but I'm glad NIS America keeps bringing niche titles.

Aaronzord

#7

Aaronzord said:

I'll be waiting until I find this cheap. I'm also grateful for all NIS' Western releases, but paying £35-40 for most of them doesn't really work for me.

I'm fine with this review anyway.I see too many reviews that just list the features of the game - if I want that, I'll find a press release or a Wiki article. Nice one for actually putting some opinion in.

SpookyMeths

#8

SpookyMeths said:

Well, at least now I know that the game is pervy, but I'm still wondering what sort of gameplay it has and whether or not it's fun.

CanisWolfred

#11

CanisWolfred said:

The first was terrible, IMO. This one sounds much better, but it still has enough things to keep me from wanting to play it.

Leave A Comment

Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...